Acute-onset high-morbidity primary photosensitisation in sheep associated with consumption of the Casbah and Mauro cultivars of the pasture legume Biserrula
Primary photosensitisation (PS) subsequent to ingestion of the pasture legume Biserrula pelecinus L. (biserrula) has recently been confirmed in grazing livestock. Given the potential utility of this pasture species in challenging climates, a grazing trial was undertaken to examine if both varieties ‘Casbah’ and ‘Mauro’ were able to cause photosensitisation in livestock, and if this could be mitigated by grazing in winter, or in combination with other common pasture species.
A controlled grazing trial was undertaken in winter in Australia with plots containing a dominant pasture of Biserrula pelecinus L. cv. ‘Casbah’ or ‘Mauro’, or mixed biserrula/perennial ryegrass populations. A photosensitisation grading system was established. 167 prime meat ewe lambs were introduced to the plots and monitored twice daily. Mild clinical signs were observed at 72 h on pasture. All animals were removed from biserrula dominant stands at this point. Four animals grazing ‘Casbah’ dominant pasture rapidly proceeded to severe photosensitisation in the following 12 h. Animals remaining on mixed biserrula/ryegrass stands did not exhibit severe PS but showed an 89% incidence of mild to moderate photosensitisation over the following 14 days. Animals on mixed lucerne showed significantly lower PS score than animals grazing biserrula varieties of any composition. The trial was halted at 14 days as only plots with low biserrula proportion still contained unaffected animals.
Necropsy revealed severe multifocal erythematous ulcerations and alopecia of the ear pinnae, severe bilateral periorbital and conjunctival oedema and variably severe subcutaneous facial oedema. No evidence of hepatopathy was present. A diagnosis of acute unseasonal primary photosensitisation caused by biserrula ingestion with no other underlying pathology was confirmed.
We report an unseasonal outbreak of acute photosensitisation in sheep grazing Biserrula pelecinus L cvs.’Casbah’ and ‘Mauro’ with exceedingly high morbidity. A grading system is also proposed as a tool for objective and consistent clinical appraisal of future PS outbreaks. This finding expands our definition of seasonal and temporal risk periods for biserrula photosensitisation, and is the first to identify that both commercial cultivars of biserrula can cause primary photosensitisation in sheep.
KeywordsPhotosensitisation Primary Unseasonal Biserrula pelecinus L. Legume Sheep
Dry sheep equivalent
Haematoxylin and eosin
Biserrula pelecinus is a self-regenerating annual legume highly suited to low to medium rainfall zones . It is able to adapt to a broad range of soil types with higher productivity compared to other legumes . Biserrula pelecinus L. var. ‘Casbah’ was commercialised in 1997, and has been widely used by farmers in Australian mixed farming systems as a break crop, especially in South Australia and New South Wales [14, 23, 24, 25, 26]. Anecdotal reports of cases of photosensitisation in livestock associated with biserrula ingestion had been noticed since this legume was commercialised in 1997 as a highly productive pasture with multiple agronomic advantages . However, it was only in the recent past that a direct connection between exposure to biserrula pasture and onset of primary photosensitisation was confirmed by detailed diagnostics .
Photosensitisation (PS) is a skin disorder caused by photodynamic pigments activated by long-wavelength ultraviolet or visible light in exposed areas of skin, resulting in dermatitis . In livestock, areas commonly affected include those lacking protective fleece, hair coat or skin pigmentation such as the muzzle, face, ears, eyes, mammary glands and genitalia .
In this study, we present an outbreak with exceedingly high morbidity in sheep grazing the Mediterranean pasture legume Biserrula pelecinus L. during its vegetative stage, in which animals exhibited an unexpected acute primary photosensitisation during mid-winter. Dissimilar to the current report, all but one  of the previous reports of PS outbreaks were reported in spring, a season classically associated with presentation of photosensitivity in livestock. Winter is not traditionally a time when photosensitisation outbreaks present to the livestock veterinarian. There are a number of reasons why this is the case: 1) lack of significant UV exposure due to cloudy conditions and short day length; 2) lack of actively growing plants, the phase during which toxic secondary compounds are commonly generated; 3) increased skin cover by hair or fleece for seasonal protection against colder conditions.
Furthermore, the clinical course and the speed of onset of clinical photosensitisation subsequent to exposure or ingestion of the presumptive or established aetiologic agent has not been clearly defined or evaluated. This is the first report of primary photosensitisation in sheep resulting from ingestion of both commercially available varieties of Biserrula, namely ‘Casbah’ and ‘Mauro’, in mid-winter, the presentation of which was acute, severe and with exceedingly high morbidity. We also define a clinical grading scale that is capable of differentiating mild, moderate and severe PS as a tool for objective and consistent clinical appraisal of PS outbreaks in the future, and describe the clinical course in relation to the severity of PS and the causative agent. This report also identifies that mixed pastures are not a guaranteed protection against incidence of PS in animals grazing this pasture species. This report highlights the need to consider photosensitisation as a differential diagnosis, even during winter months, when cases of acute dermatitis are rarely reported in grazing livestock.
One hundred sixty seven ‘Primeline’ meat ewe lambs were sourced at 10 months old from a local producer. Prior to purchase for this study, animals were maintained according to standard industry practices on a local property and were grazing mixed annual ryegrass pasture. Inclusion criteria for the trial included a healthy appearance at yarding with no visible pathology. All animals were naive for exposure to biserrula pasture. Prior to entry, animals were yarded and weighed (mean entry weight, 35.1 kg). All lambs were drenched prior to entry to pasture according to manufacturers recommendations (Ivomec®, Merial Australia). Water was provided ad libitum via automatic drinkers to all plots. As a control, an established mixed lucerne (Medicago sativa)/perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne)/subclover (Trifolium subterraneum) paddock adjacent to the sown biserrula trial site was used as an industry-standard comparison pasture.
Photosensitisation grading system
Proposed photosensitisation clinical grading system. Lesions were defined as being mild, moderate or severe if having a composite score of <7, <12 or ≥12 respectively
Face and muzzle
No apparent lesions
No apparent lesions
No apparent lesions
No apparent lesions
Mild cutaneous oedema and erythema
Mild serous blepharitis
Drooping of ears with mild oedema.
Mild erythema of exposed areas.
Cutaneous oedema and erythema; mild to mderate aural and facial oedema
Serous exudation, mild to moderate perorbital oedema and conjunctival erythema
Mild aural pitting oedema
Marked erythema of exposed areas.
Severe cutaneous erythema, crusting and black discolouration; moderate aural and facial oedema
Serous exudation, possible crusting; marked palpebral and conjunctival erythema and oedema; mild to moderate periorbital oedema
Marked aural pitting oedema, curling of ear ends, some flaking or other lesions possible
Multifocal, possibly multifocally extensive, patchy fleece loss, erythema of underlying skin.
Severe cutaneous erythema, crusting and black discolouration; severe aural and facial oedema
Severe perorbital, palpebral and conjunctival oedema. Possible corneal opacity or ulceration or opacity, serous exudate, eyelid crusting
Marked aural pitting oedema, curling of ear ends, other dermal lesions present. Skin flaking and multifocal necrosis; some tissue loss from rubbing may be evident; moderate serous exudation
Marked focal or multifocal fleece loss and dermatitis of exposed skin.
Multifocal irregularly shaped cutaneous necrosis and exudation; severe dermatitis including secondary lesions; severe facial oedema
Severe periorbital, palpebral and conjunctival oedema; eyes closed; corneal ulceration and/or opacity
Marked aural pitting oedema, curling of ear ends and tissue loss, other dermal lesions present including flaking and multifocal necrosis; abundant serous exudation
Widespread fleece loss, severe dermatitis of exposed skin. Significant fleece loss in dorsum and flanks.
A total of 167 lambs was randomly assigned to pasture in July (mid-winter) 2015 at matched stocking densities using restricted randomisation by weight (6–7 animals per plot; approximately 14 DSE/ha) (Fig. 1), 53 grazing in plots containing the biserrula variety ‘Mauro’ and 65 grazing on the variety ‘Casbah’. A further 49 lambs were grazing the non-PS mixed lucerne pasture. The ‘Mauro’ dominant pasture contained 88% biserrula by composition (n = 18 animals); while the biserrula ‘Casbah’ dominant pasture contained 81% biserrula by composition (n = 21 animals). Medium biserrula pastures of both varieties contained between 52 and 75% biserrula by composition (‘Mauro’ medium, n = 18 animals; ‘Casbah’ medium, n = 23 animals). Low biserrula pastures contained <50% biserrula species (‘Mauro’ low, n = 17 animals; ‘Casbah’ low, n = 21 animals). Animals were monitored twice daily for behavioural or physical changes (shade-seeking behaviour, reduction in grazing or general activity, physical isolation, lameness) and scored every 3 days for clinical signs of photosensitisation.
All lambs were introduced to pastures on 9 July 2015 with all remaining animals removed from trial plots on 23 July 2015. Animals exhibiting clinical signs of photosensitisation were removed from the trial on the date of observation and scored for clinical signs of PS. Withdrawn animals were removed to a non-photosensitising pasture (lucerne/ryegrass/subclover) with full availability of shade and water. Once less than 50% of the original pen cohort were remaining in any plot, all members of that cohort were removed from the trial. Any animal with a PS score > 11 was selected for euthanasia. All animals were carefully monitored both within and after the trial for increasing signs of PS. PS was observed to resolve as soon as animals were withdrawn from biserrula pastures. No other clinical intervention was required. This trial was approved and compliant with requirements of the Charles Sturt Institutional Animal Care and Ethics Committee (Protocol 13/018).
Photosensitisation scores were compared between cohorts using ANOVA and general mixed linear models using SPSS™ (IBM, Version 20), with variety, plot, composition and time as fixed factors. Significance was defined as p < 0.05.
Clinical course of the photosensitisation outbreak
Initially, animals grazing biserrula ‘Casbah’ dominant pastures were observed to exhibit some reduced grazing behaviour compared to other plots, showed less apparent activity within the plots and some individuals exhibited overt shade-seeking behaviour such as standing in a close line, nose to tail, or lying close to troughs or fence poles.
The first clinical signs of photosensitisation, ranging from mild to severe, were observed in 5 animals after only 3 days on biserulla dominant pasture. Three animals were located in the plot containing the highest contribution of biserrula ‘Casbah’ (plot 4, 98% composition, PS scores 2.5, 2.5 and 15), one was in the second highest contribution ‘Casbah’ plot (8, 92% composition, PS score 2.5), and one in a dominant ‘Mauro’ plot (plot 7, 90% composition, PS score 4). All five lambs exhibited swelling and drooping of the pinnae and blepharitis and showed shade-seeking behaviour. No PS was observed in any animal on mixed lucerne pasture at this timepoint.
Clinical photosensitisation (mild, moderate or severe) was observed in 100% (n = 39) of animals grazing either ‘Mauro’ or ‘Casbah’ dominant plots by day 6, facilitating complete withdrawal of all animals on biserrula dominant pastures at this time. Comparison between biserrula dominant pastures at day 6 showed that the animals on ‘Casbah’ had significantly higher PS score compared to the animals on ‘Mauro’ at this time point (p = <0.01). No animals showed signs of icterus.
In total, 107/118 (91%) animals on biserrula pastures showed some clinical signs of photosensitisation during the 14 day monitoring period. On day 14, the majority of animals showed composite PS scores ranging from 0 to 7.5 with most within the 0–5 range, indicating mild photosensitisation was apparent in the majority of animals that had remained on the plots until day 14 (n = 68; mean PS score 2.4). Only four moderately affected were identified on day 14 of the grazing trial, all were present in plots containing a medium composition of either B. pelecinus L. ‘Casbah’ or ‘Mauro’ (Plot 3, Casbah medium: PS scores 9 and 10; Mauro medium: plot 5, PS scores 9 and 11).
Effect of pasture and biserulla composition and biserulla variety on photosensitisation severity
Mean PS score for animals grazing mixed lucerne pastures at day 14 was 0 (zero) with animals on these pastures showing significantly lower PS score than animals grazing biserulla varieties of any composition (p ≥ 0.0001). Exit weight was not found to be statistically significant between the different pastures by variety or composition.
At day 14, biserulla variety was found to have a significant effect on severity of PS, with ‘Casbah’ showing significantly higher PS values than ‘Mauro’ (‘Casbah’ mean PS score: 3.09 ± 0.30, n = 46; ‘Mauro’ mean PS score: 1.97 ± 0.35, n = 34, F = 5.776; p = 0.019). Composition was also shown to exert a significant effect, with the medium biserulla composition mean PS score being significantly higher than the low biserulla low composition mean PS score (2.89 ± 0.34 vs: 2.31 ± 0.33, F = 6.332, p = 0.001).
Clinical pathology findings
Complete blood count of animal 1 was consistent with the presence of a mild inflammatory process, showing mild leucocytosis due to neutrophilia and monocytosis (white blood cell count 17.4 × 109/L, reference range 4.1–13.0 × 109/L; neutrophils 11.5 × 109/L, reference range 0.5–9.3 × 109/L; monocytes 1.1 × 109/L, reference range 0.0–0.7 × 109/L), likely attributable to the aural dermatitis. Serum biochemistry showed mildly elevated AST (157 U/L, reference range 87–156 U/L) and CK (600 U/L, reference range 91–472 U/L), without elevation of GGT (52 U/L, reference range 35–61 U/L) or bilirubin (2 μmol/L, reference range 4–15 μmol/L). These changes were unremarkable. Faecal egg count was negative.
Gross pathology findings
Previous reports of photosensitisation in lambs grazing biserrula identified dermal lesions of the face and ears [4, 15, 18] suggesting established or resolving lesions. Kessell et al. (2015)  also presented a PS outbreak due to biserrula Casbah in winter, affecting 25% of animals. However, the high morbidity, the speed of onset (4 days on pasture) and severity of presentation of PS described in our study have not been reported for this pasture species previously [2, 4, 18, 19, 20]. This study is the first to define the speed of onset of clinical photosensitisation subsequent to animals ingesting biserrula (<72 h). This study also identifies a change in behaviour in otherwise subclinically affected animals that could be used to predict the onset of clinical cases. Together these findings identify unique aspects of this clinical entity.
Prior to this experiment, it was not known whether both varieties of biserrula commercially available in Australia, ‘Casbah’ and ‘Mauro’, were able to induce photosensitisation. Previous reports had identified the variety ‘Casbah’ to be phytophototoxic, but it was not known if ‘Mauro’ was also able to exert this effect. The current report identified that both varieties can induce photosensitisation in sheep grazing on them with the vast majority of animals showing clinical signs on either variety at both low and high composition densities. Such high morbidity rates have also not been reported previously nor has the severity of clinical presentation been evaluated systematically in prior outbreaks [4, 13, 14, 15, 16]. Together our data suggest that a low composition pasture of B. pelecinus L cv. ‘Mauro’ might be the least photosensitising option available to producers, although neither variety is inert in its effect at a composition above 25% of total pasture.
Clinical photosensitisation occurs in three forms. Type I (primary PS) results from the direct ingestion, or exposure by dermal contact to, photodynamic compounds found within certain plant species, including biserulla, Froelichia humboldtiana, and alfalfa [2, 3, 4, 5]. Type II, not reported in sheep to date , is associated with congenitally abnormal porphyrin metabolism. Type III (hepatogenous) is the most common form of PS in livestock, and is caused by impaired liver function resulting in failure to excrete circulating phylloerythrin, a natural breakdown product of chlorophyll [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12], which in turn causes phototoxic damage to the dermal and subdermal layers of exposed skin.
This study, and previous case studies and reports on biserulla, showed no evidence of hepatopathy [4, 13, 14, 15, 16]. It is therefore suggested that biserrula cultivars contain photodynamic agents that lead to the onset of primary photosensitisation, occurring when the plant reaches show reproductive maturity [2, 4, 13, 15, 18, 21]. Although photoactive metabolites involved in this syndrome have not all been fully structurally elucidated, bioassay-guided isolation and analysis by NMR and UV spectroscopy along with mass spectrometry have revealed structural features of at least three bioactive metabolites present in the shoot extracts of both biserrula cultivars (LW, JQ unpublished data) and in seasonal equivalence to spring – early summer in NSW Australia. Photodynamic molecules such as these are polycyclic ring structures with conjugated bonds, generating potential electronic cycling and free radicals following exposure to UV irradiation, thereby leading to photosensitisation [2, 4]. At this time, investigation and structural elucidation is underway to 1) identify the photodynamic constituent(s) present in fresh B. pelecinus L. foliage and foliar extracts and 2) to investigate the potential to screen and select for less photocytotoxic genotypes for use in Mediterranean climates, including Australia.
The current study identifies the earliest phenological presentation of clinical photosensitisation to occur well prior to the reproductive phase of the plant’s life cycle, indicating that the currently unidentified photodynamic compound that causes photosensitisation may exist across all phenological stages of biserrula growth.
A diagnosis of photosensitisation is based on history, clinical signs and the exclusion of all other possible dermatopathies [1, 22]. Furthermore, the acute onset of symptoms in winter, when extensive cloud cover was present, in conjunction with the consumption of a known primary photosensitising plant species, largely rules out sunburn as a differential diagnosis in this case.
In this case, the eosinophilic infiltration of the epidermis and dermis could be a tissue response to necrotic keratinocytes, but it could also be a reaction to the deposited photodynamic substances in the skin, either through ingestion or possibly also by dermal contact in affected animals. Eosinophilic inflammation has not been reported as a histopathological finding in primary photosensitisation previously , and may represent an undetermined component involved in the aetiopathogenesis. The high morbidity rate of primary photosensitisation observed in the feeding trial (91% overall), combined with the pathologic findings in this case are highly suggestive of the presence of photosensitising compound(s) in sufficient quantity to cause severe dermatitis even in seasons of low ambient temperatures and lower UV exposure, conditions which are not usually associated with outbreaks of photosensitisation in livestock.
The high incidence of primary photosensitisation combined with the pathologic findings strongly suggest the presence of photosensitising agent(s) in sufficient quantity in both biserrula cultivars. Severe dermatitis in grazing sheep was observed unexpectedly during late winter growth conditions in central NSW, when low ambient air and soil temperatures and variable UV exposure were experienced.
Finally, the design and introduction of a quantitative grading system, such as the one proposed and applied in this report, to evaluate the severity of photosensitisation lesions will facilitate the objective evaluation, monitoring and comparison of photosensitisation cases in the future.
The authors thank the staff of the Charles Sturt University Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory for their excellent service and James Stephens for animal assistance..
JCQ and BH are both supported by Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA). This trial was funded by Meat and Livestock Australia and Australian Wool Innovations under the project code B.PSP.0013 ‘Pasture legumes in the mixed farming zones of WA and NSW: shifting the baseline’. Additional funding was provided by a Research Centre Fellowship awarded to JQ by the Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation, an alliance between NSW Department of Primary Industries and Charles Sturt University. YC is funded by a PhD Scholarship from the Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation, Charles Sturt University.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets generated during and/or analysed during the current study are available at the following weblink: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/qw7va0v0fq99chn/AACLV1CSSWHzrs03oqH2OY8ma?dl=0.
JCQ conducted the grazing trial, designed the clinical grading system and finalised the manuscript. YC reviewed the literature, drafted the manuscript and prepared the photos. BH carried out agronomic analysis of pasture compositions and assisted with the management of the trial. MST assisted with the management of the trial and animal care post trial. PL performed the necropsy, histology and diagnostic interpretation. LW provided comment on the manuscript and provided information on putative causal compounds. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.
All ethical approvals were sought and given prior to establishment of the trial and were fully in alignment with the Charles Sturt University Animal Ethics Committee requirements for use of animals in research. The protocol approval number was 13/018.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 1.Mauldin EA, Peters-Kennedy J. Integumentary System. In: Maxie MG, editor. Jubb, Kennedy, and Palmer’s Pathology of Domestic Animals, vol. 1. 6th ed. St. Louis; 2016. p. 577–80.Google Scholar
- 14.Hackney B. Hardseeded annual legumes – an on-demand break option with significant benefit to the mixed farming zone. Grains Research and Development Corporation Update papers. 2015; 2. https://grdc.com.au/resources-and-publications/grdc-update-papers/tab-content/grdc-update-papers/2015/02/hardseeded-annual-legumes; Accessed 18/7/2017.
- 15.Loi A, Revell C, Casbah NB, Biserrula M. Persistent pasture legumes for Mediterranean farming systems. Genetic Resources of Mediterranean Pasture and Forage Legumes. Dordrecht: Department of Agriculture Farmnote. 2005:90–5.Google Scholar
- 16.Salam KP, Murray-Prior R, Bowran D, Salam MU. Cadiz and Casbah pastures in Western Australia: Breeders’ expectation, Farmers' evaluation and achieved adoption. Ext Farm Sys J. 2009;5:103–12.Google Scholar
- 18.Hogg H. Photosensitisation in sheep grazing Biserrula. Western Australian Department of Agriculture and Food Farmnote. 2010;396:4.Google Scholar
- 20.Carr SJ, Loi A, Howieson JH. Attributes of Biserrula pelecinus L.(biserrula): A new pasture legume for sustainable farming on acidic sandy soils in Mediterranean environments. Cahiers Options Mediterraneennes. 1999;39:87–90.Google Scholar
- 24.Salam KP, Murray-prior R, Bowran D. A ‘Dream‘pasture and its comparison with two existing annual pasture legumes for Western Australia: a farmers’ eye view. Livest Res Rural Dev. 2010;22:1.Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.