Characterization of lymphocyte subsets over a 24-hour period in Pineal-Associated Lymphoid Tissue (PALT) in the chicken
Homeostatic trafficking of lymphocytes in the brain has important relevance to the understanding of CNS disease processes. The pineal gland of the chicken contains large accumulations of lymphocytes that suggest an important role related to homeostatic circadian neuro-immune interactions. The purpose of this initial study was to characterize the lymphocyte subsets in the pineal gland and quantitate the distribution and frequency of lymphocyte phenotypes at two time points over the 24-hour light:dark cycle.
PALT comprised approximately 10% of the total pineal area. Image analysis of immunocytochemically stained sections showed that the majority of lymphocytes were CD3+ (80%) with the remaining 20% comprising B-cells and monocytes (Bu-1+), which tended to distribute along the periphery of the PALT. T-cell subsets in PALT included CD4+ (75–80%), CD8+ (20–25%), TCRαβ/Vβ1+ (60%), and TCRγδ+ (15%). All of the T-cell phenotypes were commonly found within the interfollicular septa and follicles of the pineal gland. However, the ratios of CD8+/CD4+ and TCRγδ+/TCRαβ/Vβ1+ within the pineal tissue were each 1:1, in contrast to the PALT where the ratios of CD8+/CD4+ and TCRγδ+/TCRαβ/Vβ1+ each approximated 1:4. Bu-1+ cells were only rarely seen in the pineal interstitial spaces, but ramified Bu-1+ microglia/macrophages were common in the pineal follicles. Effects of the 24-h light:dark cycle on these lymphocyte-pineal interactions were suggested by an increase in the area of PALT, a decline in the density of TCRαβ/Vβ1+ cells, and a decline in the area density of Bu-1+ microglia at the light:dark interphase (1900 h) compared to the dark:light interphase (0700 h).
The degree of lymphocyte infiltration in the pineal suggests novel mechanisms of neuro-immune interactions in this part of the brain. Our results further suggest that these interactions have a temporal component related to the 24-hour light:dark cycle and that CD8+ and TCRγδ+ T-cells are preferentially recruited to the pineal follicles. Pineal microglia/macrophages were common and represent an important candidate for mediating these lymphocyte-pineal interactions via secretion of cytokines and chemokines.
KeywordsMelatonin Area Density Pineal Gland Neuroendocrine Function Central Lumen
The view that the central nervous system (CNS) is an immunologically privileged site has been widely accepted based on classic experiments such as those of Medawar , who showed that rabbit skin allografted into the CNS failed rejection. This immunologic privilege is specifically related to the low levels of MHC class II expression , which is responsible for antigen presentation in the brain. An additional mechanism for maintaining immune privilege is the presence of the blood-brain barrier (BBB), which is a semi-permeable barrier, composed of endothelial cells that restrict the interface between the brain and immune circulatory products.
Specific regions of the brain, the circumventricular organs, lie outside the BBB  and are therefore subject to the effects of serum-derived substances including immune factors. One of those regions is the pineal gland, which has been studied extensively in recent years for its immuno-regulatory function [4, 5, 6, 7]. The gland secretes a potent hormone, melatonin, that tends to stimulate the immune system and its production of cytokines [5, 6, 7, 8]. Because the pineal gland's neuroendocrine functions are closely linked to the 24-hour light:dark cycle , these pineal-immune interactions are also thought to have a temporal component. Evidence for effects of the pineal gland on photoperiodic changes in the immune system has been collected in both birds and mammals [10, 11, 12, 13].
Interactions between the neuroendocrine and immune systems presume that feedback mechanisms are present from one system to the other via immune soluble factors. Antigenic stimulation , inflammation  and treatment with cytokines [15, 16] have all been shown to modulate the neuroendocrine functions of the gland, although the cellular and molecular mechanisms of this feedback are still poorly understood. One cell population in the pineal gland that has been implicated as mediators of these immune effects on pinealocyte functions are the microglia/macrophages. These cells regulate pinealocyte neurite length and serotonin content in an invitro system and they upregulate cytokine expression, MHC class II and other surface antigens in response to cytokines and bacterial wall components [17, 18, 19].
Feedback of the immune system on the pineal gland is further indicated by reports of accumulations of lymphocytes in the pineal of both avian and mammalian species [2, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25]. In some species such as the chicken, these accumulations of lymphocytes account for up to 30% of the total volume of the gland . The large size of this pineal-associated lymphoid tissue (PALT) and the extent of lymphocyte infiltration suggest novel mechanisms of neuro-immune interactions in this part of the brain. The presence of PALT raises several important questions regarding the mechanisms of interactions between lymphocytes and the pineal gland, including effects on circadian rhythms in both the immune system and the pineal gland. To date, there are no studies on possible changes in the composition and distribution of lymphocytes in the pineal over a light: dark cycle. Accordingly, the purpose of this study was to further characterize the phenotypes and distribution of lymphocytes in the chicken pineal gland, and to determine if lymphocyte subsets vary over the 24-h light: dark cycle.
General histology of the pineal gland
Lymphocyte phenotypes and distributions
Two-color immuno-staining revealed that the majority of CD3+ lymphocytes were also CD4+ (Fig. 3). Fewer CD3+ lymphocytes in the PALT co-localized with CD8α. These CD3+CD8α+ cells tended to distribute randomly throughout the PALT, although on occasion were seen localized along the periphery of the PALT. Antibodies to both TCR1 (γδ) and TCR2 (αβ/Vβ1) showed staining that co-localized with CD3-positive lymphocytes, although the frequency of TCRγδ+ cells was significantly less than the frequency of TCRαβ/Vβ1 + cells. The TCRγδ+ cells tended to be found along the periphery of the PALT.
Bu-1+ cells resembling microglia/macrophages were also seen within the pineal follicles (Fig. 4). The microglia/macrophages were easily distinguished by their ramified morphologies. In contrast to the common occurrence of T-cell lymphocyte phenotypes in the interstitial spaces between follicles, round, mononuclear Bu-1+ cells were rarely seen in these compartments.
Image analysis of lymphocyte phenotypes
Measurements of the profile areas of the PALT and pineal tissue showed that PALT made up approximately 7–12% of the total pineal area. The average profile area of PALT in glands collected at the light: dark interphase was approximately 104,000 μm2 whereas the glands collected at the dark: light interphase was approximately 51,000 μm2. In contrast, the average profile area of pineal tissue did not change between the two time points studied (81 × 104 μm2 vs. 77 × 104 μm2).
BU-1-positive cells were common in the pineal tissue, although B cells could not be readily distinguished from the microglia/macrophages, which are also stained with this antibody. Immuno-staining with anti-IgM and anti-Igλ (light chain) did not resolve the B cells because these antibodies stained secretory products throughout the pineal tissue, including the lumen of follicles. Because Igλ labels most of the immunoglobulin fraction (e.g., light chain), it was observed to stain more intensely than IgM.
The day: night differences in the area density (μm2/μm2) of the Bu-1+ microglia/macrophages within pineal tissue approached significance as analyzed by a two-tailed Student's t-test (p < 0.07, n = 10 for each time point) with a 43% decline at the light: dark interphase (0.020 ± SEM 0.003) compared to the dark: light interphase (0.035 ± SEM 0.007).
The histology of the PALT in this study was in general agreement with previous reports [20, 21, 22, 23]. Moreover, the present finding that PALT occupied approximately 10% of the total pineal area in 14–21 day old chicks was reasonably close to Cogburn's  estimate that PALT occupied 18% of the total volume in older White Leghorn chickens. The phenotypes and distributions of lymphocytes in PALT resembled the gut-associated lymphoid tissues (GALT) found in mucosal structures such as the proventriculus . PALT and GALT each showed a higher concentration of T cells centrally (mostly CD4+ and TCRαβ/Vβ1+), whereas TCRγδ+ and Bu-1+ cells were found more peripherally.
Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that lymphocyte-pineal interactions vary over the light:dark cycle. The 2-fold change in profile area of PALT and the decline in density of TCRαβ/Vβ1 + cells at the light:dark interphase suggest that lymphocyte trafficking in the PALT varies with time. However, additional samples are required over the 24-h light:dark cycle as well as other criteria (e.g., free-running under constant darkness) need to be met before a circadian rhythm in pineal lymphocyte trafficking can be definitively established in this system. Because immunohistochemistry allows analysis of only a small percentage of the tissue in any gland, we are undertaking to develop methodologies of fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS) to analyze lymphocyte subsets in the gland.
Cogburn and Glick  concluded that PALT formation is dependent on the bursa and thymus based on the reduction in size of PALT following bursectomy and/or thymectomy with whole body irradiation. In a later study, Cogburn and Glick  showed that tritium-labelled lymphocytes from the thymus and bursa migrated to the pineal gland, but only in older (4–5 week old) chicks. Studies are currently underway to determine whether soluble chemotactic factors from chicken pineal glands induce migration of specific lymphocyte subtypes using an invitro migration assay. This specificity of migration is suggested by the present study showing that the ratios of CD8+ to CD4+, and TCRγδ+ to TCRαβ/Vβ1 + cells are nearly four fold greater in the pineal tissue compared to that found in PALT. The close correlation of CD8 to TCRγδ is supported by Chen et al.  who reported that the majority of TCRγδ cells expressed CD8. A preferential recruitment of CD8+ and TCRγδ+ cells into the pineal tissue was also found to occur in the retina , which is notable considering that the pineal gland shares homologies related to common photoreceptive functions . Imagawa et al.  speculated that the lymphocytes played a role in the normal surveillance of the retina and functioned to remove cell debris as well as remaining in the retina as memory T cells.
The scarcity of Bu-1+ cells in the inter-follicular (non-PALT) compartment is further evidence of the preferential recruitment of lymphocytes to the pineal tissue. Image analysis of these cells revealed that they comprised 20–25% of PALT lymphocytes, similar to that found in the spleen [31, 32]. Cogburn and Glick  described a much higher proportion of B lymphocytes (42%) based on a cytotoxic assay in older (6 weeks) chicks of a different strain (New Hampshire). However, Olah and Magyar , using the Bu-1b antibody in the New Hapmpshire strain showed staining patterns that were similar to those observed in the present study. As reported here, the Bu-1-positive cells were predominantly found along the periphery of PALT and the authors also described large clusters of Bu-1-positive cells, which they described as germinal centers .
Lymphocyte interactions with pinealocytes are clearly implicated by their common occurrence within the pineal follicles, which in some cases exhibited heavy infiltration , even as far as the central lumen of the pineal follicles (see Fig. 5). The proliferation of these cells in the non-PALT pineal compartments is greater than in the PALT based on tritiated-thymidine incorporation studies [22, 26] and counts of mitotic figures (unpublished observations). The enhanced proliferation of lymphocytes in the pineal tissue (non-PALT) suggests that the pineal cells produce blastogenic products that may also affect the differentiation of the lymphocytes . These results are additional evidence that lymphocytes traffic regularly between PALT and the pineal follicles.
The Bu-1+ cells observed within the pineal follicles are most likely microglia/macrophages because their distribution and ramified morphology resemble the microglia/macrophages described in the mammalian pineal gland [2, 3, 17, 33, 34, 35, 36]. To our knowledge, this is the first description of these cells in the avian pineal gland and, as such, represent ideal candidates as cellular interfaces between the immune system and the neuroendocrine pinealocytes. In contrast to most other parts of the brain, microglia/macrophages in the pineal gland are constitutively active as evidenced by the expression of MHC class II [2, 3, 17, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. Because these cells are actively involved in antigen presentation, and secrete potent cytokines (e.g., IL1), they have been implicated in the regulation of pinealocyte differentiation and neuroendocrine functions. Tsai and McNulty  demonstrated in the rat that pineal microglia regulate pinealocyte neurite length and the production of serotonin in vitro. The production of melatonin could also be stimulated in vivo by treatment with IL-1β , presumably produced by these activated microglia/macrophages. More recently, Jiang-Shieh et al.  demonstrated that pineal microglia/macrophages are in constant surveillance of blood-borne pathogens and presumably other serum-derived substances.
Day-night differences in the expression of the Bu-1 epitope in microglia/macrophages are consistent with their hypothesized role as interfaces in the interaction with PALT lymphocytes. Increased expression of Bu-1 occurred at the dark:light interphase (0700 h), the time immediately following when cells were exposed to the highest levels of melatonin, which is produced during the dark phase (cf ). The time-point corresponded to the rise in area density of TCRαβ/Vβ1 + cells in the PALT. This temporal relationship may be explained by increased secretion of microglial cytokines and chemokines assuming that increased expression of Bu-1 represents activation of the microglia.
The terminology used to describe microglia in the pineal gland is complicated by the fact that this organ is outside the blood-brain barrier. Although Perry and Gordon  described similar populations of cells in the choroid plexus and meninges as macrophages, we include the term "microglia" because the pineal gland is part of the brain, a terminology adapted by other authors [17, 33, 34, 40]. However, it is not clear whether these cells are undifferentiated microglia or resident macrophages derived from circulating monocytes. In addition to B-cells, the Bu-1 antibody stains cells of the monocyte line and recognizes a highly glycosylated transmembrane protein that has no similarity to known mammalian markers [31, 41, 42]. The Bu-1 antibody has also been shown to stain microglia within the sensory epithelium of the ear .
The functional significance of lymphocyte trafficking in the pineal gland has yet to be determined, although there are two overall working hypotheses, which are not mutually exclusive. One hypothesis addresses the mechanisms involved in the recruitment of lymphocytes to the gland and their possible differentiation to form distinct subpopulation(s), which are involved in immunological surveillance of the CNS including the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). In many species, the gland and the PALT are juxtaposed to the choroid plexus, which produces CSF. Lymphocytes have been shown to migrate through the choroid plexus and enter the CSF at these locations . The second hypothesis addresses immunological mechanisms regulating the neuroendocrine functions of the gland. As noted above, several studies have shown that immune-derived cytokines modulate both neural and neuroendocrine activities. It is therefore conceivable that lymphocyte trafficking in the pineal regulates the circadian production of melatonin. This potential circuit could represent a direct feedback of the immune system on a gland that is known to regulate immune functions.
In conclusion, this study has provided a detailed quantitative description of pineal-associated lymphocyte phenotypes at two time points over the 24-hour light:dark cycle. Our results show that lymphocytes comprise a significant component of pineal tissue in this species. The data further suggest that CD8+/ TCRγδ+ cells are preferentially recruited to the pinealocytes and that pineal-lymphocyte interactions are dynamically linked to the light:dark cycle. Pineal microglia/macrophages are proposed to play an important role in these interactions through their secretion of cytokines and chemokines. The unique accumulation of lymphocytes in this part of the brain has important functional implications with regard to homeostatic mechanisms of neuro-immune interactions, especially those involving circadian components of both the immune and nervous systems and the possible role of these cells in immune surveillance in other parts of the CNS. Further studies of the cellular and molecular mechanisms of these homeostataic pineal-lymphocyte interactions will provide a better understanding of disease processes in the nervous system.
Male White Leghorn chickens (3 days old) were purchased commercially (Ideal Poultry, Texas) between June and September, and raised to 2–3 weeks of age under standard laboratory conditions in a fully accredited animal care facility according to recommendations in the guide for the care and use of laboratory animals, and the guidelines of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at Loyola University Stritch School of Medicine. The photoperiod in the animal room was controlled by automatic timers programmed for a 12:12 light: dark cycle. The intensity of the light at the level of the cages was approximately 450 lux. Chicks were killed by rapid decapitation following CO2 inhalation. Glands were collected at the dark: light interphase (0700 h) and 12 h later at the light: dark interphase (1900 h) just after lights on and prior to lights off, respectively. These time points were selected because the 0700 h time point represents the delayed effects of greatest exposure to the pineal hormone melatonin, which is produced during the dark phase. The 1900 h time point represents the delayed effects of least exposure to melatonin, which is not produced during the daytime. A total of 10 animals were collected at each time point.
Preparation of tissue sections
The pineal glands were fixed in cold 4% paraformaldehyde for 1 h along with thymus, bursa of Fabricius, and spleen, which were used as control tissues. The tissues were washed in PBS (2×, 10 min) and the pineal glands cleaned of any attached meninges or vessels before being placed in the cryoprotectant (30% sucrose solution) for 2 h. Tissues were then placed in TBS Tissue Freezing Medium using a penny to determine the orientation of the pineal, frozen on dry ice and stored at -80°C. Tissue blocks were serially cut at a thickness of 6 μm on the cryomicrotome with the pineal glands sectioned from caudal to rostral. The sections were transferred to Superfrost Plus slides and stored at -80°C until staining.
Every eighth pineal section (48 μm intervals) was stained with haematoxylin and eosin (H&E). These sections were used to determine the location of the PALT, and to measure the profile areas of the pineal gland and the PALT that corresponded to the nearest sections used for immunocytochemistry. Semi-thin (1 μm), toluidine blue stained epoxy sections from a previous study  were also used to evaluate the histology of the PALT.
Immunohistochemical methods followed previously published procedures [18, 44]. Optimal conditions for immunohistochemical staining with each monoclonal antibody (mAb) were determined using spleen, thymus and bursa. Prior to staining, pineal sections were selected based on the presence of PALT as determined from H&E sections. These sections were brought to room temperature (RT) and briefly washed with PBS. A solution of Superblock, Triton-X, and 3% goat serum was added for 30 min at RT. Following PBS wash (2X), the sections were stained for 30 min with mAbs in a solution of BSA/ PBS (2 g/1000 ml) at RT. Mouse hybridoma supernatants were supplied by Dr. Chen-lo Chen (University of Alabama, Birmingham). The following clones (1:5 dilution) were used: CT-3 (anti-CD3), CT-4 (anti-CD4), CT-8 (anti-CD8α), TCR-1 (anti-TCRγδ), TCR-2 (anti-TCRαβ/Vβ1), M-1 (anti-IgM) and L1 (anti-Igλ light chain). The TCR-3 (anti-TCRαβ/Vβ2) was not used for analysis in this study because it gave a diffuse staining pattern that was inconsistent with previously published findings. Commercially purified mAb's (SouthernBiotechnology, Birmingham, AL) (1:100 dilution) for CD4 and CD8α were used to verify specificity of the supernatants. A separate anti-CD3 mAb (rat, 1:100 dilution, Abcam) was used to delineate the PALT and to determine co-localization with other T-cell markers. The Bu-1 antibody (AV20 clone, SouthernBiotechnology) was used to detect B cells and cells in the monocyte lineage. Following primary antibody incubation, sections were washed 3× in PBS for 10 min at 4°C. The secondary antibody, FITC labelled goat anti-mouse at a dilution of 1:250, or a mixture of FITC labelled goat anti-mouse at a dilution of 1:250 and Alexia-555 labelled goat anti-rat (Molecular Probes) at a dilution of 1:100 was added for 30 min at RT in the dark. Sections reacted with mouse IgG1 isotype controls were included with each staining. Other controls included serial dilutions of the primary antibody and omission of the primary antibody. Immunohistochemical images were captured with a laser scanning confocal microscope (Zeiss LSM 510).
Because the optical slice thickness (1.3 μm) of the confocal microscope was less than the thickness of the section (6 μm), all images were collected from the middle of the section as determined by focusing through the section. All confocal microscope parameters (e.g., optical slice, detector gain, detector offset) were kept constant during collection of all images. Every PALT was digitized using a 63X lens making every effort to minimize the amount of overlap from image to image.
After converting the files to 8-bit grayscale images in Photoshop (Adobe) they were imported to Scion Image (Scion Corp) software. This software was used to measure area profiles of pineal tissue and PALT from the H&E sections and area profiles of PALT from the diffraction interference contrast (DIC) images generated by the Zeiss confocal instrument. The area of immunoreaction product was measured after thresholding to determine the optical density that corresponded to specific immunostaining for each antibody as described previously . Area densities of immunostaining were calculated by dividing the area of immunoreaction product by the total area of reference (e.g., PALT). To convert area density of immunoreaction product to number of cells per area, a factor was calculated that represented the average area of reaction product per cell. Briefly, for each antibody, the average area of reaction product was calculated from 20 separate fields and divided by the average number of PALT lymphocytes in those same fields. Dividing the immunoreaction area densities by cell factors for each antibody provided estimates of the number of positive cells per unit area.
The number of positive cells found outside the PALT (i.e., within the interlobular pineal septa and follicles) were counted directly from sections by two observers. For these counts, cells along the periphery of the gland and nearest to PALT were not included.
Area density of Bu-1+ staining on ramified cells within the pineal follicles was determined from 3 random fields for each gland. As described above for lymphocytes, the threshold in Scion Image was set to the optical density that corresponded to specific immunostaining of these Bu-1+ cells.
Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. Mean values were calculated for each antibody for each animal and these means pooled according to time of sacrifice (n = 10/time point). Differences between grouped means were determined by a two-tailed Student's t-test. A difference of p < 0.05 was considered significant.
We thank Dr. Chen-lo Chen for graciously supplying supernatants. The project was supported by the National Research Initiative of the USDA Cooperative State Research, Education and Extension Service, grant number 2003-35204-13760 to JAMc.
- 2.Pedersen EB, Fox LM, Castro AJ, McNulty JA: Immunocytochemical and electron-microscopic characterization of macrophage/microglia cells and expression of class II major histocompatibility complex in the pineal gland of the rat. Cell Tissue Res. 1993, 272: 257-265. 10.1007/BF00302731.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 9.Klein DC: Circadian rhythms in the pineal gland. Endocrine rhythms. Edited by: Krieger DT. 1979, New York, Raven Press, 203-223.Google Scholar
- 10.Kliger CA, Gehad AE, Hulet RM, Roush WB, Lillehoj HS, Mashaly MM: Effects of phtoperiod and melatonin on lymphocyte activities in male broiler chickens. Poult Sci. 2000, 79:Google Scholar
- 14.Markowwska M, Bialecka B, Ciechanowska M, Koter Z, Laskowska H, Karkucinska-Wieckowska A, Skwarlo-Sonta K: Effect of immunization on nocturnal NAT activity in chicken pineal gland. Neuro Endocrinol Lett. 2000, 21: 367-373.Google Scholar
- 15.Mucha S ZKZMSJSH, Zarek-Melen G, Swietoslowski J, Stiepen H: Effect of interleukin-1 on in vivo melatonin secretion by the pineal gland in rats. Edited by: Maestroni GJM CA Reiter RJ. 1992, , John Libbey and Co., 177-181.Google Scholar
- 17.Jiang-Shieh YF, Wu CH, Chien HF, Wei IH, Chang ML, Shieh JY, Wen CY: Reactive changes in interstial clian and pinealocytes in the rat pineal gland challenged with cell wall components from gram-positive and -negative bacteria. J Pineal Res. 2005, 38: 17-26. 10.1111/j.1600-079X.2004.00170.x.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 26.Olah I, Magyar A: Pineal gland of the chicken is a transient lymphoid organ. J Thymology. 1996, 4: 93-102.Google Scholar
- 30.Vollrath L: The Pineal Organ. Hand mikroskop Anat Mensch. Edited by: Vollrath L and Oksche A. 1981, Berlin, New York, Springer-Verlag, VI/7: 589-Google Scholar
- 43.McNulty JA FL, Mosher K, Binkley S: Synaptic ribbons and N-acetyltransferase activity in the avian pineal gland: quantitative changes over a 24-h photoperiod. Journal of Pineal Res. 1986, 14: 580-581.Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.