The case against price-level targeting
As the Fed begins to wrestle with how to stimulate growth in the next economic downturn in an environment of low interest rates, a number of possible changes in its policy framework are being entertained. One in particular that has gained considerable support is price-level targeting, based on the view that this approach would tend to move inflation and nominal interest rates up late in the business cycle, yielding more room for rate cuts when the downturn ensues. We outline the inherent difficulties involved in controlling the level of inflation under the current inflation-targeting regime. We then argue that requiring the Fed to meet the more stringent objective of a price-level target could introduce significantly greater volatility into output growth—potentially worsening economic downturns—than is the case under the current policy framework. We also consider a preferred course of action that adds a bit more flexibility to the current framework, at least for the near to the medium term, and how the Fed might deal with the next recession.
KeywordsFed Monetary policy framework Price-level targeting Inflation targeting r-Star Recession
- Barnes, Michelle L and Giovanni P. Olivei. 2003. Inside and Outside Bounds: Threshold Estimates of the Phillips Curve. New England Economic Review, 2003: 3–13. https://www.bostonfed.org/publications/new-england-economic-review/2003-issues/issue-2003-issue/inside-and-outside-bounds-threshold-estimates-of-the-phillips-curve.aspx.
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. 2018. Monetary Policy Report, Part 2. February, https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/2018-02-mpr-part2.htm.
- Brookings Institution. 2018. Should the Fed stick with the 2 percent inflation target or rethink it?. January https://www.brookings.edu/events/should-the-fed-stick-with-the-2-percent-inflation-target-or-rethink-it/.
- Cashin David, Erin Syron Ferris, Beth Klee and Cailey Stevens. 2017. Take it to the Limit: The Debt Ceiling and Treasury Yields. Federal Reserve Board of Governors. March. https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2017052pap.pdf.
- Cecchetti, Stephen, Michael Feroli, Peter Hooper, Anil Kashyap, and Kermit Schoenholtz. 2017. Deflating Inflation Expectations: The Implications of Inflation’s Simple Dynamics. US Monetary Policy Forum, February. https://research.chicagobooth.edu/-/media/enterprise/centers/igm/2017-usmpf.pdf?la=en&hash=769C60A8C1846E177A583F7F4C26944F362DC954.
- Desplans, Laura, Matthew Luzzetti, Justin Weidner, Brett Ryan, Suvir Ranjan, and Rajsekhar Bhattacharyya. 2018. Acyclical inflation: What is down must come up?Deutsche Bank US Economic Perspectives. February 16, https://research.db.com/Research/Article?rid=87c5ac79-4e7f-400e-9bb6-4330abedaee0-604&kid=RP0001&documentType=R.
- Emi, Nakamura, Jon Steinsson, Patrick Sun and Daniel Villar. 2017. The Elusive Costs of Inflation: Price Dispersion during the U.S. Great Inflation. June. http://www.columbia.edu/~en2198/papers/costsinflation.pdf.
- Greenspan, Alan. 1996. FOMC transcript, page 51, July 3, https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/FOMC19960703meeting.pdf.
- Holston, Kathryn, Thomas, Laubach, and John, C. Williams. 2016. Measuring the Natural Rate of Interest: International Trends and Determinants. Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. December, https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/files/wp2016-11.pdf.
- Janet, Yellen. 2015. Inflation Dynamics and Monetary Policy. https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/yellen20150924a.htm.
- Johnson, David S, Stephen B. Reed, and Kenneth J. Stewart. 2006. Price measurement in the United States: a decade after the Boskin Report. Bureau of Labor Statistics. https://stats.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2006/05/art2full.pdf.
- Justin, Weidner, Matt Luzzetti, Laura Desplans, and Brett Ryan. 2018. A rising r-star lifts rate hike prospects. Deutsche Bank US Economic Notes. February 1, https://research.db.com/Research/Article?rid=472bd836_075b_11e8_987a_e3758a6e3d3d_604&kid=RP0001.
- Kumar, Anil and Pia Orrenius. 2015. A closer look at the Phillips curve using state-level data. Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas working paper 1409. May, https://www.dallasfed.org/assets/documents/research/papers/2014/wp1409.pdf.
- Lubik, Thomas A and Christian Matthes. 2015. Calculating the Natural Rate of Interest: A Comparison of Two Alternative Approaches. Economic Brief, Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, October. https://www.richmondfed.org/media/richmondfedorg/publications/research/economic_brief/2015/pdf/eb_15-10.pdf.
- Luzzetti, Matt and Justin Weidner. 2017a. How confident should we be that r-star is very close to zero? Not very. Deutsche Bank US Economic Perspectives https://research.db.com/Research/api/1.0/file/2795-e03eb74_b989_11e7_b07d_deb52fbc49b6_604?fileToken=YYY122_vEDwiT8h%2f%2fQGiP3PbBNITju%2fGxM85oBh6MHUutsI27rczJJc3F6lvalypGSC9tOtcI5FIxXNW9TFXKGphkMMufo3jU3WzkJ2B1wpY1CSimI%3d.
- Luzzetti, Matt, and Justin Weidner, December. 2017b. A tipping point for low wage growth? Evidence of nonlinearities from state data. Deutsche Bank US Economic Perspectives. https://research.db.com/Research/Article?rid=ae909877-392f-4e45-a235-1e789f8b86fb-604&kid=RP0001&documentType=R.
- Luzzetti, Matt, Justin Weidner, Peter Hooper, Brett Ryan and Torsten Slok. 2017. Fed policy framework: Is the price (level) right? Deutsche Bank US Economic Perspectives. November 21, https://research.db.com/Research/Atile?rid=8df28258_ce97_11e7_ac92_4c97f267772c_604&kid=RP0001.
- Luzzetti, Matt, Laura Desplans, Brett Ryan, Justin Weidner, and Rajsekhar Bhattacharyya. 2018. Inflation Regimes: The times they are a changin’? Deutsche Bank US Economic Perspectives. February 22. https://research.db.com/Research/Article?rid=1af754fb-1003-400d-92ed-d40085e66ec8-604&kid=RP0001&documentType=R.
- Mahedy, Tim and Adam Shapiro. 2017. What’s down with inflation? Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Economic Letter 2017–35. Google Scholar
- Nalewaik, Jeremy. 2016. Non-linear Phillips curves with inflation regime-switching. Federal Reserve Board. https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/feds/2016/files/2016078pap.pdf.
- Paul, A. Volcker. 1983. We can survive Prosperity. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/files/docs/historical/volcker/Volcker_19831228.pdf.
- Peach, Richard, Robert Rich, and Anna Cororaton. 2011. How does slack influence inflation? Federal Reserve Bank of New York Current Issues in Economics and Finance, 17–3 https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/current_issues/ci17-3.html.