Carbon-Based Metal-Free Electrocatalysis for Energy Conversion, Energy Storage, and Environmental Protection
- 2.5k Downloads
Carbon-based metal-free catalysts possess desirable properties such as high earth abundance, low cost, high electrical conductivity, structural tunability, good selectivity, strong stability in acidic/alkaline conditions, and environmental friendliness. Because of these properties, these catalysts have recently received increasing attention in energy and environmental applications. Subsequently, various carbon-based electrocatalysts have been developed to replace noble metal catalysts for low-cost renewable generation and storage of clean energy and environmental protection through metal-free electrocatalysis. This article provides an up-to-date review of this rapidly developing field by critically assessing recent advances in the mechanistic understanding, structure design, and material/device fabrication of metal-free carbon-based electrocatalysts for clean energy conversion/storage and environmental protection, along with discussions on current challenges and perspectives.
KeywordsMetal-free electrocatalysis Carbon-based catalysts Energy conversion and storage Environmental protection
Because of accelerating global energy consumption and growing environmental concerns, the need to develop clean and sustainable energy conversion and storage systems, such as fuel cells, dye-sensitized solar cells, metal-air batteries, and Li-CO2 batteries, is of great importance [1, 2, 3]. These renewable energy technologies rely on several important reactions, including oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), oxygen evolution reaction (OER), hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), and CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), all of which require catalysts. Currently, metal-based catalysts are widely used but suffering from multiple competitive disadvantages, such as low selectivity, poor durability, and negative environmental impacts . Therefore, the development of earth-abundant, cost-effective, stable, and catalytically active metal-free alternatives is highly desirable for application in renewable energy technologies.
The recent availability of carbon nanomaterials, such as graphene, carbon nanotubes (CNTs), graphite nanoplatelets, and three-dimensional (3D) carbon architectures offer new opportunities for the development of advanced metal-free catalysts . Because of high abundance, high electrical conductivity, structure tunability at the atomic level, high selectivity, strong tolerance to acidic/alkaline conditions, and eco-friendliness [4, 5], many nanostructured carbon materials have been developed as metal-free catalysts with impressive electrocatalytic performances for ORR, HER, OER, and/or CO2RR, key reactions involved in energy conversion/storage and environmental protection processes [3, 6, 7, 8, 9]. The electrocatalytic performances of metal-free carbon-based catalysts were further found to be tuneable through the regulation of the nanoparticles size, macrostructures, and electrode architectures, along with the introduction of heteroatoms (doping) and defects [8, 9].
In this review, general strategies for creating active sites on carbon-based catalysts for various electrochemical reactions will first be discussed. Because ORR, OER, and HER have been reviewed in several previously published articles [4, 10, 11, 12], the focus in this review will be on recent advances and new reactions (e.g., CO2RR, multifunctional electrocatalysis). A critical overview of efficient methods for developing carbon-based metal-free catalysts for various energy conversion/storage and environmental protection devices, including ORR in fuel cells [13, 14, 15, 16, 17], ORR and OER in metal-air batteries [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28], OER and HER in water-splitting units [29, 30, 31], I−/I3− reduction in dye-sensitized solar cells [32, 33, 34, 35], and CO2RR in Li-CO2 batteries [36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42] will then be provided. Finally, perspectives and challenges in this fast-growing and significant field are outlined.
2 Graphitic Carbon Materials
Carbon exists in three forms (i.e., amorphous carbon, graphite, and diamond) each with different carbon atom arrangements and properties [43, 44]. For example, graphite is a soft, black, and stable common form of carbon with strong covalent bonding in the carbon plane and much weaker van der Waals interactions in the transverse direction between layers. Diamond is hard and transparent, with each carbon atom bonding to four other carbon atoms in a regular repetitive pattern.
2.1 Carbon Nanotubes
A carbon nanotube (CNT) can be seen as a graphite sheet rolled into a nanoscale tubular to form a single-wall carbon nanotube (SWCNT) or as concentric graphene tubes attached around the core of a SWCNT to form a multi-walled carbon nanotube (MWCNT). Nanotubes usually possess diameters ranging from a few angstroms to tens of nanometres and lengths of up to several centimeters and even submeters [45, 46]. The peculiar hollow geometry, coupled with a conjugated all-carbon structure, allows CNTs to exhibit many intriguing electrical, mechanical, and thermal properties that are absent from other members of the carbon family. In particular, CNTs can exhibit semiconducting or metallic behaviors depending on the diameter and helicity of the arrangement of graphitic rings in the walls . High surface area is another important property of CNTs, with theoretical surface areas of SWCNTs reaching 1315 m2 g−1 . Because of the unique structures and extraordinary electrical, mechanical, and optical properties, CNTs are promising for various applications [49, 50, 51], ranging from composite materials to electronic and energy-related devices [52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58].
Graphene, a one-atom-thick planar sheet of sp2-bonded carbon in a honeycomb network, is a rising star in materials sciences, physics, and chemistry since its discovery in 2004 . Like CNTs, graphene possesses many excellent properties, including large specific surface area (2630 m2 g−1) , outstanding thermal conductivity (ca. 5000 W m−1 K−1 for single-layer graphene) , high Young’s modulus (1.0 TPa) , good electrical conductivity (106 S cm−1), and excellent charge mobility (200,000 cm2 V−1 s−1) . Moreover, single-layer graphene is very transparent and therefore can be used as a transparent electrode . Superior to CNTs in many physical and chemical properties, graphene has attracted a great deal of interest in a host of potential applications, including fuel cells, solar cells, batteries, supercapacitors, field-effect transistors (FETs), sensors, and actuators [58, 59, 60, 64, 65, 66].
2.3 Nanostructured Graphite and Nanodiamond
Nanostructured graphite with specific surface areas over 400 m2 g−1 is produced by mechanical milling in a hydrogen atmosphere  in which a large amount of hydrogen can be incorporated into fragmented nanostructured graphite matrixes during the milling process . The hydrogen content, size, and structure of nanostructured graphite can be controlled by regulating milling conditions (e.g., time) . Apart from mechanical milling, hot-filament CVD has also been used for the production of nanostructured graphite .
Nanodiamonds (NDs) possess diamond structures on the nanometre scale and exhibit unique optoelectronic, mechanical, thermal, and biological properties useful in a variety of important applications [70, 71, 72, 73, 74]. Single crystals of cubic diamond nanoparticles of 4–5 nm in size were first discovered in 1963 by a group of Soviet scientists detonating an oxygen deficient 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene/hexogen composition in an inert media . Subsequent reports on the use of a stirred-media milling technique to well-dispersed ND particles [76, 77] have led to the preparation of novel dispersed ultra-nanocrystalline diamonds (4–5 nm). In addition to unique mechanical properties and environmental stability, nanodiamonds possess a high dielectric constant (3.5 K), a high electrical breakdown strength (787 V/μ), high operating temperatures (> 250 °C), and a low dissipation factor of 0.05% (at 25 °C, 1 kHz), making nanodiamonds promising candidate materials for important applications, such as microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) , field emission displays , electrochemical analyses , nanomedicines , and energy storage systems .
More recently, hierarchically structured 3D carbon nanomaterials (e.g., 3D pillared CNT-graphene architecture [80, 81]) have attracted considerable attention. Possessing a conjugated all-carbon structure with unusual molecular symmetries and hierarchal architectures, CNTs, graphene, and their 3D hybrids show interesting electronic, photonic, magnetic, electrocatalytic, and mechanical properties that are attractive for a wide range of potential applications. Of particular interest, hierarchically structured carbon nanomaterials have been studied as catalysts for a wide range of energy-related and environmental protection applications [82, 83, 84].
3 Design Strategies of Graphitic Carbon Catalysts
Since the discovery of the first low-cost, but efficient, platinum alternative carbon-based metal-free catalysts (i.e., nitrogen-doped vertically aligned carbon nanotube array, VA-NCNTs) for ORR in 2009 in alkaline electrolyte , various carbon-based catalysts doped with a variety of different heteroatoms (N, B, S, P, F, etc.) have been reported . These heteroatom dopants, either electron-rich (e.g., N) or electron-deficient (e.g., B), play at least two critical roles in activating graphitic sp2 carbon for ORR: (1) breaking the electroneutrality (χ) and/or spin distribution symmetry of sp2 carbon atoms within the graphitic network to create charge/spin redistribution to facilitate the chemisorption of O2 and/or ORR intermediate products, and (2) effectively utilizing heteroatom-doping-induced electron transfer for O2 reduction. Density functional theory (DFT) simulations indicate that the electrocatalytic activity of carbon-based catalysts is related to the electron spin and atomic charge density redistribution caused by doping [86, 87].
There are multiple factors, including the electronic structure of heteroatoms, the content and distribution of dopants, and the conductivity and architecture of resulting materials, that can affect the optimized performance of heteroatom-doped carbon catalysts. Thus, an increase in the heteroatom-doping content may not always enhance carbon-based catalyst performance . In fact, the type of heteroatom dopant is of vital importance in the performance enhancement for metal-free carbon catalysts. In particular, nitrogen can exist in many different forms in N-doped carbon catalysts, such as pyridine-like, pyrrole-like, graphitic nitrogen, and pyridine-N-oxide [3, 90]. Therefore, the understanding of the effects of N-dopant chemical nature on electrocatalytic performance is of great importance. For example, by using highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) model catalysts with well-defined π conjugation and well-controlled dopant N species, pyridinic N was found to be the active site for ORR in acidic electrolytes . Another independent study demonstrated that pyridine-N-oxide did not possess any ORR activity in which the complete loss of pyridine-N-oxide groups after long-term stability tests had no effect on catalyst activity .
Recently, Yang et al. demonstrated that electron-donating quaternary N sites were responsible for ORR, whereas electron-withdrawing pyridinic N moieties served as active sites for OER in alkaline electrolytes . Clearly, further combined theoretical and experimental research is needed to better understand the effects of the chemical nature of dopants.
Even with the same doping elements and types, heteroatom-doped carbon catalyst performances vary with dopant locations. For example, doping heteroatoms at the edge of graphene sheets with minimal damage to the carbon basal plane can impart solubility and electrocatalytic activity and largely retain the physicochemical properties of the pristine graphene [94, 95]. Because the dangling bonds at the edge of graphene sheets have been demonstrated to be more reactive than covalently bonded carbon atoms within the basal plane , edge-doped/functionalized carbon/graphene can act as active metal-free catalysts for many specific applications . Heteroatoms, such as Cl, Br, I, S, Se, and Sb, have also been introduced at the edge of graphene nanoplatelets (x-GnPs) through the ball milling of graphite powder in the presence of appropriate chemicals, such as Cl2, Br2, I2, S8, Se, and Sb [89, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103].
The performance of heteroatom-doped carbon catalysts can be further improved through co-doping with different heteroatoms (e.g., N and B, N and S, N and P). This is because increased numbers of dopant heteroatoms and electronic interactions between different doped heteroatoms often generate additional synergistic effects than single heteroatom-doped counterparts . With N as the primary dopant, B, S, and P can be used as secondary elements for co-doping carbon [4, 105]. Here, it was found that S-doping, followed by P-doping, greatly promotes HER. The doping of graphene with elements such as N, S, and F was also found to create active sites for ORR in both acidic and alkaline media .
3.2 Intermolecular Charge Transfer
In addition to the heteroatom-doping-induced intramolecular charge transfer or spin redistribution that boosts electrocatalytic activities of carbon-based catalysts described above, charge-transfer doping graphitic all-carbon carbon nanomaterials with electron acceptor(s) or donor(s) can induce intermolecular charge transfer to impart catalytic activities to heteroatom-free carbon catalysts [106, 107, 108]. Much like heteroatom-doping-induced intramolecular charge redistribution to facilitate ORR processes, the physical adsorption of certain (macro)molecules onto all-carbon CNTs  or graphene sheets  can cause intermolecular charge transfers to induce ORR electrocatalytic activities similar to those of commercial Pt/C catalysts. The first experimental evidence for intermolecular-charge-transfer-induced ORR catalytic activities of carbon-based catalysts was observed as early as 2011 by Wang et al. . In their particular case, quaternary ammonium functional groups along physically adsorbed PDDA backbones possessed a strong electron-accepting ability to withdraw electrons from carbon atoms in nanotube carbon planes to induce net positive charge (Fig. 1d), facilitating the ORR catalytic activities of dopant-free CNT/graphene adsorbed with PDDA chains [107, 108]. Subsequently, graphene molecularly doped with nitrobenzene for ORR was investigated using first-principles calculations . In this investigation, the active centers were found to be zigzag edges, doped armchair edges, and opposite-side edges of doped zigzag nanoribbons with high asymmetry spin/charge densities induced by intermolecular charge transfer (Fig. 1e).
The demonstration that all-carbon CNTs/graphene sheets can be converted into efficient metal-free ORR electrocatalysts simply through adsorption-induced intermolecular charge transfer presents considerable avenues for the cost-effective preparation of various metal-free catalysts for ORR and even new catalytic materials for applications beyond ORR. Therefore, the aforementioned strategies should provide general approaches to the design of metal-free carbon-based catalysts for a wide range of applications.
3.3 Defect-Induced Charge Transfer
Like all crystalline materials, certain amounts of disorders or defects are unavoidable in graphitic carbons because of the second law of thermodynamics . In general, intrinsic defects in nanocarbon structures, including vacancies, voids, Stone–Wales defects, dislocation, and grain boundaries [110, 111, 112], often result from the absence of certain atoms and/or reconstruction of the lattice, leading to breaks in electron–hole symmetry . These defective regions in graphitic carbon materials, with dangling groups, hydrogen saturation, or reconstruction free from dangling groups, have been widely demonstrated to alter local densities of π-electrons and increase chemical reactivities . In-plane topological defects (e.g., pentagons and heptagons, instead of hexagonal rings) usually exist in graphitic carbon skeletons. These defects can also locally induce Gaussian curvatures to alter bond lengths and rehybridize electron orbitals , leading to electron redistribution and therefore high ORR activities . In addition, the ORR performance of N-doped graphene can also be greatly enhanced by Stone–Wales defects, which decrease the HOMO–LUMO energy gap of nanoscale graphene domains and change reaction pathways [116, 117].
Well-defined pore distributions and defects can affect the catalytic activity of carbon-based catalysts [111, 112, 119, 120, 121, 122]. In 2015, Jin et al. reported a new class of ORR catalysts based on graphene quantum dots supported by graphene nanoribbons with ORR performances comparable to or even better than that of Pt/C electrodes . These performances were attributed to the presence of numerous edge defects on quantum dots and graphene nanoribbons, coupled with efficient charge transfer between the two. Jiang et al. also developed defective carbon nanocages with ORR activities better than that of B-doped carbon nanotubes and comparable to that of N-doped carbon nanostructures (Fig. 2b)  with DFT calculations indicating that pentagon and zigzag edge defects were responsible for the observed high ORR activity for the defective carbon nanocages (Fig. 2c) . Recently, defective graphene (DG) materials have also been prepared from N-doped precursors using a facile nitrogen removal procedure (Fig. 2d)  which can create different types of defects for multifunctional catalytic reactions such as ORR, OER, and HER. In a similar study, a defective porous carbon (PC) material with only carbon and oxygen was synthesized through the carbonization of Zn-MOF (IRMOF-8) at 950 °C, followed by the removal of Zn atoms during the calcination process and exhibited excellent electrocatalytic activity, molecular selectivity, and long-term durability . More recently, metal-free carbon-based ORR/OER catalysts with topological defects were fabricated through the direct carbonization of carbon/nitrogen precursors on MgO templates . These as-obtained defective rich graphene materials consisting of predominantly few-layer thick graphitic carbon sheets with abundant in-plane nanopores (Fig. 2e) exhibited more favorable ORR performances than Pt/C with similar onset potentials, higher current densities, and much better durabilities in O2-saturated 0.10 M KOH. Here, DFT calculations (Fig. 2f) revealed that topological defects at the edge play an even more important role than doping and edge effects on catalytic performance with the N-free intrinsic defect of an adjacent pentagon and heptagon being identified as the optimal defect configuration to induce catalytic activities for both ORR and OER, as evidenced by the peak position in volcano plots (Fig. 2f). Additionally, dangling bonds located at the edge of sp2 nanocarbons after saturation by hydrogen can act as high-energy sites and catalytic centers for many acid–base or redox reactions . It was demonstrated that graphene edges showed a two-time higher ORR reactivity, a 4 orders of magnitude larger specific capacitance, and a faster electron-transfer rate than basal planes (Fig. 2g, h) [124, 125]. The observed edge enhanced electrocatalytic activity was further confirmed by precise measurements of ORR activity at the edge or basal-plane regions of HOPG using a micro-apparatus (Fig. 2i) . In addition, edge-rich and dopant-free CNTs and graphene were developed as highly efficient ORR electrocatalysts , and the activity origin of aerobic oxidation in porous graphene oxide (GO) catalysts was elucidated to be caused by edge sites with unpaired electrons and carboxylic groups favorable for O2 trapping and electron transport. Recent developments in defective carbon catalysts have demonstrated the critical role of edge and intrinsic defects in regulating catalytic performance of carbon catalysts [94, 119], and this is an area that will clearly benefit from further research.
3.4 Combined Effects
For heterogeneous catalysis, the active sites of a catalyst need to be exposed at the surface rather than at the bulk structure to maximize accessibility to reactants so as to increase the catalytic efficiency. Therefore, it is important to develop catalysts with desired macrostructures to achieve high exposures of active sites. For this purpose, N-doped carbon coaxial nanocables, consisting of a pristine CNT core and an N-doped carbon layered shell, were demonstrated to be an ideal metal-free carbon-based catalyst for both ORR and OER (Fig. 3b) . In this case, the intact inner tubes can act as effective electronic conducting pathways for effective charge transfer through electron tunneling between the outer wall and inner tubes and the outer wall can provide reaction sites for the absorption and dissociation of OH− and OOH* species. Similarly, N- and S-doped CNTs with superb bifunctional catalytic activities for both HER and OER in alkaline solution were also developed by improving active-site exposure (Fig. 3c) . These studies confirm that observed excellent bifunctional catalytic performances are attributable to co-doping, coupled with the efficient mass and charge transfer of carbon catalysts with high active site exposure. High HER performance has also been achieved by coupling graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) with N-doped graphene (N-G) to combine intermolecular charge transfer with heteroatom-doping . DFT calculations indicate an apparent electron transfer from conductive N-G to g-C3N4, leading to an electron-rich region on the g-C3N4 layer and a hole-rich region on the N-graphene layer (Fig. 3d, e). In a similar but independent study, g-C3N4 was coupled with S,Se-co-doped porous graphene (pGr) through a scalable approach to prepare a catalyst (Fig. 3f)  that produced high HER performance and robust stability over a wide pH range. These studies demonstrate the effectiveness of chemical and electronic coupling to promote proton adsorption and reduction kinetics.
In typical gas-involved heterogeneous catalysis, porous structures with massive pore edges can promote interfacial catalytic reactions and subsequent gas desorption [134, 135]. Therefore, the porosity of carbon-based catalysts is another critical factor in controlling catalytic activities, and the construction of carbon catalysts with highly porous or hybrid macrostructure of large surface areas is highly desirable. Because of this, the catalytic performance of crumpled graphene sheets can be significantly enhanced by generating nanoholes within the constituent graphene layers. In this context, N-doped graphene materials with relatively uniform mesopores (MPG) have been synthesized using a micelle-template, followed by N-doping, as effective HER catalysts . N-rich holey graphene monoliths (Nr-HGM) have also been prepared by pyrolysis of GO and ammonium sulfate  to opening “windows” for efficient mass transfer of electrolytes and/or hydrogen, and thus improved HER activity (Fig. 3g). Furthermore, the catalytic performance of an electrode can further be enhanced by tailoring the macrostructure of the electrode to maximize the exposure of active sites. This, coupled with controlled heteroatom-doping, creates synergistic effects .
4 Doped Nanocarbons as Metal-Free Electrocatalysts for Energy Devices
4.1 Carbon-Based Metal-Free ORR Electrocatalysts for Fuel Cells
Fuel cells convert chemical energy directly into electricity by electrochemically oxidizing fuels (e.g., H2) and reducing oxygen into water, providing instant power output with high energy conversion efficiencies and high power densities without any detrimental effects on the environment [139, 140, 141]. However, noble metal catalysts (e.g., Pt) are required for hydrogen oxidation at the anode and ORR at the cathode [142, 143]. The slow ORR on the cathode is a key limiting step to the energy conversion efficiency of fuel cells and requires substantial amounts of Pt catalysts. Carbon-based ORR electrocatalysts as low-cost alternatives to Pt have attracted significant attention due to high electrocatalytic activities, long-term stabilities, high selectivities, and scalabilities of the catalysts. Excellent ORR performance, especially in alkaline media [64, 85], has been demonstrated for many carbon-based ORR catalysts.
Of particular interest, VA-NCNTs can act as metal-free electrodes to catalyze ORR processes free from CO “poisoning” with a 3-times higher electrocatalytic activity, much smaller crossover effect, and better long-term operational stability than that of commercially available platinum/C electrodes (C2-20, 20% platinumonVulcanXC-72R; E-TEK) in alkaline fuel cells. This improved catalytic performance is attributed to the electron-accepting ability of nitrogen atoms which create net positive charges on adjacent carbon atoms in the nanotube carbon plane of VA-NCNTs to enhance O2 adsorption and attract electrons readily from the anode to facilitate ORR . The elucidation of this new ORR mechanism is significant and can be applied to the development of various other metal-free catalysts for fuel cell applications and even beyond fuel cells (vide infra).
Subsequently, Rao and Ishikawa  prepared metal-free VA-NCNTs with a N content of 8.0 at% by template-assisted pyrolysis. The resultant VA-NCNTs exhibited an ORR activity comparable to Pt/C with a 4-electron pathway and higher ethanol tolerance than Pt/C in alkali solution. In their further evaluation in anion-exchange membrane fuel cells (AEMFCs), the VA-NCNT and Pt/C electrodes exhibited a current density of 11 and 38 mA cm−2, respectively, at 0.7 V, along with a corresponding maximum power density of 37.3 and 61.7 mW cm−2. Whereas the majority of recent studies on carbon nanostructured metal-free electrocatalysts focus on ORR reactions in alkaline electrolytes, fuel cells that operate with acidic electrolytes, particularly polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFC) [14, 15], can have a more significant economic impact. Therefore, the development of effective metal-free carbon-based catalysts for acidic electrolytes is important, though still challenging [16, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150].
Shui et al.  recently demonstrated that both the VA-NCNT array and a rationally designed N-doped graphene/CNT/carbon black (Ketjenblack, KB) composite (N-G-CNT/KB) membrane electrode assembly (MEA) (Fig. 4c-e) with a well-defined porous structure exhibit excellent long-term operational stabilities and high gravimetric power densities in PEMFCs. A consistent polarization performance was observed with a peak power density over 320 W g−1 for the VA-NCNT MEA (Fig. 4f), outperforming or comparable to even the most active non-precious metal catalysts (i.e., Fe/N/C, Fig. 4g). Although such catalysts may accelerate the delivery of affordable and durable PEM fuel cells, the catalytic performance of carbon-based metal-free catalysts in acidic medium still requires further improvements to meet practical application requirements.
4.2 Bifunctional ORR/OER Metal-Free Catalysts for Metal-Air Batteries
Since the optimal active-site structures for different energy-related reactions (e.g., ORR, OER, and HER) are often not identical, bifunctional or multifunctional catalysts with more than one type of active sites are needed. Therefore, bifunctional metal-free carbon catalysts for ORR/OER [155, 156], OER/HER, and ORR/HER as well as tri-functional metal-free carbon catalysts for ORR/OER/HER have been developed [17, 25, 29, 155, 157, 158, 159].
Because of high theoretical energy densities, metal-air batteries have attracted ever-increasing interests for electric vehicle (EV) and hybrid electric vehicle (HEV) applications [160, 161, 162]. However, low energy efficiency, power density and short cycle life have hindered practical applications. To alleviate these problems, low-cost and efficient bifunctional ORR/OER catalysts are required. Carbon-based catalysts, possessing easily tunable structures and desirable bifunctional catalytic activities for both ORR and OER, are good selections for metal-air batteries . In this section, the applications of carbon-based metal-free catalysts for Li-air batteries are highlighted, including Li-O2 and Zn-air batteries.
4.2.1 Heteroatom-Doped Carbon for Li-Air Batteries
Doping heteroatoms into graphitic carbon structures can modify electronic and physicochemical properties of carbon materials and generate active sites for oxygen reduction [4, 29, 163, 164, 165]. Thus, heteroatom-doped carbon catalysts with desired pores are attractive for advanced Li-air batteries [166, 167, 168, 169, 170]. The diversity in carbon structure and morphology enables possible optimizations for gas/electrolyte diffusion and electron transport. For instance, N-doping has been demonstrated to increase catalytic activation sites for Li2O2 formations at carbon cathodes, thereby reducing charge overpotentials in Li-O2 batteries [168, 169, 171, 172]. The introduction of N species into onion-like carbons can modify electron distributions to facilitate oxygen chemisorption, leading to enhanced ORR and OER kinetics, energy output, and recharging characteristics of Li-O2 batteries . N-doping of graphene has also been demonstrated to facilitate the nucleation of Li2O2 clusters, again leading to improved electrochemical performances . Li-air batteries based on N-doped CNTs with uniform distributions of nitrogen species ensure large numbers of nucleation sites and high dispersion of discharge products, enhancing discharge capacities .
In addition to N-doping, other heteroatom-doping or co-doping has also been demonstrated to positively contribute to catalytic activity enhancements and cell performances. In this context, N-doping was demonstrated to contribute to discharge capacities and S-doping was verified to favor stable cycling behaviors in graphene-based Li-O2 batteries . Based on first-principles thermodynamics, Ren et al. predicted that B-doped graphene can improve charge rates of Li-air batteries and reduce O2 evolution barriers by ca. 0.4 eV . Indeed, B-doped graphene was found to provide stronger adsorption for Li2O2 than the pristine graphene. Thus, the introduction of B into graphene architectures can active Li-O bonds and oxidize O22− to O2 .
4.2.2 Defect and Pore Controlled Carbon Nanostructures for Li-Air Batteries
The introduction of defects into carbon materials can generate active sites for electrochemical reactions and is proven to be an effective strategy to improve catalytic activities of carbon-based materials for ORR and OER [111, 114]. Therefore, defects are also considered to be a good means to achieve the high performance in metal-air batteries. Combining theoretical and experimental studies, lattice defect sites were confirmed to play a critical role in the formation of small-sized discharge products for Li-O2 batteries  in which Li2O2 prefers to nucleate and form near functionalized lattice defects on graphene. These isolated nanosized Li2O2 formations on the graphene sheet ensured smooth oxygen transport during discharge processes. Partially cracked carbon nanotubes with active edge sites and various pores have also been used as catalysts for Li-air batteries, producing an almost 2 times higher discharge capacity than raw nanotubes . Generally speaking, micropores can induce high surface areas and facilitate rapid gas diffusion, ensuring a large solid–liquid–gas region, whereas mesopores can effectively improve electrode–electrolyte interactions and provide more active sites for electrochemical reactions. Macropores can reduce the blockage of electrolytes and oxygen pathways to improve O2 diffusion and reversible conversion [175, 176]. Because discharge products, such as Li2O2, continuously accumulate on the surface of cathode catalysts during cycling processes, it can clog electrodes and cause electrodes to electrically disconnected. Therefore, porous carbon materials with rationally designed architectures are highly desirable as cathode materials , with the capacity of Li-O2 batteries using carbon cathodes being mainly determined by the surface area, pore volume and pore size available for the deposition of discharge products [177, 178].
Carbon-based catalysts with ordered pores have also been used to achieve high performances for Li-air batteries. For instance, Park et al.  employed ordered mesoporous carbon (OMC) materials as an oxygen electrode to significantly reduce charge potentials in which OMC channels can limit the size of discharge products through the confined formation of Li2O2. Ordered mesoporous/macroporous channels can further improve electrolyte immersion and facilitate Li+ diffusion and electron transfer (Fig. 5c). Designed hierarchical porous architectures with macropores surrounded by ordered mesoporous channels can provide enough space for O2 diffusion and O2/Li2O2 conversion, leading to perfect cycling performance (Fig. 5d) .
In addition to hierarchical pores and ordered pores, 3D interconnected porous frameworks were also found to improve the performance of Li-O2 batteries. This is because 3D frameworks provide an ideal backbone support for catalytically active sites . In particular, 3D porous N-doped graphene networks constructed with interconnected nanocages possess great potential in Li-O2 batteries , showing a high rate capacity of 5987 mAh g−1 at 3200 mA g−1, and a long cycle stability of 54 cycles at 1000 mA g−1. These 3D interpenetrated frameworks can not only provide multidimensional conductive networks and large areas to accommodate discharge products but can also function as “highways” for the rapid transport of O2 and Li+ within the entire electrode matrix.
4.2.3 Carbon-Based Bifunctional Catalysts for Zn-Air Batteries
Among all metal-air battery technologies, Zn-air battery technology is the most mature and are considered to be one of the most viable options to power electric vehicles in the future due to its high theoretical energy density (1086 Wh kg−1) and low costs [180, 181]. However, the development of rechargeable Zn-air batteries has been impeded by low power output capabilities associated with a lack of satisfactory air catalysts and limited cyclabilities of Zn anodes. ORR and OER electrocatalysts have important impacts on the power density, energy efficiency, and lifetime of Zn-air batteries and much effort has been made to develop proper electrocatalysts to reduce ORR overpotentials and enhance battery discharge performances. Pt is an excellent ORR catalyst for Zn-air batteries, but it has poor OER performances and its widespread use is prohibited by its scarcity and high costs. Thus, it is crucial to explore alternative earth-abundant, low-cost, and highly effective electrocatalysts. Here, carbon-based metal-free catalysts with remarkable performances for ORR and OER, together with low costs, high corrosion resistance, and high earth abundancy, have become attractive for applications in Zn-air batteries [25, 182].
Compared with N-doped carbon bifunctional ORR and OER catalysts, co-doping carbon nanomaterials with different heteroatoms provide more efficient modulation of electronic properties and surface polarities to further increase ORR and OER activities. By using a N,P-doped carbon foam as the ORR/OER bifunctional catalyst, Dai and co-workers  developed highly efficient Zn-air batteries (Fig. 6d) in which their primary battery produced an open circuit potential of 1.48 V, a specific capacity of 735 mAh g Zn −1 (corresponding to an energy density of 835 Wh kg Zn −1 ), a peak power density of 55 mW cm−2, and sustain stable operations for 240 h after mechanical recharging. Their two-electrode rechargeable battery also cycled stably for 180 cycles at 2 mA cm−2. Even at 2 mA cm−2, a three-electrode rechargeable battery using their N,P-doped carbon foam produced acceptable stability (600 cycles for 100 h) (Fig. 6e) .
To meet the demand for flexible high-energy storage, significant efforts have also been made to develop various flexible power sources. In this regard, Liu et al.  prepared a nanoporous carbon nanofiber film as the air cathode in a liquid Zn-air battery and a flexible all-solid-state rechargeable Zn-air battery. The liquid Zn-air battery produced a maximum power density of 185 mW cm−2, an energy density of 776 Wh kg−1, a small voltage gap of 0.73 V at 10 mA cm−2, and an excellent stability of up to 500 cycles. As for the flexible all-solid-state device (Fig. 7b), a low overpotential (0.78 V at 2 mA cm−2) and a long cycle life (6 h) under repeated bending conditions were achieved (Fig. 7c), indicating excellent cycling performance with high mechanical stability.
4.3 Carbon-Based Metal-Free OER/HER Bifunctional Catalysts for Water Splitting
Water and sunlight are both renewable and readily available; therefore, sustainable energy generation from water and sunlight holds great promise in solving current energy and environmental challenges. The electrocatalytic water electrolysis reaction H2O → 1/2O2 + H2 consists of two half-reactions of water oxidation (i.e., OER) and proton reduction (i.e., HER), attractive for H2 and O2 production without the involvement of fossil fuels or the generation of greenhouse gases.
In 2013, Zhao et al.  first reported N-doped graphite nanomaterials that were generated from direct pyrolysis of N-rich polymers as metal-free catalysts exhibiting comparable OER catalytic activities to non-precious metal catalysts in basic mediums. Subsequently, Zheng et al. prepared C3N4@N-doped graphene as a metal-free electrocatalyst for sustainable and efficient H2 production under acidic and alkaline conditions . Thereafter, various heteroatom-doped carbon materials have been exploited as metal-free, active and stable OER and/or HER catalysts, as briefly described in previous reviews [4, 11].
A facile two-step method was developed to fabricate N,S-co-doped graphite foam (NSGF) from commercial graphite foils (GFL) , and the resultant NSGF, possessing high electrical conductivity, good flexibility, and good mechanical strength, was directly used as an electrocatalytic electrode for water oxidation. Similarly, N and F dual-doped porous graphene nanosheets (NFPGNS, Fig. 8b) have been synthesized as efficient OER/HER bifunctional metal-free electrocatalysts for overall water splitting . By combining co-doping with structural regulation, 2D N,S-co-doped graphitic sheets with a unique hierarchical structure consisting of stereoscopic holes over graphitic surfaces (SHG) were developed as tri-functional catalysts for ORR, OER, and HER (Fig. 8c) . The presence of stereoscopic holes ensures high surface areas with abundant interfacial active sites for electrochemical reactions. Heteroatom-doping of SHG with nitrogen and sulfur atoms can also modulate electronic and chemical characteristics to further impart functionalities. Abundant accessible active sites coupled with efficient pathways for electron and electrolyte/reactant transport allow the newly developed SHG to be applied as an efficient metal-free ORR/OER/HER tri-functional catalyst with long-term stability in alkaline electrolytes, and its applications as a multifunctional catalyst were demonstrated in a water-splitting device .
Aside from these N-doped, N,F- or N,S-co-doped carbon-based OER/HER bifunctional catalysts for water splitting, a N,O-co-doped porous carbon OER/HER bifunctional catalyst was prepared by pyrolyzing a metal–organic framework (MOF); such as zeolitic imidazolate framework-8 (ZIF-8), followed by H2SO4 modulation (Fig. 8d), and demonstrated high performances for water splitting with a current density of 10 mA cm−2 over 8 h under a potential of 1.82 V and a faraday efficiency (FE) of 98.0–99.1% in 0.1 M KOH electrolyte . N,P,O-tri-doped porous graphite carbon@oxidized carbon cloth (donated as: PGC/OCC) has also been developed for overall water splitting with a low overpotential of 410 mV, a current density of 10 mA cm−2, a small Tafel slope of 83 mV dec−1, and a long-term electrochemical durability . Impressively, this 3D porous carbon cloth catalyst showed not only high catalytic performances in alkaline water electrolyzers (10 mA cm−2 at a cell voltage of 1.66 V) but also superior catalytic activity and stability under both strongly acidic and neutral conditions. This observed excellent HER and OER catalytic performance was attributed to the high conductivity of graphitized carbon, the unique 3D porous architecture between PGC and OCC, and the presence of electron-rich phosphorus and nitrogen dopants. Another carbon-based metal-free OER/HER bifunctional catalyst for high-performance water splitting is defect-rich porous carbon (DRPC) prepared using a template approach. This catalyst was also used for self-powered electrochemical water splitting (Fig. 8e-g) to demonstrate its great potential for practical applications .
4.4 Carbon-Based Metal-Free ORR-OER-HER Tri-functional Catalysts for Integrated Energy Devices
Chemical energy in the form of H2 can be generated by splitting water, which in turn can be used in fuel cells to produce clean electricity to meet growing energy demands. For this purpose, the low-cost production of H2 through water splitting by either the direct use of sunlight for photocatalytic water splitting or through electricity generated from photovoltaic devices for photoelectrochemical water splitting is essential. Through photocatalytic and/or photoelectrochemical water splitting, clean electricity can be continuously generated from water and sunlight by simply feeding fuel cells with hydrogen and oxygen gases from water splitting to produce electricity with water being the only by-product. The water by-product can then be reused for photocatalytic/photoelectrochemical water splitting to maintain the whole cycle for renewable generation of clean electricity. To realize this ideal energy cycle, efficient catalysts are required for HER, OER, and ORR.
Recently, metal-free photocatalysts based on carbon dots/g-C3N4 have been reported . Lee and co-workers  found that a very small loading of carbon dots (0.0016 wt%) embedded in the matrix of g-C3N4 can lead to stable overall water splitting to H2 and O2 in a stoichiometric ratio under visible light for at least 200 days. Remarkably, a solar-to-hydrogen yield of 2% was obtained with a carbon dot loading of 0.48 wt% under AM 1.5G solar simulation .
Through a facile procedure to remove nitrogen from a N-doped precursor, Yao and co-workers  developed high-performance defect-induced tri-functional carbon catalysts for ORR, OER, and HER. Zhang et al. , also prepared a high-performance ORR/OER/HER tri-functional metal-free catalyst through in situ tri-doping of a self-assembled graphene foam with N, P, and F (Fig. 9b). The resultant N,P,F-tri-doped graphene foam was tested as an OER/HER bifunctional catalyst for oxygen and hydrogen gas production in an electrochemical water-splitting unit that was powered by an integrated Zn-air battery based on an air electrode made from the same electrocatalyst for ORR (Fig. 9c-e) . Although recent studies have demonstrated the feasibility of constructing integrated energy systems of (photo)electrochemical or even photocatalytic water splitting coupled with fuel cells, practical applications are still not within reach.
4.5 Carbon-Based Metal-Free Catalysts for Solar Cells and Metal-I2 Batteries
Like graphene-based catalysts, defective CNT microballs have also been used to replace Pt-based cathodes in DSSCs to achieve remarkable energy conversion efficiencies of about 7% [34, 35]. Of particular interest, a free-standing vertically aligned N-doped CNT array, instead of randomly oriented CNTs, has also been used as a counter-electrode catalyst in DSSCs to exhibit a high power conversion efficiency of 7.04%, which is close to that of conventional Pt counter electrodes . A vertically aligned SWCNT array also displayed a high conversion efficiency of 5.5%, comparable to 5.6% obtained with a Pt-based DSSC tested under the same conditions . In addition, carbon catalysts comprised of CNTs coated onto a flexible graphene paper achieved 83% conversion efficiency of that of a Pt electrode .
In addition to solar cells, the redox reactions of iodine also play a vital role in Li/Na-I2 batteries. However, the development of economically efficient and highly conducting iodine-based cathodes with stable and high iodine loading is challenging . Several carbon hosts, including carbon black , nanoporous carbon , vertically aligned carbon nanotubes , and porous carbon microtubes , have been employed to load I2 for Li-I2 batteries.
Inspired by the excellent electrocatalytic activities induced by heteroatom-doping for metal-air batteries [25, 202] and its significant effects on enhancing capacity and cycling stability of Na/Li-ion batteries , Lu et al.  used hierarchical porous N,P-co-doped carbon matrixes as hosts for I2 loading in I2-based batteries (Fig. 10e). Here, high discharge capacities of 386 and 253 mAh g−1 with good stabilities up to 2000 cycles and 500 cycles were achieved for Li-I2 and Na-I2 batteries, respectively, based on iodine-containing cathodes. Excellent reversible capacities with good capacity retentions (e.g., 76.7% after 500 cycles and 69.8% after 300 cycles at 500 mA g−1) were also obtained even for Li-I2 and Na-I2 batteries with I2-contained hierarchical porous N,P-doped carbon matrix cathodes and hierarchical porous N,P-doped carbon matrix anodes.
4.6 Carbon-Based Metal-Free Catalysts for CO2 Reduction and Li-CO2 Batteries
Comparison of materials, preparation methods, specific performances, and characteristics of reported metal-free carbon-based catalysts for CO2RR
N-doped carbon fibers
Electrospinning and carbonization
An order of magnitude higher current density compared with silver catalysts
The first metal-free carbon-based catalyst for RRCO2
Microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition
High FE (74%) for formaldehyde production
The first B-doped diamond catalyst for CO2RR
N-doped carbon nanotubes
Liquid chemical vapor deposition
Conversion selectivity of CO2 to CO can reach 80%
With large amounts of pyridinic N active sites
Photolithography and deposition
Converts CO2 to acetate with an onset potential of − 0.36 V
Good selectivity for converting CO2 to acetate over formate
Current remains at least 3 times higher than that of graphene electrodes
Reveal mechanistic details of CO2 adsorption and subsequent conversion to formic acid/formate
Nanometre-size N-doped graphene quantum dots
Exfoliating and cutting graphene oxide
A high total FE of carbon dioxide reduction of up to 90%, with selectivity for ethylene and ethanol conversions reaching 45%
Generates C2 and C3 production
N-doped mesoporous carbon
Efficient production of ethanol with nearly 100% selectivity and high FEof 77% at − 0.56 V
Synergetic effects of N-doping and cylindrical channel configurations facilitate superior electrocatalytic performance for synthesizing ethanol
Hydrothermal process and electrodeposition
Ethanol selectivity achieved on BND with a high FE of 93.2% (− 1.0 V)
The first co-doped nanodiamond for CO2RR
As seen in Fig. 11, metal-free carbon catalysts based on N-doped carbon nanofibers (NCNFs) generated from the electrospinning of polyacrylonitrile (PAN) was first reported in 2013 for CO2RR . Subsequently, N-doped CNTs (NCNTs) were demonstrated to be highly active, selective, and stable catalysts for the electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO [37, 38, 39, 40]. Combined XPS analyses and DFT calculations indicate that pyridinic N plays an important role in CO2RR, whereas for graphitic N, electrons are localized in the π antibonding orbital, becoming less accessible for CO2 binding. Pyrrolic N is believed to have minimal impacts on CO2RR. This is because pyrrolic N atoms are often located toward the center of the carbon framework, making it difficult for lone pairs of pyrrolic N to be accessible for CO2 binding. N-doped graphene (NG) electrocatalysts have also been demonstrated to show robust electrocatalytic activities toward CO2RR [38, 215]. Particularly, N-doped graphene-like carbon materials (NGMs) were reported to be highly efficient electrocatalysts for CO2RR in ionic liquid electrolytes (e.g., 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate, [BMIM]BF4) to produce CH4 as the main product with a FE as high as 93.5% and a more than 6 times higher current density than metal Cu-based catalysts .
Along with N-doped carbon fibers and CNTs, boron-doped graphene (BG) has also been studied for the reduction of CO2 to formate . Even boron-doped diamonds (BDD) have been demonstrated to show promising catalytic activity for the reduction of CO2 to methanol, despite diamonds being often considered chemically inert . Here, it was found that sp3-bonded carbons on BDD can act as active sites for CO2RR. Because C2 products are more valuable than C1 products, the development of efficient carbon electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO2 to C2 products is highly desirable. N-doped diamonds (NDD) can serve as promising electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction to not only C1 products (formate), but also C2 products (acetate) with high efficiency, fast kinetics, and good selectivity . The higher production rates for acetate than formate on NDD catalysts indicate that C–C coupling preferentially occurs at the initial stage of CO2RR. Co-doping was also found to enhance CO2 reduction. Here, B,N-co-doped diamonds (BND) were found to be efficient and stable electrodes for the selective reduction of CO2 to ethanol  in which B- and N-doping regulates the electronic structure of the diamond [217, 218] through synergistic effects to convert CO2 into highly reduced C2 products (i.e., CH3CH2OH). N,S-co-doped polymer-derived carbon (CPSN) was also demonstrated to be an electrocatalyst for CO2RR; producing a higher FE than S-doped polymer-derived carbons (CPS), with positively charged carbon atoms in the vicinity of pyridinic N- and/or S-heteroatoms being main active sites .
Much like carbon catalysts for other electrocatalytic reactions discussed above, 3D architectures and topological defects also play important roles in regulating CO2 reduction. For example, graphitic carbon nitride/carbon nanotube composites (g-C3N4/CNT), displaying good catalytic performances for CO2RR to CO with a maximum FE of 60% at an applied potential of − 0.75 V, can attribute its high catalytic activity to the N-doping, high specific surface area (123.4 m2 g−1), and high electrical conductivity of CNTs . In an independent study, a binder-free N-doped nanoporous carbon/CNT (HNCM-CNT) composite electrode was also demonstrated to show high activity, selectivity, and stability for formate production from CO2, achieving a high FE of 81% .
With rich topology and edges , N-doped graphene quantum dots (NGQDs) were reported as active metal-free electrocatalysts for CO2RR with high reduction current densities at low overpotentials. By regulating the applied potential, CO2 can be reduced on NGQDs into a series of species ranging from C1 to C3 products. Recent studies confirm that products from CO2RR can be controlled by structure configurations of N-doped carbon-based catalysts. A class of mesoporous and inverse mesoporous N-doped carbons with highly uniform cylindrical channels were subsequently developed to dramatically boost C–C bond formations in CO2 electroreductions . The uniformly distributed pyridinic/pyrrolic N sites on the inner surface of the cylindrical channels efficiently supply electrons necessary for the dimerization of CO* intermediates to produce ethanol.
The electrochemical reduction of CO2 to more reduced organic feedstocks (e.g., HCOOH, CH3OH, C2H4, CH4, CO) is a promising method to store energy from intermittent electricity sources (i.e., wind and solar) and synthesize carbon-based compounds from CO2 through carbon fixation. Compared with CO2RR using metal-based electrocatalysts  however, CO2RR using metal-free carbon-based electrocatalysts still require further development. Continued research efforts in this growing field will lead to eventual commercialization, allowing for both efficient energy storage and environmental protection.
5 Concluding Remarks
Upon doping of heteroatoms and/or introduction of defects into carbon networks, graphitic carbon materials exhibit interesting catalytic properties that are attractive for eco-friendly electrochemical energy conversion and storage applications, including water-splitting, dye-sensitized solar cells, metal-air batteries, fuel cells, and carbon dioxide reductions. The combination of photocatalytic/photoelectrochemical water splitting for on-site generation of O2 and H2 gases with H2-O2 fuel cells creates a cost-effective and H2-storage-free approach toward the renewable generation of clean electricity from sunlight and water. Sustainable energy generation from water and sunlight holds great promise as a solution to current energy and environmental challenges. However, low-cost but efficient catalysts are required. Recent developments in carbon nanomaterials with various architectures offer opportunities for the development of advanced carbon-based catalysts with multifunctionalities. The introduction of heteroatoms (e.g., N) and/or defects into graphitic carbon nanomaterials has been demonstrated to cause electron modulation to provide desirable electronic structures for many catalytic processes, including ORR, OER, HER, triiodide reduction, and CO2RR. Although numerous progresses have been achieved, there are still many challenges that must be overcome in order for carbon-based catalysts to replace metal-based counterparts in commercial applications.
In most cases, the exact catalytic role and location of heteroatoms in carbon-based catalysts are still not fully understood, and long-term durability, particularly in practical devices, has not been tested with standard evaluation protocols. Difficulties in determining active-site structures hinder efforts to precisely control active sites and hence electrocatalytic performance. Therefore, new synthetic and/or doping strategies must be developed to precisely control the location, content, and distribution of dopants in heteroatom-doped carbon catalysts. The development of in situ, real-time characterization techniques is also important to probe the nature of active sites and to understand electrocatalytic mechanisms. Combined experimental and theoretical approaches are crucial as computer simulations and calculations have been proven to be powerful tools in the search for active centers and the study of the basic sciences behind electrocatalysis. In addition to further studies into catalytic mechanisms and kinetics, long-term performance evaluations of metal-free carbon-based catalysts in various actual devices need to be performed. For industrial applications, the development of facial and cost-effective methods for large-scale production of carbon nanomaterials with well-defined structures and catalytic properties is essential. With the large number of carbon catalysts already reported and more to be developed, the possibility of producing multifunctional carbon-based metal-free catalysts with exotic electrocatalytic properties suitable for a wide range of energy devices and environmental protection systems can soon be achieved. Continued research and development in this exciting field will overcome major hurdles faced by carbon catalysts for energy conversion and storage and environmental protection, leading to better fuel economy, decreased harmful emissions, and reduced reliance on petroleum sources.
We would like to thank our colleagues for their contributions to the works cited. We are also grateful for the financial support from NSF (CMMI-1400274, DOD-AFOSR-MURI (FA9550-12-1-0037), NASA (NNX16AD48A, NNC16CA42C), the Key Program of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51732002), the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2017YFA0206500), the Distinguished Scientist Program at BUCT (buctylkxj02), and the National Basic Research Program of China (2011CB013000).
- 44.Dai, L. (ed.): Carbon Nanotechnology: Recent Developments in Chemistry, Physics, Materials Science and Device Applications. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2006)Google Scholar
- 71.Xing, Y., Dai, L.: Nanodiamonds for nanomedicine. Nanomedicine (London, UK) 4, 207 (2009) Google Scholar
- 77.Gruen, D.: Ultrananocrystalline diamond films from fullerene precursors. In: Osawa, E., (ed.) Perspectives of Fullerene Nanotechnology. Springer, Dortrecht (2002)Google Scholar
- 92.Zhang, H.R., Liang, E.J., Ding, P., et al.: Production and growth mechanisms of BCN nanotubes. Acta Phys. Sin. 51, 2901–2905 (2002)Google Scholar
- 141.Wang, S.Y., Jiang, S.P.: Prospects of fuel cell technologies. Natl. Sci. Rev. 4, 163–166 (2017)Google Scholar
- 143.Schmidt, T.J., Markovic, N.M.: Encyclopedia of Surface and Colloid Science. Taylor & Francis, New York (2006)Google Scholar
- 157.Li, X.H., Antonietti, M.: Polycondensation of boron-and nitrogen-codoped holey graphene monoliths from molecules: carbocatalysts for selective oxidation. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 52, 457–4576 (2013)Google Scholar