Abstract
Human trafficking is an increasing field of academic research, but the obstacles of investigation and prosecution of traffickers is still under-researched. This article analyses the challenges of prosecution of criminal groups facilitating the prostitution of Hungarian women to Western European countries by focusing on international cooperation of law enforcement agencies. Although the scientific literature mostly focuses on the influence of international agreements on national level policing, based on a multilevel analysis, the current article scrutinizes the organizational and individual dimensions in transnational policing and the implementation of the anti-trafficking measures in practice. Despite the aims of the global prohibition regime, victim-focus approach in human trafficking remains neglected by large in the Hungarian practice. The article is based on structured interviews with members of law enforcement agencies, observation of court trials, legal documents and secondary written sources on the investigation of organized crime in Hungary.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Throughout the whole article I will refer to women in trafficking and pandering cases, as during the research I have encountered only female victims or subjects of pandering.
Allain (2018) explains in detail the development of the international conventions and agreements: 1904 Agreement; 1910 International Convention for the Suppression of the White Slave Traffic; 1921 International Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Women and Children; 1933 International Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Women of Full Age; 1949 Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Persons and of the Exploitation of the Prostitution of Others
Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. Adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 55/25 of 15 November 2000. http://www.ohchr.org/EN/ProfessionalInterest/Pages/ProtocolTraffickingInPersons.aspx
On the regulation of asset recovery see Mátyás et al. 2016.
See more about the victims’ assistance and dysfunctions of the Dutch system in Brunovskis and Skilbrei 2016.
European Multidisciplinary Platform against Criminal Threats; prioritized criminal offences listed by the Europol.
Translation for the original German text: „Die Durchführung von JITs ist nicht mehr nur eine Option, sondern auch ein Ziel für die Mitgliedsländer.“(Szabo 2015:56)
References
Agustin L (2007) Sex at the margins: migration, labour markets and the rescue industry. Zed Books, London
Allain J (2018) Genealogies of human trafficking and slavery. In: Piotrowicz R, Rijken C, Uhl BH (eds) Routledge Handbook of Human Trafficking. Routledge, New York
Andreas P, Nadelmann EA (2006) Policing the globe: Criminalization and crime control in international relations. Oxford University Press, New York
Bezsenyi T, Katona N (2017) A szervezett bűnözés nyomozása és a szervezeti non-konformitás In: A határrendészettől a rendészettudományig. Ed: Gaál G, Hautzinger Z. MHT Határőr Szakosztály Pécsi Szakcsoportja, Pécs, Hungary 2016:203-212
Benyon J (1994) Policing the European Union: The changing basis of cooperation on law enforcement. Int Aff 70(3):497–517
Bernstein E (2010) Militarized humanitarianism meets carceral feminism: the politics of sex, rights, and freedom in contemporary antitrafficking campaigns. Signs (Chic) 36(1):45–71
Betlen A (2010) Jog, jogvédelem, ellátás. Szakmaközi együttműködés kiépítése Magyarországon a prostitúció és szexuális kizsákmányolás céljából folytatott emberkereskedelem leküzdése és az áldozatok segítése érdekében. MONA, Budapest
Betlen A (2013) Prostitúció és emberkereskedelem a szociális ellátásban és a gyermekvédelemben Magyarországon, 2013. Az áldozat-ellátás intézményrendszere. Available via MONA. https://monafriends.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/aldozatellatas-2013.pdf. Accessed 10 Sept 2018
Bezsenyi T (2015) A szervezett bűnözés elleni nemzetközi együttműködés értelmezései a magyar igazságszolgáltatásban. Polgári Szemle 11(1–3) Available via: http://old.polgariszemle.hu/?view=v_article&ID=671. Accessed 7 Feb 2019
Bezsenyi T (2016) A magyarországi nemzetközi jellegű szervezett bűnözés információáramlásának kutatási lehetőségei. Belügyi Szemle 2016(9) Available via: https://www.academia.edu/30117622/A_magyarországi_nemzetközi_jellegű_szervezett_bűnözés_információáramlásának_kutatási_lehetőségei. Accessed 7 Feb 2019
Bierschenk T (2016) Police and state. In: Bradford B, Jauregui B, Loader I, Steinberg J (eds) The sage handbook of global policing. Sage, London
Block L (2011) Joint Investigation Teams: the panacea for fighting organised crime? Available via https://ecpr.eu/filestore/paperproposal/c8c1d626-bfb7-4f6a-9855-493fce0e4c8b.pdf. Accessed 22 Feb 2018
Breuil BCO, Siegel D, van Reenen P, Beijer A, Roos L (2011) Human trafficking revisited: legal, enforcement and ethnographic narratives on sex trafficking to Western Europe. Trends Organ Crim 14:30–46
Brunovskis A, Skilbrei ML (2016) Two Birds with One Stone? Implications of conditional assistance in victim protection and prosecution of traffickers. Anti-Trafficking Review 6:13–30
de Buck B (2007) Joint Investigation Teams: the participation of Europol officials. ERA Forum 8:253–264
Deflem M (2000) Bureaucratization and social control: historical foundations of international police cooperation. Law Soc Rev 34:739–778
Deflem M (2002) Policing world society: Historical foundations of international police cooperation. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Dés F (2018) “470et adott és csak egy kicsit fojtogatott” – szegénységben élő nők a félperiféria és a centrum között. Prostitúcióban élő Magyar nők Zürichben. Fordulat 24:187–214
Esser LB, Dettmeijer-Vermeulen CE (2016) The Prominent Role of National Judges in Interpreting the International Definition of Human Trafficking. Anti-Trafficking Review 6:91–105
Fägersten B (2010) Bureaucratic Resistance to International Intelligence Co-operation – the Case of Europol. 25(4) Intelligence and National Security 500
Farrell A, McDevitt J, Pfeffer R, Fahy S, Owens C, Dank M, Adams W (2012) Identifying challenges to improve the investigation and prosecution of state and local human trafficking. Available via https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/238795.pdf. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
Farrell A, Owens C, Mcdevitt J (2014) New laws but few cases: understanding the challenges to the investigation and prosecution of human trafficking cases. Crime Law Soc Chang 61:139–168
Farrell A, Pfeffer R, Bright K (2015) Police perceptions of human trafficking. J Crim Justice 38(3)
Fehér L (2009) Prostitúció, Emberkereskedelem. In: Nagy I, Pongrácz T (eds) Szerepváltozások. Jelentések nők és férfiak helyzetéről. TÁRKI – Szociális és Munkaügyi Minisztérium, Budapest
Finger S (2016) Sex-work and Mobility as a Coping Strategy for Marginalized Hungarian Roma Women. An International Journal for Critical Geographies 15(1)
Finszter G (1991) A magyar rendőrség helyzetéről. Rendészeti szemle 7:36–41
Finszter G (1994) Rendőrségi modellek. Rendészeti szemle 3:3–17
Finszter G (2008) Víziók a rendőrségről. Rendészeti Szemle 1:10–41
Finszter G (2014) Rendészetelmélet. Nemzeti Közszolgálati Egyetem Rendészettudományi Kar, Budapest.
Gallagher AT (2012) Editorial. Anti-Trafficking Review 1:2–9
Gallagher AT (2016) Editorial: The Problems and Prospects of Trafficking Prosecutions: Ending impunity and securing justice. Anti-Trafficking Review 6:1–11
Gallagher AT (2018) Trafficking in transnational criminal law. In: Routledge Handbook of Human Trafficking. Routledge, New York, pp 21–40
Grubb JA, Muftic LR, Deljkic I (2016) An exploratory analysis of prosecutorial attitudes of sex trafficking in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Trends Organ Crim (2016) 19:175
Helfferich C, Kavemann B, Rabe H (2011) Determinants of the willingness to make a statement of victims of human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation in the triangle offender–police–victim. Trends Organ Crim 14:125–147
Hollan M (2012) Emberkereskedelem.A kizsákmányolás büntetőjogi esetei és a büntetőjogi szabályozás határai. Hvg-Orac Lap- és Könyvkiadó Kft, Budapest
Hufnagel S (2011) Cross-border police co-operation: Traversing domestic and international frontiers. Crim Law J 35(6):333–344
Jahic G, Finckenauer J (2005) Representation and Misrepresentations of Human Trafficking. Trends Organ Crim 8:3
Jahnsen S, Skilbrei ML (2015) From Palermo to the Streets of Oslo: Pros and cons of the trafficking framework. Anti-Trafficking Review 4:156–160
Katona N (2017) Loved or seduced? Intimate Relationships between Hungarian Sex Workers and Pimps in Berlin’s Kurfürstenstraße. In: Third party sex work and pimps in the age of anti-trafficking. Ed: Amber Horning and Anthony Marcus. Springer, New York, pp 49–69
Kempadoo K (2005) Trafficking and prostitution reconsidered: new perspectives on migration, sex work and human rights. Paradigm Publishers, Boulder
Klimek L (2012) Joint Investigation Teams in the European Union. Internal Security 4(1):63–67
Kovács I (2013) Kerítés bűncselekmény nyomozása. Belügyi Szemle 5:130–135
Kovács I (2017) Magyarország határain átnyúló szervezett bűnözés és prostitúciós bűncselekmények a schengeni térségben, különös tekintettel a SOCTA és EUROSTAT étékelésére. Határrendészeti Tanulmányok. 2017/4
Leser J (2017) Policing the absence of the victim. An ethnography of raids in sex trafficking operations. In: Sanders T, Laing M (eds) Policing the Sex Industry: Protection, Paternalism and Politics. Routledge, New York
Leser J, Pates R, Dölemeyer A (2017) The Emotional Leviathan: How Street-Level Bureaucrats govern Human Trafficking Victims. Digithum 19:19–36
Lipsky M (2010) Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services 30th anniv. Russell Sage Foundation, New York
Loyens K (2016) How police detectives deal with policy alienation in the investigation of human exploitation crimes: reinforcing or counterbalancing fatalism. In: Burke RB (ed) Stress in Policing: Sources, consequences and interventions. Routledge, New York
Manning PK (2005) The study of policing. Police Q 8:23–43
Mátyás S, Frigyer L, Bezsenyi T, Nyitrai E (2016) Regulations of asset recovery in the light of criminal cases in Hungary. Kritische Zeiten: Zeitschrift für Humanwissenschaften 2016(1–2):34–47
Molland S (2013) Tandem ethnography: On researching ‘trafficking’and ‘anti-trafficking’. Ethnography 14(3):300–323
Munk V (2017) Kéjutca – Magyar Szex Euróért. Bookline Könyvek, Budapest
Nagy J (2010) Közös nyomozócsoportok az Európai Unió tagállamai közötti bűnügyi együttműködésben. PhD thesis. Budapest. Available via: http://193.224.191.196:8080/phd/nagy_judit_tezisek.pdf. Accessed 11 Sept 2018
Nilsson H G (2005) Special investigation techniques and developments in mutual legal assistance: the crossroads between police cooperation and judicial cooperation. In: Cornell S (ed) Resource Material Series (2005) 65: 39–45 Available at: http://www.unafei.or.jp/english/pdf/RS_No65/No65_07VE_Nilsson2.pdf. Accessed 11 Sept 2018
Papanicolaou G (2008) The sex industry, human trafficking and the global prohibition regime: a cautionary tale from Greece. Trends Organ Crim 11:379–409
Papanicolaou G (2011) Transnational policing and sex trafficking in Southeast Europe. Policing the imperialist chain. Palgrave Macmillan, New York
Pates R and Schmidt D (2008) Wahrheiten über Opfer: Menschenhandelsdiskurse im Vergleich. In: Der involvierte Blick. Zwansprostitution und ihre Repräsentation. HU Berlin: Zentrum für transdisziplinäre Geschlechterstudien: Bulletin Texte 35: 90–105.
Petrunov G (2011) Managing money acquired from human trafficking: case study of sex trafficking from Bulgaria to Western Europe. Trends Organ Crim 14:165–183
Plambech S (2016) Sex, Deportation and Rescue: Economies of Migration among Nigerian Sex Workers. Fem Econ 23(3):1–26
Sebhelyi V, Varga-Sabjan D (2016) Az emberkereskedelem kérdésére adott szakpolitikai válaszok Magyarországon az Európai Unió iránymutatásainak tükrében. In: Juhasz B (ed) A Magyar Női Érdekérvényesítő Szövetség Közpolitikai Ajánlásai. Magyar Női Érdekérvényesítő Szövetség, Budapest
Sheptycki JWE (2000) Introduction. In: Sheptycki JWE (ed) Issues in transnational policing. Routledge, London
Sheptycki JWE (2002) In search of transnational policing: Towards a sociology of global policing. Ashgate, Aldershot
Sheptycki JWE (2005) Transnational policing. The Canadian Review of Policing Research 1:2005
Skilbrei ML (2010) Taking trafficking to court. Women Crim Just 20(1–2):40–56
Skrivankova K (2018) Defining exploitation in the context of trafficking – what is a crime and what is not. In: Piotrowicz R, Rijken C, Uhl BH (eds) Routledge handbook of human trafficking. Routledge, New York
Szabo S (2015) Praktische Erfahrungen mit gemeinsamen Ermittlungsgruppen – eine wirksame Lösung mit Kompromissen bei der Bekämpfung des Menschenhandels. Mitteleuropaische Polizeiakademie. Erfahrungen mit JIT. MEPA Fachjournal 2:55–61
Szabo S (2017) Case study: the hungarian aspect of the international and cross border cooperation. Public talk at the workshop: human trafficking in hungary: present and future, challenges and best practices. 4 December 2017, Budapest. Available via: https://csnsc.uk/3960-2/. Accessed 10 Sept 2018
Szoboszlai K (2012) A prostitúció társadalmi háttere: a szegénység. In: IRIS 2012 – Szociális szolgáltatások fejlesztése prostitúcióban élő Magyar nők részére Magyarorszgáon és Svájcban. Helyzetkép és teendő. Sex Educatio Alapítvány, Budapest
Valverde M (2010) The force of law. Groundwood Books Ltd, Ontario
Verhoeven M, van Gestel B (2011) Human trafficking and criminal investigation strategies in the Amsterdam red Light District. Trends Organ Crime 14(2–3):148–164
von Lampe K (2008) Organised crime research in Europe: development and stagnation. In: van Duyne PC, Harvey J, Maljević A, Scheinost M, von Lampe K (eds) European crime-markets at cross roads: Extended and extending criminal Europe. Wolf Legal Publishers, Nijmegen
Vidra Z, Baracsi K, Katona N, Sebhelyi V (2015) Child Trafficking in Hungary. Sexual Exploitation, Forced Begging and Pickpocketing / Gyermekkereskedelem Magyarországon. Szexuális kizsákmányolás, koldultatás és zsebtolvajlásra kényszerítés. CEU, CPS. 2015.
Vidra Z, Katona N, Sebhelyi V (2017) State policies and institutional procedures and practices addressing prostitution and sex trafficking of children in Hungary. Crit Soc Policy 38:645–66
Weitzer R (2005) Flawed Theory and Method in Studies of Prostitution. Violence Against Women 11(7):934–949
Weitzer R (2007) The social construction of sex trafficking: ideology and institutionalization of a moral crusade. Polit Soc. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032329207304319
Williams P (2001) Transnational criminal networks. In: Arquilla J, Ronfeldt D (eds) Networks and netwars: the future of terror, crime, and militancy. Rand Networks Series, Santa Monica
Windt S (2014) 2013, az emberkereskedelem elleni fellépés éve Magyarországon. Belügyi Szemle 1:58–74
Zhang SX (2009) Beyond the ‘Natasha’ story – a review and critique of current research on sex trafficking. Glob Crime 10(3):178–195
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethical approval
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Katona, N. Combating trafficking of Hungarian women to Western Europe: a multi-level analysis of the international law enforcement cooperation. Trends Organ Crim 23, 115–142 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-019-09358-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-019-09358-7