Abstract
Extreme inequality of opportunity leads to a number of social tensions, inefficiencies and injustices. One issue of increasing concern is the effect inequality is having on people’s fair chances of attaining meaningful work, thus limiting opportunities to make a significant positive contribution to society and reducing the chances of living a flourishing life and developing their potential. On a global scale, we can observe an increasingly uneven provision of meaningful work, raising a series of ethical concerns that need detailed examination. The aim of this article is to explore the potential of a normative framework based upon the idea of contributive justice to defend a fairer provision of meaningful work.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Adrian Walsh (1994, 248) concludes that “meaningful work (i.e., eudaimonian activity in the workplace) is a legitimate distributive good, which should be included alongside other distributive goods such as wealth, education, leisure goods, and income”. Yet while we may be able to identify jobs that in their job description offer opportunities to exercise and develop skills that demand engagement with theory, in practice we can only distribute such jobs within a small group provided all commit to do a fair share of tedious tasks as well. At a global level, the task of distributing meaningful work fairly becomes unfeasible. This type of practical impediment pushes the distribution of meaningful work beyond the realm of what can be addressed through principles of distributive justice (cf. Lamont & Favor, 2013).
See Yeoman (2014, 237) for a discussion, primarily questioning the real freedom people have to choose the work they will do in the labour market.
For strong scepticism that the principle of equality of opportunity shall ever be more than a mere ideal, see Mijs (2016).
For an excellent discussion of the job market for academic philosophy and its effect on diversity and well-being, see Behrensen and Kaliarnta (2017).
References
Anderson, E. (2015). Equality and freedom in the workplace: Recovering republican insights. Social Philosophy and Policy, 31(02), 48–69.
Arneson, R. (1987). Meaningful work and market socialism. Ethics, 97(3), 517–545.
Arneson, R. (2009). Meaningful work and market socialism revisited. Analyse & Kritik, 31(1), 139–151.
Arneson, R. (2015). Equality of opportunity. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2015 Edition).
Arnold, S. (2012). The difference principle at work. Journal of Political Philosophy, 20(1), 94–118.
Barry, B. (1982). Humanity and justice in global perspective. Nomos, 24, 219–252.
Bascara, R. (2016). Compatriot partiality and cosmopolitan justice: Can we justify compatriot partiality within the cosmopolitan framework? Etikk i praksis-Nordic Journal of Applied Ethics, 10(2), 27–39.
Behrensen, M., & Kaliarnta, S. (2017). Sick and tired: Depression in the margins of academic philosophy. Topoi, 36(2), 355–364.
Bowie, N. E. (1998). A Kantian theory of meaningful work. Journal of Business Ethics, 17(9), 1083–1092.
Brennan, J. (2011). The right to a competent electorate. The Philosophical Quarterly, 61(245), 700–724.
Britz, J. J. (2008). Making the global information society good: A social justice perspective on the ethical dimensions of the global information society. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 59(7), 1171–1183.
Britz, J. J., & Lipinski, T. A. (2001). Indigenous knowledge: A moral reflection on current legal concepts of intellectual property. Libri, 51(4), 234–246.
Britz, J. J., & Lor, P. (2004). A moral reflection on the digitization of Africa’s documentary heritage. IFLA Journal, 30(3), 216–223.
Burchell, B., Sehnbruch, K., Piasna, A., & Agloni, N. (2014). The quality of employment and decent work: Definitions, methodologies, and ongoing debates. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 38(2), 459–477.
Calder, G. (2016). Family autonomy and class fate. Symposion, 3(2), 131–149.
Campesina, Via. (1996). The right to produce and access land. Rome: Via Campesina.
Claassen, R. (2012). Temporal autonomy in a laboring society. Inquiry, 55(5), 543–562.
Claassen, R. (2015). The capability to hold property. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 16(2), 220–236.
Danaher, J. (2017). Will life be worth living in a world without work? Technological unemployment and the meaning of life. Science and Engineering Ethics, 23(1), 41–64.
Deranty, J. P., & MacMillan, C. (2012). The ILO’s Decent Work initiative: Suggestions for an extension of the notion of “decent work”. Journal of Social Philosophy, 43(4), 386–405.
Dieterlen, P. (2003). La pobreza: un estudio filosófico. México, DF: Fondo de Cultura Económica.
Dietsch, P. (2008). Distributive lessons from division of labour. Journal of Moral Philosophy, 5(1), 96–117.
Dodds, W. K. (2005). The commons, game theory and aspects of human nature that may allow conservation of global resources. Environmental Values, 14, 411–425.
Elster, J. (1986). Self-realization in work and politics: The Marxist conception of the good life. Social Philosophy and Policy, 3(02), 97–126.
Espindola, J., & Vaca, M. (2014). The problem of historical rectification for Rawlsian theory. Res Publica, 20(3), 227–243.
Fricker, M. (2007). Epistemic injustice: Power and the ethics of knowing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Frischmann, B. M. (2012). Infrastructure: The social value of shared resources. New York: Oxford University Press.
Gheaus, A., & Herzog, L. (2016). The goods of work (other than money!). Journal of Social Philosophy, 47(1), 70–89.
Gilabert, P. (2015). The socialist principle “from each according to their abilities, to each according to their needs”. Journal of Social Philosophy, 46(2), 197–225.
Gilabert, P. (2016). Labor human rights and human dignity. Philosophy & Social Criticism, 42(1), 171–199.
Gilabert, P. (forthcoming). Dignity at work. In H. Collins, G. Lester, & V. Mantouvlou (Eds.), Philosophical foundations of labour law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gomberg, P. (1995). Against competitive equal opportunity. Journal of Social Philosophy, 26(3), 59–73.
Gomberg, P. (2007). How to make opportunity equal. New York: Wiley.
Gomberg, P. (2010). Dilemmas of Rawlsian opportunity. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 40(1), 1–24.
Gomberg, P. (2016). Why distributive justice is impossible but contributive justice would work. Science & Society, 80(1), 31–55.
Gomberg, P. (2017). Workers without rights. Symposion, 4(1), 49–76.
Gourevitch, A. (2016). Quitting work but not the job: Liberty and the right to strike. Perspectives on Politics, 14(02), 307–323.
Graeber, D. (2006). Turning modes of production inside out or, Why capitalism is a transformation of slavery. Critique of Anthropology, 26(1), 61–85.
Graeber, D. (2013). On the phenomenon of bullshit jobs. Strike! Magazine, August (pp. 10–11).
Hardwig, J. (2015). Ownership, possession, and consumption: On the limits of rational consumption. Journal of Social Philosophy, 46(3), 281–296.
Hasan, R. (2015). Rawls on meaningful work and freedom. Social Theory and Practice, 41(3), 477–504.
Herzog, L. (2011). Wer Sind Wir, Wenn Wir Arbeiten? Soziale Identität Im Markt Bei Smith Und Hegel. Deutsche Zeitschrift Für Philosophie, 59(6), 835–852.
Hsieh, N. H. (2009). Justice at work: Arguing for property-owning democracy. Journal of Social Philosophy, 40(3), 397–411.
Kates, M. (2015). The ethics of sweatshops and the limits of choice. Business Ethics Quarterly, 25(2), 191–212.
Keat, R. (2009). Anti-perfectionism, market economies and the right to meaningful work. Analyse & Kritik, 31(1), 121–138.
Kelbessa, W. (2013). Indigenous knowledge and its contribution to biodiversity conservation. International Social Science Journal, 64(211–212), 143–152.
Kohn, M. L., & Schooler, C. (1982). Job conditions and personality: A longitudinal assessment of their reciprocal effects. American Journal of Sociology, 87(6), 1257–1286.
Kumar, M., & Santoro, D. (2014). Being bound to fail. How epistemic injustice fails educational opportunities. https://imera.univ-amu.fr/sites/imera.univamu.fr/file/being_bound_to_fail.how_epistemic_injustice_fails_educational_opportunities_draft_0.pdf. Accessed 6 Oct 2017.
Lamont, J., & Favor, C. (2013). Distributive Justice. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (spring 2013 edition). Stanford: Stanford University.
Lane, R. E. (1991). The market experience. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lepisto, D. A., & Pratt, M. G. (2017). Meaningful work as realization and justification: Toward a dual conceptualization. Organizational Psychology Review, 7(2), 99–121.
Lips-Wiersma, M., & Morris, L. (2009). Discriminating between ‘meaningful work’ and the ‘management of meaning’. Journal of Business Ethics, 88(3), 491–511.
Louwaars, N. (2007). Seeds of confusion: The impact of policies on seed systems. Ph.D. thesis, Wageningen Universiteit.
Lucas, K. (2015). Workplace dignity: Communicating inherent, earned, and remediated dignity. Journal of Management Studies, 52(5), 621–646.
May, D. R., Li, C., Mencl, J., & Huang, C.-C. (2014). The ethics of meaningful work: Types and magnitude of job-related harm and the ethical decision-making process. Journal of Business Ethics, 121(4), 651–669.
Mijs, J. J. (2016). The unfulfillable promise of meritocracy: Three lessons and their implications for justice in education. Social Justice Research, 29(1), 14–34.
Moellendorf, D. (2006). Equality of opportunity globalized. Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, 19, 301–318.
Murnion, W. E. (1989). The ideology of social justice in economic justice for all. Journal of Business Ethics, 8(11), 847–854.
Narisada, A. (2017). Socioeconomic status and the relationship between under-reward and distress: Buffering-resource or status-disconfirmation? Social Justice Research, 30(3), 191–220.
Nozick, R. (1974). Anarchy, state, and utopia. New York: Basic Books.
Offe, C. (2009). Basic income and the labor contract. Analyse & Kritik, 31(1), 49–79.
Ooms, G. (2010). Why the west is perceived as being unworthy of cooperation. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 38(3), 594–613.
Otsuka, M. (2008). Freedom of occupational choice. Ratio, 21(4), 440–453.
Parr, T. (2015). From philanthropy to philanthropists. In B. Morvaridi (Ed.), New philanthropy and social justice: Debating the conceptual and policy discourse (pp. 64–77). Bristol: Policy Press.
Pogge, T. W. (2008). World poverty and human rights: Cosmopolitan responsibilities and reforms (2nd ed.). Cambridge: Polity.
Rawls, J. (1999). A theory of justice (Rev. edn.). Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Robeyns, I. (2011). The capability approach. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (summer 2011 edition). Stanford: Stanford University.
Roessler, B. (2012). Meaningful work: Arguments from autonomy. Journal of Political Philosophy, 20(1), 71–93.
Sarkin, J., & Koenig, M. (2011). Developing the right to work: Intersecting and dialoguing human rights and economic policy. Human Rights Quarterly, 33(1), 1–42.
Sayer, A. (1989). Postfordism in question. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 13(4), 666–695.
Sayer, A. (2009). Contributive justice and meaningful work. Res Publica, 15, 1–16.
Sayer, A. (2011). Habitus, work and contributive justice. Sociology, 45(1), 7–21.
Sayer, A. (2012). Capabilities, contributive injustice and unequal divisions of labour. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 13(4), 580–596.
Schaff, K. P. (2012). Democratic rights in the workplace. Inquiry, 55(4), 386–404.
Schwartz, A. (1982). Meaningful work. Ethics, 92(4), 634–646.
Schweiger, G. (2013). Recognition and social exclusion. A recognition-theoretical exploration of poverty in Europe. Ethical Perspectives, 20(4), 529–554.
Sen, A. (2001). Development as freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sen, A. (2009). The idea of justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Sennett, R. (2008). The craftsman. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Shaheed, F. (2012). Report of the Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights. United Nations (A/HRC/20/26).
Shaver, L. (2010). The right to science and culture. Wisconsin Law Review, 121, 121–184.
Shiffrin, S. V. (2003). Race, labor, and the fair equality of opportunity principle. Fordham Law Review, 72, 1643–1675.
Sison, A. J. G., Ferrero, I., & Guitián, G. (2016). Human dignity and the dignity of work: Insights from Catholic Social Teaching. Business Ethics Quarterly.
Sklair, L. (2016). The transnational capitalist class, social movements, and alternatives to capitalist globalization. International Critical Thought, 6(3), 329–341.
Snyder, J. (2010). Exploitation and sweatshop labor: Perspectives and issues. Business Ethics Quarterly, 20(02), 187–213.
Sparrow, R., & Goodin, R. E. (2001). The competition of ideas: Market or garden? Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 4(2), 45–58.
Spencer, D. A. (2013). Promoting high quality work: Obstacles and opportunities. Journal of Business Ethics, 114(3), 583–597.
Stanczyk, L. (2012). Productive justice. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 40(2), 144–164.
Steger, M. F. (2017). Creating meaning and purpose at work. In: The Wiley Blackwell handbook of the psychology of positivity and strengths-based approaches at work (pp. 60–81). Hoboken: Wiley.
Sturn, R. (2009). Volenti non fit iniuria? Contract freedom and labor market institutions. Analyse und Kritik, 31(1), 81–99.
Tablan, F. (2015). Catholic social teachings: Toward a meaningful work. Journal of Business Ethics, 128(2), 291–303.
Taka, I., & Foglia, W. D. (1994). Ethical aspects of “Japanese leadership style”. Journal of Business Ethics, 13(2), 135–148.
Taylor, C. (1994). The politics of recognition. In A. Gutmann (Ed.), Multiculturalism: Examining the politics of recognition (pp. 25–74). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Taylor, R. (2004). Self-realization and the priority of fair equality of opportunity. Journal of Moral Philosophy, 1(3), 333–347.
Terzi, L. (2007). The capability to be educated. In M. Walker & E. Unterhalter (Eds.), Amartya Sen’s capability approach and social justice in education (pp. 25–43). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Tight, M. (1998). Lifelong learning: Opportunity or compulsion? British Journal of Educational Studies, 46(3), 251–263.
United States Catholic Bishops. (1997). Economic justice for all: Pastoral letter on Catholic Social Teaching and the U.S. economy. Washington, DC: United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Valente, R. R., & Berry, B. J. (2016). Working hours and life satisfaction: A cross-cultural comparison of Latin America and the United States. Journal of Happiness Studies, 17(3), 1173–1204.
Van Parijs, P. (1997). Real freedom for all: What (if anything) can justify capitalism?. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Veltman, A. (2016). Meaningful work. New York: Oxford University Press.
Walsh, A. J. (1994). Meaningful work as a distributive good. The Southern journal of philosophy, 32(2), 233–250.
Walzer, M. (1983). Spheres of justice: A defense of pluralism and equality. New York: Basic Books.
Wolf, S. (2010). Meaning in life and why it matters. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Wolff, J. (2004). Training, perfectionism and fairness. Journal of applied philosophy, 21(3), 285–295.
Yeoman, R. (2014). Conceptualising meaningful work as a fundamental human need. Journal of Business Ethics, 125(2), 235–251.
Young, I. M. (2004). Responsibility and global labor justice. Journal of Political Philosophy, 12(4), 365–388.
Ziegler, J. (2011a). Destruction massive: Géopolitique de la faim. Paris: Seuil.
Ziegler, R. (2011b). Fair competition of ideas. Paper presented at the responsible innovation conference, The Hague, April 18–19, 2011.
Timmermann, C., & Félix, G. F. (2015). Agroecology as a vehicle for contributive justice. Agriculture and Human Values, 32(3), 523–538.
Timmermann, C. (2014). Sharing in or benefiting from scientific advancement? Science and Engineering Ethics, 20(1), 111–133.
Timmermann, C., & van den Belt, H. (2012). Global justice considerations for a proposed “climate impact fund”. Public Reason, 4(1–2), 182–196.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank the participants at workshops in Mexico City, Budapest and Campinas, Isabella Trifan, Georges Félix, the journal’s editor and the anonymous reviewers for valuable feedback and Michael Pockley also for careful language editing on earlier versions of this article.
Funding
This study was funded by a postdoctoral fellowship UNAM-DGAPA [National Autonomous University of Mexico, no grant numbers are given] and a postdoctoral fellowship by FONDECYT/CONICYT No. 3170068.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author declares no conflict of interest.
Ethical Approval
This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by the author.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Timmermann, C. Contributive Justice: An Exploration of a Wider Provision of Meaningful Work. Soc Just Res 31, 85–111 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11211-017-0293-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11211-017-0293-2