The fate of the direct argument and the case for incompatibilism
- 112 Downloads
In this paper, I distinguish causal from logical versions of the direct argument for incompatibilism. I argue that, contrary to appearances, causal versions are better equipped to withstand an important recent challenge to the direct-argument strategy. The challenge involves arguing that support for the argument’s pivotal inference principle falls short just when it is needed most, namely when a deterministic series runs through an agent’s unimpaired deliberations. I then argue that, while there are limits to what causal versions can accomplish, they can be used to buttress the ultimacy argument, another important argument for incompatibilism.
KeywordsIncompatibilism Direct argument Determinism Moral responsibility Transfer principle Ultimate responsibility Michael McKenna
- Campbell, J. K. (2007). Free will and the necessity of the past. Analysis, 67, 105–111.Google Scholar
- Fischer, J. M. (1994). The metaphysics of free will. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
- Fischer, J. M. (2002). Frankfurt-style compatibilism. In S. Buss & L. Overton (Eds.), The contours of agency (pp. 1–26). Cambridge, MA: MIT press.Google Scholar
- Fischer, J. M. (2006). The transfer of nonresponsibility. In My way: Essays on moral responsibility. New York: Oxford University Press (Originally printed in J. Campbell, M. O’Rourke, & D. Shier (Eds.), Freedom and determinism: Topics in contemporary philosophy series. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).Google Scholar
- Kane, R. (1985). Free will and values. Albany: State University of New York.Google Scholar
- Kane, R. (1996). The significance of free will. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- McKenna, M. (2001). Source incompatibilism, ultimacy, and the transfer of non-responsibility. American Philosophical Quarterly, 38, 37–52.Google Scholar
- Shabo, S. (2007). Review of John Fischer, My way: Essays on moral responsibility (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006). The Journal of Value Inquiry, 41, 353–357. doi: 10.1007/s10790-007-9069-5.
- Shabo, S. (2010, forthcoming). Uncompromising source incompatibilism. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research.Google Scholar
- van Inwagen, P. (1983). An essay on free will. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
- Wallace, R. J. (1994). Responsibility and the moral sentiments. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Warfield, T. (2000). Causal determinism and human freedom are incompatible: A new argument for incompatibilism. Philosophical Perspectives, 14, 167–180.Google Scholar