Abstract
In 2002, The (UK) Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) together with the Environment Agency published document SGV10 “Contaminants in soil: collation of toxicological data and intake values for humans. Lead”. This publication sets out the derivation of Soil Guideline Values for lead contamination. Values for soil lead that are protective of the health of children and also for adults are derived using the model recommended by an international task force working under the auspices of the Society for Environmental Geochemistry and Health (SEGH) (Wixson and Davies 1993, 1994). Detailed examination of the DEFRA publication shows it uses unrealistic values for two variables in the SEGH model. The consequence is both actual and has potential adverse societal impacts. These impacts could be avoided if the appropriate scientific community were regarded as stakeholders in the legislative outcome and not simply the providers of the research data.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alonso, E., Cambra, K., & Martinez, T. (2001). Lead and cadmium exposure from contaminated soil among residents of a farm area near an industrial site. Archives of Environmental Health, 56, 278.
Alloway, B. J., & Davies, B. E. (1971). Trace element content of soils affected by base metal mining in Wales. Geoderma, 5, 197–207.
Bornschein, R. L., Clark, C. S., Grote, J., Road, S., & Succop, P. (1989). Soil lead-blood lead relationships in a former lead mining town. In B. E. Davies & B. G. Wixson (Eds.), Lead in Soil: Issues and guidelines (pp. 149–160). Northwood: Science Reviews Ltd.
CDC. (2002). Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Managing elevated blood lead levels among young children: Recommendations from the Advisory Committee on Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention. Atlanta: CDC.
Chisholm, J. J. (2001). The road to primary prevention of lead toxicity in children. Pediatrics, 107, 581–583.
Cotter-Howells, J., & Thornton, I. (1991). Sources and pathways of environmental lead to children in a Derbyshire mining village. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 13, 127–135.
Culbard, E. B., Thornton, I., Watt, J., Wheatley, M., Moorcroft, S., & Thompson, M. (1988). Metal contamination in British urban dusts and soils. Journal of Environmental Quality, 17, 226–234.
Davies, B. E. (1978). Plant-available lead and other metals in British garden soils. Science of the Total Environment, 9, 243–262.
Davies, B. E., & Holmes, P. L. (1972). Lead contamination of roadside soil and grass in Birmingham, England, in relation to naturally occurring levels. Journal Agricultural Science (Cambridge), 79, 479–484.
Davies, B. E., and Wixson, B. G. (Eds.). (1988). Lead in soil: Issues and guidelines. In: Proceedings of a conference in Chapel Hill, NC, USA (p 315). Northwood, England: Science Reviews.
DD. (2006) Guidance for development, or change of use, on land falling within the target area for lead (Pb) contamination. Derbyshire Dales District Council, Matlock, England.
DEFRA. (2002) Soil guideline values for lead contamination (p 20). Bristol, UK : R&D Publication SGV 10 Environment Agency.
DEFRA. (2005). Soil guideline values and the determination of land as contaminated land under Part IIA CLAN 2/05 (p 3). Bristol, UK: Environment Agency.
DEFRA. (2006). Soil guideline values: the way forward (p 38). Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, England.
DEFRA CLR 10. (2002). The contaminated land exposure assessment (CLEA) model: Technical basis and algorithms (p 20). Bristol, UK: Environment Agency.
Duggan, M. J., & Inskip, M. J. (1985). Childhood exposure to lead in surface dust and soil: A community health problem. Public Health Reviews, 13, 1–54.
Federal Register. (2001). Environmental Protection Agency: Lead, identification of dangerous levels of lead; final rule, 40 CFR Part 745, Washington DC
Jin, A., Teschke, K., & Copes, R. (1997). The relationship of lead in soil to lead in blood and implications for standard setting. The Science of The Total Environment, 208, 23–40.
Lanphear, B. P., Succop, P., Roda, S., & Henningsen, G. (2003). The effect of soil abatement on blood lead levels in children living near a former smelting and milling operation. Public Health Reports, 118, 83–89.
Le Riche, H. H. (1968). Metal contamination of soil in the Woburn market-garden experiment resulting from the application of sewage sludge. Journal Agricultural Science (Cambridge), 71, 205–208.
Lindsay, C. (2003) A century of labour market change: 1900 to 2000: Labour Market trends, March 2003
Marcus, A. H., & Cohen, J. (1988). Modelling the blood lead-soil lead relationship. In B. E. Davies & B. G. Wixson (Eds.), Lead in soil: Issues and guidelines (pp. 161–174). Northwood: Science Reviews Ltd.
McNair, S., Flynn, M., Owen, L., Humphreys, C., Woodfield, S. (2004) Changing work in later life: A study of job transitions. Centre for Research into the Older Workforce, University of Surrey, March 2004, p. 93.
Nriagu, J. O. (1990). The rise and fall of leaded gasoline. The Science of the Total Environment, 92, 13–28.
Rabinowitz, M. B., & Bellinger, D. C. (1988). Soil lead-blood lead relationship among Boston children. Bulletin Environmental Toxicology and Health, 41, 791–797.
von Lindern, I. H., Spalinger, S. M., Bero, B. N., Petrosyan, V., & von Braun, M. C. (2003). The influence of soil remediation on lead in house dust: The Science of The Total Environment, 303, 59–78.
Warren, H. V., & Delavault, R. E. (1971). Variations in the copper, zinc, lead, and molybdenum contents of some vegetables and their supporting soils. Geological Society America Memoirs, 123, 97–108.
Wixson, B. G., & Davies, B. E. (1993). “Lead in Soil” task force: Recommended guidelines: Northwood, England, Science Reviews, p. 132.
Wixson, B. G., & Davies, B. E. (1994). Guidelines for lead in soil. Environmental Science and Technology, 28, 26–31.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Davies, B.E. Protective values for soil lead with respect to child health: a critique of UK guidelines. Environ Geochem Health 30, 639–646 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-008-9192-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-008-9192-7