Abstract
The paper reviews the debate on innovation in services which has flourished over the last 20 years and suggests a research agenda for the services innovation literature. We discuss whether, and the extent to which, the ill-definition and mis-measurement of service output have influenced the conceptualization and analysis of innovation in services. We propose a reclassification of the literature according to whether it has been mainly assimilated or differentiated with respect to the traditional conceptualization of innovation in the manufacturing sector. We also review the integrative (or synthesizing) contributions, and suggest a taxonomy for the modes of innovation in services, based on the Lancasterian characteristics-based approach to product definition. We conclude with a summary of the key arguments and a proposed agenda for the evolutionary theory to integrate the conceptualization of innovation in services.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
It is beyond the scope of this paper to provide an overview of the classical tradition. However, it is interesting to consider here that Marx’s classification of service activities was mainly based on the social and economic relationships underlying the provision of services, rather than the physical manifestation of such provision. Interestingly, he considers transport services to be part of industrial production, and therefore part of the material sphere, as well as a source of surplus value. Unlike transport, trade and banking are categorized as belonging to the sphere of “commercial and financial capital”; they produce neither value nor surplus value, but only add to the profits. More specifically, these activities are not labelled unproductive because of their immateriality, a criterion that many scholars applied at the time; instead, they were seen as part of more a complex speculation as far as their role within the social reproduction of capital was concerned (Delaunay and Gadrey 1992).
See also Windrum et al. in this special issue.
References
Abernathy WJ, Utterback JM (1975) A dynamic model of process and product innovation. Omega 3(6):639–656
Abernathy WJ, Utterback JM (1978) Patterns of industrial innovation. Technol Rev 80:41–47
Aglietta M, Brender A (1984) Les métamorphoses de la société salariale. Calman-Lévy, Paris
Appelbaum E, Schettkat R (2001) Are prices unimportant? The changing structure of the industrialised economies. In: ten Raa T, Schettkat R (eds) The growth of service industries. The paradox of exploding costs and persistent demand. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 121–131
Attali J (1981) Les trois mondes. Fayard, Paris
Bacon R, Eltis W (1978) Britain’s economic problem: too few producers. Macmillan, London
Barcet A, Bonamy J, Mayère A (1987) Modernisation et innovation dans les services aux entreprises. Commissariat Général du Plan
Barras R (1986) Towards a theory of innovation in services. Res Policy 15:161–173
Barras R (1990) Interactive innovation in financial and business services: the vanguard of the service revolution. Res Policy 19:215–237
Baumol WJ (1967) Macroeconomics of unbalanced growth: the anatomy of an urban crisis. Am Econ Rev 57:415–426
Baumol WJ (2001) Paradox of the services: exploding costs, persistent demand. In: ten Raa T, Schettkat R (eds) The growth of service industries. The paradox of exploding costs and persistent demand. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 3–28
Baumol WJ (2002) Services as leaders and the jeader of the services. In: Gadrey J, Gallouj F (eds) Productivity, innovation and knowledge in services. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 147–163
Baumol WJ, Bowen W (1966) Performing arts: the economic dilemma. Twentieth Century Fund, New York
Baumol WJ, Blackman S, Wolff E (1985) Unbalanced growth revisited: asymptotic stagnancy and new evidence. Am Econ Rev 75:806–816
Baumol WJ, Blackman S, Wolff E (1989) Productivity and American leadership. MIT, Cambridge
Bell D (1973) The coming of post-industrial society. A venture in social forecasting. Basic Books, New York
Belleflamme C, Houard J, Michaux B (1986) Innovation and research and development process analysis in service activities. IRES, EEC-FAST report, August
Bresand A, Nicolaïdis K (1988) Les services au cœur de l’économie relationnelle. Revue d’Economie Industrielle 43:141–163
Browning H, Singelmann J (1978) The transformation of the U.S. labour force: the interaction of industries and occupation. Polit Soc 3–4:481–509
Caccomo J-L, Solonandrasana B (2001) L’innovation dans l’industrie touristique. L’Harmattan, Collection Tourisme et Sociétés, Paris
Cainelli G, Evangelista R, Savona M (2006) Innovation and economic performance in services. A firm-level analysis. Cambridge J Econ 30:435–458
Ciarli T, Valente M (2005) Firms’ interaction and industrial development: a simulation model. In: Giuliani E, Rabellotti R, Van Dijk MP (eds) Clusters facing competition: the importance of external linkages. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp 259–290
Clark C (1940) The conditions of economic progress. Macmillan, London
Cohen S, Zysman J (1987) Manufacturing matters. Basic Books, New York
Daveri F (2002) The new economy in Europe, 1992–2001. Oxf Rev Econ Policy 18(3):345–362
De Bandt J, Gadrey J (eds) (1994) Relations de service, marchés des services. CNRS Editions, Paris
Delaunay JC, Gadrey J (1992) Services in economic thought—three centuries of debate. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht
Desai M, Low W (1987) Measuring the opportunity for product innovation. In: De Cecco M (ed) Changing money: financial innovation in developed countries. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, pp 112–140
De Vries E (2006) Innovation in services in networks of organizations and in the distribution of services. Res Policy 35(7):1037–1051
Djellal F (2000) The rise of information technologies in non informational services. Vierteljahrshefte zur wirtschaftsforschung 69(4) (Special issue)
Djellal F (2002) Innovation trajectories in the cleaning industry. New Technol Work Employ 17(2):119–131
Djellal F, Gallouj F (1999) Services and the search for relevant innovation indicators: a review of national and international surveys. Sci Public Policy 26(4):218–232
Djellal F, Gallouj F (2005) Mapping innovation dynamics in hospitals. Res Policy 34:817–835
Djellal F, Gallouj F (2008a) A model for analysing the innovation dynamic in services: the case of assembled services. Int J Serv Technol Manag 9(3/4):285–304
Djellal F, Gallouj F (2008b) Measuring and improving productivity in services: issues, strategies and challenges. Edward Elgar, London (forthcoming)
Djellal F, Francoz D, Gallouj C, Gallouj F, Jacquin Y (2003) Revising the definition of research and development in the light of the specificities of services. Sci Public Policy 30(6):415–430
Evangelista R (2000) Sectoral patterns of technological change in services. Econ Innov New Technol 9:183–221
Evangelista R, Savona M (2003) Innovation, employment and skills in services: firm and sectoral evidence. Struct Chang Econ Dyn 14:449–474
Fisher AGB (1935) The clash of progress and security. Macmillan, London
Fourastié J (1949) Le grand espoir du XX siècle. Presse Universitaire de France, Paris
Fuchs V (1968) The service economy. National Bureau of Economic Research, New York
Fuchs V (1977) The service industries and U.S. economic growth since World War II. NBER Working Paper Series 211 (November)
Gadrey J (1996) Services: la productivité en question. Desclée de Brouwer, Paris
Gadrey J (2000) The characterization of goods and services: an alternative approach. Rev Income Wealth Series 46(3):369–387 (September)
Gadrey J, Gallouj F (1998) The provider-customer interface in business and professional services. Serv Indust J 18(2):1–15
Gallouj C (2007) Innover dans la grande distribution. De Boeck, Bruxelles
Gallouj F (1994) Economie de l’innovation dans les services, Editions L’Harmattan. Logiques économiques, Paris
Gallouj F (1998) Innovating in reverse: services and the reverse product cycle. Eur J Innov Manag 1(3):123–138
Gallouj F (2002) Innovation in the service economy: the new wealth of nations. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Gallouj F, Weinstein O (1997) Innovation in services. Res Policy 2:537–556
Gershuny J (1978) After industrial society? The emerging self-service economy. MacMillan, London
Griliches Z (ed) (1971) Price indexes and quality change. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Griliches Z (ed) (1992) Output measurement in the service sector. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Hill TP (1977) On goods and services. Rev Income Wealth 4(23):315–338
Hill TP (1999) Tangibles, intangibles and services: a new taxonomy for the classification of output. Can J Econ 32(2):426–444
Hollander SC (1966) Notes on the retail accordion. J Retail 42(2):24–34
Howells J (2006) Where to from here for services innovation? A paper presented at the Knowledge Intensive Services Activities (KISA) Conference, Sydney, 22 March
Kline S, Rosenberg N (1986) An overview of innovation. In: Landau R, Rosenberg N (eds) The positive sum strategy: harnessing technology for economic growth. National Academy, Washington DC, pp 275–305
Kox H, Rubalcaba L (2007) Analysing the contribution of business services to European economic growth. Bruges European Economic Research Papers, 9 January
Kutscher R, Mark J (1983) The service-producing sector: some common perceptions reviewed. Monthly Labour Rev, 21–24 April
Kuznets S (1957) Quantitative aspects of the economic growth of nations, II: Industrial distribution of national product and labour force. Economic Development and Cultural Change Supplement, July
Kuznets S (1966) Modern economic growth, rate, structure and spread. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
Lancaster KJ (1966) A new approach to consumer theory. J Polit Econ 14:133–156
Lorenzi J-H, Pastré O, Tolédano J (1980) La crise du XXe siècle. Economica, Paris
McNair MP (1958) Significant trends and developments in the post war period. In: Smith AB (ed) Competitive distribution in a free high level economy and its implication for the university. University of Pittsburgh Press, Philadelphia
Miles I (2000) Service innovation: coming of age in the knowledge based economy. Int J Innov Manag 4:371–389
Miles I (2002) Service innovation: towards a tertiarisation of innovation studies. In: Gadrey J and Gallouj F (eds) Productivity, innovation and knowledge in services. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 164–196
Miles I (2005) Innovation in services. In: Fagerberg J, Mowery D, Nelson R (eds) The Oxford handbook of innovation. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Miozzo M, Soete L (2001) Internationalisation of services: a technological perspective. Technol Forecast Soc Change 67(2/3):159–185
Moulton BR (1991) A Bayesian approach to regression selection and estimation, with application to a price index for radio services. J Econom 49:169–193
Moulton BR (2001) The expanding role of Hedonic methods in the official statistics of the United States. Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Department of Commerce, June
Niehans J (1983) Financial innovation, multinational banking, and monetary policy. J Bank Financ 7:537–51
OECD (2000a) A new economy? The role of innovation and information technology in recent OECD economic growth. OECD, Paris
OECD (2000b) A new economy? The changing role of innovation and information technology in growth. OECD, Paris
OECD (2000c) The service economy. OECD, Paris
OECD (2001) The new economy: beyond the hype. The OECD growth project. OECD, Paris
Pavitt K (1984) Sectoral patterns of technical change: towards a taxonomy and a theory. Res Policy 13:343–374
Pavitt K, Robson M, Townsend J (1989) Technological accumulation, diversification and organisation in UK companies. Manage Sci 35:81–99
Peneder M (2001) Structural change, development and growth. Paper presented at the the future of innovation studies conference. Eindhoven University, Eindhoven, Netherlands
Peneder M, Kaniovsky S, Dachs B (2003) What follows tertiarisation? Structural change and the role of knowledge-based services. Serv Ind J 23:47–66
Petit P (1986) Slow growth and the service economy. Pinter, London
Saviotti PP, Metcalfe JS (1984) A theoretical approach to the construction of technological output indicators. Res Policy 13:141–151
Savona M (2004) Structural change and macro-economic performance. The structural bonus hypothesis for services. Paper presented at the XIV international conference of RESER, IUT Castres and Toulouse, France, 23–25 September
Savona M, Lorentz A (2005) Demand and technology contribution to structural change and tertiarisation. An input-output structural decomposition analysis. LEM Working Paper Series, 2005/25. http://www.lem.sssup.it/WPLem/files/2005–25.pdf
Schettkat R, Yocarini L (2006) The shift to services employment: a review of the literature. Struct Chang Econ Dyn 17:127–147
Smith A (1960) [1776] The wealth of nations. The Modern Library, Random House, New York
Soete L, Miozzo M (1989) Trade and development in services: a technological perspective. Maastricht Economic Research Institute on Innovation and Technology (MERIT) Working paper 89–031
Sundbo J (1998) The organisation of innovation in services. Roskilde University Press, Roskilde, Denmark
Sundbo J, Gallouj F (1999) Innovation as a loosely coupled system in services. Int J Serv Technol Manag 1(1):15–36
Sundbo J, Orfila-Sintes F, Soerensen F (2007) The innovative behaviour of tourism firms. Comparative studies of Denmark and Spain. Res Policy 36(1):88–106
Ten Raa T, Schettkat R (eds) (2001) The growth of service industries. The paradox of exploding costs and persistent demand. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Tether B (2005) Do services innovate (differently)?: insights from the European innobarometer survey. Ind Innov 12:153–184
Tushman ML, Anderson P (1986) Technological discontinuities and organizational environments. Adm Sci Q 31:439–465
Valente M (1999) Evolutionary economics and computer simulation. A model for the evolution of markets Vol. 1: consumer behaviour and technological complexity in the evolution of markets. DPhil dissertation, University of Aalborg, Denmark
Windrum P, Birchenhall C (1998) Is life cycle theory a special case?: dominant designs and the emergence of market niches through co-evolutionary learning. Struct Chang Econ Dyn 9:109–134
Windrum P, Birchenhall C (2005) Structural change in the presence of network externalities: a co-evolutionary model of technological successions. J Evol Econ 15(2):123–148
Windrum P, Garçia-Goni M (2008) A neo-Schumpeterian model of health services innovation. Res Policy 37(4):649–672
Acknowledgements
This research has been supported by the EC within the context of the FP7 ServPPIN (The Contribution of Public and Private Services to European Growth and Welfare, and the Role of Public-Private Innovation Networks) Project.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Maria Savona is also Research Fellow at the Cambridge-MIT Institute, University of Cambridge and at SPRU, Science and Technology Policy Research, University of Sussex, UK. The authors gratefully acknowledge the suggestions from two anonymous referees. The usual disclaimers apply.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gallouj, F., Savona, M. Innovation in services: a review of the debate and a research agenda. J Evol Econ 19, 149–172 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00191-008-0126-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00191-008-0126-4