Advertisement

Combating Human Trafficking for the Purpose of Organ Removal: Lessons Learned from Prosecuting Criminal Cases

  • Frederike AmbagtsheerEmail author
Living reference work entry

Abstract

Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal (THBOR) is a new and neglected form of human trafficking about which limited knowledge and awareness exists. A growing body of research suggests that the crime is proliferating globally. Nonetheless, the number of convictions remains considerably low. This chapter presents the experiences of police and prosecution in investigating and prosecuting two cases that involved (elements of) THBOR: the Netcare Case and the Medicus Clinic Case. The overarching objective is to draw lessons from police and prosecutors’ experiences and to offer possible explanations for why convictions of THBOR remain almost nonexistent. In both cases, police and prosecutors experienced numerous challenges, among which the length of the investigations, lack of experience prosecuting THBOR, lack of knowledge and awareness of THBOR, lack of resources, evidentiary issues, and legal loopholes. Lessons learned in the fight against THBOR also include reluctance to prosecute transplant professionals and other complicit officials. Indicators and reporting mechanisms for transplant professionals may be effective tools to improve nonlegislative responses to THBOR. Medical professionals and law enforcement should collaborate in the combat against THBOR. Despite these strategies, the challenges to investigation and prosecution of THBOR are likely to remain significant. Criminal prosecution should not be thought of as the primary tool for addressing all forms of organ trade but should be focused exclusively on excessive exploitation. Initiatives that boost organ supply, reduce harm, and enhance victim protection should be emphasized regardless of the success or failure of the prosecution of THBOR.

Keywords

Trafficking in human beings for organ removal Organ trade Organized crime Prosecution Criminal justice Law enforcement 

References

  1. Ambagtsheer F (2017) OrganTrade. Erasmus University Rotterdam retrieved from www.hottproject.com (accessed 4th July 2018)Google Scholar
  2. Ambagtsheer F, De Jong J, Bramer WM, Weimar W (2016) On patients who purchase organs abroad American Journal of Transplantation 16:2800–2815CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Ambagtsheer F, van Balen LJ, Duijst-Heesters WLJM, Massey EK, Weimar W (2015) Reporting organ trafficking networks: a survey-based plea to breach the secrecy oath American Journal of Transplantation 15:1759–1767CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Ambagtsheer F, Weimar W (eds) (2016) Trafficking in Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal: Results and Recommendations. Pabst Science Publishers, LengerichGoogle Scholar
  5. Anker AE, Feeley TH (2012) Estimating the risks of acquiring a kidney abroad: A meta-analysis of complications following participation in transplant tourism Clinical Transplantation 26:E232–E241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Balkaninsight (2018) Kosovo Convicts Two in Organ-Trading Trial. http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/kosovo-organ-trafficking-medicus-trial-verdict-05-24-2018/1425/3 (accessed 4th July 2018), Pristina
  7. Barratt A, Snyman P (2018) UPDATE: Researching South African Law Globalex http://www.nyulawglobal.org/globalex/South_Africa1.html (accessed 4th July 2018)
  8. Bosma A, Rijken C (2016) Key Challenges in the Combat of Human Trafficking: Evaluating the EU Trafficking Strategy and EU Trafficking Directive New Journal of European Criminal Law 7:315–330CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Budiani-Saberi DA, Raja KR, Findley KC, Kerketta P, Anand V (2014) Human Trafficking for Organ Removal in India: A Victim-Centered, Evidence-Based Report Transplantation 97:380–384CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Capron AM, Danovitch GM, Delmonico FL (2014) Organ markets: Problems beyond harms to vendors. American Journal of Bioethics 14(10):23–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Capron AM et al. (2016) Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal: stimulating and enhancing partnerships between transplant professionals and law enforcement Transplant Direct 2:e57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Caulfield T et al. (2016) Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal and the ethical and legal obligations of healthcare providers Transplant Direct 2:e60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Clawson HJ, Dutch N, Lopez S, Tiapula S (2008) Prosecuting human trafficking cases: Lessons learned and promising practices. National Institute of Justice, Washington DC https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/abstractdb/AbstractDBDetails.aspx?id=245913 (accessed 2 March 2018)Google Scholar
  14. Columb S (2015) Beneath the organ trade: a critical analysis of the organ trafficking discourse Crime, Law and Social Change 63:21–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Columb S (2016) Excavating the Organ Trade: An Empirical Study of Organ Trading Networks in Cairo, Egypt British Journal of Criminology 57:1301–1321Google Scholar
  16. Columb S, Ambagtsheer F, Bos M, Ivanovski N, Moorlock G, Weimar W (2017) Re-conceptualizing the organ trade: separating “trafficking” from “trade” and the implications for law and policy Transplant international 30:209–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Commission of the European Communities (2007) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council. Organ Donation and Transplantation: Policy Actions at EU Level, 1–11. Brussels: European Commission http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A52007DC0275 (accessed 30 May 2018).
  18. Cronin AJ, Johnson RJ, Birch R, Lechler RI, Randhawa G (2011) Solving the Kidney Transplant Crisis for Minority Ethnic Groups in the UK: is being transplanted overseas the answer? In: Weimar W, Bos MA, Busschbach JJ (eds) Organ Transplantation: Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects. Expanding the European Platform. Pabst Science Publishers Lengerich, pp 62–72Google Scholar
  19. Danovitch GM et al. (2013) Organ trafficking and transplant tourism: the role of global professional ethical standards—the 2008 Declaration of Istanbul Transplantation 95:1306–1312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. De Jong J (2017) Human Trafficking for the Purpose of Organ Removal. Utrecht Utrecht University (retrieved at www.hottproject.com)Google Scholar
  21. De Jong J, Ambagtsheer F (2016) Indicators to Identify Trafficking in Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal Transplantation Direct 2:e56  https://doi.org/10.1097/txd.0000000000000568CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Domínguez-Gil B et al. (2018) Management of patients who receive an organ transplant abroad and return home for follow-up care: recommendations from the Declaration of Istanbul Custodian Group Transplantation 102:e2–e9CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Domínguez-Gil B, López-Fraga M, Muller E, Gill JS (2017) The key role of health professionals in preventing and combating transplant-related crimes Kidney International 92:1299–1302  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.kint.2017.08.034CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Efrat A (2016) Global Efforts against Human Trafficking: The Misguided Conflation of Sex, Labor, and Organ Trafficking International Studies Perspectives 17:34–54Google Scholar
  25. European Committee on Crime Problems (1980) Report on Decriminalization Council of Europe Strasbourg (available on request)Google Scholar
  26. Farrell A, Owens C, McDevitt J (2014) New laws but few cases: understanding the challenges to the investigation and prosecution of human trafficking cases Crime, Law and Social Change 61:139–168CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Fry-Revere S (2014) The Kidney Sellers. A Journey of Discovery in Iran. Carolina Academic Press, Durham, North CarolinaGoogle Scholar
  28. Fry-Revere S, Chen D, Bastani B, Golestani S, Agarwal R, Kugathasan H, Le M (2018) Coercion, dissatisfaction, and social stigma: an ethnographic study of compensated living kidney donation in. Iran International Urology and Nephrology 1–12Google Scholar
  29. Ghods AJ, Savaj S (2006) Iranian model of paid and regulated living-unrelated kidney donation Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology 1:1136–1145CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gill J, Diec O, Landsberg DN, Rose C, Johnston O, Keown PA, Gill JS (2011) Opportunities to deter transplant tourism exist before referral for transplantation and during the workup and management of transplant candidates Kidney International 79:1026–1031CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. GODT (2017) Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation (GODT). Newsletter Transplant. International figures on donation and transplantation 2016 EDQM http://www.transplant-observatoryorg/download/newsletter-2017/ (accessed 16th August 2018) Volume 22
  32. Greenberg O (2013) The Global Organ Trade. A Case in Point Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 22:238–245CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Gutmann E (2014) The slaughter: mass killings, organ harvesting, and China’s secret solution to its dissident problem. Prometheus Books New York, NY,Google Scholar
  34. Haken J (2011) Transnational crime in the developing world. Global Financial Integrity http://www.gfintegrity.org/storage/gfip/documents/reports/transcrime/gfi_transnational_crime_web.pdf (accessed 20 October 2016),
  35. Harris J, Erin C (2002) An ethically defensible market in organs Br Med J 325:114–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hilhorst MT, Van Dijk G (2007) Financial incentives for organ donation. An investigation of the ethical issues. Centre for Ethics and Health http://hottproject.com/userfiles/Publicaties/FinancialIncentivesVanDijkHilhorst.pdf (accessed 30th May 2018), The Hague
  37. Holmes P et al. (2016) Establishing trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal and improving cross-border collaboration in criminal cases Transplant Direct 2:e58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Khalaf H, Farag S, El-Hussainy E (2004) Long-term follow-up after liver transplantation in Egyptians transplanted abroad Saudi Med J 25:1931–1934Google Scholar
  39. Koplin J (2014) Assessing the likely harms to kidney vendors in regulated organ markets American Journal of Bioethics 14(10):7–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Kwon CHD, Lee SK, Ha J (2011) Trend and outcome of Korean patients receiving overseas solid organ transplantation between 1999 and 2005 J Korean Med Sci 26:17–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lundin S (2012) Organ economy: Organ trafficking in Moldova and Israel Public Underst Sci 21:226–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Mahdavi-Mazdeh M (2012) The Iranian model of living renal transplantation Kidney Int 82:627–634CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Manzano A, Monaghan M, Potrata B, Clayton M (2014) The invisible issue of organ laundering Transplantation 98:600–603CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Martin D et al. (2016) Prevention of Transnational Transplant-Related Crimes-What More Can be Done? Transplantation 100:1776–1784CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Matas AJ (2006) Why we should develop a regulated system of kidney sales: a call for action! Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 1:1129–1132CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Matas D, Kilgour D (2009) Bloody harvest: The killing of Falun Gong for their organs. Seraphim Editions, Woodstock ON CanadaGoogle Scholar
  47. Merion RM et al. (2008) Transplants in foreign countries among patients removed from the US transplant waiting list American Journal of Transplantation 8:988–996CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Newton PJ, Mulcahy TM, Martin SE (2008) Finding victims of human trafficking. Citeseer, Bethesda: National Opinion Research CenterGoogle Scholar
  49. Orr Z (2014) International norms, local worlds: An ethnographic perspective on organ trafficking in the Israeli context. In: Weimar W, Bos MA, van Busschbach JJV (eds) Ethical, legal, and psychosocial aspects of transplantation: Global issues, local solutions. Pabst Science Publishers, Lengerich, pp 39–49Google Scholar
  50. OSCE (2013) Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal in the OSCE region: analysis and findings. Office of the Special Representative and Co-ordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings. Vienna http://www.osce.org/cthb/10339 (accessed 15 March 2016)
  51. Pascalev A et al. (2016) Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal: a comprehensive literature review. In: Ambagtsheer F, Weimar W (eds) Trafficking in Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal. Results and Recommendations. Pabst Lengerich, pp 15–68Google Scholar
  52. Sanal A (2004) “Robin Hood” of techno-Turkey or organ trafficking in the state of ethical beings Cult Med Psychiatry 28:281–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Sanal A (2011) New organs within us: transplants and the moral economy. Experimental Futures. Duke University Press, Durham [N.C.]Google Scholar
  54. Scheper-Hughes N (2004) Parts unknown undercover ethnography of the organs-trafficking underworld Ethnography 5:29–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Scheper-Hughes N (2011) Mr Tati’s holiday and João’s safari - Seeing the world through transplant tourism Body & Society 17:55–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Shafran D, Kodish E, Tzakis A (2014) Organ Shortage: The Greatest Challenge Facing Transplant Medicine World Journal of Surgery 38:1650–1657  https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-014-2639-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Sharif A, Singh MF, Trey T, Lavee J (2014) Organ Procurement From Executed Prisoners in China Am J Transplant 14:2246–2252  https://doi.org/10.1111/ajt.12871CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Shimazono Y (2007) The state of the international organ trade: a provisional picture based on integration of available information Bull World Health Organ 85:955–962CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Simforoosh N (2007) Kidney donation and rewarded gifting: an Iranian model Nat Clin Pract Urol 4:292–293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Territo L, Matteson R (2011) The international trafficking of human organs: a multidisciplinary perspective. CRC Press,Google Scholar
  61. Tong A, Chapman JR, Wong G, Cross NB, Batabyal P, Craig JC (2012) The experiences of commercial kidney donors: Thematic synthesis of qualitative research Transplant International 25:1138–1149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Tsai HJ, Yu CM, Wang YL (2011) Types of donor solicitation and their effectiveness on blood donation rates in eastern Taiwan Vox Sang 101:52Google Scholar
  63. United Nations (2000) United Nations Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. Vienna. Treaty Series, vol. 2237. https://www.unodc.org/unodc/treaties/CTOC/
  64. UNODC (2016) Global Report on Trafficking in Persons. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Vienna https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/glotip/2016_Global_Report_on_Trafficking_in_Persons.pdf (last accessed 1 March 2018)
  65. UNODC (2018) Case Law Database. Available from SHERLOC, from United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (last accessed 29th January 2019). http://www.unodc.org/cld/index-sherloc-cld.jspx.
  66. Yea S (2010) Trafficking in part(s): The commercial kidney market in a Manila slum, Philippines Global Social Policy 10:358–376CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Yousaf FN, Purkayastha B (2015) ‘I am only half alive’: Organ trafficking in Pakistan amid interlocking oppressions International Sociology 30:637–653CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Zargooshi J (2008) Iran’s commercial renal transplantation program: Results and complications. In: Weimar W, Busschbach J, Bos MA (eds) Organ Transplantation: Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects - Towards a Common European Policy, Lengerich, Pabst, pp 80–92Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Internal Medicine, Section Transplantation and NephrologyErasmus MCRotterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations