Advertisement

Human Dignity in Malta

  • David Edward ZammitEmail author
  • Mary Muscat
Living reference work entry

Abstract

The concept of dignity draws upon roots diffused throughout Malta’s mixed legal system, reflecting the historical influence of the Ius Commune, as modulated through Civilian doctrine and jurisprudence and complemented by British Constitutional principles and Socialist and Liberal ideals. In the colonial period, express legislative references to dignity concerned nonhuman entities, including particular professions and institutions. After Independence in 1964, the concept of human dignity was introduced through three distinct generations of legislation comprising: (a) the Constitution as subsequently complemented by the European Convention of Human Rights Act, (b) postcolonial legislation, and (c) legislative efforts to align Maltese and EU law. Thanks to the activity of the courts and the legislator, various concepts of dignity coexist within Maltese legal discourse and the concept of human dignity has sometimes been broadly applied as synonymous with respect to the intrinsic humanity, identity and equality of all human persons. However, the treatment of informal migrants and undocumented asylum-seekers provides a clear practical counterexample, revealing how the compartmentalised approach to legal interpretation in Malta’s mixed jurisdiction places significant constraints on the possibility of further developing human dignity as a fundamental value underlying all Maltese legislation.

Keywords

Malta Legal hybridity Jurisprudence Professional/institutional dignity Generation of legislation Compartmentalisation Human dignity Undocumented migrants Dignity of the worker Dignity of the spouse Dignity of the tort victim 

References

  1. Andò B (2011) The role of judges in the development of mixed legal systems: the case of Malta. J Civ Law Stud 4:237–260Google Scholar
  2. Andò B, Aquilina K, Scerri-Diacono J, Zammit D (2012) Malta. In: Palmer V (ed) Mixed jurisdictions worldwide: the third legal family, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 528–576CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Anonymous (1958) Towards a Maltese Constitution: a long story of vicissitudes. Roundtable Commonw J Int Aff 48:345–354CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Anonymous (2018) ‘Good Samaritan’ bill to protect first aiders to be discussed tomorrow in parliament. The Malta Independent, 3 July 2018Google Scholar
  5. Aquilina K (2018) Constitutional Law in Malta. Kluwer Law International, Alphen aan den RijnGoogle Scholar
  6. Attard DJ (2012) The Maltese legal system, vol I. Malta University Press, MsidaGoogle Scholar
  7. Attard DJ (2015) The Maltese legal system, vol II. Malta University Press, MsidaGoogle Scholar
  8. Azzopardi J (2004) Police culture in Malta. Dissertation, University of Leicester. http://www.humanrightsmalta.org/uploads/1/2/3/3/12339284/police_culture_malta.pdf. Accessed 13 Aug 2018
  9. Bonello G (2004) The Maltese Civil Code: a brief historical introduction. In: Bonello G (ed) Histories of Malta – reflections and rejections, vol 5. Fondazzjoni Patrimonju Malti, Valletta, pp 190–197Google Scholar
  10. Bonello G (2018a) Misunderstanding the Constitution: a battery of pointless ‘principles’? Sunday Times of Malta, 7 January 2018Google Scholar
  11. Bonello G (2018b) Forget your human rights unless you exhaust other remedies? Sunday Times of Malta, 21 January 2018Google Scholar
  12. Bonello G (2018c) Misunderstanding the Constitution – 11: are these the daft remedies the Constitution wants? Sunday Times of Malta, 1 April 2018Google Scholar
  13. Bonello G (2018d) Misunderstanding the Constitution – 12: legal fictions? Lost in translation? Sunday Times of Malta, 8 April 2018Google Scholar
  14. Borg T (2007) Exile of 43 Maltese 60 years ago: one of the most shameful episodes of Malta’s history. http://www.maltamigration.com/news/times89353.shtml. Accessed 13 Aug 2018
  15. Borg T (2016) Commentary on the Constitution of Malta. Kite Group, Birkirkara, MaltaGoogle Scholar
  16. Caruana Demajo G, Quintano L, Zammit D (2015) Malta. In: Karner E, Steininger B (eds) European Tort Law yearbook 2014. De Gruyter, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  17. Caruana Demajo G, Quintano L, Zammit D (2016) Malta. In: Karner E, Steininger B (eds) European Tort Law yearbook 2015. De Gruyter, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  18. Ciappara F (2018) Church-State relations in late eighteenth century Malta: Gio. Nicolo Muscat (1735–1803). Malta University Press, MsidaGoogle Scholar
  19. Cremona JJ (1996) Malta and Britain – the early constitutions. Publishers Enterprises Group, San Gwann, MaltaGoogle Scholar
  20. Cremona JJ (1997) The Maltese Constitution and constitutional history since 1813. Publishers Enterprises Group, San Gwann, MaltaGoogle Scholar
  21. Cremona JJ (2001) Human rights documentation in Malta. Mediterr J Hum Rights 5:153–168. Double IssueGoogle Scholar
  22. De Bono D (2013) ‘Less than human’: the detention of irregular migrants in Malta. Race Class 55:60–81Google Scholar
  23. De Gaetano VA (2012) Social rights. http://www.judiciarymalta.gov.mt/documents. Accessed 1 Aug 2018
  24. Donlan SP, Andò B, Zammit D (2012) “A happy union?” Malta’s legal hybridity. Tulane Eur Civ Law Forum 27:165–208Google Scholar
  25. Donlan SP, Marrani D, Twomey M, Zammit DE (2017) Legal education and the profession in three mixed/micro jurisdictions: Malta, Jersey and Seychelles. In: Butler P, Morris C (eds) Small states in a legal world. Springer International Publishing, Cham, pp 191–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE) (2018) Malta intensifies crackdown on rescuing organisations, while deaths in the Mediterranean are on the rise. https://www.ecre.org/malta-intensifies-crackdown-on-rescuing-organisations-while-deaths-in-the-mediterranean-are-on-the-rise. Accessed 28 Aug 2018
  27. Farrugia R (2007) The position in Malta juxtaposed to the principles of European Family Law: divorce and maintenance. In: Mair J, Orucu E (eds) Juxtaposing legal systems and the principles of European Family Law. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 99–127Google Scholar
  28. Gallagher A, Pistone M, Zammit D (2007) The subject of rights immersed in a “sea of troubles”. Mediterr J Hum Rights 11:9–16Google Scholar
  29. Ganado JM (1947) Maltese Law. J Comp Legis Int Law 29:32–39Google Scholar
  30. Ganado JM (1950) British Public Law and the Civil Law in Malta. Curr Leg Probl 3(1):195–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Ganado JM (1996) Malta: a microcosm of international influences. In: Örücü E, Attwooll E, Coyle S (eds) Studies in legal systems: mixed and mixing. Kluwer Law International, The Hague, pp 225–247Google Scholar
  32. Government of Malta (1920) Government of Malta blue book 1919–1920. Government Printing Press, VallettaGoogle Scholar
  33. Government of Malta (1927) Government of Malta blue book 1927. Government Printing Press, VallettaGoogle Scholar
  34. Harding HW (1980) Maltese legal history under British rule (1801–1836). Malta University Press, Msida, MaltaGoogle Scholar
  35. Mangion R (2015) Aspects on forces of influence by persons and groups under Malta’s first responsible government. In: Agius E, Scerri H (eds) The quest for authenticity and human dignity. Gutenberg Press, Tarxien, pp 303–337Google Scholar
  36. Micallef Grimaud C (2011a) Article 1045 of the Maltese Civil Code: is compensation for moral damage compatible therewith? J Civ Law Stud 4(2):480–513Google Scholar
  37. Micallef Grimaud C (2011b) Moral damages outside the ambit of the Maltese Civil Code. Id-Dritt 21:109–139Google Scholar
  38. Mifsud I (2015) The Constitution: 50 years of proposals and counter proposals. University of Malta, MsidaGoogle Scholar
  39. Mifsud-Bonnici U (2008) Human rights in Maltese legislation. In: Zammit DE (ed) Maltese perspectives on human rights. University of Malta, Msida, pp 99–117Google Scholar
  40. Reflections by 100 Academics (2018) Embryo Protection (Amendment) Bill: matters of concern. ReportGoogle Scholar
  41. Sadegh I (2018) Third country national. In: Bartolini A, Colcelli V, Cippitani R (eds) Dictionary of statuses within EU Law. Springer, Dordrecht (in press)Google Scholar
  42. Sadegh I, Zammit DE (2018) Legitimising a Muslim marriage in Malta: navigating legal and normative structures. Oxf J Law Relig 7(3):1–21Google Scholar
  43. Said-Pullicino J (2001) Malta. In: Blackburn R, Polakiewicz J (eds) Fundamental rights in Europe, the European Convention on Human Rights and its Member States 1950–2000. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 559–594Google Scholar
  44. Said Pullicino J (2008) The ombudsman: his role in human rights protection and promotion. In: Zammit DE (ed) Maltese perspectives on human rights. University of Malta, Msida, pp 118–146Google Scholar
  45. Savvidis C (2016) Court delay and human rights remedies. Routledge, Oxford/New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Suban R, Zammit DE (2017) Promoting the integration of third-country nationals through the labour market: combating discrimination in employment: the case of third-country nationals in Malta. In: Mediterranean human rights review, vol 1. https://www.um.edu.mt/laws/?a=336450. Accessed 21 Oct 2018
  47. Women’s Anti-Discrimination Committee (2004) UN Women’s Anti-Discrimination Committee experts urge Malta to incorporate convention into Domestic Law. https://www.un.org/press/en/2004/wom1456.doc.html. Accessed 19 Aug 2018
  48. Zammit EL (1984) A colonial inheritance: Maltese perceptions of work, power and class structure with reference to the labour movement. University of Malta Press, MsidaGoogle Scholar
  49. Zammit DE (1998) Laws and stories: towards an ethnographic study of Maltese legal representation. Dissertation, University of DurhamGoogle Scholar
  50. Zammit DE (2002) The case of the ‘Faithful Prostitute’: judicial creativity and family values in a Southern European context. Tijdschrift voor Familie- en Jeugdrecht 1:10–15Google Scholar
  51. Zammit DE (2008) Introduction. In: Zammit DE (ed) Maltese perspectives on human rights. University of Malta, Msida, pp 1–15Google Scholar
  52. Zammit DE (2013) Balancing between patronage and professionalism: an ethnographic account of lawyering in Malta. In: Azzopardi J, Formosa S, Scicluna S, Willis A (eds) Key issues in criminology. University of Malta, Msida, pp 65–86Google Scholar
  53. Zammit DE (2016a) Does the non cumul rule exist in our civil law? Dike kai nomos 10:55–94Google Scholar
  54. Zammit DE (2016b) Vernacularizing Asylum Law in Malta. In: Arnold R, Colcelli V (eds) Europeanization through private law instruments. Universitätsverlag Regensburg, Regensburg, pp 73–107Google Scholar
  55. Zammit DE (2018) Subsidiary status. In: Bartolini A, Colcelli V, Cippitani R (eds) Dictionary of statuses within EU Law. Springer International Publishing, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  56. Zammit EL, Brincat M (2006) Malta. In: Blanpain R (ed) Labour Law and industrial relations international encyclopaedia of laws. Kluwer Law International, London & The NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
  57. Zammit DE, Grima C (2014) Medical liability and psychological damage in Maltese jurisprudence. In: Ferrari V, Tlokinski W, Zammit DE (eds) Responsabilita Medica ed Organizzazione Sanitaria. Aracne Editrice, Rome, pp 197–236Google Scholar
  58. Zammit DE, Xerri K (2015) “Lease, Locazioni and Kera”: merging legal concepts in postcolonial Malta. In: Farran S, Gallen J, Rautenbach C (eds) The diffusion of law: the movement of laws and norms around the world. Ashgate, London, pp 77–90Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Civil Law, Faculty of LawsUniversity of MaltaMsidaMalta

Personalised recommendations