Abstract
In The Communist Manifesto, Marx and Engels wrote that workers have no country. This chapter defends that tendency in Marxist thought. Patriotism is identification with and loyalty to a nation-state. States arise in human prehistory to consolidate and extend exploitation and oppression of laboring classes by a ruling class. Philosophers often write of a “national community,” but class societies in general and capitalist societies in particular are so brutal in their oppression of workers that the language of “community” is nonsense. In capitalist society, the state suppresses those who are exploited and oppressed by capitalists and advances capitalists’ aims beyond national borders. So for the working class, patriotism is loyalty to the state of those who oppress them, and it makes no sense to be loyal to one’s oppressors.
Both Marx and Engels and Marxists who followed them were ambivalent about national and patriotic loyalties. Lenin argued that workers have an internationalist duty to recognize the right of national self-determination because otherwise they side with oppressing ruling classes against oppressed nationalities. Lenin neglected the possibility of opposing national (and racial) oppression without recognizing a right of national self-determination. This neglect was due to the belief, inherited from Marx and Engels, that nationalist movements could be progressive and help the development toward communist society. However, the history of the twentieth century shows that this is wrong. Nationalism and patriotism undermine the struggle for classless society by creating alliances with capitalists and dividing workers from other workers. Patriotism and proletarian internationalism are truly contradictory. Workers have no country.
Keywords
An early draft of this chapter was discussed at a session of the Davis Area Group on Ethics and Related Subjects (DaGERS), where Tina Rulli, Adam Sennett, Kyle Adams, Tim Houk, Noel Joshi-Richard, Jacob Velasquez, and Chris Healow raised helpful criticisms and suggestions. I am grateful to David Copp, Michael Merry, Mary Gomberg, Barbara Foley, Sheldon Jones, and Bill Sacks for criticisms of more final drafts.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
References
Alexander M (2010) The new Jim crow. The New Press, New York
Anderson B (2006) Imagined communities. Verso, London
Baptist EE (2014) The half has never been told. Basic Books, New York
Baron M (1997) Patriotism and “liberal” morality. In: McKim R, McMahan J (eds) The morality of nationalism. Oxford University Press, New York
Barton RF (1930) The half-way sun. Brewer and Warren, New York
Bello W (1994) Dark victory. Pluto Press, London
Blackmon DA (2008) Slavery by another name. Doubleday, New York
Byock JL (1988) Medieval Iceland. University of California Press, Berkeley
Chang KC (1976) Early Chinese civilization. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Chossudovsky M (1997) The globalization of poverty. Third World Network, Penang
Earle T (1997) How chiefs come to power. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Gomberg P (1997) How morality works and why it fails. J Soc Philos 28(3):43–70
Gomberg P (2002) The fallacy of philanthropy. Can J Philos 32(1):29–66
Gomberg P (2007) How to make opportunity equal: race and contributive justice. Blackwell, Oxford
Gutman H (1977) Work, culture and Society in Industrializing America. Vintage, New York
Haas J (1982) The evolution of the prehistoric state. Columbia University Press, New York
Haywood H (1978) Black Bolshevik. Liberator Press, Chicago
Jessop B. The state: past, present, future. Cambridge: polity; 2016
Lee RB (1979) The !Kung san: men, women, and work in a foraging society. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Lenin VI (1963a) The right of nations to self-determination. In: Lenin VI (ed) Selected works, vol 1. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Lenin VI (1963b) The war and Russian social democracy. In: Lenin VI (ed) Selected works, vol 1. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Lenin VI (1964) The socialist revolution and the right of nations to self-determination. In: Lenin VI (ed) Collected works, vol 22. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Lenin VI (1972) Critical remarks on the National Question. In: Lenin VI (ed) Collected works volume, vol 20. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Lenin VI (1967) The state and revolution. In: Lenin VI (ed) Selected works volume, vol 2. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Mao Z. On new democracy. Peking: foreign languages press; 1966
MacIntyre A. Is patriotism a virtue? Lawrence: University of Kansas; 1984
Marx K (1974a) The revolutions of 1848. Vintage, New York
Marx K (1974b) The first international and after. Vintage, New York
Marx K, Engels F (1975) Selected correspondence 1844–1895 third revised edition. Progress Publishers, Moscow
Miller D (1995) On nationality. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Miller RW (1998) Cosmopolitan respect and patriotic concern. Philos Public Aff 27(3):202–224
Nathanson S (1989) In defense of moderate patriotism. Ethics 99(3):535–552
Nussbaum M (1996) For love of country. Beacon Press, Boston
Oldenquist A (1982) Loyalties. J Philos 79(4):173–193
Parenti C (1999) Lockdown America. Verso, London
Perkinson R (2010) Texas tough. Metropolitan Books, New York
Primoratz I, Pavković A (eds) (2016) Patriotism: political and philosophical perspectives. Routledge, London
Progressive Labor Party (1969, August) Revolutionaries must fight nationalism. PL Magazine 7 (2):2–13. Available at www.plp.org
Progressive Labor Party (1971, November) Road to revolution III. PL Magazine 8(3):8–24. Available at www.plp.org
Progressive Labor Party (n.d.) Smash racism: a fighter’s manual. Available at www.plp.org
Sahlins M (1974) Stone age economics. Tavistock, London
Scheffler S (1997) Liberalism, nationalism, and egalitarianism. In: McKim R, McMahan J (eds) The morality of nationalism. Oxford University Press, New York
Solomon M (1998) The cry was unity: communists and African Americans, 1917–1936. University Press of Mississippi, Jackson
Stalin J (1975) Marxism and the National Question. In: Stalin J. Marxism and the national-colonial question. Proletarian Publishers, San Francisco
Stalin J. On the great patriotic war of the soviet union. Moscow: foreign languages publishing house; 1946
Stuesse A (2016) Scratching out a living: Latinos, race, and work in the deep south. University of California Press, Berkeley
Tajfel H (1981) Human groups and social categories. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Taylor M (1982) Community, anarchy and liberty. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Weber M (1946) Essays in sociology. Oxford University Press, New York
Williams WA (1959) The tragedy of American diplomacy. World Publishing, Cleveland
Wright A (1990) The death of Ramon Gonzalez. University of Texas Press, Austin
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2018 Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature
About this entry
Cite this entry
Gomberg, P. (2018). Against Patriotism, for Internationalism: A Marxist Critique of Patriotism. In: Sardoc, M. (eds) Handbook of Patriotism. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30534-9_13-1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30534-9_13-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-30534-9
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-30534-9
eBook Packages: Springer Reference Religion and PhilosophyReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Humanities