Abstract
Groundwater recharge estimation in arid and semi-arid southern Africa is reviewed based on four decades of recharge investigation in the region. This paper updates an earlier review by incorporating emerging and grey literature from a wide range of research sectors in southern Africa, collected during the past decade. For ease of comparison, methods commonly used are critically reviewed with a rating provided in terms of accuracy, application and costs. These include, but are not limited to, the methods of chloride mass balance (CMB), rainfall infiltration breakthrough (RIB), Extended model for Aquifer Recharge and moisture Transport through unsaturated Hardrock (EARTH), water-table fluctuation (WTF), water balance in the saturated zone (including equal volume spring flow (EVSF) and saturated volume fluctuation (SVF)), and groundwater modelling (GM). As the methods based on mass balance and relationships between rainfall, water-level fluctuations and abstraction are proven to have the potential to simulate and forecast groundwater recharge, the EVSF and CMB methods are highly recommended for use in the southern African region according to this review. Caution on the uncertainty associated with error input and propagation for all the methods is advised, based on a case study in South Africa. The review provides an updated source of references related to recharge estimation in arid and semi-arid regions of Sub-Saharan Africa in general and to ongoing projects for the implementation for Resource Directed Measures (part of the National Water Resources Strategy) in South Africa in particular.
Résumé
L’évaluation de la recharge des eaux souterraines en Afrique australe aride et semi-aride est. passée en revue sur la base de quatre décennies de recherche sur la recharge dans la région. Cet article met à jour une revue précédente en incorporant de la littérature émergente et de la littérature grise provenant d’une large gamme de travaux de recherches en Afrique australe, rassemblés pendant la décennie passée. Pour faciliter la comparaison, les méthodes généralement utilisées sont passées en revue de manière critique à l’aide d’une estimation produite en termes d’exactitude, application et coûts. Celles-ci incluent, sans s’y limiter, le bilan des chlorures (CMB), le développement Pluie-Infiltration (RIB), le modèle étendu pour la recharge de l’aquifère et le transport de l’humidité à travers la zone non saturée des roches de socle (EARTH), l’analyse des fluctuations de nappe (WTF), le bilan hydrologique dans la zone saturée (y compris l’équivalence volumique au débit des sources (EVSF), la fluctuation du volume saturé (SVF), ainsi que la modélisation des eaux souterraines (GM). Comme il s’avère que les méthodes basées sur le bilan massique et les rapports entre les précipitations, les fluctuations de niveau d’eau et les prélèvements ont le potentiel de simuler et de prévoir la recharge d’eaux souterraines, les méthodes d’EVSF et de CMB sont fortement recommandées pour être utilisées dans la région de l’Afrique australe, selon cette revue. La prudence sur l’incertitude liée à l’entrée et à la propagation d’erreur pour toutes les méthodes est. conseillée, selon une étude de cas en Afrique du Sud. La revue fournit une source actualisée de références concernant l’évaluation de la recharge dans des régions arides et semi-arides de l’Afrique sub-saharienne en général et, les projets en cours pour l’exécution du programme Mesures Axées sur la Ressource (élément de la stratégie nationale des ressources en eau) en Afrique du Sud en particulier.
Resumen
Se analiza la estimación de la recarga de agua subterránea en el África austral árida y semiárida sobre la base de cuatro décadas de investigación en la región. Este documento actualiza una revisión anterior incorporando literatura emergente e inédita de una amplia gama de sectores de investigación en el sur de África, recopilados durante la última década. Para facilitar la comparación, los métodos comúnmente utilizados se analizar críticamente con una calificación proporcionada en términos de precisión, aplicación y costos. Estos incluyen, pero no se limitan a, los métodos de Balance de Masa de Cloruro (CMB), de infiltración de la precipitación (RIB), del modelo EARTHH (modelo extendido para recarga de acuífero y transporte de humedad a través de la zona no saturada, de la fluctuación de niveles freáticos (WTF), del equilibrio de agua en la zona saturada (incluido el flujo de manantiales de igual volumen (EVSF) y de la fluctuación de volumen saturado (SVF)) y del modelado de aguas subterráneas (GM). Como los métodos basados en el balance de masa y las relaciones entre lluvia, fluctuaciones del nivel del agua y extracción han demostrado tener el potencial de simular y pronosticar la recarga de aguas subterráneas, los métodos EVSF y CMB son altamente recomendables para su uso en la región del sur de África según esta revisión. Se recomienda precaución sobre la incertidumbre asociada con la entrada de error y la propagación para todos los métodos, según un estudio de caso en Sudáfrica. La revisión proporciona una fuente actualizada de referencias relacionadas con la estimación de la recarga en regiones áridas y semiáridas del África subsahariana en general y con proyectos en curso para la implementación de medidas dirigidas a los recursos (parte de la estrategia nacional de recursos hídricos) en especial en Sudáfrica.
摘要
根据四十年的补给调查,论述了非洲南部干旱半干旱地区地下水补给量估算情况。本文通过把过去十年在非洲南部各个部门收集到的新和老的文献结合在一起,对早先的综述进行了更新。为便于比较,根据准确性、应用情况和成本提供的等级对常用的方法进行了详尽的论述。这些方法包括、但不限于,氯化物质量平衡法、降雨入渗突破法、通过非饱和硬岩的含水层补给和水分运移的扩展模型法、水位波动法、饱和带水平衡法(等量容积泉水流法和饱和容积波动法)以及地下水模拟。由于这些基于质量平衡及降雨、水位波动和抽水之间的相互关系的方法证明具有模拟和预测地下水补给的潜力,因此,本文综述强烈建议在非洲南部采用等量容积泉水流法和氯化物质量平衡法。根据南非一个研究案例,特别提醒在所有方法中,要谨慎对待与错误输入和传播相关的不确定性。综述提供了与非洲撒哈拉以南干旱半干旱地区补给量估算有关的以及与南非正在进行的资源指导措施实施项目相关的最新参考源。
Resumo
A estimativa de recarga de águas subterrâneas na África austral árida e semiárida é revisada com base em quatro décadas de investigação de recarga na região. Este artigo atualiza uma revisão anterior, incorporando literatura recente e passada de uma ampla gama de setores de pesquisa na África austral, coletados durante a última década. Para facilitar a comparação, os métodos comumente usados são revisados criticamente com uma classificação baseada em termos de precisão, aplicação e custos. Estes incluem, mas não estão limitados a, os métodos de Balanço de Massa de Cloreto (BMC/CBM), Ruptura da Infiltração da Precipitação (RIP/RIB), Modelo Estendido para Recarga de Aquífero e Transporte de Umidade através de Rocha Insaturada (EARTH), Variação da Superfície Livre (VSL/WTF), Balanço Hídrico na Zona Saturada (incluindo Fluxo de Fonte de Volume Igual (FFVI/EVSF) e Flutuação do Volume Saturado (FVS/SVF)) e Modelagem de Águas Subterrâneas (MAS). Como os métodos baseados em balanço de massa e relações entre chuvas, flutuações no nível da água e captação têm o potencial de simular e prever a recarga das águas subterrâneas, os métodos FFVI e BMC são altamente recomendados para uso na região da África austral de acordo com esta revisão. É aconselhável ter cuidado com a incerteza associada à entrada e propagação de erros para todos os métodos, com base em um estudo de caso na África do Sul. A revisão fornece uma fonte atualizada de referências relacionadas à estimativa de recarga em regiões áridas e semiáridas da África Subsaariana em geral e a projetos em andamento para a implementação de Medidas Dirigidas à Recursos (parte da Estratégia Nacional de Recursos Hídricos) na África do Sul em especial.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams S (2002) Bulk rainfall samplers and groundwater recharge. In: Proceedings of the Conference on Tales of a Hidden Treasure, 16 Sept 2002, Somerset West
Adams S (2004) Groundwater recharge assessment of the basement aquifers of central Namaqualand. PhD thesis, University of the Western Cape
Ahmadi T, Ziaei AN, Rasoulzadeh A, Davary K, Esmaili K, Izady A (2014) Mapping groundwater recharge areas using CRD and RIB methods in the semi-arid Neishaboor Plain, Iran. Arab J Geosci 8:2921–2935. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12517-014-1321-2
Albhaisi M, Brendonck L, Batelaan O (2013) Predicted impacts of land use change on groundwater recharge of the upper Verg catchment, South Africa. Water SA 39(2):211–220
Aller L, Bennet T, Lehr JH, and Petty RJ (1987) DRASTIC – A standardised system for evaluating groundwater pollution potential using hydrogeological setting. US EPA Report EPA/600/2–87/035, Washington, DC
Allison GB, Gee GW, Tyler SW (1994) Vadose-zone techniques for estimating groundwater recharge in arid and semi-arid regions. Soil Sci Soc Am J 58:6–14
Bear J (1972) Dynamics of fluids in porous media. American Elsevier, New York, pp 764
Beekman HE, Gieske A, Selaolo ET (1996) GRES: Groundwater recharge studies in Botswana 1987-1996. Botswana J of Earth Sci III:1–17
Beekman HE, Selaolo ET, De Vries JJ (1999) Groundwater recharge and resources assessment in the Botswana Kalahari. GRES II Executive summary and technical reports, Gaborone, pp 48
Beekman HE and Sunguro S (2002) Groundwater recharge estimation – Suitability and reliability of three types of rain gauges for monitoring chloride deposition. In: Proceedings of the Conference on Tales of a Hidden Treasure, 16 Sept 2002, Somerset West
Beekman HE, Sunguro S (2015) Groundwater Management of the Nyamandlovu Aquifer System with special emphasis on the Nyamandlovu Wellfield —“Nyamanadlovu Groundwater Model – Steady State. A final report for a project commissioned by ZINWA and financed by GIZ and AusAid, June 2015, Harare
Beekman HE, Xu Y, Saayman I, Adams S (2003) A Report to START on the regional workshop entitled: Framework for recharge estimation in Southern Africa, 10–11 July 2003, Somerset West, pp 24
Beekman HE, Xu Y (2003) Review of groundwater recharge estimation in arid and semi-arid southern Africa In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Bonsor HC, MacDonald AM (2010) Groundwater and climate change in Africa: review of recharge studies. British Geological Survey Internal Report, IR/10/075, pp 30
Braune E, Xu Y (2010) The role of ground water in Sub-Saharan Africa. Ground Water 48(2):229–238
Bredenkamp DB, Vogel JC (1970) Study of a dolomitic aquifer with carbon-14 and tritium. In: Isotope Hydrology 1970, Proc. Symp. IAEA, 9–13 March 1970, Vienna
Bredenkamp DB, Schutte, JM, Dutoit, GJ (1974) Recharge of a dolomitic aquifer as determined from tritium profiles. Isotope Techniques in Groundwater Hydrology, IAEA, Vienna, pp 73–94
Bredenkamp DB, Botha LJ, Van Tonder GJ, Van Rensburg HJ (1995) Manual on Quantitative Estimation of Groundwater Recharge and Aquifer Storativity. WRC Report TT 73/95, Pretoria, pp 407
Bufler R, Ambs P, Himmelsbach T, Tordiffe E, Baumle R (2000) Preliminary assessment of the groundwater potential of the Tsumeb aquifers in northern Namibia. In: Proc. XXX IAH Congress on Groundwater: past achievements and future challenges, 26 Nov–1 Dec 2000, Cape Town
Cave L, Beekman HE, Weaver J (2003) Impact of climate change on groundwater resources, In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Cook PG (2003) A guide to regional groundwater flow in fractured rock aquifers. CSIRO-Seaview Press, South Australia, ISBN 1740082338, pp 108
De Vries JJ and Von Hoyer M (1988) Groundwater recharge studies in semi-arid Botswana – a review. In: Simmers I (ed) Estimation of Natural Groundwater Recharge. NATO ASI series C222, Reidel, Dordrecht, pp 339-348
De Vries JJ, Selaolo ET, Beekman HE (2000) Groundwater recharge in the Kalahari, with reference to paleo-hydrologic conditions. J Hydrol 238(1–2):110–123
De Vries JJ, Simmers I (2002) Groundwater recharge: an overview of processes and challenges. Hydrogeol J 10(1):5–17
Doll P, Fiedler K (2007) Global-scale modeling of groundwater recharge. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci Discuss 4:4069–4124. http://www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci-discuss.net/4/4069/2007. Accessed 14 March 2018
DWA (2010) Groundwater Resource Assessment II: 3a Recharge, presented by Conrad J of GEOSS. In: Proceedings of the Recharge Workshop UWC 14–16 Nov 2011, Cape Town
Eriksson E, Khunakasem V (1969) Chloride concentration in groundwater, recharge rate and rate of deposition of chloride in the Israel coastal plain. J Hydrol 7:178–197
Fluhler H, Polomski J, Blaser P (1982) Retention and movement of fluoride in soils. J Environ Qual 11(3):461–468
Ford D, Williams P (2007) Karst Hydrogeology and Geomorphology. Wiley, Chichester
Foster SSD, Bath AH, Farr JL, Lewis WJ (1982) The likelihood of active groundwater recharge in the Botswana Kalahari. J Hydrol 55:113–136
Gieske A (1992) Dynamics of groundwater recharge: A case study in semi-arid Eastern Botswana. PhD thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam
Healy RW (2010) Estimating groundwater recharge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Houston J (1988) Rainfall-runoff-recharge relationships in the basement rocks of Zimbabwe. In: Simmers I (ed) Estimation of Natural Groundwater Recharge. NATO ASI series C222, Reidel, Dordrecht, 349-366
Lubczynski MW (2006) Groundwater fluxes in semi-arid environments. In: A Baba et al (eds) Groundwater and ecosystems, 225–236, 2006 Springer, Enschede
Lubczynski MW (2009) (2009) The hydrogeological role of trees in water-limited environments. Hydrogeol J 17:247–259
Izady AK, Davary A, Alizadeh A, Ziaei N, Akhavan S, Alipoor A, Joodavi A, Brusseau ML (2015) Groundwater conceptualization and modeling using distributed SWAT-based recharge for the semi-arid agricultural Neishaboor plain, Iran. ISSN 1431–2174 23(1)
Jennings CMH (1974) The Hydrogeology of Botswana. PhD thesis, University of Natal, pp 850
JICA (2002) The Study of Groundwater Potential Evaluation and Management Plan in the Southeast Kalahari (Stampriet) Artesian Basin in the Republic of Namibia-Final Report. JICA Report, Pacific Consultants International Co., LTD, Tokyo
Kim J and Jackson RB (2011) A Global Analysis of Groundwater Recharge for Vegetation, Climate, and Soils. Vadose Zone J. https://doi.org/10.2136/vzj2011.0021RA Received 5 Mar. 2011. URL: http:/www.VadoseZoneJournal.org
Kinzelbach W, Aeschbach W, Alberich C, Goni IB, Beyerle U, Brunner P, Chiang WH, Rueedi J, Zoellmann K (2002) A survey of methods for groundwater recharge in arid and semi-arid regions. Early warning and assessment report series, UNEP/DEWA/RS.02–2. Nairobi, pp 101
Kirchner J (2003) Changing rainfall – changing recharge? In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Klock H (2001) Hydrogeology of the Kalahari in north-eastern Namibia with special emphasis on groundwater recharge, flow modelling and hydrochemistry. PhD Thesis, Univ. Würzburg
Lerner DN, Isswar A, Simmers I (1990) A guide to understanding and estimating natural recharge. IAH International Contributions to Hydrogeology, 8, Verlag Heinz Heisse, pp 345
Levy J, Xu Y (2012) Review: Groundwater management and groundwater/surface-water interaction in the context of South African water policy, Hydrogeology Journal 20(2)
Lloyd JW (1986) A review of aridity and groundwater. Hydrol Process 1:63–78
Lin D, Jin M, Liang X, Zhan H (2013) Estimating groundwater recharge beneath irrigated farmland using environmental tracers fluoride, chloride and sulphate. Hydrogeol J 21:1469–1480
Marechal JC, Dewandel B, Ahmed S, Galeazzi L, Zaidi FK (2006) Combined estimation of specific yield and natural recharge in a semi-arid groundwater basin with irrigated agriculture. J Hydrol 329(1–2):281–293
Mazor E, Verhagen BTH, Sellschop JPF, Jones MT, Robins NS, Hutton L, Jennings CMH (1977) Northern Kalahari groundwaters: hydrologic, isotopic and chemical studies at Orapa. Botswana J Hydrol 34:203–234
Mohammadi Z, Salimi M, Faghih A (2014) Assessment of groundwater recharge in a semi-arid groundwater system using water balance equation, southern Iran, J African Earth Sci 95:1–8
Nyagwambo NL (2006) Groundwater Recharge Estimation and Water Resources Assessment in a Tropical Crystalline Basement Aquifer. PhD thesis, Delft University of Technology
Parsons R, Wentzel J (2007) Groundwater Resource Directed Measures Manual: Setting Resource Directed Measures (RDM) for Groundwater: A pilot study. WRC Report No TT 299/07, Pretoria
Rezaei Z, Mohammadi Z (2017, 2017) Annual safe groundwater yield in a semiarid basin using combination of water balance equation and water table fluctuation. J Afr Earth Sci
Sami K, Hughes DA (1996) A comparison of recharge estimates to a fractured sedimentary aquifer in South Africa from a chloride mass balance and an integrated surface-subsurface model. J Hydrol 179(1–4):111–136
Schalk K (1961) The water balance of the Uhlenhorst cloudburst in South West Africa. In: Inter-African Conference on Hydrology (pp 443–449), Nairobi: CCTA Publication 66, 1961, Nairobi
Scanlon BR (2000) Uncertainties in estimating water fluxes and residence times using environmental tracers in an arid unsaturated zone. Water Resour Res 36(2):395–409
Scanlon BR, Healy RW, Cook PG (2002) Choosing appropriate techniques for quantifying groundwater recharge. Hydrogeol J 10(1):18–39
Schmidt G, Ploethner D (2000) Hydrogeological investigations in the Otavi Mountain Land. In: Proceedings of the XXX IAH Congress on Groundwater: past achievements and future challenges, 419–424, Cape Town
Schulze RE (1995) Hydrology and Agrohydrology: a text to accompany the ACRU 3.00 agrohydrological modelling system. WRC Report No. TT69/95, Pretoria
Selaolo ET (1998) Tracer studies and groundwater recharge assessment in the eastern fringe of the Botswana Kalahari – The Lethlakeng – Botlhapatlou area. PhD thesis, Free University- Amsterdam, pp 224
Selaolo ET, Beekman HE, Gieske ASM and De Vries JJ (2003) Multiple tracer profiling in Botswana – Findings of the GRES Project. In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Shamboko-Mbale B, Siwale C, Baumle R, Kreleler T (2012) Development of a groundwater information & management program for the Lusaka groundwater system. Report No 7: Water balance estimates for sub-catchments of the Chongwe and Mwembeshi Rivers in the Lusaka Region (BGR report), 2012, Lusaka
Simmers I (1988) Estimation of Natural Groundwater Recharge. NATO ASI series C, vol 222 (Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop, Antalya, Turkey, March 1987) Reidel, Dordrecht, pp 510
Simmers I, Hendrickx JMH, Kruseman GP, Rushton KR (1997) Recharge of phreatic aquifers in (semi)-arid areas. IAH International Contributions to Hydrogeology, vol 19, AA Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 277
Smit PJ (1978) Groundwater recharge in the dolomite of the Ghaap Plateau near Kuruman in the Northern Cape, Republic of South Africa. Water SA 4(2):8192
Stone AEC, Edmunds WM (2011) Sand, salt and water in the Stampriet Basin, Namibia: Calculating unsaturated zone (Kalahari dunefield) recharge using the chloride mass balance approach. Water SA, 38(3), pp 367–380
Sun X, Xu Y, Jovanovic NZ, Kapangaziwiri E, Brendonck L, Bugan RDH (2013) Application of the rainfall infiltration breakthrough (RIB) model for groundwater recharge estimation in west coastal South Africa. Water SA 39(2):221–230
Van Der Lee J, Gehrels JC (1997) Modelling of groundwater recharge for a fractured dolomite aquifer under semi-arid conditions. In: Simmers I (ed) IAH-Recharge of Phreatic Aquifers in (Semi-) Arid Areas, AA Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 129–144
Van Tonder GJ, Xu Y (2000) Recharge – Excel-based software to quantify recharge. Geohydrology Report of Department of Water Affairs and Forestry, Pretoria
Van Wyk E, Van Tonder GJ, Vermeulen D (2011) Characteristics of local groundwater recharge cycles in South African semi-arid hard rock terrains – rainwater input. Water SA 37(2):147–154
Verhagen B, Mazor E, Sellschop J (1974) Radiocarbon and tritium evidence for direct rain recharge to groundwaters in the Northern Kalahari. Nature 249:643–644
Wang L, Dochartaigh BO, MacDonald D (2010) A literature review of recharge estimation and groundwater resource assessment in Africa, Groundwater Resources Programme Internal Report IR/10/051. British Geological Survey, Nottingham
Weaver JMC, Talma AS (1999) Field studies of chlorofluorocarbons (CFC’s) as a groundwater dating tool in fractured rock aquifers, WRC Report 731/1/99, Pretoria
Xu Y (2012) Book review: Urban Geology, edited by Peter Huggenberger and Jannis Epting (Springer Basel, 2011), Hydrogeol J 20:1211. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-012-0860-4
Xu Y, Beekman HE (2003a) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa, In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Xu Y, Beekman EH (2003b) A box model for estimating recharge – the RIB method. In: Xu Y and Beekman HE (eds) Groundwater recharge estimation in Southern Africa. UNESCO IHP Series No. 64, ISBN 92-9220-000-3, Paris
Xu Y, Pienaar H, Braune E, Cao J (2015) A review of the implementation of groundwater protection measures, in particular Resource Directed Measures, in South Africa in the context of ChinAfrica Water Forum dialogues. WRC report (WRC KSA1: K8/1097/1), Pretoria
Xu Y, Van Tonder GJ (2001) Estimation of recharge using a revised CRD method. Water SA 27(3):341–344
Xu Y, Colvin C, Van Tonder GJ, Hughes D, Le Maitre D, Zhang GJ, Mafanya T, Braune E (2003) Towards the resource directed measures: groundwater component. WRC Report No. 1090–2/1/03, Pretoria
Xu Y, Titus R, Holness SD, Zhang J, Van Tonder GJ (2002) A hydrogeomorphological approach to quantification of groundwater discharge to streams in South Africa. Water SA 28(4):375–380
Xu Y, Wu Y, Duah A (2007) Groundwater recharge estimation of table mountain group aquifer systems with case studies, WRC Report 1329/1/07, Pretoria
Acknowledgements
This paper builds upon a UNESCO publication by Beekman and Xu (2003). Grey literature, including reports, were provided by many groundwater practitioners including Diganta Sarma, Eddie van Wyk, Phil Hobbs and others. The College of Water Resources Science and Engineering at Taiyuan University of Technology in China is acknowledged for providing support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Xu, Y., Beekman, H.E. Review: Groundwater recharge estimation in arid and semi-arid southern Africa. Hydrogeol J 27, 929–943 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-018-1898-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-018-1898-8