Abstract
Compliant coating research is one of those areas which experienced its fair share of triumphs and debacles. For over forty years, the subject has fascinated, frustrated and occasionally gratified scientists and engineers searching for methods to delay laminar-to-turbulence transition, to reduce skin-friction drag in turbulent wall-bounded flows, to quell vibrations, and to suppress flow-induced noise. In its simplest form, the technique is passive, relatively easy to apply to an existing vehicle or device, and perhaps not too expensive. Through the years, however, claims for substantial drag and noise reductions were made, only to be later refuted when the results were more critically examined. There are several important issues with regard to the reliability of available analytical, numerical and experimental results. In this chapter, some of these issues, particularly as they relate to the search for drag-reducing compliant coatings, will be addressed with the objective of elucidating the potential pitfalls to newcomers to the field. Problem formulation with the proper boundary conditions, impossibility of obtaining first-principles analytical solutions when the wall-bounded flow is turbulent, and limitations of existing numerical simulations will be elaborated. The effects of background turbulence in a wind or water tunnel, accurate drag measurements, compliant wall motion, and the geometry and properties of the coatings used will be among the outstanding experimental issues discussed. Attempts will be made to explain some of the seemingly contradictory results available in the open literature.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Aleyev, Yu.G. (1977) Nekton, Dr. W. Junk b.v. Publishers, the Hague, the Netherlands.
Au, D., and Weihs, D. (1980) “At High Speeds Dolphins Save Energy by Leaping,” Nature 284, no. 5756, 10 April, pp. 548–550.
Babenko, V.V., and Kozlov, L.F. (1972) “Experimental Investigation of Hydrodynamic Stability on Rigid and Elastic Damping Surfaces,” J. Hydraulic Res. 10, pp. 383–408.
Benjamin, T.B. (1960a) “Effects of a Flexible Boundary on Hydrodynamic Stability,” J. Fluid Mech. 9, pp. 513–532.
Benjamin, T.B. (1960b) “Fluid Flow with Flexible Boundaries, Proc. Eleventh International Congress of Applied Mechanics, ed. H. Görtler, pp. 109–128, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Benjamin, T.B. (1963) “The Threefold Classification of Unstable Disturbances in Flexible Surfaces Bounding Inviscid Flows,” J. Fluid Mech. 16, pp. 436–450.
Benjamin, T.B. (1966) “Fluid Flow with Flexible Boundaries,” in Proc. Eleventh International Congress of Applied Mechanics, ed. H. Görtler, pp. 109–128, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Betchov, K. (1960) “Simplified Analysis of Boundary-Layer Oscillations,” J. Ship Res. 4, pp. 37–54.
Blick, E.F., and Walters, R.R. (1968) “Turbulent Boundary-Layer Characteristics of Compliant Surfaces,” J. Aircraft 5, pp. 11–16.
Buckingham, A.C., Hall, M.S., and Chun, R.C. (1985) “Numerical Simulations of Compliant Material Response to Turbulent Flow,” AIAA J. 23, pp. 1046–1052.
Burton, T.E. (1974) “The Connection Between Intermittent Turbulent Activity Near the Wall of a Turbulent Boundary Layer with Pressure Fluctuations at the Wall,” Massachusetts Institute of Technology Report No. 70208–10, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Bushnell, D.M., and Moore, K.J. (1991) “Drag Reduction in Nature,” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 23, pp. 65–79.
Bushnell, D.M., Hefner, J.N., and Ash, R.L. (1977) “Effect of Compliant Wall Motion on Turbulent Boundary Layers,” Phys. Fluids 20, no. 10, part II, pp. S31—S48.
Carpenter, P.W. (1988) “The Optimization of Compliant Surfaces for Transition Delay, in Turbulence Management and Relaminarisation, eds. H.W. Liepmann and R. Narasimha, pp. 305–313, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Carpenter, P.W. (1990) “Status of Transition Delay Using Compliant Walls,” in Viscous Drag Reduction in Boundary Layers, eds. D.M. Bushnell and J.N. Hefner, pp. 79–113, AIAA, Washington, D.C.
Carpenter, P.W. (1993) “Optimization of Multiple-Panel Compliant Walls for Delay of Laminar-Turbulent Transition,” AIAA J. 31, pp. 1187–1188.
Carpenter, P.W. (1998) “Current Status of the Use of Wall Compliance for Laminar-Flow Control,” Exp. Thermal Fluid Sci. 16, pp. 133–140.
Carpenter, P.W., and Garrad, A.D. (1985) “The Hydrodynamic Stability of Flow over Kramer-Type Compliant Surfaces. Part 1. Tollmien—Schlichting Instabilities,” J. Fluid Mech. 155, pp. 465–510.
Carpenter, P.W., and Garrad, A.D. (1986) “The Hydrodynamic Stability of Flow over Kramer-Type Compliant Surfaces. Part 2. Flow-Induced Surface Instabilities,” J. Fluid Mech. 170, pp. 199–232.
Carpenter, P.W., Davies, C., and Lucey, A.D. (2000) “Hydrodynamics and Compliant Walls: Does the Dolphin have a Secret?,” Current Science 79, no. 6, pp. 758–765.
Carpenter, P.W., Lucey, A.D., and Davies, C. (2001) “Progress on the Use of Compliant Walls for Laminar-Flow Control,” J. Aircraft 38, pp. 504–512.
Choi, K.-S., editor (1991) Recent Developments in Turbulence Management, Kluwer, Dordrecht, the Netherlands.
Choi, K.-S., Yang X., Clayton B.R., Glover E.J., Atlar M., Semenov B.N., and Kulik V.M. (1997) “Turbulent Drag Reduction Using Compliant Surfaces,” Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 453, 2229–2240.
Chu, H.H., and Blick, E.F. (1969) “Compliant Surface Drag as a Function of Speed,” J. Spacecraft Rockets 6, pp. 763–764.
Colley, A.J., Thomas, P.J., Carpenter, P.W., and Cooper, A.J. (1999) “An Experimental Study of Boundary-Layer Transition over a Rotating, Compliant Disk,” Phys. Fluids 11, pp. 3340–3352.
Cooper, A.J., Carpenter, P.W. (1995) “The Effects of Wall Compliance on Instability in Rotating Disc Flow,” AIAA Paper No. 95–2257, Washington, D.C.
Cooper, A.J., Carpenter, P.W. (1997a) “The Stability of Rotating-Disc Boundary-Layer Flow over a Compliant Wall. Part 1. Type I and II Instabilities,” J. Fluid Mech. 350, pp. 231–259.
Cooper, A.J., Carpenter, P.W. (1997b) “The Stability of Rotating-Disc Boundary-Layer Flow over a Compliant Wall. Part 2. Absolute Instability,” J. Fluid Mech. 350, pp. 261–270.
Cooper, A.J., Carpenter, P.W. (1997c) “The Effect of Wall Compliance on Inflexion Point Instability in Boundary Layers,” Phys. Fluids 9, pp. 468–470.
Daniel, A.P., Gaster, M., and Willis, G.J.K. (1987) “Boundary Layer Stability on Compliant Surfaces,” Final Report No. 35020, British Maritime Technology Ltd., Teddington, Great Britain.
Davies, C., and Carpenter, P.W. (1997a) “Numerical Simulation of the Evolution of Tollmien-Schlichting Waves over Finite Compliant Panels,” J. Fluid Mech. 335, pp. 361–392.
Davies, C., and Carpenter, P.W. (1997b) “Instabilities in a Plane Channel Flow between Compliant Walls,” J. Fluid Mech. 352, pp. 205–243.
Dinkelacker, A. (1966) “Preliminary Experiments on the Influence of Flexible Walls on Boundary Layer Turbulence,” J. Sound Vibr. 4, pp. 187–214.
Dixon, A.E., Lucey, A.D., and Carpenter, P.W. (1994) “The Optimization of Viscoelastic Compliant Walls for Transition Delay,” AIAA J. 32, pp. 256–267.
Domaradzki, J.A., and Metcalfe, R.W. (1987) “Stabilization of Laminar Boundary Layers by Compliant Membranes,” Phys. Fluids 30, pp. 695–705.
Duncan, J.H. (1986) “The Response of an Incompressible, Viscoelastic Coating to Pressure Fluctuations in a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” J. Fluid Mech. 171, pp. 339–363.
Duncan, J.H. (1987) “A Comparison of Wave Propagation on the Surfaces of Simple Membrane Walls and Elastic Coatings Bounded by a Fluid Flow,” J. Sound Vibr. 119, pp. 565–573.
Duncan, J.H. (1988) “The Dynamics of Waves at the Interface between a Two-Layer Viscoelastic Coating and a Fluid Flow,” J. Fluids Structures 2, pp. 35–51.
Duncan, J.H., and Sirkis, J.S. (1992) “The Generation of Wave Patterns on Isotropic Coatings by Pressure Fluctuations in a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” J. Sound Vibr. 157, pp. 243–264.
Duncan, J.H., and Hsu, C.C. (1984) “The Response of a Two-Layer Viscoelastic Coating to Pressure Disturbances from a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” AIAA Paper No. 84–0535, New York.
Duncan, J.H., Waxman, A.M., and Tulin, M.P. (1985) “The Dynamics of Waves at the Interface between a Viscoelastic Coating and a Fluid Flow,” J. Fluid Mech. 158, pp. 177–197.
Fischer, M.C., and Ash, R.L. (1974) “A General Review of Concepts for Reducing Skin Friction, Including Recommendations for Future Studies,” NASA Technical Memorandum No. X-2894, Washington, D.C.
Fisher, D.H., and Blick, E.F. (1966) “Turbulent Damping by Flabby Skins,” J. Aircraft 3, pp. 163–164.
Fraser, L.A., and Carpenter, P.W. (1985) “A Numerical Investigation of Hydroelastic and Hydrodynamic Instabilities in Laminar Flows over Compliant Surfaces Comprising One or Two Layers of Viscoelastic Material,” in Numerical Methods in Laminar and Turbulent Flow, eds. C. Taylor et al., pp. 1171–1181, Pineridge Press, Swansea, Great Britain.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1986a) “Boundary Layer Interactions with Compliant Coatings: An Overview,” Appl. Mech. Rev. 39, pp. 511–524.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1986b) “The Response of Elastic and Viscoelastic Surfaces to a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” J. Appl. Mech. 53, pp. 206–212.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1987) “Compliant Coatings Research: A Guide to the Experimentalist,” J. Fluids Structures 1, pp. 55–70.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1994) “Interactive Control of Turbulent Boundary Layers: A Futuristic Overview,” AIAA J. 32, pp. 1753–1765.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1996a) “Compliant Coatings: A Decade of Progress,” Appl. Mech. Rev. 49, no. 10, part 2, pp. S1—S11.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (1996b) “Modern Developments in Flow Control,” A ppl. Mech. Rev. 49, pp. 365–379.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (2000) Flow Control: Passive, Active, and Reactive Flow Management, Cambridge University Press, London, United Kingdom.
Gad-el-Hak, M. (editor) (2001) The MEMS Handbook, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida.
Gad-el-Hak, M., Blackwelder, R.F., and Riley, J.J. (1984) “On the Interaction of Compliant Coatings with Boundary Layer Flows,” J. Fluid Mech. 140, pp. 257–280.
Garrad, A.D., and Carpenter, P.W. (1982) “A Theoretical Investigation of Flow-Induced Instabilities in Compliant Coatings,” J. Sound Vibr. 85, pp. 483–500.
Gaster, M. (1988) “Is the Dolphin a Red Herring?,” in Turbulence Management and Relaminarisation, eds. H.W. Liepmann and R. Narasimha, pp. 285–304, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Gray, J. (1936) “Studies in Animal Locomotion. VI. The Propulsive Powers of the Dolphin,” J. Exp. Biol. 13, pp. 192–199.
Hansen, R.J., and Hunston, D.L. (1974) “An Experimental Study of Turbulent Flows over Compliant Surfaces,” J. Sound Vibr. 34, pp. 297–308.
Hess, D.E. (1990) “An Experimental Investigation of a Compliant Surface beneath a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” Ph.D. Dissertation, the Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland.
Hess, D.E., Peattie, R.A., and Schwarz, W.H. (1993) “A Nonintrusive Method for the Measurement of Flow-Induced Surface Displacement of a Compliant Surface,” Exp. Fluids 14, pp. 78–84.
Huerre, P., and Monkewitz, P.A. (1990) “Local and Global Instabilities in Spatially Developing Flows,” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 22, pp. 473–537.
Johnson, R.P. (1980) “Review of Compliant Coating Research of M. O. Kramer, RPJ Associates Technical Report No. RPJA-TR-0955–001, Palos Verdes Peninsula, California.
Joslin, R.D., and Morris, P.J. (1992) “Effect of Compliant Walls on Secondary Instabilities in Boundary-Layer Transition,” AIAA J. 30, pp. 332–339.
Kaplan, R. E. (1964) “The Stability of Laminar Incompressible Boundary Layers in the Presence of Compliant Boundaries,” Sc.D. Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Kramer, M.O. (1957) “Boundary-Layer Stabilization by Distributed Damping,” J. Aeronaut. Sci. 24, pp. 459–460.
Kramer, M.O. (1960a) “Boundary-Layer Stabilization by Distributed Damping,” J. Aero/ Space Sci. 27, p. C9.
Kramer, M.O. (1960b) “Boundary Layer Stabilization by Distributing Damping,” J. Am. Soc. Naval Engrs. 72, pp. 25–33.
Kramer, M.O. (1960c) “The Dolphin’s Secret,” New Scientist 7, 5 May, pp. 1118–1120.
Kramer, M.O. (1961) “The Dolphin’s Secret,” J. Am. Soc. Nav. Engrs. 73, pp. 103–107.
Kramer, M.O. (1962) “Boundary Layer Stabilization by Distributed Damping,” J. Am. Soc. Naval Engrs. 74, pp. 341–348.
Kramer, M.O. (1965) “Hydrodynamics of the Dolphin,” in Advances in Hydroscience, ed. V.T. Chow, vol. 2, pp. 111–130, Academic Press, New York.
Kramer, M.O. (1969) “Die Widerstandsverminderung Schneller Unterwasserkörper Mittels Künstlicher Delphinhaut,” in Jahrbuch 1969 der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Luftund Raumfahrt, eds. H. Blenk and W. Schulz, pp. 1–9, Köln, Federal Republic of Germany.
Landahl, M.T. (1962) “On the Stability of a Laminar Incompressible Boundary Layer over a Flexible Surface,” J. Fluid Mech. 13, pp. 609–632.
Landau, L.D., and Lifshitz, E.M. (1987) Fluid Mechanics, second edition, Pergamon Press, Oxford, Great Britain.
Lang, T.G. (1963) “Porpoise, Whales, and Fish: Comparison of Predicted and Observed Speeds,” Naval Eng. J. 75, pp. 437–441.
Lee, T., Fisher, M., and Schwarz, W.H. (1993a) “Investigation of the Stable Interaction of a Passive Compliant Surface with a Turbulent Boundary Layer,” J. Fluid Mech. 257, pp. 373–401.
Lee, T., Fisher, M., and Schwarz, W.H. (1993b) “The Measurement of Flow-Induced Surface Displacement on a Compliant Surface by Optical Holographic Interferometry,” Exp. Fluids 14, pp. 159–168.
Lee, T., Fisher, M., and Schwarz, W.H. (1995) “Investigation of the Effects of a Compliant Surface on Boundary-Layer Stability,” J. Fluid Mech. 288, pp. 37–58.
Lee, T., Fisher, M., and Schwarz, W.H. (1997) “An Experimental Study of the Boundary-Layer Nonlinear Instability over Compliant Walls,” unpublished manuscript originally submitted to J. Fluid Mech..
Lissaman, P.B.S., and Harris, G.L. (1969) “Turbulent Skin Friction on Compliant Surfaces,” AIAA Paper No. 69–164, New York.
Looney, R.W., and Blick, E.F. (1966) “Skin Friction Coefficients of Compliant Surfaces in Turbulent Flow,” J. Spacecraft & Rockets 3, pp. 1562–1564.
Lucey, A.D., and Carpenter, P.W. (1993) “The Hydroelastic Stability of Three-Dimensional Disturbances of a Finite Compliant Panel,” J. Sound Vibr. 165, pp. 527–552.
Lucey, A.D., and Carpenter, P.W. (1995) “Boundary Layer Instability over Compliant Walls: Comparison between Theory and Experiment,” Phys. Fluids 7, pp. 2355–2363.
McMichael, J.M., Klebanoff, P.S., and Meese, N.E. (1980) “Experimental Investigation of Drag on a Compliant Surface,” in Viscous Flow Drag Reduction, ed. G.R. Hough, pp. 410–438, AIAA, New York.
McMurray, J.T., Metcalfe, R.W., and Riley, J.J. (1983) “Direct Numerical Simulations of Active Stabilization of Boundary Layer Flows,” Proc. Eighth Biennial Symp. on Turbulence, eds. J.L. Zakin and G.K. Patterson, paper no. 36, University of Missouri, Rolla, Missouri.
Metcalfe, R.W. (1994) “Boundary Layer Control: a Brief Review, in Computational Fluid Dynamics ‘94, eds. J. Periaux and E. Hirschel, pp. 52–60, Wiley, New York.
Metcalfe, R.W., Battistoni, F., Ekeroot, J., and Orszag, S.A. (1991) “Evolution of Boundary Layer Flow over a Compliant Wall during Transition to Turbulence,” in Proc. Boundary Layer Transition and Control Conference, pp. 36.1–36.14, Royal Aeronautical Society, Cambridge, Great Britain.
Metcalfe, R.W., Rutland, C.J., Duncan, J.H., and Riley, J.J. (1986) “Numerical Simulations of Active Stabilization of Laminar Boundary Layers, AIAA J. 24, pp. 1494–1501.
Nisewanger, C.R. (1964) “Flow Noise and Drag Measurements of Vehicle with Compliant Coating,” U.S. Naval Ordnance Test Station Report No. 8518, NOTS No. TP-3510, China Lake, California.
Orszag, S.A. (1979) “Prediction of Compliant Wall Drag Reduction,” NASA Contractor Report No. 3071, Washington, D.C.
Puryear, F.W. (1962) “Boundary Layer Control: Drag Reduction by Use of Compliant Coatings,” David Taylor Model Basin Report No. 1668, Bethesda, Maryland.
Rayleigh, Lord (1887) “On Waves Propagated along the Plane Surface of an Elastic Solid,” Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. XVII, pp. 4–11.
Riley, J.J., Gad-el-Hak, M., and Metcalfe, R.W. (1988) “Compliant Coatings,” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 20, pp. 393–420.
Ritter, H., and Messum, L.T. (1964) “Water Tunnel Measurements of Turbulent Skin Friction on Six Different Compliant Surfaces of 1 Ft Length,” British Admiralty Research Laboratory Report No. ARL/N4/GHY/9/7, ARL/G/N9, London, Great Britain.
Ritter, H., and Porteous, J.S. (1964) “Water Tunnel Measurements of Skin Friction on a Compliant Coating,” British Admiralty Research Laboratory Report No. ARL/N3/ G/HY/9/7, London, Great Britain.
Robinson, S.K. (1991) “Coherent Motions in the Turbulent Boundary Layer,” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 23, pp. 601–639.
Sen, P.K., and Arora, D.S. (1988) “On the Stability of Laminar Boundary-Layer Flow over a Flat Plate with a Compliant Surface,” J. Fluid Mech. 197, pp. 201–240.
Smith, R.L., and Blick, E.F. (1966) “Skin Friction of Compliant Surfaces with Foamed Material Substrate,” J. Hydronautics 3, pp. 100–102.
Spalart, P.R. (1988) “Direct Simulation of a Turbulent Boundary Layer up to Rθ = 1410,” J. Fluid Mech. 187, pp. 61–98.
Thomas, M.D. (1992a) “On the Resonant Triad Interaction in Flows over Rigid and Flexible Boundaries,” J. Fluid Mech. 234, pp. 417–442.
Thomas, M.D. (1992b) “On the Nonlinear Stability of Flows over Compliant Walls,” J. Fluid Mech. 239, pp. 657–670.
Willis, G.J.K. (1986) “Hydrodynamic Stability of Boundary Layers over Compliant Surfaces,” Ph.D. Thesis, University of Exeter, Exeter, Great Britain.
Yeo, K.S. (1988) “The Stability of Boundary-Layer Flow over Single- and Multi-Layer Viscoelastic Walls,” J. Fluid Mech. 196, pp. 359–408.
Yeo, K.S. (1990) “The Hydrodynamic Stability of Boundary-Layer Flow over a Class of Anisotropic Compliant Walls,” J. Fluid Mech. 220, pp. 125–160, 1990.
Yeo, K.S. (1992) “The Three-Dimensional Stability of Boundary-Layer Flow over Compliant Walls, J. Fluid Mech. 238, pp. 537–577.
Yeo, K.S., and Dowling, A.P. (1987) “The Stability of Inviscid Flows over Passive Compliant Walls,” J. Fluid Mech. 183, pp. 265–292.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2003 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this paper
Cite this paper
Gad-El-Hak, M. (2003). Drag Reduction Using Compliant Walls. In: Carpenter, P.W., Pedley, T.J. (eds) Flow Past Highly Compliant Boundaries and in Collapsible Tubes. Fluid Mechanics and Its Applications, vol 72. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-0415-1_9
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-0415-1_9
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-90-481-6235-2
Online ISBN: 978-94-017-0415-1
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive