Reimagining the Smart UTOPIA: A Conclusion

Abstract

Smart energy technologies are not some fanciful or futuristic idea. They are here — now. However, they rarely constitute the rational and deliberative tools of many energy utilities’ dreams. Instead they represent a diverse array of possibilities, being used to justify leaving the clothes dryer on, re-negotiate expectations of thermal comfort, support existing and create new spiritual experiences, or enrol householders in practices of ‘growing’ their own energy. The absence of these realities from the Smart UTOPIA means that, while it holds exciting potential, it is a fundamentally flawed vision. In seeking to perform a self-reproducing smart ontology in which human action is framed around the idealised energy consumer — Resource Man — the Smart UTOPIA excludes, ignores or seeks to eradicate the vast majority of human experience and energy’s role within it. The fact that this internationally pervasive vision has so far failed to receive significant critical interrogation is of serious concern.