Ideology and Motivations in the First Crusade

  • Jean Flori
Part of the Palgrave Advances book series (PAD)

Abstract

The ideology of crusade did not suddenly appear with Pope Urban II’s appeal at Clermont in November 1095. Scholars now acknowledge that it resulted from a slow evolution that, in the course of one millennium, led the Church from its original pacifism preached by Jesus of Nazareth to the concept of holy war that blossomed before the end of the eleventh century. Pope Urban II, however, added to this ideology a new sacral dimension which derived from the distinctive objectives of the crusade, the liberation of Jerusalem and the holy places. This new dimension explains its immense success. It transformed the former ‘ordinary’ holy war into a ‘most holy’ war, the crusade, whose ideology would dominate the western mind for several centuries, reactivate the jihād in the Muslim Near East and, in its turn, arouse other ideologies against it, which would lead on the one hand to the Protestant Reformation and on the other to the birth of secular thought.

Keywords

Burning Migration Europe Syria Expense 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Notes

  1. 1.
    A. Becker, Papst Urban H (1988–1099), 2 vols (Stuttgart, 1964), vol. 1, pp. 24–78; J. Riley-Smith, The First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading (London, 1993), p. 12.Google Scholar
  2. 2.
    J. Flori, ‘L’Eglise et la guerre sainte: de la paix de Dieu a la croisade’, Annales: Economies, SociEtés, Civilisations, 47 (1992), 88–99; H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘From the Peace of God to the First Crusade’, in La primera cruzada novecientos arios después: el concilio de Clermont y los origenes del movimiento cruzado, ed. L. Garcia-Guijarro Ramos (Castello d’Impressio, 1997), pp. 51–61; J. Flori, ‘De la paix de Dieu a la croisade? Un réexamen’, Crusades, 2 (2003), 1–23. The most famous statement of the case is by C. Erdmann, Die Entstehung des Kreuzzugsgedankens (Stuttgart, 1935), translated by M. W. Baldwin and W. Goffart as The Origin of the Idea of Crusade (Princeton, 1977), pp. 59–67, 75–7. For a contrary view, see M. Bull, Knightly Piety and the Lay Response to the First Crusades: The Limousin and Gascony, c. 970-c. 1130 (Oxford, 1993), pp. 20–69.Google Scholar
  3. 3.
    J. Flori, ‘Chevalerie et liturgie. Remise des armes et vocabulaire “chevaleresque” dans les sources liturgiques du IXe au XIVe siecle’, Le Moyen Age, 84 (1979), 409–42; J. Flori, ‘Les origines de l’adoubement chevaleresque: Etude des remises d’armes et du vocabulaire qui les exprime dans les sources historiques latines jusqu’au debut du XIII siecle’, Traditio, 35 (1979), 209–72; M. Keen, Chivalry (New Haven and London, 1984), pp. 64–77.Google Scholar
  4. 4.
    Erdmann, Origin of the Idea of Crusade, pp. 148–81; E. Delaruelle, ‘Essai sur la formation de l’idée de croisade’, Bulletin de littérature ecclésiastique, 42 (1941), 24–45 and 86–103; 45 (1944), 13–46 and 73–90; 54 (1953), 226–39; 55 (1954), 50–63; repr. in E. Delaruelle, Lidée de croisade (Turin, 1980), especially p. 46ff.; A History of the Crusades, ed. K. M. Setton, vol. 1: The FirstHundred Years, ed. M. W. Baldwin (Philadephia, 1955), pp. 222–5; I. S. Robinson, ‘Gregory VII and the Soldiers of Christ’, History, 58 (1973), 169–72; J. Gilchrist, ‘The Papacy and War against the “Saracens”#x2019;, International HistoryReview, 10 (1988), 174–97; H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘Pope Gregory VII and the Bearing of Arms’, Montloie: Studies in Crusade History in Honour of Hans Eberhard Mayer, ed. B. Z. Kedar, J. RileySmith and R. Hiestand (Aldershot, 1997), pp. 21–35.Google Scholar
  5. 6.
    Erdmann, Origin of the Idea of Crusade; Delaruelle, ‘Essai sur la formation’; P. Rousset, Histoire dune idéologie. La croisade (Lausanne, 1983), pp. 25–40; C. Violante, ‘La pataria e la militia Dei nelle fonti e nella realta’, in ‘Militia Chrisrie Crociata nei secoli XI-XIII: Atti della undecima Settimana internazionale di studio, Mendola, 28 agosto -1 settembre 1989 (Milan, 1992), pp. 103–27; H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘The Genesis of the Crusades: The Springs of Western Ideas of Holy War’, in The Holy War, ed. T. P. Murphy (Columbus, 1976), pp. 9–32; J. Flori, La guerre sainte. La formation de lidée de croisade dans lOccident chrétien (Paris, 2001), especially pp. 101–88.Google Scholar
  6. 7.
    Gregory VII, ‘Registrum’, ed. E. Caspar, Monumenta Germaniae Historica Epistolae selectae, vol. 2 (Berlin, 1967), II.49, pp. 188–90, and IX.21, p. 602; The Register ofPope Gregory VII, 1073–1085: An English Translation, trans. H. E. J. Cowdrey (Oxford, 2002), pp. 139–40, 420–1.Google Scholar
  7. 8.
    On this evolution, see Flori, La guerre sainte. Older discussions include Erdmann, Origin of the Idea of Crusade; Gilchrist, ‘Papacy and War’; J. RileySmith, The First Crusaders, 1095–1131 (Cambridge, 1997), pp. 40–52; C. Tyerman, The Invention of the Crusades (Basingstoke, 1998), pp. 8–13.Google Scholar
  8. 9.
    Distinction underlined by H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘Christianity and the Morality of Warfare during the First Century of Crusading’, in The Experience of Crusading, vol. 1: Western Approaches, ed. M. Bull and N. Housley (Cambridge, 2003), pp. 175–92.Google Scholar
  9. 10.
    P. Rousset, Les origines et les caracteres de la premiere croisade (Neuchâtel, 1945), especially p. 27 ff., p. 134ff.; H. E. Mayer, The Crusades, trans. J. Gillingham, 2nd edn (Oxford, 1988), esp. pp. 27–37; H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘Pope Urban II’s Preaching of the First Crusade’, History, 55 (1970), 177–88 (repr. in H. E. J. Cowdrey, Popes, Monks and Crusaders (London, 1984), no. XVI); J. Flori, Pierre lermite et la premiere croisade (Paris, 1999), pp. 108–51; Flori, La guerre sainte, p. 316ff.Google Scholar
  10. 11.
    The role of Jerusalem as a goal for the crusade from the beginning has been debated by historians, but is now generally accepted: The First Hundred Years, ed. Baldwin, p. 244 and n. 51; Cowdrey, ‘Pope Urban II’s Preaching’; Mayer, The Crusades, pp. 9–11; Riley-Smith, First Crusade and Idea of Crusading, pp. 20–5. See also M. Bull, ‘Views of Muslims and of Jerusalem in Miracle Stories, c. 1000-c. 1200: Reflections on the Study of First Crusaders’ Motivations’, in The Experience of Crusading, vol. 1, ed. Bull and Housley, pp. 13–35.Google Scholar
  11. 12.
    Gregory VII, ‘Registrum’, II.31, pp. 165–8; Register of Pope Gregory VII, trans. Cowdrey, pp. 122–4. Erdmann, Origin of the Idea of Crusade, saw the reform papacy as crucial to the development of the crusade ideology; Gilchrist, ‘Papacy and War’, argued for a continuity in papal attitudes towards warfare from the ninth century onwards; see also The FirstHundred Years, ed. Baldwin, p. 224.Google Scholar
  12. 13.
    The extent of influence is debated. Bull, KnightlyPiety, pp. 70–114, argues that events of Spain were ‘of minimal relevance’ for the First Crusade at the level of lay piety, but Riley-Smith argued that ‘Urban regarded the new crusade to the East as part of a wider movement of Christian liberation and did not distinguish it from the Spanish Reconquest’: First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading, p. 20. Baldwin also relates the two movements: The First Hundred Years, ed. Baldwin, pp. 231–3.Google Scholar
  13. 14.
    For an attempt to reconstruct Urban’s Clermont sermon, see D. C. Munro, ‘The Speech of Pope Urban II at Clermont, 1095’, American Historical Review, 11 (1906), 231–42.Google Scholar
  14. 15.
    P. J. Cole, The Preaching of the Crusades to the Holy Land, 1095–1270 (Cambridge, Mass., 1991), pp. 5, 9–33; P. J. Cole, “‘O God, the Heathen have come into your Inheritance” (Ps. 78.1). The Theme of Religious Pollution in Crusade Documents, 1095–1188’, in Crusaders and Muslims in Twelfth-Century Syria, ed. M. Shatzmiller (Leiden, 1993), pp. 84–111.Google Scholar
  15. 16.
    On the total numbers on the First Crusade, see J. Flori, Croisade et chevalerie, XIe-XIIe siecles (Paris and Brussels, 1998), pp. 319–43; J. France, Victory in the East: A Military History of the First Crusade (Cambridge, 1994), pp. 122–42; J. Riley-Smith, ‘Casualities and the Number of Knights on the First Crusade’, Crusades, 1 (2002), 13–27.Google Scholar
  16. 17.
    P. Alphandéry and A. Dupont, La chreriente et lidée de croisade (Paris, 1954, repr. 1995); Riley-Smith, First Crusade and Idea of Crusading, pp. 90–119; and more recently Flori, Pierre lermite, pp. 179–99.Google Scholar
  17. 18.
    G. Constable, ‘Medieval Charters as a Source for the History of the Crusades’, in Crusade and Settlement, ed. P. W. Edbury (Cardiff, 1985), pp. 73–89, and the numerous works of J. Riley Smith, especially ‘The State of Mind of Crusaders to the East, 1095–1300’, in The Oxford Illustrated History of the Crusades, ed. J. Riley-Smith (London, 1995), pp. 66–90, and The First Crusaders, 1095–1131 (Cambridge, 1997).Google Scholar
  18. 20.
    Urban II, ‘Letter to all the faithful in Flanders’, in Epistulae et chartae ad historiam primi belli sacri spectantes: Die Kreuzzugsbriefe aus den Jahren 1088–1100, ed. H. Hagenmeyer (Innsbruck, 1901), pp. 136–7.Google Scholar
  19. 21.
    Text in R. Somerville, The Councils of Urban II, vol. 1: Decreta Claramontensia (Amsterdam, 1972), pp. 71–81.Google Scholar
  20. 22.
    See N. Paulus, Geschichte des Ablasses im Mittelalter vom Ursprunge bis zur Mitte des 14. Jahrhunderts (Paderborn, 1922); Mayer, The Crusades, pp. 23–33, 293–5 n. 15; and more recently J. Richard, ‘L’indulgence de croisade et le pelerinage en Terre sainte’, in II concilio di Piacenza e le crociate, (Piacenza, 1996), pp. 213–23. On the formation of the concept of purgatory, see J. Le Goff, La naissance du purgatoire (Paris, 1981), translated by Arthur Goldhammer as The Birth of Purgatory (Chicago, 1986), but compare to B. P. McGuire, ‘Purgatory, the Communion of the Saints, and Medieval Change’, Viator, 20 (1989), 61–84.Google Scholar
  21. 23.
    See especially M. Bull, ‘The Roots of Lay Enthusiasm for the First Crusade’, History, 78 (1993), 353–72; M. Bull, ‘Origins’, in Oxford Illustrated History of the Crusades, ed. Riley-Smith, pp. 13–33; J. Riley-Smith, The First Crusaders, 1095–1131 (Cambridge, 1997); J. Riley-Smith, ‘The Idea of Crusading in the Charters of Early Crusaders, 1095–1102’, in Le Concile de Clermont de 1095 et lappel a la Croisade (Actes du Colloque Universitaire International de ClermontFerrand (23–25 juin 1095) (Rome, 1997), pp. 155–66. For Jerusalem as a pilgrimage destination prescribed for serious sins see J. Sumption, Pilgrimage: An Image of Medieval Religion (London, 1975), pp. 98–103.Google Scholar
  22. 24.
    On this point see also J. Flori, ‘Jerusalem terrestre, celeste et spirituelle: trois facteurs de sacralisation de la premiere croisade’, in Segundas Jornadas Internacionales sobre la Primera Cruzada (Huesca, 7–11 set. 1999), ed. L. GarciaGuijarro Ramos (forthcoming); Keen, Chivalry, pp. 51–63.Google Scholar
  23. 25.
    On this point, see J. Flori, Lessor de la chevalerie, 11eme-12eme s. (Geneva, 1986), pp. 268–303; Keen, Chivalry, pp. 44–63; C. B. Bouchard, Strong of Body, Brave and Noble. Chivalry and Society in Medieval France (Ithaca, NY, 1998), pp. 75–102; J. Flori, Chevaliers et chevalerie au Moyen Age (Paris, 1998), pp. 203–34.Google Scholar
  24. 26.
    On this opposition see J. Flori, ‘Croisade et chevalerie; convergence idéologique ou rupture?’, in Femmes, Mariages, Lignages (XIIemeXIIIeme siecles), Melanges offerts a Georges Duby (Brussels, 1992), pp. 157–76; Bernard of Clairvaux, In Praise of the New Knighthood: A Treatise on the Knights Templar and the Holy Places of Jerusalem, trans. C. Greenia (Kalamazo, Mich, 2000), ch. 2, p. 38.Google Scholar
  25. 27.
    Guibert de Nogent, Gesta Dei gesta per Francos, ed. R. B. C. Huygens, Corpus Christianorum Continuatio Medievalis 127A (Turnhout, 1996), Bk 1 part 1, pp. 86–8.Google Scholar
  26. 28.
    Jonathan Riley-Smith denies it, Jean Flori affirms it, H. E. J. Cowdrey and Colin Morris are undecided: J. Riley-Smith, ‘Death on the First Crusade’, in The End of Strife, ed. D. Loades (Edinburgh, 1984), pp. 14–31; H. E. J. Cowdrey, ‘Martyrdom and the First Crusade’, in Crusade and Settlement, ed. Edbury, pp. 47–56; C. Morris, ‘Martyrs on the Field of Battle before and during the First Crusade’, in Martyrs and Martyrologies, ed. D. Wood, Studies in ChurchHistory, 30 (1993), pp. 93–104; J. Flori, ‘Mort et martyre des guerriers vers 1100; l’exemple de la premiere croisade’, Cahiers de Civilisation Medievale, 34 (1991), 121–39; J. Flori, ‘Les heros changes en saints … et les saints en héros. Sacralisation et beatification du guerrier dans l’epopee et les chroniques de la premiere croisade’, PRIS-MA: bulletin de liaison de lEquipe de recherche sur la litterature dimagination du moyen age, 30 (1999), 255–72.Google Scholar
  27. 29.
    On this point, see Flori, Pierre lennite, p. 216ff.; Riley-Smith, First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading, pp. 114–19; The First Hundred Years, ed. Baldwin, p. 248.Google Scholar
  28. 30.
    See the numerous works of J. Riley-Smith, including ‘An Approach to Crusading Ethics’, Reading Medieval Studies, 6 (1980), 3–19, and ‘Crusading as an Act of Love’, History, 65 (1980), 177–92.Google Scholar
  29. 31.
    P. Rousset, ‘La notion de chretiente aux Xleme et XIIeme siecles’, Le Moyen Age, 4th series, 69 (1963), 191–203; Rousset, Histoire dune idéologie, pp. 31–3.Google Scholar
  30. 32.
    N. Daniel, Heroes and Saracens: An interpretation of the Chansons de geste (Edinburgh, 1984); J. V. Tolan, Saracens: Islam in the Medieval European Imagination (New York, 2002).Google Scholar
  31. 33.
    M. Bennett, ‘First Crusaders’ Images of Muslims: The Influence of Vernacular Poetry?’, Forum for Modern Language Studies, 22 (1986), 101–22; M. A. Jubb, ‘Enemies in Holy War, but Brothers in Charity: The Crusaders’ View of their Saracen Opponents’, in Aspects de lepopee romane: mentalites, ideologies, intertexualitiés, ed. Hans van Dijk and Willem Noomen (Groningen, 1995), pp. 251–9; Tolan, Saracens. Google Scholar
  32. 34.
    P. Rousset, ‘Recherches sur 1’emotivite a l’époque romane’, Cahiers de Civilisation Medievale, 2 (1959), 65–7; Munro, ‘Speech of Pope Urban II’, 238, 242; Cole, “‘O God, the Heathen have come into your Inheritance”#x2019;.Google Scholar
  33. 35.
    D. R. French, ‘Journeys to the Center of the Earth: Medieval and Renaissance Pilgrimages to Mount Cavalry’, in Journeys Toward God: Pilgrimage and Crusade, ed. B. N. Sargent-Baur (Kalamazoo, 1992), pp. 45–67; B. Hamilton, ‘The Impact of Crusader Jerusalem on Western Christendom’, Catholic Historical Review, 80 (1994), 695–713.Google Scholar
  34. 37.
    Die Kreuzzugsbriefe, ed. Hagenmeyer, pp. 129–36; for a summary of the debates over this letter see The First Hundred Years, ed. Baldwin, p. 228 and n. 14.Google Scholar
  35. 38.
    J. Riley-Smith, ‘The First Crusade and the Persecution of the Jews’, Persecution and Toleration, ed. W. J. Sheils, Studies in Church History, 21 (1984), pp. 51–72; R. Chazan, European Jewry and the First Crusade (London, 1987); J. Flori, ‘Une ou plusieurs “premiere croisade#x201D;? Le message d’Urbain II et les plus anciens pogroms d’occident’, Revue Historique, 285 (1991) 3–27; Munro, ‘Speech of Pope Urban’, 240–2; N. Cohn, The Pursuit of the Millennium: Revolutionary Millenarians and Mystical Anarchists of the Middle Ages (London, 1957; new edn, 1993), pp. 63–73. For the legend of the Last Emperor see M. Reeves, The Influence of Prophecy in the Later Middle Ages: A Study in Joachimism (Oxford, 1969), pp. 299–302.Google Scholar
  36. 39.
    A. Vauchez ‘Les composantes eschatologiques de l’idée de croisade’, in Le Concile de Clermont de 1095 et lappel a la Croisade, pp. 233–43; Flori, Pierre 1’ermite, pp. 175ff. and 271ff.; for an earlier appraisal of Alphandery’s theory, see E. O. Blake, ‘The Formation of the Crusade Idea’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 21 (1970), 19–20.Google Scholar
  37. 40.
    J. Flori, ‘La croix, la crosse et l’épée. La conversion des infideles dans La Chanson de Roland et les chroniques de croisade’, in ‘Plaist vos oir bone canfon vallant?Melanges de Langue et de Littérature Medievales offerts a FranFois Suard, vol. 1 (Lille, 1999), pp. 261–72; J. Flori, ‘Premiere croisade et conversion des “pafens”#x2019;, in Migrations etdiasporas méditerranéennes (Xe-XVIe s.), ed. M. Balard and A. Ducellier (Paris, 2002), pp. 449–57; S. Luchitskaja, ‘L’idee de conversion dans les chroniques de la premiere croisade’, Cahiers de Civilisation Medievale, 45 (2002), 39–53.Google Scholar
  38. 41.
    See on these points E. Siberry, ‘Missionaries and Crusaders, 1095–1274, Opponents or Allies?’ in The Church and War, ed. W. J. Sheils, Studies in Church History, 20 (1983), pp. 103–10; B. Z. Kedar, Crusade and Mission: European Approaches towards the Muslims (Princeton, 1984); and, more recently, L.A. Hunt, ‘Excommunicata generatione: Christian Imagery of Mission and Conversion of the Muslim Other Between the First Crusade and the Early Fourteenth Century’, Al-Masaq: Studia arabo-islamica mediterranea, 8 (1995), 79–153.Google Scholar
  39. 42.
    W. L. Wakefield, Heresy, Crusade and Inquisition in Southern France, 1100–1250 (London, 1974), pp. 93–4; M. Barber, The Cathars: DualistHererics in Languedoc in the High Middle Ages (Harlow, 2000), pp. 112–13, 120–3; M. Lambert, The Cathars (Oxford, 1998), pp. 97–106.Google Scholar
  40. 43.
    Crusade and Conversion on the Baltic Frontier, 1150–1500, ed. A. V. Murray (Aldershot, 2001). See Chapter 8 in this volume, by Sven Ekdahl.Google Scholar
  41. 44.
    See for example Keen, Chivalry, pp. 51–2, 103–7.Google Scholar
  42. 45.
    J. A. Brundage, ‘An Errant Crusader: Stephen of Blois’, Traditio, 16 (1960), 380–95; compare to P. Rousset, ‘Etienne de Blois, fuyard, croisé, martyr’, Geneva, 9 (1963), 163–95.Google Scholar
  43. 46.
    See for example Riley-Smith, The First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading, pp. 29, 41.Google Scholar
  44. 47.
    The best study of this unusual character remains that by J. C. Payen, Le prince dAquitaine. Essai sur Guillaume IX et son oeuvre érotique (Paris, 1980).Google Scholar
  45. 48.
    See on this Flori, Lessor de la chevalerie; Keen, Chivalry, pp. 18–43.Google Scholar
  46. 49.
    Les chansons de Conon de Béthune, ed. A. Wallenskold (Paris, 1921), pp. 6–7.Google Scholar
  47. 50.
    Keen, Chivalry, pp. 171–4.Google Scholar
  48. 51.
    See for instance Mayer, The Crusades, pp. 21–3; for further discussion of this problem see R. Bartlett, The Making of Europe: Conquest, Colonization and Cultural Change, 950–1350 (Harmondsworth, 1994), pp. 24–59.Google Scholar
  49. 52.
    See especially J. Riley-Smith, ‘The Motives of the Earliest Crusaders and the Settlement of Latin Palestine, 1095–1188’, English Historical Review, 98 (1983), 721–36; J. Riley-Smith, ‘Early Crusaders to the East and the Costs of Crusading, 1095–1130’, in Cross-cultural Convergences in the Crusader Period (Essays presented to Aryeh Grabols on his sixty-fifth birthday), ed. M. Goodich, S. Menache and S. Schein (New York, 1995), pp. 237–57; J. Riley-Smith, ‘The State of Mind of Crusaders to the East, 1095–1300’, in Oxford Illustrated History of the Crusades, ed. J. Riley-Smith, pp. 66–90.Google Scholar
  50. 53.
    G. M. Anderson et al., ‘An Economic Interpretation of the Medieval Crusades’, Journal of European Economic History, 21 (1992), 339–63.Google Scholar
  51. 54.
    J. Prawer, The Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem: European Colonialism in the Middle Ages (New York, 1972); J. Prawer, ‘The Roots of Medieval Colonialism’, in The Meeting of Two Worlds: Cultural Exchanges Between East and West during thePeriod of the Crusades, ed. V. P. Goos and C. V. Bornstein (Kalamazoo, 1986), pp. 23–38; discussion in J. Richard, ‘La croisade; l’évolution des conceptions et des strategies’, in From Clermont to Jerusalem: The Crusades and Crusader Societies 1095–1500, ed. A. V. Murray (Turnhout, 1998), pp. 3–25; Le partage du monde: échanges et colonisation dans la Méditerranée medievale, ed. M. Balard and A. Ducellier (Paris, 1998).Google Scholar
  52. 55.
    History of William Marshal, ed. A. J. Holden, trans. S. Gregory, notes by D. Crouch (London, 2002—), lines 6891–906, 7239–302.Google Scholar
  53. 56.
    On this type of motivation see J. France, ‘Patronage and the Appeal of the First Crusade’, in The First Crusade, Origin and Impact, ed. J. Phillips (Manchester, 1997), pp. 5–20.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jean Flori

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations