Abstract
Charles Scott Sherrington’s thoughts on the so-called “hard problem”, the substance dualism of qualia and brain, are discussed in detail. Having inherited Thomas Henry Huxley’s and Michael Foster’s Cartesian approach to pre-modern neurophysiology, Sherrington was adamant that no investigation of the physiology of the brain, no matter how subtle it may be, will ever discover the ‘whisper of a thought or a feeling.’ Pre-figuring Chalmers’ ‘hard problem’, Sherrington said that the mental is not a form of energy; no analysis of the various forms of energy can take us across the gap that separates psychiatry from physiology.
Keywords
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
‘But strictly, we have to regard the relation of brain to mind as still not merely unsolved but still devoid of a basis for its very beginning.’
Charles Sherrington 1933, The Rede Lecture, p. 32
Author was deceased at the time of publication.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsNotes
- 1.
Gaukroger 1995.
- 2.
Galilei 1638, Day 3, Cor. 3.
- 3.
Gaukroger 1995.
- 4.
- 5.
Huxley 1874, p. 201.
- 6.
- 7.
Foster 1901/1970.
- 8.
Foster 1901/1970, p. 1.
- 9.
Foster, ibid., p. 298.
- 10.
The major activity of the Brown Institute was veterinary medicine. It was established in 1871 and directed by a number of distinguished figures including Sir John Burdon-Sanderson, Victor Horsley and Charles Sherrington.
- 11.
Further detail is given in Nobelprize.org
- 12.
Sherrington 1906; 2nd edition 1947.
- 13.
Sherrington, Nobel Prize.
- 14.
Denny-Brown 1939.
- 15.
Ibid., p. ix.
- 16.
Sherrington 1925.
- 17.
Fuller 2007.
- 18.
In a poem written in 1916, ‘Now in the cloister few feet that roam,’ he writes of the Oxford bells hearing ‘from far the filial bugles blow’. But by the war’s end in 1917 and 1918, his poems ‘Dawn’s Red’ and ‘I met a man by yonder mill’, the language, although still sub-Tennysonian, tells of a much darker mood.
- 19.
Sherrington 1951.
- 20.
This historical approach to the abiding issues of philosophy would have pleased Thomas Huxley who averred in one of his essays that ‘that there is assuredly no more effective way of clearing one’s own mind on a subject than by talking it over, so to speak, with men of power and grasp, who have considered it from a totally different point of view … the parallax of time helps us to the true position of a conception as the parallax of space helps us to that of a star.’ (Huxley 1874, p. 202).
- 21.
Sherrington 1946.
- 22.
Kermode 1971, p. 64.
- 23.
Sherrington 1951, p. 240.
- 24.
- 25.
Ibid., chapter 5. It might be said that a more fundamental principle is encapsulated in thermodynamics second law: entropy inexorably increases.
- 26.
Sherrington hesitates to use the more Nietszchean expression ‘will-to-live’ because it may be mistaken for implying some ‘conscious’ intention.
- 27.
Modern medicine and environmental control has reduced this atrocious sum of human death and suffering somewhat since Sherrington wrote in the first half of the twentieth century. A recent summary in Nature shows that about a million malaria-induced deaths still occur each year (Shetty 2012).
- 28.
Sherrington 1933.
- 29.
Sherrington 1951, p. 238.
- 30.
Sherrington 1951, p. 238.
- 31.
Ibid., p. 239.
- 32.
Sherrington 1933, p. 28.
- 33.
Ibid., p. 25.
- 34.
Sherrington, 151, pp. 253–4.
- 35.
Ibid., p. 255.
- 36.
Ibid., p. 255.
- 37.
Ibid., p. 258.
- 38.
Some have suggested that a way out of Sherrington’s impasse is to use metaphors derived from the physicists’ familiar recourse to higher dimensions than our commonsensical four. The physicist, of course, is merely generalising from the Cartesian method of locating a dimensionless point in four-dimensional space-time.
- 39.
Ibid., p. 261.
- 40.
Ibid., p. 302.
- 41.
Ibid., p. 288.
- 42.
See Barrow and Tipler 1988.
- 43.
Ibid., p. 305.
- 44.
Ibid., p. 294.
- 45.
Further biographical detail may be found Nobel Foundation http://nobel.sdsc.edu/, in Anderson and Lundberg 1997; Borck 1999.
- 46.
Further details of Eccles’ life and personality may be found in Fillenz 2012.
- 47.
Eccles 1977.
- 48.
Eccles 1951.
- 49.
Eccles 1953, p. vi.
- 50.
Eccles and Gibson 1979, p. 183.
- 51.
Eccles scientific papers.
- 52.
Honderich 1988, p. 91 etc.
- 53.
- 54.
Margenau 1984.
- 55.
Beck 2000.
- 56.
See Chap. 18.
- 57.
Heisenberg uncertainty is not due to the imprecision of our observational instruments; it is the way things are in the world.
- 58.
Eccles 1986.
- 59.
Eccles 1994, p. 146.
- 60.
See Jack et al. 1981. A quantum of neurotransmitter consists of from 5 000 to 10 000 transmitter molecules and is contained in a single synaptic vesicle. It is released as a unit into the synaptic gap.
- 61.
Eccles 1989.
- 62.
Beck and Eccles 1992, p. 11358.
- 63.
- 64.
Eccles 1994, p. 73.
- 65.
- 66.
- 67.
The term ‘psychon’ had, in fact, been coined, unbeknownst to Eccles, by Mario Bunge in his 1980 book on the mind-brain problem (Bunge 1980).
- 68.
See Smith 1982.
- 69.
- 70.
See Smith et al. 2012.
- 71.
Eccles 1994, p. 118.
- 72.
Eccles 1986.
- 73.
Stys 2011.
- 74.
Eccles 1994, p. 182.
- 75.
Tennyson, Ulysses. In Tennyson 1911, p. 165.
- 76.
Libet 2002.
- 77.
Foucault 2002, p. xi.
- 78.
See Chap. 18.
- 79.
Nietzsche 1882, §125.
References
Anderson P, Lundberg A (1997) John C Eccles (1903–1997). Trends Neurosci 20:324–325
Barrow JD, Tipler FJ (1988) The anthropic cosmological principle. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Beck F (1996) Can quantum processes control synaptic emission? Int J Neural Syst 7:343–353. Workshop on the control of random events in biological systems
Beck F (2000) Modern physics opens the pathway to understand mind-brain interaction. In: Eccles H, Biersack HJ (eds) Sir John Eccles: in memoriam – a tireless warrior for dualism. Ecomed, Landsberg
Beck F, Eccles JC (1992) Quantum aspects of consciousness and the role of consciousness. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 89:11357–11361
Borck C (1999) John C Eccles (1903–1997); neurophysiologist and neurophilosopher. J Hist Neurosci 7:76–81
Bunge M (1980) The mind-body problem: a psychobiological approach. Pergamon, Oxford
Denny-Brown D (1939) Selected writings of Sir Charles Sherrington. Hamish-Hamilton, London
Desmond A (1997) Huxley: evolution’s high priest. Joseph, London
Eccles JC (1951) Hypotheses relating to the mind-brain problem. Nature 168:53–57
Eccles JC (1953) The neurophysiological basis of mind. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Eccles JC (1977) My scientific odyssey. Annu Rev Physiol 39:1–18
Eccles JC (1986) Do mental events cause neural events analogously to the probability fields of quantum mechanics? Proc R Soc B 227:411–422
Eccles JC (1989) Evolution of the brain. Creation of the self. Routledge, London
Eccles JC (1990) A unitary hypothesis of mind-brain interaction in the cerebral cortex. Proc R Soc B 240:433–451
Eccles JC (1994) How the self controls its brain. Springer, Berlin
Eccles JC, Gibson WC (1979) Sherrington: his life and thought. Springer, Berlin
Feldman ML (1984) Morphology of the neocortical pyramidal neuron. In: Peters A, Jones EG (eds) Cerebral cortex, vol 1. Plenum, New York, pp 141–145
Fillenz M (2012) Memories of John Eccles. J Hist Neurosci 21:214–226
Fleischhauer K (1978) Cerebral architectonics. The last fifty years and some problems today. In: Brazier MAB, Petsche H (eds) Architectonics of the cerebral cortex. Raven Press, New York
Foster M (1901/1970) Lectures on the history of physiology during the sixteenth, seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Dover, New York
Foucault M (2002) The order of things. Routledge, London
Fuller J (2007) The poetry of Sir Charles Sherrington. Brain 130:1981–1983
Galilei G (1638) Discorsi …. Intorno a Due Nuove Scienze. Leida. Trans: Crew H, de Salvio A (1953) Dialogues concerning two new sciences. Dover Books, New York
Gaukroger S (1995) Descartes: an intellectual biography. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Gotfredsen E (1950) A dissertation on the anatomy of the brain by Nicolaus Steno. NYT Nordisk Forlag Arnold Busck, Copenhagen
Honderich T (1988) A theory of determinism: the mind, science and life-hopes. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Huxley TH (1874) On the hypothesis that animals are automata and its history. In: Huxley TH (1898) Collected essays, vol 1. Macmillan, London
Jack JJB, Redman SJ, Wong K (1981) The components of synaptic potentials evoked in cat spinal motor neurons by impulses in single group 1a afferents. J Physiol 321:65–96
Kermode F (1971) Modern essays. Fontana Press, Glasgow
Libet B (2002) The timing of mental events: Libet’s experimental findings and their implications. Conscious Cogn 11:291–299
Margenau H (1984) The miracle of existence. Ox Bow Press, Woodbridge
Maudsley H (1870) Body and mind: an enquiry into their connection and mutual influence. Macmillan, London
Nietzsche F (1882) The gay science (trans and ed: Kaufmann W. 1974). Vantage, New York
Sherrington CS (1906; 2nd edn. 1947) Integrative action of the nervous system. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sherrington CS (1925, 2nd edn, 1940) The assaying of Brabantius and other verse. Oxford University Press, London
Sherrington CS (1933) The brain and its mechanism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sherrington CS (1946) The endeavour of Jean Fernel. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sherrington CS (1951) Man on the his nature. Penguin Books, Harmondsworth
Shetty P (2012) The numbers game. Nature 484:S14
Smith CUM (1982) Evolution and the problem of mind: 1. Herbert Spencer. J Hist Biol 15:55–82
Smith CUM (2009) The ‘hard problem’ and the quantum physicists. Part 2: modern times. Brain Cognit 71:54–63
Smith CUM, Frixione E, Finger S, Clower W (2012) The animal spirit doctrine and the origins of neurophysiology. Oxford University Press, New York
Stensen N (1669) Discours sur l’anatomie du cerveau. Nicolai Stenonis Opera Philosophica, Copenhagen, p 18
Stys PK (2011) The axo-myelinic synapse. Trends Neurosci 34:393–400
Tennyson A (1911) Poems of Tennyson. Oxford University Press, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Smith, C.U.M. (2014). The ‘Hard Problem’ and the Cartesian Strand in British Neurophysiology: Huxley, Foster, Sherrington, Eccles. In: Smith, C., Whitaker, H. (eds) Brain, Mind and Consciousness in the History of Neuroscience. History, Philosophy and Theory of the Life Sciences, vol 6. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-8774-1_14
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-8774-1_14
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-017-8773-4
Online ISBN: 978-94-017-8774-1
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawPhilosophy and Religion (R0)