Abstract
The validation of models used in population management can be complicated by the number of component parts and by the large temporal and spatial scales often necessary. This is especially true for models developed for the analysis of management policy in forest-pest situations. In the case study considered here, a large-scale spruce budwormforest simulation model (Jones, 1979) was tested by comparing its output with data collected annually by the Maine Forest Service survey at 1000 sites from 1975 to 1980.
In practice, model validation usually involves a comparison of observations, independent of those used to construct the model, with overall model output. This ‘typical’ validation was performed. In addition, separate tests were conducted on the model’s major components. These components represent the forest protection policy, the budworm-forest dynamics, and pest control efficacy.
The model’s output was not always consistent with the Maine survey data. In some situations, compensating inaccuracies in different model components allowed the overall model output to reasonably represent the overall behavior of the system. There were also problems in scaling the findings of studies of nonlinear population dynamics from small experimental plots to the much larger spatial scales used in the models. The results of this validation imply that some modification of the optimal management strategies suggested by the models is appropriate.
This paper concerns the validation of large-scale, process-oriented models in general. The spruce budworm-forest model is discussed as an illustrative case study.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Alcamo, J. and J. Bartnicki (1987), ‘A framework for error analysis of a long-range transport model with emphasis on parameter uncertainty’, Atmospheric Environment, 21 (10), 2121–2131.
Antonovsky, M.Y., R.A. Fleming, Y.A. Kuznetsov and W.C. Clark (1990), ‘Forest-pest interaction dynamics: the simplest mathematical models’, Theoretical Population Biology, 37, 343–367.
Baskerville, G.L. (1976), ‘Report of the task-force for evaluation of budworm control alternatives’, New Brunswick Department of Natural Resources, Fredericton, Canada
Baskerville, G. and S. Kleinschmidt (1981), ‘A dynamic model of growth in defoliated firstands’, Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 11, 206–214.
Blais, J.R. (1985), ‘The ecology of the eastern spruce budworm: a review and discussion’, In: C.J. Sanders, R.W. Stark, E.J. Mullins, and J. Murphy, editors. Recent Advances in Spruce Budworms Research, Canadian Forestry Service, Ottawa, Canada, pp. 49–59.
Casti, J. (1982), ‘Catastrophes, control and the inevitability of spruce budworm outbreaks’, Ecol. Model., 14, 293–300.
Caswell, H. (1976), ‘The validation problem’, In: Systems Analysis and Simulation in Ecology, vol. 4, B.C. Patten (ed.), Academic Press, New York, pp. 313–325.
Clark, W.C., and C.S. Holing (1979), ‘Process models, equilibrium structures, and population dynamics: on the formulation and testing of realistic theory in ecology’, Fortschr. Zool., 25, 29–52.
Fleming, R.A. (1991), ‘Scale effects in developing models for integrated control: lessons from a case study of the eastern spruce budworm’, Mededlingen Faculteit van de Landbouwwetenschappen Rijksuniversiteit Gent, 56 (2a), 287–294.
Fleming, R.A. and C.A. Shoemaker (1992), ‘Evaluating models for spruce budworm-forest management: comparing output with regional field data’, Ecological Applications, 2 (4), 460–477.
Fleming, R.A., C.A. Shoemaker and J.R. Stedinger (1984), ‘An assessment of the impact of large scale spraying operations on the regional dynamics of spruce budworm (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) populations’, Canadian Entomologist, 116, 633–644.
Gage, S.H. and A.J. Sawyer (1979), ‘A simulation model for eastern spruce budworm populations in a balsam fir stand’, In: W.G. Vogt and M.H. Mickle, editors. Modeling and Simulation. Volume 10. Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Pittsburg Conference, Instrument Society of America, Pittsburg, PA, USA, pp. 1103–1113.
Guckenheimer, J. (1989), ‘Obstacles to modelling large dynamical systems’, In: Proc. Mathematical Approaches to Problems in Resource Management and Epidemiology, Lecture Notes in Biomathematics, vol. 10, C. Castillo-Chavez, S.A. Levin, and C.A. Shoemaker (eds.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 319–327.
Holling, C.S. (editor), (1978), ’Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management’, John Wiley & Sons, Toronto, Canada
Holling, C.S., D.D. Jones and W.C. Clark (1979), ‘Ecological policy design: A case study of forest and pest management’, In: G.A. Norton and C.S. Holling, editors. Pest Management. Pergamon Press, Oxford, U.K., pp. 13–90.
Jones, D.D. (1979), ‘The budworm site model’, In: G.A. Norton and C.S. Holing, editors. Pest Management. Pergamon Press, Oxford, U.K, pp. 9–155.
Lewandowski, A. (1982), ‘Issues in model validation’, Angewandte Systemanalyse, 3 (1), 2–11.
Likens, G.E. (editor), (1989), ’Long-term Studies in Ecology’, Springer-Verlag, New York, N.Y.
Ludwig, D., D.D. Jones and C.S. Holling (1978), ‘Qualitative analysis of insect outbreak systems: the spruce budworm and the forest’, Journal of Animal Ecology, 47, 315–332.
Morris, R.F. (editor), (1963), ‘The dynamics of epidemic spruce budworm populations’, Memoirs of the Entomological Society of Canada, 31, 1–332.
Mott, D.G. (1980), ‘Spruce budworm protection management in Maine’, Maine Forest Review, 13, 26–33.
Odman, M.T. and A.G. Russell (1991), ‘A multiscale finite element pollutant transport scheme for urban and regional modeling’, Atmospheric Environment, 25A, 2385–2394.
O’Neill, R.V., A.R. Johnson and A.W. King (1989), ‘A hierarchical framework for the analysis of scale’, Landscape Ecology, 3, 193–205.
Peters, R.H. (1991), ‘A Critique for Ecology’, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
Reynolds, M.R., Jr. and M.L. Deaton (1982), ‘Comparisons of some tests for validation of stochastic simulation models’, Communications in Statistics-Simulation and Computation, 11 (6), 769–799.
Royama, T. (1984), ‘Population dynamics of the spruce budworm, (Choristoneura fumiferana)’, Ecological Monographs, 54, 429–462.
Salt, G.W. (1983), ‘Roles: their limits and responsibilities in ecological and evolutionary research’, American Naturalist, 122, 697–705.
Seymour, R.S., D.G. Mott, S.M. Kleinschmidt, P.H. Triandafillou and R. Keane (1985), ‘Green Woods Model-a forecasting tool for planting timber harvesting and protection of spruce-fir forests attacked by the spruce budworm: a dynamic simulation of the Maine spruce-fir forests attacked by the spruce budworm’, United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service General Technical Report NE-91.
Stedinger, J.R. (1984), ‘A spruce budworm-forest model and its implications for suppression programs’, Forest Science, 30, 597–615.
Trial, H. Jr. and A.S. Thurston (1980), ‘Spruce budworm in Maine: 1979’, Maine Forest Service Entomology Division Technical Report 14
Trial, H., Jr. and M.E. Devine (1982), ‘Spruce budworm in Maine: 1981’, Maine Forest Service Entomology Division Technical Report 18.
Turner, M.G., V.H. Dale and R.H. Gardiner (1989), ‘Predicting across scales: Theory development and testing’, Landscape Ecology, 3, 245–252.
Wallach, D. and B. Goffinet (1989), ‘Mean squared error of prediction as a criterion for evaluating and comparing system models’, Ecol. Model., 44, 299–306.
Webb, F.E. and H.J. Irving (1983), ‘My fir lady’, Forestry Chronicle, 59, 118–122. Wiens, J.A. (1989), ’Spatial scaling in ecology’, Functional Ecology, 3, 385–397.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1994 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Fleming, R.A., Shoemaker, C.A. (1994). Validation of Large Scale Process-Oriented Models for Managing Natural Resource Populations: A Case Study. In: Grasman, J., van Straten, G. (eds) Predictability and Nonlinear Modelling in Natural Sciences and Economics. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-0962-8_12
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-0962-8_12
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-4416-5
Online ISBN: 978-94-011-0962-8
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive