Advertisement

Land and Resource Planning and Indigenous Interests: Reproducing or transforming the social relations of resource use

  • Max Barlow
  • Wolf Tietze
Part of the The GeoJournal Library book series (GEJL, volume 67)

Abstract

This chapter concerns the planning and policy processes that surrounded the approval and development of a large zinc mine, Century, in northern Australia (see Map 1). On one level it is a story that belongs to a genre too readily and repeatedly told in volumes of this kind: a story of a state planning process which uncritically promoted the interests of capital against those of a politically marginal constituent. We hope, however, to use the story to explore another question. We are interested in the contribution of planners and planning to the reproduction of inequality in the ownership and use of land and resources in Australia. Some commentators on resource planning in Australia have argued that state planning is essentially post-facto justification or legitimization of corporate decision-making (see Howitt, 1989), thereby perpetuating inequality and indigenous marginality. We ask, is the planner an uncritical supplicant whose work inevitably perpetuates of existing social relations of resource use, or can the planner work to overcome these relations, as Forester (among others) hoped (1989)?

Keywords

Century Case Indigenous People Aboriginal People Resource Planning Environmental Impact Assessment 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Bodley, J.H. (1982) Victims of Progress, Benjamin Cummins, Melno Park.Google Scholar
  2. Chase, A.K. (1990) Anthropology and impact assessment: Development pressures and indigenous interests in Australia. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,10(1/2): 11–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. CLC [Carpentaria Land Council]. 13/01/1994, Letter to the Prime Minister Paul Keating, the Premier Wayne Goss, and CRA CEO John Ralph.Google Scholar
  4. CLC [Carpentaria Land Council] 16/08/94. Letter to Century Zinc Limited.Google Scholar
  5. CLC [Carpentaria Land Council]. 27/02/1995, Letter to Queensland Coordinator General.Google Scholar
  6. COG [Queensland Coordinator General]. 11/11/1994, Letter to Carpentaria Land Council.Google Scholar
  7. COG [Queensland Coordinator General]. 14/03/1995, Letter to Carpentaria Land Council.Google Scholar
  8. Cosgrove, L. and Kliger, B. (1997) Planning with a difference: A reflection on planning and decision making with indigenous peoples in Broome, Western Australia, Urban Policy Research, 15(3): 211–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cowell, S.G. (1996) Aboriginal Interests and the Century Zinc Proposal: Resource Planning, Development and Impact Aassessment in the Gulf of Carpentaria, Unpublished Honours dissertation. Griffith University, Brisbane.Google Scholar
  10. CRAE [CRA Exploration]. 02/10/1991, Letter to Carpentaria Land Council.Google Scholar
  11. Craig and Ehrlich, Ross, H., Lane, M.B. and Uren, C. (1996) Indigenous Participation in Commonwealth Environmental Impact Assessment. Commonwealth Environment Protection Agency, Canberra, Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
  12. Crough, G. and Cronin, D. (1995) Aboriginal people and the Century Project: The ‘Plains of Promise’ Revisited?. A Report to the CLC, Burketown, commissioned by Century Zinc Limited through Kinhill Cameron McNamara. NARU, Darwin.Google Scholar
  13. CZL [Century Zinc Limited]. (1995) The Century Project - Aboriginal Issues: Supplementary Report Draft Impact Assessment Study August 1995, compiled by Kinhill Cameron MacNamara, Brisbane.Google Scholar
  14. CZL [Century Zinc Limited]. 03/08/1994, Letter to Carpentaria Land Council.Google Scholar
  15. Dale, A.P. (1993) An Assessment of Planning for Government-Funded Land-use Development Projects for Aboriginal Communities in Eastern Australia. Ph.D., Griffith University.Google Scholar
  16. Dale, A.P. and Bellamy, J.A. (1998) Regional resource use planning: An Australian review. LWRRDC Occasional Paper 6/98, LWRRDC, Canberra.Google Scholar
  17. Davies, J. and Young, E. (1996) Taking centre stage: Aboriginal strategies for redressing marginalisation. In R. Howitt, J. Connell, and P. Hirsch, (eds.), Resources, Nations and Indigenous Peoples: Case Studies from Australasia, Melanesia and Southeast Asia, Oxford University Press, Melbourne. pp•152–71.Google Scholar
  18. DEH [Department of Environment and Heritage]. 08/03/1995, Letter from Director General DEH, to Queensland Coordinator General.Google Scholar
  19. DFSAIA [Department of Family Services, Aboriginal and Islander Affairs]. 24/01/1995, Letter to Queensland Coordinator General.Google Scholar
  20. DFSAIA [Department of Family Services, Aboriginal and Islander Affairs]. 08/03/1995, Letter to Queensland Coordinator General.Google Scholar
  21. Dixon, R. (1990) Aborigines as purposive actors or passive victims?, In R.A. Dixon, and M.C. Dillon, (eds.), Aborigines and Diamond Mining.’ The Politics of Resource Development in the East Kimberley, Western Australia, University of Western Australia Press, Perth. pp. 66–94.Google Scholar
  22. Dorcey, A.J. (1986), Bargaining in the Governance of Pacific Coastal Resources: Research and Reform, Westwater Research Center, Vancouver.Google Scholar
  23. Edelstein, M. R. and Kleese, D.A. (1995) Cultural relativity of impact assessment: Native Hawaiian opposition to geothermal energy development. Society and Natural Resources 8: 19–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Faludi, A. (1973), Planning Theory, Pergamon, Oxford.Google Scholar
  25. Forester, J. (1989), Planning in the Face of Power, University of California Press, Berkeley.Google Scholar
  26. Guy, K. (1996) Development and conservation in Queensland: Environmental racism?, Ecopolitics IX – Conference Papers and Resolutions, Northern Territory University: Darwin. September 1–3, 1995.Google Scholar
  27. Healey, P. (1992), Planning through debate: The Communicative turn in planning theory, Town Planning Review 63(2): 143–62.Google Scholar
  28. Hillier, J. (1993) To boldly go where no planners have ever…. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 11: 89–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hillier, J. (1995) The unwritten law of planning theory: Common sense, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 14: 292–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Howitt, R. (1995) Changing Places: sustainability and developmentalism in regional narratives at Weipa, North Australia Research Unit Discussion Paper No. 23, North Australia Research Unit, Australian National University, Casuarina.Google Scholar
  31. Howitt, R. (1989) Social impact assessment and resource development: Issues from the Australian experience. Australian Geographer 20(2): 155–167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Howitt, R., Connell, J. and Hirsch, P. (1996) Resources, nations and indigenous peoples. In R. Howitt, J. Connell, and P. Hirsch, (eds.), Resources, Nations and Indigenous Peoples: Case Studies from Australasia, Melanesia and Southeast Asia, Oxford University Press, Melbourne. pp. 1–30.Google Scholar
  33. Huxley, M. and Yiftachel, O. (1998) New Paradigm or Old Myopia?Unsettling the ‘Communicative Turn ’ in Planning Theory, Paper presented to thePlanning Theory Conference, Oxford, UK, February 1998. Inns, J. (1995) Planning theory’s emerging paradigm: Communicative action and interactive practice –closing the theory-practice gap, Journal of Planning Education and Research 14(3): 183–189.Google Scholar
  34. Jackson, S. (1997) A disturbing story: The fiction of rationality in land use planning in Aboriginal Australia, Australian Planner, 34(4): 221–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Johnson, A., Cowell. S., Loneragan. N., and Dews. G. (1999) Sustainable Development of Tropical Australia: R&D for Management of Land, Water and Marine Resources –Scoping Study. LWRRDC Occasional Paper 05/99.Google Scholar
  36. Kelly, R. 17/06/1991, Letter to Minister for Family Services and Aboriginal and Islander Affairs.Google Scholar
  37. Lane, M.B. (1997) Aboriginal participation in environmental planning, Australian Geographical Studies 35(3): 308–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Lane, M.B. and Cowell, S. (1995) The Gulf of Carpentaria: People and place under threat. Habitat Australia 24(3): 11–17.Google Scholar
  39. Lane, M.B. and Dale, A.P. (1995) Cross cultural project assessment: The Australian indigenous experience and the need for reform. Australian Journal of Environmental Management, 2(1): 19–30.Google Scholar
  40. Lane, M.B. and Rickson, R.E. (1997) Resource development and resource dependency: Australia’s Jawoyn Aborigines and mining at Coronation Hill. Society and Natural Resources 10(2): 121–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lane, M.B., Brown, A.L. and Chase, A.K. (1997) Land and resource planning under native title: Towards an initial model, Environmental and Planning Law Journal, 14(4): 249–59.Google Scholar
  42. Leavitt, J. (1994) Planning in an age of rebellion: Guidelines to activist research and applied planning, Planning Theory,10/11: 111–30.Google Scholar
  43. McDonald, G.T. (1996) Planning as sustainable development, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 15(3): 225–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. O’Faircheallaigh, C. (1996) Negotiating with resource companies: issues and constraints for Aboriginal communities in Australia. In R. Howitt, J. Connell, and P. Hirsch, (eds.), Resources, Nations and Indigenous Peoples. Case Studies from Australasia, Melanesia and Southeast Asia, Oxford University Press, Melbourne. pp.184–202.Google Scholar
  45. Oakley, P. (1991) The concept of participation in development, Landscape and Urban Planning 20: 115–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Ross, H., Young, E. and Liddle, L. (1994) Mabo: An inspiration for Australian land management, Australian Journal of Environmental Management, 1(1): 24–41.Google Scholar
  47. Sandercock, L. (1998) Towards Cosmopolis, Wiley, Chichester.Google Scholar
  48. Sewter, S. 17/06/1991, Letter to Queensland Division of Aboriginal and Islander Affairs.Google Scholar
  49. Throgmorton, J.A. (1993) Planning as a rhetorical activity: Survey research as a trope in arguments about electric power planning in Chicago, Journal of the American Planning Association 59(3): 334–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Toyne, P. (1994) The Reluctant Nation: Environment,law and politics in Australia. ABC Books, Sydney.Google Scholar
  51. Trigger, D. S. (1995) The Century Project Supplementary Report: Aboriginal Issues: Comment, A submission to Queensland Coordinator General on the Century Aboriginal Issues Supplementary Report to the Draft IAS.Google Scholar
  52. Waltho, A. E. and Andrews, S. J. (1993) The Century zinc-lead deposit, Northwest Queensland. The AusIMM Centenary Conference. Adelaide 30 March - 4 April 1993: 41–50.Google Scholar
  53. Williams, B. 06/02/1995, Channel worry on big mine, The Courier Mail, pp.1–2.Google Scholar
  54. Young, I. M. (1990) Justice and the Politics of Difference, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Max Barlow
    • 1
  • Wolf Tietze
    • 2
  1. 1.Concordia UniversityCanada
  2. 2.HelmstedtGermany

Personalised recommendations