Abstract
Consider eliminating the transformational component of a generative grammar. In particular, consider the elimination of all movement rules, whether bounded or unbounded, and all rules making reference to identity of indices. Suppose, in fact, that the permitted class of generative grammars constituted a subset of those phrase structure grammars capable only of generating context-free languages. Such a move would have two important metatheoretical consequences, one having to do with learnability, the other with processability. In the first place, we would be imposing a rather dramatic restriction on the class of grammars that the language acquisition device needs to consider as candidates for the language being learned. And in the second place, we would have the beginnings of an explanation for the obvious, but largely ignored, fact that humans process the utterances they hear very rapidly.1 Sentences of a context-free language are provably parsable in a time which is proportional to the cube of the length of the sentence or less (Younger (1967), Earley (1970)). But no such restrictive result holds for the recursive or recursively enumerable sets potentially generable by grammars which include a transformational component.
Chapter PDF
References
Abbott, B. (1976) “Right Node Raising as a Test for Constituenthood,” Linguistic Inquiry 7, 639–642.
Andrews, A.D. (1975) Studies in the Syntax of Relative and Comparative Clauses, Doctoral dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Bach, E. (1976), “An Extension of Classical Transformational Grammar,” mimeo, University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Bach, E. and R. Cooper (1978) “The NP-S Analysis of Relative Clauses and Compositional Semantics,” Linguistics and Philosophy 2, 145–150.
Baker, C.L. (1978) Introduction to Generative-Transformational Syntax, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Bever, T.G., J.M. Carroll, and R. Hurtig (1976) “Analogy or Ungrammatical Sequences That Are Utterable and Comprehensible Are the Origins of New Grammars in Language Acquisition and Linguistic Evolution,” in T.G. Bever, J.J. Katz, and D.T. Langendoen., eds., An Integrated Theory of Linguistic Ability, Thomas Cromwell, New York, 149–182.
Bresnan, J.W. (1974) “The Position of Certain Clause-Particles in Phrase Structure,” Linguistic Inquiry 5, 614–619.
Bresnan, J.W. (1976) “Evidence for a Theory of Unbounded Transformations,” Linguistic Analysis 2, 353–393.
Bresnan, J.W. (1977) “Variables in the Theory of Transformations,” in P.W. Culicover, T. Wasow, and A. Akmajian, eds., Formal Syntax, Academic Press, New York, 157–196.
Brown, H.D. (1971) “Children’s Comprehension of Relativized English Sentences,” Child Development 42, 1923–1936.
Colarusso, J. (1976) “An Instance of Unbounded Rightward Movement: Wh-Movement in Circassian,” unpublished paper, University of Vienna.
Cooper, R. (1975) Montague’s Semantic Theory and Transformational Syntax, Doctoral dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts.
Cooper, R. (forthcoming) Formal Semantics and Transformational Grammar, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Dougherty, R.C. (1970) “A Grammar of Coordinate Structures I,” Language 46, 850–898.
Earley, J. (1970) “An Efficient Context-free Parsing Algorithm,” Communications of the ACM 13, 94–102.
Engdahl, E. (1980) The Syntax and Semantics of Questions in Swedish, Doctoral dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Ferreiro, E., C. Othenin-Girard, H. Chipman, and H. Sinclair (1976) “How Do Children Handle Relative Clauses?” Archives de Psychologie 45, 229–266.
Fiengo, R. (1977) “On Trace Theory,” Linguistic Inquiry 8, 35–61.
Fodor, J.A., T.G. Bever, and M. Garrett (1974) The Psychology of Language: An Introduction to Psycholinguistics and Generative Grammar, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Frauenfelder, U., J. Segui, and J. Mehler (1979) “Monitoring around the Relative Clause,” unpublished paper.
Frazier, L. (1979) “On Comprehending Sentences: Syntactic Parsing Strategies,” mimeo, Indiana University Linguistics Club, Bloomington, Indiana.
Frazier, L. and J.D. Fodor (1978) “The Sausage Machine: A New Two-Stage Parsing Model,” Cognition 6, 291–325.
Gazdar, G.J.M. (1980a) “A Cross-categorial Semantics for Coordination,” Linguistics and Philosophy 3, 407–409.
Gazdar G.J.M. (1980b) “A Phrase Structure Syntax for Comparative Clauses,” in T. Hoekstra, H. v.d. Hulst, and M. Moortgat eds., Lexical Grammar, Foris Publications, Dordrecht, 165–179.
Gazdar, G.J.M. (1982) “Phrase Structure Grammar,” In P. Jacobson and G.K. Pullum, eds., The Nature of Syntactic Representation, Reidel, Boston, 131–186.
Gazdar, G.J.M., G.K. Pullum, and I. Sag (1980) “A Phrase Structure Grammar of the English Auxiliary System,” in I. Sag, ed., Stanford Working Papers in Grammatical Theory, Volume I, Stanford Cognitive Science Group, 1–124.
Grimshaw, J. (1978) “On the Syntax of Conjoined wh Words in English,” in R.M. Saenz, ed., University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers in Linguistics Volume 3, Graduate Linguistic Student Association, University of Massachusetts at Amherst, 1–10.
Grosu, A. (1971) “On Perceptual and Grammatical Constraints,” in D. Adams et al., eds., Papers from the Seventh Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, 416–427.
Grosu, A. (1972) “The Strategic Content of Island Constraints,” Ohio State University Working Papers in Linguistics 13.
Hankamer, J. (1971) Constraints on Delection in Syntax, Doctoral dissertation, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut.
Harman, G.H. (1963) “Generative Grammars without Transformation Rules: A Defense of Phrase Structure,” Language 39, 597–616.
Hellan, L. (1977) “\( \bar{X} \)-syntax, Categorial Syntax and Logical Form,” in T. Fretheim and L. Hellan, eds., Papers from the Trondheim Syntax Symposium, Trondheim, 83–135.
Holmes, V.M. (1979) “Some Hypotheses about Syntactic Processing in Sentence Comprehension,” in W.E. Cooper and E. Walker, eds., Sentence Processing Studies Presented to Merrill Garrett, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, New Jersey.
Horn, G.M. (1974) The NP Constraint, Doctoral dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst. Also distributed by the Indiana University Linguistics Club, Bloomington, Indiana.
Jackendoff, R. (1977) \( \bar{X} \) Syntax: A Study of Phrase Structure Linguistic Inquiry Monograph 2, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Karttunen, L. (1977) “Syntax and Semantics of Questions,” Linguistics and Philosophy 1,3–44.
Kaufman, E.S. (1974) “Navajo Spatial Enclitics: A Case for Unbounded Rightward Movement,” Linguistic Inquiry 5, 507–533.
Keenan, E.L. and B. Comrie (1977) “Noun Phrase Accessibility and Universal Grammar,” Linguistic Inquiry 8, 63–99.
Keenan, E.L. and L. Faltz (1978) “Logical Types for Natural Language,” UCLA Occasional Papers in Linguistics 3.
Klein, E.H. (1980) “Determiners and the Category Q,” unpublished paper, University of Sussex.
Kohrt, M. (1975) “A Note on Bounding,” Linguistic Inquiry 6, 167–171.
Langendoen, D.T. (1976) “On the Weak Generative Capacity of Infinite Grammars,” CUNY Forum 1,13–24.
Levy, L.S. (forthcoming) “Automata on Trees: A Tutorial Survey,” to appear in Egyptian Computer Journal.
Maling, J. and A. Zaenen (1982) “A Base-generated Account of ‘Extraction Phenomena’ in Scandinavian Languages,” In P. Jacobson and G.K. Pullum, eds., The Nature of Syntactic Representation, Reidel, Boston, 229–282.
Marslen-Wilson, W.D. (1973) Speech Shadowing and Speech Perception, Doctoral dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
McCawley, J.D. (1968) “Concerning the Base Component of a Transformational Grammar,” Foundations of Language 4, 243–269. Reprinted in Grammar and Meaning, Academic Press, New York, 35–58.
McCloskey, J. (1978) “Questions and Relative Clauses in Modern Irish,” Texas Linguistic Forum 12.
McCloskey, J. (1979) Transformational Syntax and Model Theoretic Semantics, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Mills, A.E. (1979) “Surface Structure Order and Comprehension of Ambiguous Clauses,” paper presented to the Spring meeting of the Linguistics Association of Great Britain, Hull.
Perkins, E. (1975) “Extraposition of Relative Clauses in Navajo,” The Navajo Language Review 2.2 [cited by Andrews (1975, 114)].
Perlmutter, D.M. and J.R. Ross (1970) “A Nonsource for Comparatives,” Linguistic Inquiry 1, 127–128.
Postal, P.M. (1974) On Raising, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Postal, P.M. and G.K. Pullum (1978) “Traces and the Description of English Complementizer Contraction,” Linguistic Inquiry 9, 1–29.
Read, C, A. Kraak, and L. Boves (1980) “The Interpretation of Ambiguous Who-Questions in Dutch: The Effect of Intonation,” in W. Zonnefeld, ed., Linguistics in the Netherlands, 1977–1979, Foris Publications, Dordrecht.
Roeper, T. and M.E.A. Siegel (1978) “A Lexical Transformation for Verbal Compounds,” Linguistic Inquiry 9, 199–260.
Ross, J.R. (1967) Constraints on Variables in Syntax, Doctoral dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Also distributed by the Indiana University Linguistics Club, Bloomington, Indiana.
Satyanarayana, P. and K.V. Subbarao (1973) “Are Rightward Movement Rules Upward Bounded?” Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 3, 182–192.
Schachter, P. (1976) “A Nontransformational Account of Gerundive Nominals in English,” Linguistic Inquiry 7, 205–241.
Schachter, P. (1977) “Constraints on Coordination,” Language 53, 86–103.
Sheldon, A. (1976) “Speakers’ Intuitions about the Complexity of Relative Clauses in Japanese and English,” in S. Mufwene, C. Walker, and S. Steever, eds., Papers from the Twelfth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, 558–567.
Sheldon, A. (1977) “On Strategies for Processing Relative Clauses: A Comparison of Children and Adults,” Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 6, 305–318.
Shir, N.E. (1977) “On the Nature of Island Constraints,” mimeo, Indiana University Linguistics Club, Bloomington, Indiana.
Smith, M. (1974) “Relative Clause Formation between 29–36 Months: A Preliminary Report,” Papers and Reports on Child Language Development 8, 104–110.
Stewart, J. and H. Sinclair (1975) “Comprehension of Questions by Children between 5 and 9,” International Journal of Psycholinguistics 3, 17–26.
Stump, G.T. (1978) “Interpretive Gapping in Montague Grammar,” in D. Farkas, W.M. Jacobsen, and K.W. Todrys, eds., Papers from the Fourteenth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, 472–481.
Thatcher, J.W. (1973) “Tree Automata: An Informal Survey,” in A.V. Aho, ed., Currents in the Theory of Computing, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Tyack, D. and D. Ingram (1977) “Children’s Production and Comprehension of Questions,” Journal of Child Language 4, 211–224.
de Villiers, J.G., H.B. Tager Flusberg, K. Hakuta, and M. Cohen (1979) “Children’s Comprehension of Relative Clauses,” Journal of Psycho-linguistic Research 8, 499–518.
Vergnaud, J.R. (1973) “Formal Properties of Lexical Derivations,” Quarterly Progress Report of the Research Laboratory in Electronics No. 108, MIT, 280–287.
Wanner, E. and M. Maratsos (1978) “An ATN Approach to Comprehension,” in M. Halle, J. Bresnan, and G.A. Miller, eds., Linguistic Theory and Psychological Reality, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Wijngaarden, A. van (1969) “Report on the Algorithmic Language ALGOL 68,” Numerische Mathematik 14, 79–218.
Williams, E.S. (1977) “Across-the-Board Application of Rules,” Linguistic Inquiry 8, 419–423.
Williams, E.S. (1978) “Across-the-Board Rule Application,” Linguistic Inquiry 9, 31–43.
Witten, E. (1972) “Centrality,” in Report No. NSF-28 to The National Science Foundation, The Computation Laboratory of Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Younger, D.H. (1967) “Recognition and Parsing of Context-free Languages in Time n3,” Information and Control 10, 189–208.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1981 The Massachusetts Institute of Technology
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Gazdar, G. (1981). Unbounded Dependencies and Coordinate Structure. In: Savitch, W.J., Bach, E., Marsh, W., Safran-Naveh, G. (eds) The Formal Complexity of Natural Language. Studies in Linguistics and Philosophy, vol 33. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-3401-6_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-3401-6_8
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-1-55608-047-0
Online ISBN: 978-94-009-3401-6
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive