Abstract
This essay is about decisions concerning the resuscitation of the aged, how they mirror general social policy towards the elderly, and how they characterize and occasionally define tacit and otherwise unrecognized attitudes and prejudices. It examines whether resuscitation should be carried out automatically whenever death threatens, or whether, in certain situations, the obligation to resuscitate is suspended. It asks whether there is only a prima facie, rather than an absolute obligation to resuscitate; whether the attainment of a certain age modifies this obligation by restricting either the obligation to resuscitate or the right to be resuscitated; and whether there is any change when death threatens unexpectedly rather than after a long and painful illness. Finally, it questions whether the patient’s or the family’s wishes or beliefs enable or compel the modification of this obligation in any way, and whether there is a distinct obligation to respect, elicit, or even to leave advance directives (e.g., a “living will”). There are no simple answers to any of these questions.
Chapter PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Keywords
- England Journal
- American Medical Association
- Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation
- Advanced Directive
- Irreversible Cessation
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Bibliography
Abramson, N. S., Meisel, A. and Safar, P.: 1981, ‘Informed Consent in Resuscitation Research’, Journal of the American Medical Association 246, 2828–2830.
Angell, M.: 1984, ‘Respecting the Autonomy of Competent Patients’, New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1115–1116.
Anonymous: 1732, Notes From the Dead: In the Revival of Anne Green, Hanged at Oxford in 1650. With Near 40 Ingenious Poems on the Subject in Latin English, etc. by the Prime Wits of that University, Phoenix Brittanicus, Vol. I; cited in [85] (W. G. A. Robertson).
Avorn, J.: 1984, ‘Benefit and Cost Analysis in Geriatric Care. Turning Age Discrimination into Health Policy’, New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1294–1301.
Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Shabbat, 152b.
Baer, L. S.: 1978, ‘Nontreatment of Some Severe Strokes’, Annals of Neurology 4(4), 381–382.
Beecher, H. K.: 1968, ‘Ethical Problems Created by the Hopelessly Unconscious Patient’, New England Journal of Medicine 278, 1425–1430.
Beecher, H. K.: 1969, ‘Procedures for the Appropriate Management of Patients Who May Have Supportive Measures Withdrawn’, Journal of the American Medical Association 209, 405.
Bedell, S. E., Delbanco, T. L., Cook, S. F. et al.: 1983, ‘Survival After Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Hospital’, New England Journal of Medicine 309, 569–575.
Bedell, S. E. and Delbanco, T. L.: 1984, ‘Choices About Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Hospital. When Do Physicians Talk with Patients?’ New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1089–1093.
Black, P. McL.: 1980, ‘From Heart to Brain: The New Definitions of Death’, American Heart Journal 99(3), 279–81.
Campion, E. W.; Mulley, A. G.; Goldstein, R. L., et al.: 1981, ‘Medical Intensive Care for the Elderly. A Study of Current Use, Costs, and Outcomes’, Journal of the American Medical Association 246, 2052–2056.
Cassem, N.: 1980, ‘When Illness is Judged Irreversible: Imperative and Elective Treatments’, Man and Medicine 5(3), 154–166.
Cassem, N. H.: 1980, ‘Consultation to Continue or Stop Treatment Measures in Irreversible Illness’, Advances in Psychosomatic Medicine 10, 119–131.
Dagi, T. F.: 1974, ‘The Ethical Tribunal in Medicine’, Boston University Law Review 54(2), 269–277.
Dagi, T. F.: 1978, ‘Cause and Culpability’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1(4), 349–377.
Davies, M. J. and Thomas, A.: 1984, ‘Thrombosis and Acute Coronary Artery Lesions in Sudden Cardiac Ischemic Death’, New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1137–1140.
DeBard, M. L.: 1980, ‘The History of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation’, Annals of Emergency Medicine 9, 273–275.
Editorial: 1982, ‘Cardiac Resuscitation in Hospital: More Restraint Needed?’ The Lancet 1, 27–28.
Editorial: 1982, ‘Death in Old Age’, The Lancet 2, 477.
Eisenberg, M. S., Hallstrom, A. and Bergner, L.: 1982, ‘Long Term Survival after Out of Hospital Cardiac Arrest’, The New England Journal of Medicine 306, 1340–1343.
Eisendrath, S. J. and Jonsen, A. R.: 1983, ‘The Living Will. Help or Hindrance? Journal of the American Medical Association 249, 2054–2058.
Epstein, F. H., Bedell, S. E., and Delbanco, T. L.: 1983, ‘Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation of Old People’, [letter] The Lancet 2, 794.
Evans, K. G.: 1981, ‘“No Resuscitation” Orders — An Emerging Consensus’, Canadian Medical Association Journal 125, 892–896.
Federal Emergency Medical Systems Act: 1980, 42 USCA sec 300a-300d-9 (1980 Suppl).
Fletcher, G. P.: 1967, ‘Prolonging Life’, Washington Law Review 42, 999–1016.
Fuesgen, I. and Summa, J.-D.: 1978, ‘How Much Sense is There in an Attempt to Resuscitate an Aged Person?’ Gerontology 24, 37–451.
Gillick, M.: 1980, ‘The Ethics of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation: Another Look’, Ethics in Science and Medicine 7, 161–169.
Gillick, M.: 1984, ‘Is the Care of the Chronically 111 a Medical Prerogative?’ New England Journal of Medicine 310, 190–191.
Graham, J. and Livesley, B.: 1983, ‘Dying as a Diagnosis: Difficulties of Communication and Management in Elderly Patients’, The Lancet 2, 670–672.
Hartikainen, M., Cozanitis, D. A. and Heikkila, J.: 1982. ‘Resurrection’, Southern Medical Journal 75(10), 1301.
Hashinmoto, D. M.: 1983, ‘Structural Analysis of the Physician Patient Relationship in No-Code Decision Making’, Yale Law Journal 93, 362–383.
Haug, M.: 1978, ‘Aging and the Right to Terminate Medical Treatment’, Journal of Gerontology 35(4), 586–591.
Henry, J. B. and Smith, F. A.: 1980, ‘Estimation of the Postmortem Interval by Chemical Means’, American Journal of Forensic Medical Pathology 1, 341–347.
Hershey, C. O. and Fisher, L.: 1982, ‘Why Outcome of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in General Wards is So Poor’, The Lancet 1, 31–34.
Hunter, J.: 1776, ‘Proposals for the Recovery of People Apparently Drowned’, Phil Reans 66, 412; cited in Deciding to Forego Life-Sustaining Treatment, [63], p. 232.
Jakobovits, I.: 1959, Jewish Medical Ethics, Bloch Publishing Company, New York.
Kapp. M. B.: 1983, ‘Age and Mental Incompetence’, [letter] Annals of Internal Medicine 98 (Part I), 669–670.
Key References in Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation: 1982, Part I, Circulation 66(4), 898–900; continued in Part II, Circulation 66(5) 1133–1135.
II Kings: 4:31–37.
Knight, B.: 1983, ‘A Comparative Survey of the Medico-Legal Aspects of Death in Europe’, Medicine and Law 2(2) 137–156.
Kohn, R. R.: 1982, ‘Cause of Death in Very Old People’, Journal of the American Medical Association 247, 2793–2797.
Kouwenhoven, W. B., Jude, J. R. and Knickerbocker, G. G.: 1960, ‘Closed-chest Cardiac Massage’, Journal of the American Medical Association 173, 1064–1067.
Lamb, D. and Easton, S. M.: 1982, ‘Philosophy of Medicine in the United Kingdom’, Metamedicine, 3, 3–34.
Levenson, S. A., List, N. D. and Zaw-Win, B.: 1981, ‘Ethical Considerations in Critical and Terminal Illness in the Elderly’, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 29(12), 563–567. See Table II in particular.
Lewis, B.: 1983, ‘Death in the First Ten Minutes’, British Medical Journal 286, 1768–1769.
Lidz, C. W., Meisel, A., Osterweis, M., et al.: 1983, ‘Barriers to Informed Consent’, Annals of Internal Medicine 99, 539–543.
Linko, K., Honkavaara, P. and Salmenpera, M.: 1982, ‘Recovery after Discontinued Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation’, The Lancet 1, 106–107.
Lo, B. and Jonsen, A. R.: 1980, ‘Clinical Decisions to Limit Treatment’, Annals of Internal Medicine 93, 764–768.
Lo, B. and Steinbrook, R. L.: 1983, ‘Deciding Whether to Resuscitate’, Annals of Internal Medicine 143, 1561–1563.
Longstreth, W. T., Diehr, P. and Inui, T. S.: 1983, ‘Prediction of Awakening after Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest’, New England Journal of Medicine 308, 1378–1382.
Longstreth, W. T., Inui, T. S., Cobb, L. A., et al.: 1983, ‘Neurologic Recovery after Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest’, Annals of Internal Medicine 98 (Part I), 588–592.
Lund, I. and Skulberg, A.: 1976, ‘Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation by Lay People’, The Lancet 2, 702–704.
MacDonell, J. A.: 1981,’ “No Resuscitation” Orders’, Canadian Medical Association Journal 125, 809–810.
Micetich, K. C. and Thomasma, D. C.: 1984, The Ethics of Patient Requests in Experimental Medicine’, CA: A Journal for Clinicians 34(2), 118–120.
Miles, S. H., Cranford, R. and Schultz, A. L.: 1982, The Do-Not-Resuscitate Order in a Teaching Hospital. Considerations and a Suggested Policy’, Annals of Internal Medicine 96, 660–664.
Morris, N: 1958, ‘The History of Cardiac Resuscitation’, in H. E. Stevenson, Jr. (ed.). Cardiac Arrest, C. V. Mosby, St. Louis, pp. 15–31.
Morse, M.: 1983, ‘A Near-Death Experience in a 7-Year-Old Child’, American Journal of the Diseases of Children 137, 959–961.
Motro, H.: 1983, ‘Medicolegal Aspects of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation’, Medicine and Law 2(2), 103–112.
Najman, J. N. and Levene, S.: 1981, ‘Evaluating the Impact of Medical Care and Technologies on the Quality of Life: A Review and Critique’, Social Science and Medicine 15(f), 107–115.
Negovsky, V.: 1982, ‘Reanimatology Today: Some Scientific and Philosophic Considerations’, Critical Care Medicine 10(2), 130–133.
Powner, D. J. and Grenvik, A.: 1979, ‘Triage in Patient Care: From Expected Recovery to Brain Death’, Heart and Lung 8(6), 1103–1108.
President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research: 1983, Deciding to Forego Life-Sustaining Treatment, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.-C.
Preuss, J.: 1978, Biblical and Talmudic Medicine, translated and edited F. Rosner, Sanhedrin Press, New York.
Rabkin, M. T., Gillerman, G. and Rice, N. R.: 1976, ‘Orders Not to Resuscitate’, New England Journal of Medicine 295, 364–366.
Ramsey, P.: 1976, ‘Prolonged Dying: Not Medically Indicated’, Hastings Center-Report 6, 14–17.
Robertson, G. S.: 1983, ‘Ethical Dilemmas of Brain Failure in the Elderly’, British Medical Journal 287, 1775–1777.
Robertson, W. G. A.: 1935, ‘Recovery after Judicial Hanging’, British Medical Journal (Jan 19), 121–122.
Rosenberg, A. J.: 1980, Mikraot G’dolot: The Book of Kings, Translation of Text, Rashi and Commentary, Judaica Press, New York.
Ross, W. D.: 1930, The Right and The Good, Oxford University Press, London.
Safar, P.: 1982, ‘Reanimatology’, Critical Care Medicine 10, 134–136.
Schneider, E. L. and Brody, J. A.: 1983, ‘Aging, Natural Death, and the Compression of Morbidity — Another View’, New England Journal of Medicine 309, 854–856.
Shakespeare, W.: 1917, Romeo and Juliet, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.
Sladen, A.: 1984, ‘Closed-chest Massage, Kouwenhoven, Jude, Knickerbocker’, Journal of the American Medical Association 251, 3137–3140.
Soleveichik, A.: 1978, ‘Jewish Law and the Time of Death’, [letter] Journal of the American Medical Association 240, 109.
Sowden, G. R., Robins, D. W. and Baskett, J. F.: 1984, ‘Factors Associated with Survival and Eventual Cerebral Status Following Cardiac Arrest’, Anesthesia 39, 39–43.
St. Louis, P., Carter, W. B. and Eisenberg, M. S.: 1982, ‘Prescribing CPR: A Survey of Physicians’, American Journal of Public Health 72(10), 1158–1160.
Anon.: 1980, ‘Standards and Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) and Emergency Cardiac Care (ECC)’ Journal of the American Medical Association 244, 453–509.
Stevenson, I: 1977, ‘Research into Evidence of Man’s Survival after Death: A Historical and Critical Survey with a Summary of Recent Developments’, Journal of Nervoustand Mental Disease 165, 152–170.
Tendler, M. B.: 1978, ‘Jewish Law and the Time of Death’, [letter] Journal of the American Medical Association 240, 109.
Teres, D., Brown, R. B. and Leneshow, S.: 1982, ‘Predicting Mortality of Intensive Care Unit Patients: The Importance of Coma’, Critical Care Medicine 10(2), 86–95.
Thomasma, D. C.: 1983, ‘Beyond Medical Paternalism and Patient Autonomy: A Model of Physician Conscience for the Physician-Patient Relationship’, Annals of Internal Medicine 98, 243–248.
Thomson, R., Hallstrom, A. and Cobb, L.: 1979, ‘Bystander-Initiated Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Management of Ventricular Fibrillation’, Annals of Internal Medicine 90, 737–740.
Veith, F. J., Fein, J. M., Tendler, M. D., et al.: 1977,‘Brain Death I. A Status Report of Medical and Ethical Consideration’, Journal of the American Medical Association 238, 1651–1655; and [in continuation] ‘Brain Death II. A Status Report of Legal Considerations’, Journal of the American Medical Association 238, 1744–1748.
Vt. Stat. Anno., ch. 12, sec 519 (1981).
Wagner, A.: 1984, ‘Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Aged’, New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1129–1130.
Wanzer, S. H., Adelstein, S. J., Cranford, R. E., et al.: 1984, ‘The Physician’s Responsibility Towards Hopelessly Ill Patients’, New England Journal of Medicine 310, 955–959.
Wilson, P.: 1982, ‘Anxiety and Depression in Elderly and Dying Patients’, Medical Clinics of North America 66(5), 1011–1016.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1987 D. Reidel Publishing Company
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Dagi, T.F. (1987). Revival, Resuscitation, and Resurrection: The Rights of Passage. In: Spicker, S.F., Ingman, S.R., Lawson, I.R. (eds) Ethical Dimensions of Geriatric Care. Philosophy and Medicine, vol 25. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-3391-0_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-3391-0_8
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-8020-0
Online ISBN: 978-94-009-3391-0
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive