Abstract
The main aim of this ‘critical position’ chapter is to provide a foundation and framework for developing effective local, contextual, collaborative, integrated planning and action for achieving sustainability within our food systems. Deep (eco-design/redesign-based) organics is distinguished from shallow (substitution-based) organics by the originator of these terms. A discussion is provided of the redesign implications for a transition from conventional agriculture and shallow organics to the more sustainable deep organics, using social ecology and associated ‘testing questions’ relating to personal, social, ecological and general aspects, as a framework for implementation. In addition to documenting the historical origins of these concepts and arguing for their relevance to achieving sustainability within food systems, emphasis is placed on the need to understand and address the psychological and psychosocial roots of the unsustainability challenges to modern societies. Failure to do this is considered as a main reason for the limited progress that has been made in addressing most current problems. Also, proactive, ecodesign-based preventative approaches to problems are advocated over reactive, curative approaches.
An Efficiency-Substitution-Redesign (ESR) progression in relation to change is illustrated using pest control to characterise the differences between the stages involved.
It is acknowledged that the changes being advocated here will require a fundamental shift in the paradigms underlying current dominant thinking and action. An innovative, proactive approach to enabling such a shift and facilitate meaningful change, based on ‘lying’, is provided.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsNotes
- 1.
See also: White (1991).
- 2.
This is an extension of Coleman’s earlier ‘plant-positive’ approach to production; Coleman and Ridgeway (1983).
- 3.
Until very recently, for nearly 100 years, virtually all research funding had been channeled to conventional agriculture.
- 4.
- 5.
deMause (2002) prefers the term helping.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
The failure to appreciate the significance of Yeomans’ design work in Australia is apparent from the recent rejection of an application to preserve his farm as a Heritage site where design research could have been continued, and its likely conversion into a housing estate (http://nrdcaa.blogspot.com/).
- 9.
- 10.
- 11.
- 12.
- 13.
- 14.
For its effects on the Canadian food system, see: Koc et al. (2008).
- 15.
A lecture based on the ideas presented in this chapter is available at: (www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzY1eZLwOdk), and my research in this area is ongoing.
References
Aberley D (ed) (1994) Futures by design: the practice of ecological planning. New Society Publishers, Gabriola Island
Aertsens J, Mondelaers K, Verbeke W, Buysse J, Van Huylenbroeck G (2011) The influence of subjective and objective knowledge on attitude, motivations and consumption of organic food. Brit Food J 113(11):1353–1378
Alexander C (2002) The nature of order: an essay on the art of building and the nature of the universe (Book one: the phenomenon of life). Oxford University Press, New York
Alexander C, Ishikawa S, Silverstein M (1977) A pattern language. Oxford University Press, New York
Altieri M (1987, 2nd edn. 1995) Agroecology: the science of sustainable agriculture. Westview Press, Boulder
Altieri MA, Martin PB, Lewis WJ (1983) A quest for ecologically based pest management systems. Environ Manag 7(1):91–100
Andrews P (2008) Beyond the brink: Peter Andrews’ radical vision for a sustainable Australian landscape. ABC Books, Ultimo
Bellon S, Desclaux D, Le Pichon V (2010) Innovation and research in organic farming: a multi-level approach to facilitate cooperation among stakeholders. In: WS1.8—Knowledge systems innovations and social learning in organic farming, 9th European IFSA Symposium, 4–7 July 2010, Vienna, Austria, pp 703–717
Buck D, Getz C, Guthman J (1997) From farm to table: the organic vegetable commodity chain in Northern California. Sociol Rural 37(1):3–20
Bugg RD (1992) Using cover crops to manage arthropods on truck farms. HortSci 27(7):741–745
Butterfield J, Bingham S, Savory A (2006) Holistic management handbook: healthy planet, healthy profits. Island Press, Washington. See also: www.holisticmanagement.org
Campbell A (1994) Landcare: communities shaping the land and the future. Allen and Unwin, St Leonards
Catacutan D, Neely C, Johnson M, Poussard H, Youl R (2009) Landcare: local action—global progress. World Agroforestry Centre, Nairobi
Coleman E (1999) Discussion session 1(The effects of plant health and soil health on susceptibility to pests). In: Stoner KA (ed) Alternatives to insecticides for managing vegetable insects (Proceedings of a Farmer/Scientist Conference, Dec 6–7 1998, New Haven, CT). Natural Resource, Agriculture and Engineering Service, Cooperative Extension, Ithaca, NY, p 7
Coleman E (2004) Can organics save the family farm? The Rake Mag [2002–2008, after which it was renamed Secrets of the City], September, Minneapolis, MN. http://archives.secretsofthecity.com/magazine/reporting/features/can-organics-save-family-farm. Accessed 5 Feb 2005
Coleman E (2009) The Winter Harvest handbook: year round vegetable production using deep organic techniques and unheated greenhouses. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction
Coleman EW, Ridgeway RL (1983) Role of stress tolerance in integrated pest management. In: Knorr D (ed) Sustainable food systems. AVI Publishing, Westport, pp 124–142
Constance DH (2010) Sustainable agriculture in the United States: a critical examination of a contested process. Sustainability 2(1):48–72
Coombes B, Campbell J (1998) Dependent reproduction of alternative modes of agriculture: organic farming in New Zealand. Sociol Rural 38(2):127–145
Darnhofer I, Lindenthal T, Bartel-Kratochvil R, Zollitsch W (2010) Conventionalisation of organic farming practices: from structural criteria towards an assessment based on organic principles: a review. Agron Sustain Dev 30:67–81
deMause L (2002) The emotional life of nations. Other Press, New York. www.psychohistory.com
Doré T, Makowsi D, Malézieux E, Munier-Jolain N, Tschamitchian M, Tittonell P (2011) Facing up to the paradigm of ecological intensification in agronomy: revisiting methods, concepts and knowledge. Eur J Agron 34:197–210
Ewel JJ (1999) Natural systems as models for the design of sustainable systems of land use. Agrofor Syst 45:1–21
Farley J, Schmitt FA, Alvez J, de Freitas Jr NR (2011) How nature can transform agriculture. Solutions 2:64–73
Fenton JD (2010) The untrained environmentalist. Allen and Unwin, St Leonards
Fukuoka M (1985) The natural way of farming: the theory and practice of green philosophy. Japan Publications, Tokyo
Georgescu-Roegen N (1971) The entropy law and the economic process. Harvard University, Cambridge
Glickson A, Mumford L (1971) The ecological basis of planning. Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, Netherlands
Gliessman SR (1997) Agroecology: ecological processes in sustainable agriculture (2nd edn. 2007, Agroecology: the ecology of sustainable food systems). CRC Press, Taylor & Francis, New York
Gliessman SR, Rosemeyer M (eds) (2010) The conversion to sustainable agriculture: principles, processes, and practices. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis, New York
Greenleaf RK (2002) Servant leadership: a journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness, 25th Anniversary Edition. Paulist Press, Mahwah
Guthman J (2004a) The trouble with ‘organic lite’ in California: a rejoinder to the ‘conventionalisation’ debate. Sociol Rural 44(3):301–316
Guthman J (2004b) Agrarian Dreams? The paradox of organic farming in California. University of California Press, Berkeley
Hill SB (1976) Conditions for a permanent agriculture. Maine Org Farming Gard 3(5): 8–9 [Reprinted in the Soil Assoc Q Rev 3(2):1–4, 1977]
Hill SB (1984a) Deep organics. Nat Farming [USA] Fall: 3, 10
Hill SB (1984b) Ecological pest control: confronting the causes. Int J Biosoc Res 6:1–3
Hill SB (1985) Redesigning the food system for sustainability. Altern 12(3/4):32–36
Hill SB (1991) Ecological and psychological pre-requisites for the establishment of sustainable prairie agricultural communities. In: Martin J (ed) Alternative futures for prairie agricultural communities. Faculty of Extension, University of Alberta, Edmonton, pp 197–229
Hill SB (1998) Redesigning agroecosystems for environmental sustainability: a deep systems approach. Syst Res Behav Sci 15:391–402
Hill SB (1999) Landcare: a multi-stakeholder approach to agricultural sustainability in Australia. In: Dragun AK, Tisdell C (eds) Sustainable agriculture and environment: globalisation and the impact of trade liberalisation. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 125–134
Hill SB (2004a) Redesigning pest management: a social ecology approach. In: Clements D, Shrestha A (eds) New dimensions in agroecology. Haworth Press, Binghamton, pp 491–510
Hill SB (2004b) Camping to change the world. Austr J Outdoor Educ 8(1):3–10
Hill SB (2005a) Social ecology as a framework for understanding and working with social capital and sustainability within rural communities. In: Dale A, Onyx J (eds) A Dynamic balance: social capital and sustainable community development. University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver, pp 48–68
Hill SB (2005b) Critically acknowledging, celebrating and enabling further development in ‘Deep Organics’ contributions to sustainability and wellbeing: a Social Ecology perspective. Keynote to IFOAM 2005 Conference [Adelaide, SA; 20–23 Sept] web; pp 12. www.ifoam.org
Hill SB (2005c) Sustainable living through permaculture: a social ecology perspective (Keynote to the 8th Australian Permaculture Convergence, Melbourne, 8–15 April; available at: http://organicdesign.co.nz/Sustainable_Living_through_Permaculture:A_Social_Ecology_Perspective
Hill SB (2006) Enabling redesign for deep industrial ecology and personal values transformation: a social ecology perspective. In: Green K, Randles S (eds) Industrial Ecology and Spaces of Innovation. Edward Elgar, London, Chapter 12, pp 255–271
Hill SB (2011a) Social ecology: an Australian perspective. In: Wright D, Camden-Pratt C, Hill S (eds) Social ecology: applying ecological understanding to our lives and our planet. Hawthorn Press, Stroud, UK. Powerpoint presentations on applied social ecology are available at: www.stuartbhill.com and www.scribd.com/doc/55937783
Hill SB (2011b) Afterword: four key features of permaculture (applicable to ‘everything’); and an opportunity for the future (also applicable to ‘everything’). In: Dawborn K, Smith C (eds) Permaculture pioneers: stories from the new frontier. Melliodora Publishing, Hepburn, VIC
Hill SB, MacRae R (1995) Conceptual frameworks for the transition from conventional to sustainable agriculture. J Sustain Agric 7:81–87
Hill SB, Vincent C, Chouinard G (1999) Evolving ecosystems approaches to fruit insect pest management. Agric Ecosyst Environ 73:107–110
Holmgren D (2002) Permaculture: principles & pathways beyond sustainability. Holmgren Design Services, Hepburn
Hunter D, Bailey A, Taylor B (1997) Co-operacy: a new way of being at work. Tandem Press, Birkenhead
Ikerd J (2009) Fundamentals of environmental responsibility: ensuring a sustainable environment for global food production. Institute of food technologists annual meeting, Anaheim, CA, June 9,2009.http://web.missouri.edu/~ikerdj/papers/California%20IFT%20Environmental%20Responsibiity.htm. Accessed 10 Jan 2010
Jackson W (2002) Natural systems agriculture: a truly radical alternative. Agric Ecosyst Envir 88:111–117
Jeavons J (1974) How to grow more vegetables than you ever thought possible on less land than you can imagine. Ecology action of the Midpeninsula, 2225 El Camino Real, Palo Alto, CA 94306 [6th edn., 2002; Ten Speed Press, Berkeley, CA], 240p
Josselson R (1996) The space between us: exploring the dimensions of human relationships. Sage, Thousand Oaks
Koc M, MacRae R, Desjardins E, Roberts W (2008) Getting civil about food: the interactions between civil society and the State to advance sustainable food systems in Canada. J Hunger Environ Nutr 3(2):122–144
Koepf HH (1989) The biodynamic farm: agriculture in the service of the earth and humanity. Anthroposophic Press, Hudson
Laing RD (1971) The politics of the family. Penguin, New York
Lamine C (2011) Transition pathways towards a robust ecologization of agriculture and the need for system redesign: cases from organic farming and IPM. J Rural Stud 27(2):209–219
Lamine C, Bellon S (2009) Conversion to organic farming: a multidimensional research object at the crossroads of agricultural and social sciences. A review. Agron Sustain Dev 29:97–112. doi:10.1051/agro:2008007
Lamine C, Barbier M, Blanc J, Buurma J, Haynes I, Lehota J, Maraccini E, Noe E, Paratte R, Szabo Z, Wierzbicka A (2010) Reducing the dependence on pesticides: a matter of transitions within the whole agri-food system, in WS4.4 – Transitions towards sustainable agriculture: from farmers to agro-food systems, 9th European IFSA Symposium, 4–7 July 2010, Vienna (Austria), pp 1943–1954
Lamine C, Navarrete M, Cardona A (2014) Transitions towards organic farming at the farm and at the local scales: the role of innovative production and organisational modes and networks. In: Bellon S, Penvern S(eds) Organic farming, prototype for sustainable agricultures. Springer, Chap. 23, pp 423–438
Lefroy EC, Hobbs RJ, O’Connor MH, Pate JS (1999) Agriculture as a mimic of natural ecosystems. Current plant science and biotechnology in agriculture. Vol. 37. Kluwer Academic Publishing, Dordrecht
Lockeretz WR (1978) Economic and resource comparison of field crop production on organic farms and farms using conventional fertilization and pest control methods in Midwestern United States. In: Besson JM, Vogtmann H (eds) Towards a sustainable agriculture. Proc. IFOAM Int. Conf., Sissach, Switzerland, 1977. Verlag Wirz Aarau, Switzerland, pp 157–169
Lockeretz W, Shearer G, Kohl DH (1984) Organic farming in the Corn Belt. Sci 211:540–547
Lockie S, Halpin D (2005) The conventionalisation thesis reconsidered: structural and ideological transformation of Australian organic agriculture. Sociol Rural 45(4):284–307
Lynch DH, MacRae R, Martin RC (2011) The carbon and global warming potential impacts of organic farming: does it have a significant role in an energy constrained world? Sustain 3:322–362
MacRae R (2011) A joined-up food policy for Canada. J Hunger Environ Nutr 6:1–33
MacRae R, Toronto Food Policy Council (1999) Not just what, but how: creating agricultural sustainability and food security by changing Canada’s agricultural policy making process. Agric Hum Values 16:187–201
MacRae RJ, Lynch D, Martin RC (2010) Improving the energy efficiency and GHG mitigation potential in Canadian organic farming systems. J Sustain Agric 34(5):549–580
Mäder P, Fließbach A, Dubois D, Gunst L, Fried P, Niggli U (2002) Soil fertility and biodiversity in organic farming. Science 296(5573):1694–1697
Malézieux E (2011) Designing cropping systems from nature. Agronomy for sustainable development. http://www.springerlink.com/content/x810823737671q46/fulltext.pdf. Accessed 3 Jan 2012
Marshall A (2009) Wild design: ecofriendly innovations inspired by nature. North Atlantic Books, Berkeley
Martin JF, Roy ED, Diemont SAW, Ferguson BG (2010) Traditional ecological knowledge (TEK): ideas, inspiration, and designs for ecological engineering. Ecol Eng 36:839–849
McCullum C, Desjardins E, Kraak VI, Ladipo P, Costello H (2005) Evidence-based strategies to build community food security. J Am Diet Assoc 105:278–283
McMurty J (2002) Value wars: the global market versus the life economy. Pluto Press, London
Mollison B (1988) Permaculture: a designer’s manual. Tagari Books, Tyalgun
Mollison B, Holmgren D (1978) Permaculture one: a perennial agriculture for human settlements. Transworld (Corgi, Bantam), Melbourne
Mulligan M, Hill SB (2001) Ecological pioneers: a social history of Australian ecological thought and action. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne (Ch. 8)
Naess A (1973) The shallow and the deep, long-range ecology movement. Inquiry 16:95–100
Papanek V (1995) The green imperative: ecology and ethics in design and architecture. Thames and Hudson, London
Pimentel D (2005) Environmental and economic costs of the application of pesticides primarily in the United States. Environ Dev Sustain 7:229–252
Prokopy RJ (1994) Integration in orchard pest and habitat management: a review. Agric Ecosyst Environ 50(1):1–10
Quinney J (1984) Designing sustainable farms. Mother Earth News 88(Jul/Aug):54–65
Ratnadass A, Fernandes P, Alevino J, Habib R (2011) Plant species diversity for sustainable management of crop pests and diseases in agroecosystems: a review. Agron Syst Dev 31:31. doi:10.1007/s13593-011-0022-4
Rodale Institute (2011) The farming systems trial: celebrating 30 years. Rodale Institute, Kutztown
Rosin C, Campbell H (2008) Beyond bifurcation: examining the conventions of organic agriculture in New Zealand. J Rural Stud 25(1):35–47
Rosset P, Altieri MA (1997) Agroecology versus input substitution: a fundamental contradiction of sustainable agriculture. Soc Nat Resour 10(3):283–295
Sattmann-Frese W, Hill SB (2008) Learning for sustainability: psychology of ecological transformation. Lulu, Morrisville. www.lulu.com
Savory A, Butterfield J (1999) Holistic management: a new framework for decision making. Island Press, Washington
Savory A, Parsons SD (1980) The Savory grazing method. Rangelands 2(6):234–237
Stallibrass A (1989) Being me and also us: lessons from the Peckham experiment. Scottish Academic Press, Edinburgh. See also: www.thephf.org
Soleri P (2006) Arcology: the city in the image of man, 4th edn. Cosanti Press, Mayer
Sylvander B, Bellon S, Benoit M (2006) Facing the organic reality: the diversity of development models and their consequences on research policies. OF and European Rural Development; Joint Organic Congress, Odense (DK), 30–31
Thomas VG, Kevan PG (1993) Basic principles of agroecology and sustainable agriculture. J Agric Environ Ethics 6(1):1–19
Todd NJ (2006) A safe and sustainable world: the promise of ecological design. Island Press, Washington
Todd NJ, Todd J (1984) Bioshelters, ocean arks, city farming: ecology as the basis of design. Sierra Club, San Francisco
Toyne P, Farley R (1989) A national land management program. Aust J Soil Water Conserv 2(2):6–9
Van der Ryn S, Cowan S (2007) Ecological design, 2nd edn. Island Press, Washington
Voisin A, Lecomte A (1962) Rotational grazing. Crosby lockwood, London
Warner KD (2007) Agroecology in action: extending alternative agriculture through social networks. MIT Press, Boston
Weathers J (1909) French market-gardening: including practical details of “Intensive Cultivation” for English growers. J Murray, London
Wezel A, Bellon S, Dore T, Francis C, Vallod D, David C (2009) Agroecology as a science, a movement and a practice: a review Agron Sustain Dev 29:503–515
White J (1991) Deep organics: avoiding inputs by design and management [based on viewing a video of a talk by SB Hill on ‘Deep Organics’ to the Northeast Organic Farming Association in 1984]. Maine Org Farmer Gard Jan/Feb: 12–13
Williams J, Gascoigne H (2003) Redesign of plant production systems for Australian landscapes. Proc. 11th Australian Agronomy Conference, Geelong, VIC. http://www.regional.org.au/au/asa/2003/i/4/williams.htm. Accessed 5 Feb 2010
Williamson GS, Pearse IH (1980) Science, synthesis and sanity. Scottish Academic Press, Edinburgh
Yeang K (2013) Ecomimicry: ecological design by imitating ecosystems. Routledge, New York, 256p
Yeomans PA (1958) The challenge of landscape: the development and practices of keyline. Keyline Press, Sydney
Yeomans PA (1971) The city forest: the keyline plan for the human environment revolution. Keyline Press, Sydney
Yeomans PA (1978) Water for every farm using the keyline plan. Murray Books, Ultimo
Yeomans AJ (2005) Priority one: together we can beat global warming. Keyline Press, Gold Coast City, QLD. See also: www.yeomansplow.com.au
Youl R, Marriott S, Nabben T (2006) Landcare in Australia: founded on local action (first published 1999). SILC and Rob Youl Consulting, Melbourne
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Hill, S. (2014). Considerations for Enabling the Ecological Redesign of Organic and Conventional Agriculture: A Social Ecology and Psychosocial Perspective. In: Bellon, S., Penvern, S. (eds) Organic Farming, Prototype for Sustainable Agricultures. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-7927-3_22
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-7927-3_22
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-007-7926-6
Online ISBN: 978-94-007-7927-3
eBook Packages: Biomedical and Life SciencesBiomedical and Life Sciences (R0)