Abstract
Concerning the use of history and philosophy in science teaching, the topic of thermal phenomena and thermodynamics is fertile because it relates to various epistemological and philosophical themes, which can be accessible and useful for secondary education, and its history shows interesting debates among scientists and strong relationships between science, technology and socio-economic problems. Moreover, many students’ conceptions are similar to ideas and reasoning of ancient theories, and residues of these theories are still present in current scientific language and in textbooks. The debate about the meaning and implications of the second law of thermodynamics involved broad scientific and philosophical problems. Entropy was connected with the theory of information, and thermodynamic ideas were assumed in other fields, such as economy, ecology and sociology. After a general introduction on the role of history and philosophy in science teaching, the chapter presents the main results of research on students’ conceptions and difficulties about thermal phenomena, a review of research concerning the use of history and philosophy in teaching thermodynamics and a discussion of historical and philosophical themes having valuable conceptual and cognitive implications that can be appropriate for teaching. Philosophical themes of didactic interest are discussed together with their teaching and learning implications. These themes include the meaning, interpretations and implications of the second law (irreversibility, time arrow, statistical and probabilistic laws and determinism); the relationships between macroscopic properties and microscopic structures; the nature of thermodynamics, its characteristics, language and explanations and its relationships and differences with mechanics; and the relationships between science, technology and general cultural context in the case of thermodynamics. Some case histories useful for teaching are presented, including the theories on the nature of heat; the discovery of thermal radiation, the debate on its nature and the search for its law; the calorific and frigorific rays in thermal radiation; the discovery of the second law; the history of steam engines; the Carnot cycle and its connections with caloric theory and entropy; the history of the cooling law and the definition of a good temperature scale; and the construction of the physical quantity temperature.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
See Arnold and Millar (1996), Besson et al. (2010), Chiou and Anderson (2010), Clough and Driver (1985), Cochran and Heron (2006), Cotignola et al. (2002), de Berg (2008), Erickson (1979, 1980), Erickson and Tiberghien (1985), Jasien and Oberem (2002), Leinonen et al. (2009), Lewis and Linn (1994), Sciarretta et al. (1990); Shayer and Wylam (1981), Stavy and Berkovitz (1980), Wiser and Amin (2001), and Wiser and Carey (1983).
- 2.
All quotations that were in French or in Italian in the original have been translated into English by the author of the present paper.
References
Arnold, M. & Millar, R. (1996). Learning the Scientific Story: A Case Study in the Teaching and Learning of Elementary Thermodynamics, Science Education. 80(3), 249–281.
Bacon, F. (1620). Novum Organum, sive indicia vera de interpretatione naturae. Edited by T. Fowler (1889) Oxford, Clarendon Press. English translation by G.W. Kitchin (1855) Oxford, University Press.
Baracca, A. & Besson, U. (1990). Introduzione storica al concetto di energia. Firenze: Le Monnier.
Begoray, D.L. & Stinner, A. (2005). Representing Science through Historical Drama. Science & Education, 14, 457–471.
Bénard, H. (1900). Étude expérimentale du mouvement des liquides propageant de la chaleur par convection. Régime permanente, tourbillons circulaires. Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences, 130, 1004–1007.
Besson, U. (2001) Work and Energy in the Presence of Friction: The Need for a Mesoscopic Analysis. European Journal of Physics, 22, 613–622.
Besson, U. (2003). The distinction between heat and work: an approach based on a classical mechanical model. European Journal of Physics, 24, 245–252.
Besson, U. (2010). Calculating and Understanding: Formal Models and Causal Explanations in Science, Common Reasoning and Physics Teaching. Science & Education, 19(3), 225–257.
Besson, U. (2011). The cooling law and the search for a good temperature scale, from Newton to Dalton. European Journal of Physics, 32(2), 343–354.
Besson, U. (2012). The history of cooling law: when the search for simplicity can be an obstacle. Science & Education 21(8), 1085–1110.
Besson, U. (2013). Historical Scientific Models and Theories as Resources for Learning and Teaching: The Case of Friction. Science & Education 22(5), 1001–1042.
Besson, U., De Ambrosis., A. and Mascheretti, P. (2010). Studying the physical basis of global warming: thermal effects of the interaction between radiation and matter and greenhouse effect. European Journal of Physics, 31, 375–388.
Besson, U. & De Ambrosis A. (2013). Teaching Energy Concepts by Working on Themes of Cultural and Environmental Value. Science & Education, DOI: 10.1007/s11191-013-9592-7.
Biot M. (1816) Sur la loi de Newton relative à la communication de la chaleur. Bulletin de la Société Philomatique, 21–24.
Black, J. (1803). Lectures on the Elements of Chemistry. Edinburgh: John Robison.
Boltzmann, L. (1872). Weitere Studien über das Wärmegleichgewicht unter Gasmolekülen. Sitzungsberichte der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien, Part II, 66, 275–370. English translation in Brush 2003, pp. 262–349.
Boltzmann, L. (1897). Zu Hrn. Zermelo’s Abhandlung “Über die mechanische Erklärung irreversibler Vorgänge”. Annalen der Physik 296(2), 392–398. English translation in Brush (2003), pp. 412–419.
Brace, D.B. (1901). The Laws of Radiation and Absorption. New York: American Book Company.
Brenni, P, Giatti, A. & Barbacci, S. (2009). Steam, Work, Energy. http://hipstwiki.wetpaint.com/page/Case+Study+2
Brush, S.G. (1976). The kind of motion we call heat. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company.
Brush, S.G. (2003). The Kinetic Theory of Gases: An Anthology of Classic Papers with Historical Commentary. London: Imperial College Press.
Callender, C. (1999). Reducing Thermodynamics to Statistics Mechanics: The Case of Entropy. The Journal of Philosophy, 96(7), 348–373.
Campanaro, J.M. (2002). The parallelism between scientists’ and students’ resistance to new scientific ideas. International Journal of Science Education, 24(10), 1095–1110.
Cardwell, D.S.L. (1971). From Watt to Clausius: The Rise of Thermodynamics in the Early Industrial Age. London: Heinemann.
Carnot, S. (1824–1897). Réflexions sur la puissance motrice du feu. Paris: Mallet-Bachelier. English translation: (1897) New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Carey, S. (1988). Reorganisation of Knowledge in the Course of Acquisition. In S. Strauss (Ed.) Ontogeny, Phylogeny and Historical Development (pp. 1–27). Norwood: Ablex.
Cassidy, D., Holton, G. & Rutherford, J. (2002). Understanding Physics. New York: Springer Verlag.
Chang, H. (2002). Rumford and the reflection of radiant cold: Historical reflections and metaphysical reflexes. Physics in Perspective, 4, 127–169.
Chang, H. (2004). Inventing Temperature: Measurement and Scientific Progress. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chang, H. (2011). How Historical Experiments Can Improve Scientific Knowledge and Science Education: The Cases of Boiling Water and Electrochemistry. Science & Education, 20, 317–341.
Chiou, Guo-Li & Anderson, O.R. (2010). A study of undergraduate physics students’ understanding of heat conduction based on mental model theory and an ontology–process analysis. Science Education, 94(5), 825–854.
Clapeyron, E. (1834). Mémoire sur la Puissance motrice de la chaleur. Journal de l’École Royale Polytechnique, Tome XIV, cahier 23, 153–190.
Clausius, R. (1854). Über eine veränderte Form des zweiten Hauptsatzes der mechanischen Wärmetheorie. Annalen der Physik 169(12), 481–506. English translation in Clausius (1867), pp. 111–135.
Clausius, R. (1862). Über die Anwendung des Satzes von der Äquivalenz der Verwandlungen auf die innere Arbeit. Annalen der Physik 192(5), 73–112. English translation in Clausius (1867), pp. 215–250.
Clausius, R. (1865). Über verschiedene für die Anwendung bequeme Formen der Hauptgleichungen der mechanischen Wärmetheorie. Annalen der Physik 201(7), 353–400. English translation in Clausius (1867), pp. 327–365.
Clausius, R. (1867). The Mechanical Theory of Heat - with its Applications to the Steam Engine and to Physical Properties of Bodies. London: Archer Hirst.
Clough, E. & Driver, R. (1985). Secondary students’ conceptions of the conduction of heat: Bringing together scientific and personal views. Physics Education, 20(4), 176–182.
Cochran, M.J. & Heron, P.R.L. (2006). Development and assessment of research-based tutorials on heat engines and the second law of thermodynamics. American Journal of Physics, 74, 734–741.
Collier, J.D. (1990). Two Faces of Maxwell’s Demon Reveal the Nature of Irreversibility. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science, 21, 257–268.
Conant, J.B. (1957). Harvard Case Histories in Experimental Science. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Cornell, E.S. (1936). Early studies in radiant heat. Annals of Science, 1(2), 217–225.
Cotignola, M.I., Bordogna, C., Punte, G. & Cappannini, O.M. (2002). Difficulties in Learning Thermodynamic Concepts: Are They Linked to the Historical Development of this Field? Science & Education, 11, 279–291.
Dalton, J. (1808). A new system of chemical philosophy. Manchester, vol. 1, pp. 1–140.
Daub, E. (1970). Maxwell’s Demon. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 1, 213–227.
Davy, H. (1799). An essay on heat, light, and the combinations of light. In J. Davy (Ed.) (1839) The collected works of H. Davy (Vol. 2, pp. 5–86). London: Smith, Elder, and Co. Cornhill.
de Berg, K. C. (2008). The Concepts of Heat and Temperature: The Problem of Determining the Content for the Construction of an Historical Case Study which is Sensitive to Nature of Science Issues and Teaching-Learning Issues. Science & Education, 17, 75–114.
De Filippo, G. & Mayer, M. (1991). Riflessioni sul rapporto scienza – tecnologia: le macchine termiche e la termodinamica. In C. Tarsitani & M. Vicentini (Eds), Calore, energia, entropia (pp. 95–128). Milano: Franco Angeli.
Delaroche, F. (1812). Observations sur le calorique rayonnant. Journal de Physique, XXV, 201–228.
Doige, C.A. & Day, T. (2012). A Typology of Undergraduate Textbook Definitions of ‘Heat’ across Science Disciplines. International Journal of Science Education, 34(5), 677–700.
Duhem, P. (1908). Σωζειν τα Φαινομενα, Essai sur la notion de théorie physique de Platon à Galilée. Paris: Hermann. Reprint: 1990, Paris: Vrin.
Dulong, P. & Petit, A. (1817). Recherches sur les Mesures des Température set sur les Lois de la communication de la chaleur. Annales de Chimie et de Physique (Paris: Clochard), VII, 113–154, 225–264, 337–367.
Erickson, G. L. (1979). Children’s conceptions of heat and temperature. Science Education, 63(2), 221–230.
Erickson, G. L. (1980). Children’s viewpoints of heat: A second look. Science Education, 64(3), 323–336.
Erickson, G. & Tiberghien, A. (1985). Heat and temperature. In R. Driver, E. Guesne & A. Tiberghien (Eds), Children’s ideas in science (pp. 52–84). Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Fourier, J. (1822). Théorie Analytique de la Chaleur. Paris: Firmin Didot Père et Fils.
Haglund, J., Jeppsson, F. & Strömdahl, H. (2010). Different senses of entropy - Implications for education. Entropy, 12(3), 490–515.
Holton, G. (2003a). What Historians of Science and Science Educators Can Do for One Another? Science & Education, 12, 603–616.
Holton, G. (2003b). The Project Physics Course, Then and Now. Science & Education, 12, 779–786.
Hutton, J. (1794). A Dissertation upon the Philosophy of Light, Heat and Fire. Edinburgh & London: Cadell and Davis.
Jasien, P.G. & Oberem, G.E. (2002). Understanding of elementary concepts in heat and temperature among college students and K-12 teachers. Journal of Chemical Education, 79(7), 889–895.
Jaynes, E. T. (1957). Information theory and statistical mechanics. Physical Review, 106(4), 620–630.
Joule, J.P. & Thomson, W. (1854). On the Thermal Effects of Fluids in Motion, Part 2. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 144, 321–364.
Kesidou, S. & Duit, R. (1993). Students’ conceptions of the second law of thermodynamics: An interpretive study. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 30(1), 85–106.
Lambert, F.L. (2002). Disorder - A cracked crutch for supporting entropy discussions. Journal of Chemical Education, 79, 187–192.
Landauer, R. (1961). Irreversibility and heat generation in the computing process. IBM Journal of Research and Development, 5(3), 183–191.
Lavoisier, A. (1789). Traité élémentaire de chimie. Paris: Cuchet.
Lavoisier, A. & Laplace, P.S. (1780). Mémoire sur la chaleur, Mémoires de l’Académie Royale des sciences (pp. 355–408). Paris: Imprimerie Royale.
Lebowitz, J.L. (1999). Microscopic Origins of Irreversible Macroscopic Behavior. Physica A, 263, 516–527.
Leinonen, R., Rasanen, E., Asikainen, M. & Hirvonen, P. (2009). Students’ pre-knowledge as a guideline in the teaching of introductory thermal physics at university. European Journal of Physics, 30, 593–604.
Leite, L. (1999). Heat and temperature: An analysis of how these concepts are dealt with in textbooks. European Journal of Teacher Education, 22(1), 75–88.
Leslie, J. (1804). An Experimental Inquiry into the Nature and Propagation of Heat. London: J. Mawman.
Lewis, E. L. & Linn, M. C. (1994). Heat and temperature concepts of adolescents, adults, and experts: Implications for curriculum improvements. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31(6), 657–677.
Loverude, M.E., Kautz, C.H. & Heron, P.R.L. (2002). Student understanding of the first law of thermodynamics: Relating work to the adiabatic compression of an ideal gas. American Journal of Physics, 70, 137–148.
Mäntylä, T. & Koponen, I.T. (2007). Understanding the Role of Measurements in Creating Physical Quantities: A Case Study of Learning to Quantify Temperature in Physics Teacher Education. Science & Education, 16, 291–311.
Matthews, M.R. (1994). Science Teaching. The Role of History and Philosophy of Science. New York – London: Routledge.
Maxwell, J.C. (1871). Theory of heat. London: Longmans, Green & Co, 10th edition 1891.
Maxwell, J.C. (1875). On the dynamical evidence of the molecular constitution of bodies. Nature 4, 357–359, 374–377.
Meltzer, D. (2004). Investigation of Students’ Reasoning Regarding Heat, Work, and the First Law of Thermodynamics in an Introductory Calculus-based General Physics Course. American Journal of Physics, 73, 1432–1446.
Metz, D. & Stinner, A. (2006). A Role for Historical Experiments: Capturing the Spirit of the Itinerant Lecturers of the 18th Century. Science & Education, doi: 10.1007/s11191-006-9016-z.
National Science Education Standards (1996). National Academy Press. http://www.nap.edu/catalog/4962.html.
Nersessian, N. J. (1995). Opening the black box: Cognitive science and the history of science. Osiris, 10(1), 194–211.
Newburgh, R. (2009). Carnot to Clausius: caloric to entropy. European Journal of Physics, 30, 713–728.
Newton, I. (1701). Scala graduum caloris, Calorum Descriptiones & Signa (Scale of the Degrees of Heat). Philosophical Transactions, 22(270), 824–829. English translation in: Newton I. (1809) Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Abridged, 4, 572–575.
Oversby, J. (2009). Temperature – what can we find out when we measure it? http://hipst.eled.auth.gr/hipst_docs/instruments.pdf
Piaget, J. & Garcia, R. (1983). Psychogenèse et histoire des sciences. Paris: Flammarion.
Planck, M. (1882). Verdampfen, Schmelzen und Sublimiren. Annalen der Physik 251(3), 446–475.
Planck, M. (1897). Vorlesungen über Thermodynamik. Leipzig: Verlag von Veit & Comp.
Poisson, S.D. (1835). Théorie Mathématique de la Chaleur. Paris: Bachelier.
Prigogine, I. & Stengers, I. (1988). Entre le temps et l’éternité. Paris: Fayard.
Project Physics Course (1970). New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Reif, F. (1965). Berkeley Physics Course, Vol. 5, Statistical Physics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Reif, F. (1999). Thermal physics in the introductory physics course: Why and how to teach it from a unified atomic perspective. American Journal of Physics, 67, 1051–1062.
Rozier, S. & Viennot, L. (1991). Students’ reasoning in thermodynamics. International Journal of Science Education, 13, 159–170.
Sciarretta, M.R., Stilli, R. & Vicentini, M. (1990). On the thermal properties of materials: common‐sense knowledge of Italian students and teachers. International Journal of Science Education, 12(4), 369–379.
Seroglou, F. & Koumaras, P. (2001). The contribution of the history of physics in physics education: A review. Science & Education, 10(1), 153–172.
Shannon, C. E. (1948). A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 27, 379–423 and 623–656.
Shayer, M. & Wylam, H. (1981). The development of the concepts of heat and temperature in 10–13 years-olds. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 5, 419–434.
Stavy, R. & Berkovitz, B. (1980). Cognitive conflict as a basis for teaching quantitative aspects of the concept of temperature. Science Education, 64(5), 679–692.
Stengers, I. (1997). Thermodynamique : la réalité physique en crise. Paris: La Découverte.
Styer, D.F. (2000). Insight into entropy. American Journal of Physics, 68(12), 1090–1096.
Stinner, A. (1995). Contextual Settings, Science Stories, and Large Context Problems: Toward a More Humanistic Science Education. Science Education, 79(5), 555–581.
Stinner, A. & Teichmann, J. (2003). Lord Kelvin and the Age-of-the-Earth Debate: A Dramatization. Science & Education, 12, 213–228.
Stinner, A., McMillan, B., Metz, D., Jilek, J. & Klassen, S. (2003). The Renewal of case studies in Science education. Science & Education, 12, 617–643.
Teixeira, E.S., Greca, I.M. & Freire, O. (2012). The History and Philosophy of Science in Physics Teaching: A Research Synthesis of Didactic Interventions. Science & Education, 21(6), 771–796.
Tarsitani, C. & Vicentini, M. (1996). Scientific Mental Representations of Thermodynamics. Science & Education, 5(1), 51–68.
Thomson, B. (Rumford) (1804). An enquiry concerning the nature of heat and the mode of its communication. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 94, 77–182.
Thomson, W. (Kelvin) (1851). On the Dynamical Theory of Heat. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, March 1851, 174–210. Philosophical Magazine, 4(22, 23, 24, 27) 8–21, 105–117, 168–176, 424–434.
Thomson, W. (Kelvin) (1852). On a Universal Tendency in Nature to the Dissipation of Mechanical Energy. Philosophical Magazine, 4(25) 304–306.
Thomson, W. (Kelvin) (1874). The Kinetic Theory of the Dissipation of Energy. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 8, 325–334.
Viard, J. (2005). Using the history of science to teach thermodynamics at the university level: The case of the concept of entropy. Eighth International History, Philosophy, Sociology & Science Teaching Conference, http://www.ihpst2005.leeds.ac.uk/papers/Viard.pdf
Viglietta, L. (1990). Efficiency in the teaching of Energy. Physics Education, 25, 317–321.
Wang, H.A. & Marsh, D.D. (2002). Science Instruction with a Humanistic Twist. Science & Education, 11, 169–189.
Welch, W.W. (1973). Review of the research and evaluation program of Harvard Project Physics. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 10(4), 365–378.
Wiebe, R. & Stinner, A. (2010). Using Story to Help Student Understanding of Gas Behavior. Interchange, 41 (4), 347–361.
Wiser, M. & Amin, T. (2001). “Is heat hot?” Inducing conceptual change by integrating everyday and scientific perspectives on thermal phenomena. Learning and Instruction, 11(4), 331–355.
Wiser, M. & Carey, S. (1983). When heat and temperature were one. In D. Gentner & A. Stevens (Eds.), Mental models (pp. 267–297), Hillsdale: NJ: Erlbaum.
Wicken, J.S. (1981). Causal Explanations in Classical and Statistical Thermodynamics. Philosophy of Science, 48(1), 65–77.
Zambrano, A.C. (2005). A curricular sequence based on a historical study of conceptual change in science. Eighth International History, Philosophy, Sociology & Science Teaching Conference, http://www.ihpst2005.leeds.ac.uk/papers/Zambrano.pdf
Zemanski M.W. (1968). Heat and Thermodynamics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Acknowledgements
I wish to thank Robyn Yucel from Latrobe University, Australia, who did the copyediting of the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Besson, U. (2014). Teaching About Thermal Phenomena and Thermodynamics: The Contribution of the History and Philosophy of Science. In: Matthews, M. (eds) International Handbook of Research in History, Philosophy and Science Teaching. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-7654-8_9
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-7654-8_9
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-007-7653-1
Online ISBN: 978-94-007-7654-8
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawEducation (R0)