The Central Asian Response to “Models”

  • Anita Sengupta


Chap. 5 examines the central Asian response to the Turkish Model which can only be considered in terms of the political, economic and social realities at the time of the emergence of the republics (which was the only time when it had been seriously considered) but also in terms of the fact that the region had only just emerged out of being a part of a larger Soviet Union, was being considered by China, the state bordering the eastern side of the region, as its zone of influence and was generally being visualized as an emerging arena for international competition for its natural resources. This was also the time when the states were in the process of transforming themselves and there was reassertion of the “national” in every sphere. It is also necessary to keep in mind that the reaction of the four “Turkic” states of central Asia to the model was also dissimilar. Domestic compulsions and foreign policy orientation of the states determined the level of enthusiasm of these states regarding their relations with Turkey and the “Turkish Model.” This chapter argues that the level of enthusiasm that the states displayed towards the model was dependent not only on considerations of “ethnic” or “linguistic” connections or even on the economic support that Turkey could extend to them but also on various other factors like the level of Russian interest in the region, Russia’s relations with Turkey, Chinese concerns about eastern Turkestan, international politics and the significance of the region in geopolitical terms, oil and pipeline politics and the projection of Turkey as a bridge for the states’ relation with the West. In this context it examines the relevance of the Gulen movement in the relation of these states with Turkey.


Foreign Policy Foreign Minister Central Asian Region Deputy Prime Minister Central Asian Republic 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


  1. Asia Times Online (2000). Russia frets over Islamic militants, August 29.
  2. Auezov, M. M. (2004). India, Russia and China in the emerging dynamics of Central Asia. In K. Santhanam & R. Dwivedi (Eds.), India and Central Asia: Advancing the common interest. New Delhi: Anamaya Publishers.Google Scholar
  3. Bal, I. (2000). Turkey’s relations with the West and Turkic republics, the r ise and fall of the Turkish Model. Burlington: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  4. Chufrin, G. (Ed.). (1999). Russia and Asia:The emerging security agenda. New York: OUP.Google Scholar
  5. Dillon, M. (2004). Xinjiang—China’s Muslim Far Northeast. London: Routledge Curzon.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. (2007). Uzbekistan wants to be friends with Turkey again and counts on its support, August 31.Google Scholar
  7. (2013). Sait Nursi and Fethullah Gülen: Religious and educational activities between Turkey and central Asia 20 years after the end of the USSR, January 27.Google Scholar
  8. Galyamova, V. (2002). Vozrozhdayushiesya Gigant i Kitaiskaya Ugroza v Istorichiskoi Retrospektive. Kazakhstan i Sovremennie Mir, 1(2).Google Scholar
  9. Gokalp, Z. (1992). The principles of Turkism. Leiden: E.J. Brill.Google Scholar
  10. Hymen, A. (1997). Turkestan and Pan Turkism revisited. Central Asian Survey, 16(3).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Islamov, B. A. (1994). Post Soviet Central Asia and the Commonwealth of Independent States. In B. Manz (Ed.), Central Asia in historical perspective. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
  12. Iwashita, A. (2004). A 4000 kilometer journey along the Sino-Russian border, Slavic Research Centre. Hokkaido University: Sapporo.Google Scholar
  13. Jackson, N. J. (2003). Russian foreign policy and the CIS: Theories, debates and actions. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  14. Karimov, I. A. (1995). Yedinstvo, Proshlovo i Budusheyevo, Rech na Torzhestvennom Otkritii Dnei Kazakhstana v Uzbekistane, May 23, 1994, in Turkestan Nash Obshii Dom. Tashkent: Uzbekistan.Google Scholar
  15. Karimova, G. (1995). Politico Aakonomichyeskoiye Reforme v Uzbekistane Realii I Perspektivi. Tashkent: Uzbekistan.Kazakhstanskaya Pravda. (1995). The Kazakh President defines the republic’s foreign policy, February 16.Google Scholar
  16. Laruelle, M., & Peyrouse, S. (2012). The Chinese question in Central Asia, domestic order, social c hange and the Chinese factor. London: Hurst and Co.Google Scholar
  17. Makarenko, T. (2000). Russian language in Kyrgyzstan: Balancing the security with Economics. Central Asia and Caucasus Analyst.Google Scholar
  18. Malik, D. J. M. (1993). China, Central Asia, India and Pakistan now come face to face with vigorous separatism. Defence and Foreign Affairs Strategic Policy, September 30.Google Scholar
  19. Marat, E. (2007). Turkey’s cultural and economic presence grows in Kyrgyzstan. Eurasia Daily Monitor, 4(145).Google Scholar
  20. Melet, Y. (1998). China’s political and economic relations with Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Central Asian Survey, 17(2).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Naribaev, M. K. (1999). Cooperation Kazakhstan-Turkey—Turkey as a constituent part of integration process. Vestnik KazGu, Almaty, No. 1.Google Scholar
  22. Niyazov, S. A. (2000). Turkmens, Turkmenistan, the world: Millennia and the 21st Century, Link between times and civilizations. http// Scholar
  23. Niyazov, S. A. (2003). It is very difficult to build a state. Address at the conference of the Humanitarian Association of “World Turkmens,” http//:presidentniyazov.tripod. com/id14html.Google Scholar
  24. Niyazov, S. A. (2004). Strategic partnership in the ideals of peace and humanism. UN Chronicle Online Edition, Issue 2,
  25. Ormushev, A. S. (2005). Turkish republic’s contribution to the sphere of education in Kyrgyzstan in role and place of the Turkic civilization among the world civilizations. Proceedings of the second international Congress on Turkic civilization. Bishkek: Kyrgyz Turkish Manas University Publication.Google Scholar
  26. Osmonov, J. (2011). Turkish Prime Minister visits Kyrgyzstan. Central Asia-Caucasus Institute Analyst, February 3.Google Scholar
  27. Presidency of the Republic of Turkey. (2010). Decision to lend a helping hand to Kyrgyzstan from Turkic Council, June 15,
  28. Raczka, W. (1998). Xinjiang and its Central Asian Borderlands. Central Asian Survey, 17(3).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Sen, M. (2005). Turkish Islamist Entrepreneurs in Central Asia. In B. N. Schlyter (Ed.), Prospects for democracy in Central Asia, Istanbul: Swedish Research Institute in Istanbul.Google Scholar
  30. Sengupta, A. (2009). Heartlands of Eurasia: The geopolitics of political space. Lanham: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
  31. Sergei, G. (1997). Russia’s Policy Towards Central Asia. Washington, D.C: Carnegie Moscow Centre.Google Scholar
  32. State News Agency of Turkmenistan. (2011). Leaders of Turkmenistan and Turkey discuss prospects of strategic partnership, June 1,
  33. Syroezhkin, K. (1999). The policy of Russia in Central Asia: A perspective from Kazakhstan. In C. Gennady (Ed.), Russia and Asia:The emerging security agenda. New York: OUP.Google Scholar
  34. Tajikistan Daily Digest. (2002). Central Asian nations may prefer USA to Russia: Tajik Newspaper, January 24.Google Scholar
  35. The Journal of Turkish Weekly. (2010). Turkey-Uzbekistan: Strengthening cooperation and achieving progress, December 2.Google Scholar
  36. Today’s Zaman. (2009). Turkey-Kazakhstan relations hit a peak, October 25.Google Scholar
  37. Today’s Zaman. (2013). Turkey signs 12 agreements with Turkmenistan during Gul’s visit, May 30.Google Scholar
  38. Valkenier, E. K. (1994). Russian policies in Central Asia: Change or continuity. SAIS Review, 14(2), Summer-Fall.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. World Bulletin. (2011). Turkish, Turkmen presidents meet to discuss gas transfer cooperation, May 31.Google Scholar
  40. Yanik, L. K. (2004 March). The politics of educational exchange: Turkish education in Eurasia. Europe-Asia Studies, 56(2).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Yermukanov, M. (2005). Kazakhstan and Turkey search for common ground. Eurasia Daily Monitor, 2(87), May 4.Google Scholar
  42. Zvyagelskaia, I. D. (1994). Central Asia and the Caucasus: New geopolitics. In N. Vitaly (Ed.), Central Asia and Transcaucasus: Ethnicity and conflict. Westport: Greenwood Publishing Group.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Maulana Abul Kalam Azad Institute of Asian Studies (MAKAIAS) 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Maulana Abul Kalam Azad Institute of Asian StudiesKolkataIndia

Personalised recommendations