Comparing Real & Synthetic Scenes using Human Judgements of Lightness
Increased application of computer graphics in areas which demand high levels of realism has made it necessary to examine the manner in which images are evaluated and validated. In this paper, we explore the need for including the human observer in any process which attempts to quantify the level of realism achieved by the rendering process, from measurement to display. We introduce a framework for measuring the perceptual equivalence (from a lightness perception point of view) between a real scene and a computer simulation of the same scene. Because this framework is based on psychophysical experiments, results are produced through study of vision from a human rather than a machine vision point of view. This framework can then be used to evaluate, validate and compare rendering techniques.
KeywordsLightness Perception Psychophysical Experiment Real Scene Global Illumination Original Scene
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.E. H. Adelson, Lightness Perception and Lightness Illusions, 339–351, MIT Press, 1999, pp. 339–351.Google Scholar
- 3.H. Coolican, Research methods and statistics in psychology, Hodder and Stoughton, Oxford, 1999.Google Scholar
- 4.S. Daly, The visible difference predictor: an algorithm for the assessment of ima ge fidelity, In A. B. Watson Editor, Digital Images and Human Vision, MIT Press, 1993, pp. 179–206.Google Scholar
- 5.J. A. Ferwerda, S.N. Pattanaik, P. Shirley, and D. P. Greenberg, A model of visual adaptation for realistic image synthesis, Computer Graphics 30 (1996), no. Annual Conference Series, 249–258.Google Scholar
- 12.A. McNamara, A. Chalmers, T. Troscianko, and E. Reinhard, Fidelity of graphics reconstructions: A psychophysical investigation, Proceedings of the 9th Eurographics Rendering Workshop, Springer Verlag, June 1998, pp. 237–246.Google Scholar
- 14.K. Myszkowski, The visible differences predictor: Applications to global illumination problems, Rendering Techniques ‘98 (Proceedings of Eurographics Rendering Workshop ‘98) (New York, NY) (G. Drettakis and N. Max, eds.), Springer Wien, 1998, pp. 233–236.Google Scholar
- 15.H. Rushmeier, G. Ward, C. Piatko, P. Sanders, and B. Rust, Comparing real and synthetic images: Some ideas about metrics, Eurographics Rendering Workshop 1995, Eurographics, June 1995.Google Scholar
- 16.D. Travis, Effective color displays, Academic Press, 1991.Google Scholar
- 17.G. J. Ward, The RADIANCE lighting simulation and rendering system, Proceedings of SIG-GRAPH ‘94 (Orlando, Florida, July 24–29, 1994) (Andrew Glassner, ed.), Computer Graphics Proceedings, Annual Conference Series, ACM SIGGRAPH, ACM Press, July 1994, ISBN 0–89791–667–0, pp. 459–472.Google Scholar