Double Taxation Relief, Transfer Pricing Adjustments and State Aid Law

  • Werner HaslehnerEmail author
Part of the MPI Studies in Tax Law and Public Finance book series (MPISTUD, volume 6)


This contribution explores the influence of state aid law on tax measures for the provision of relief from double taxation and the consequences of its application to transfer pricing adjustments. In particular, it analyses the compatibility of measures that prevent merely virtual double taxation and transfer pricing adjustments that might result in “white income”. It also reviews the merits of the Commission’s claim that Member States have to apply the arm’s length standard to transfer pricing adjustments as a matter of State aid law.


Transfer Price Multinational Enterprise Fundamental Freedom Double Taxation Foreign Income 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


  1. Brauner Y (2013) Formulary apportionment and transfer pricing: the good, the bad and the misguided. In: Dourado A (ed) Movement of persons and tax mobility in the EU: changing winds. IBFD, Amsterdam, pp 387–411Google Scholar
  2. Bullen A (2011) Arm’s length transaction structures – recognizing and restructuring controlled transactions in transfer pricing. IBFD, Amsterdam, pp 305–346Google Scholar
  3. Desai M, Hines J (2003) Evaluating tax reform. Natl Tax J 56(3):487–502CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Eigelshoven A (2015) In: Vogel K, Lehner M (eds) DBA Art. 9 paragraph 23, p 1049Google Scholar
  5. European Commission (2015) Commission Press Release, State Aid: Commission opens formal investigation into Luxembourg’s tax treatment of McDonald’s, 3 December 2015, IP/15/6221Google Scholar
  6. European Commission (2016) European Commission Press Release, State Aid: Commission concludes Belgian “Excess Profit” tax scheme illegal; around €700 million to be recovered from 35 multinational companies, 11 January 2016, IP/16/42Google Scholar
  7. Flett J, Walkerova K (2008) An Ecotax under the State Aid Spotlight: The UK Aggregates Levy. In: EC State Aid Law – Liber Amicorum Francisco Santaolalla Gadea. Wolter Kluwer International, Alphen aan Den Rijn, pp 223–237Google Scholar
  8. Gunn A, Luts J (2015) Tax rulings, APAs and state aid: legal issues. EC Tax Rev 24(2):119–125Google Scholar
  9. Haslehner W (2012) Materielle Selektivität von Steuerbeihilfen im Lichte des Gibraltar-Urteils des EuGH. In: Jaeger T, Haslinger B (eds) Jahrbuch Beihilferecht 2012. Neuer Wissenschaftlicher Verlag, Vienna, pp 301–324Google Scholar
  10. Hines J (2009) Reconsidering the taxation of foreign income. Tax Law Rev 62(2):269–298Google Scholar
  11. Kane M (2006) Ownership neutrality, ownership distortions, and international tax welfare benchmarks. Virginia Law Rev 26:53–79Google Scholar
  12. Kofler G (2015) Article 9. In: Reimer, Rust A (eds) Klaus Vogel on Double Taxation Conventions. Kluwer, Alphen aan den Rijn, pp 577–703Google Scholar
  13. Lang M (2011) Das Gibraltar-Urteil des EuGH: Neue beihilfenrechtliche Vorgaben für das Steuerrecht? ÖStZ 24:593–600Google Scholar
  14. Lang M (2012) Europäisches Beihilferecht und Besteuerung – am Beispiel des § 8c KStG. In: Lüdicke (ed) Praxis und Zukunft des deutschen Internationalen Steuerrechts. Dr. Otto Schmidt, Cologne, pp 85–115Google Scholar
  15. Luja R (2004) Tax treaties and state aid: some thoughts. Eur Tax 44(5):234–238Google Scholar
  16. Lyal R (2015) Transfer pricing rules and state aid. Fordham Int Law J 38:1017–1043Google Scholar
  17. Rossi-Maccanico P (2015) Fiscal state aids, tax base erosion and profit shifting. EC Tax Rev 24(2):63–77Google Scholar
  18. Rust A (ed) (2011) Double taxation within the European Union. Kluwer Law International, LondonGoogle Scholar
  19. Schön W (1999) Taxation and state aid law in the European Union. Common Mark Law Rev 36(5):911–936CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Schön W (2012a) State aid in the area of taxation. In: Hancher L, Ottervanger T, Slot PJ (eds) EU state aids. Sweet & Maxwell, London, pp 321–362Google Scholar
  21. Schön W (2012b) Transfer pricing – business incentives, international taxation and corporate law. In: Schön W, Konrad K (eds) Fundamentals of international transfer pricing in law and economics. Springer, Berlin, pp 47–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Schön W (2013) Transfer pricing, the arm’s length standard and European Union law. In: Richelle I, Schön W, Traversa E (eds) Allocating taxing powers within the European Union. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 73–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Schön W (2015) Transfer pricing issues of BEPS in the light of EU law. Br Tax Rev 3:417–428Google Scholar
  24. Shaviro D (2014) Fixing U.S. international taxation. Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  25. Vann R (2010) Taxing international business income: hard-boiled wonderland and the end of the world. World Tax J 2(3):291–346Google Scholar
  26. Weisbach D (2016) The use of neutralities in international tax policy, Oxford University Centre for Business taxation. Working Paper Series 14/14. Acceded 18 March 2016
  27. Wilkie S (2012) Reflecting on the “Arm’s Length Principle”: What is the “Principle”? Where Next? In: Schön W, Konrad K (eds) Fundamentals of international transfer pricing in law and economics. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 137–156CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of LuxembourgLuxembourgLuxembourg

Personalised recommendations