To assess rationality before anything else. A remark on the legitimacy of Rational Technology Assessment
This involves a comment on the chapter by Michael Decker and Armin Grunwald in this volume, that is, on what these author’s have coined “Rational Technology Assessment” (RTA). And although the richness of Decker and Grunwald’s account deserves a lot more, I will confine myself to only one aspect: the “rationality” of RTA. I believe that the kind of rationality exploited in RTA makes Technology Assessment expedient, rather than legitimate. To develop my argument, I take two steps. First, I give a brief sketch of the history of Technology Assessment until the rise of social constructivist approaches, and try to explicate the rationale of RTA on the basis of this sketch. In fact, I regard RTA as a new and courageous attempt to complement social constructivist philosophy with a feasible plan of work. Second, however, I argue that RTA simultaneously divagates from this philosophy, in that it neglects its legitimate basis by depending on expert knowledge too heavily. RTA resembles what Habermas has called a “technocratic model”.
KeywordsEurope Stake Smit Milton
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Banta HD, Luce BR (1993) Health care technology and its assessment: an international perspective. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Carpenter SR (1983) Technoaxiology: appropriate norms for Technology Assessment. In: Durbin PT, Rapp F (eds) Philosophy and technology. D. Reidel Publishing Company, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
- Gago JM (1998) The social science bridges. Portugese Ministry of Science and Technology, The social science bridge, Observatório das Ciências e das Tecnologias, LisbonGoogle Scholar
- Habermas J (1996) The scientization of politics and public opinion. In: Outhwaite W (ed) The Habermas Reader. Polity Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- MacKenzie D, Wajcman J (1985) The social shaping of technology — how the refrigerator got its hum. Open University Press, Milton KeynesGoogle Scholar
- Rapp F (1983) The prospects for Technology Assessment. In: Durbin PT, Rapp F (eds) Philosophy and technology. D. Reidel Publishing Company, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
- Rip A, Misa ThJ, Schot J (1995) Managing technology in society: the approach of constructive Technology Assessment. Pinter, LondonGoogle Scholar