Clinical Perplexities in the Treatment of Treatment-Refusing Forensic Patients
For many, the right to refuse treatment in a forensic hospital is a contradiction in terms. Court systems require maximum security hospitals for the protection of society from the committed, psychiatrically ill individual whose rights to privacy and autonomy are thereby modified, yet the involuntary “patient’s” rights to privacy and autonomy are upheld by the courts in defense of treatment refusal. Court-committed patients are met on admission by a patient advocate who explains the treatment authorization form for signature — before the patient has contact with the admitting psychiatrist. Although the courts accept recommendations of competency to stand trial contingent upon continuation of antipsychotic medication , the same medications have been considered mind controlling  in support of the right to refuse treatment. The invasive nature of psychoses  has not been conceded by the legal system.
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 2.Gutheil TG (1980) In search of true freedom: drug refusal, involuntary medication, and “rotting with your rights on.” Am J Psychiatry 137: 327–328Google Scholar
- 3.Heller A (1979) Impact of Davis v. Watkins on Ohio forensic hospital practice. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 7: 39–62Google Scholar
- 4.Rodenhauser P, Heller A (to be published) Management of forensic patients who refuse treatment — two scenarios. J Forensic SciGoogle Scholar
- 6.Appelbaum PS, Gutheil TG (1980) Drug refusal: a study of psychiatric inpatients. Am J Psychiatry 137: 340–346Google Scholar
- 8.Monahan J (1982) Clinical prediction of violent behavior. Psychiatric Ann 12: 509–513Google Scholar
- 9.Rofman ES, Askinazi C, Fant E (1980) The prediction of dangerous behavior in emergency civil commitment. Am J Psychiatry 137:1061–1064Google Scholar
- 10.Wilkerson CD, O’Connor WA (1982) Human ecology and mental illness. Am J Psychiatry 139: 985–990Google Scholar
- 11.Zusman J (1979) Against the right to refuse treatment. Adv Now 5:12–16Google Scholar
- 13.Appelbaum PS, Roth LH (1981) Clinical issues in the assessment of competency. Am J Psychiatry 138:1462–1467Google Scholar
- 14.Roth LH, Meisel A, Lidz CW (1977) Tests of competency to consent to treatment. Am J Psychiatry 134: 279–284Google Scholar
- 15.Gutheil TG, Shapiro R, St Clair RL (1980) Legal guardianship in drug refusal: an illusory solution. Am J Psychiatry 137: 347–352Google Scholar
- 16.Appelbaum PS (1982) Limitations on guardianship of the mentally disabled. Law and Psychiatry 33:183–184Google Scholar
- 17.Bryne G (1981) Conference report: refusing treatment in mental health institutions: values in conflict. Hosp Community Psychiatry 12: 255–258Google Scholar