Differential Diagnosis: Depression Versus Dementia

  • J. R. M. Copeland
  • M. E. Dewey
Part of the Advances in Applied Neurological Sciences book series (NEUROLOGICAL, volume 2)

Abstract

Post (1951) and Roth and Morrisey (1952) drew attention to the importance of distinguishing between depressive illness and dementia in hospital samples of elderly persons aged over 65. They pointed to the difficulty of making the distinction and its important prognostic implications. Kramer (1961) had reported differences between the diagnostic frequencies for first admissions of the elderly to US state hospitals and Area mental hospitals in England and Wales. Organic disorders appeared to be almost twice as frequent among US admissions than UK admissions, in contrast to functional disorders, which comprised only about one-sixth of the proportion entering the UK hospitals. Kramer was concerned that numbers of functional disorders, particularly depression, were being diagnosed as organic disorders in American hospitals. The available statistics also showed that patients admitted to US hospitals were twice as likely to die in the hospital within 1 year of admission than those admitted to British hospitals, while British elderly patients appeard three times more likely than their US counterparts to be discharged within 1 year.

Keywords

Depression Dementia Tate 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. American Psychiatric Association (1980) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM III ) 3rd edn. American Psychiatric Association, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  2. Copeland JRM (1981) What is a case, a case for what? In: Wing JK, Bebbington P, Robbins LN (eds) What is a case, the problems of definition in psychiatric community surveys. Grant McIntyre, LondonGoogle Scholar
  3. Copeland JRM, Kelleher MJ, Kellett JM, Gourlay AJ, Barron G, Cowan DW, De Gruchy J, Gurland BJ, Sharpe L, Simon R, Kuriansky J, Stiller P (1975) Cross-national study of diagnosis of the mental disorders: a comparison of the diagnosis of elderly psychiatric patients admitted to mental hospitals serving Queens County in New York and the Old Borough of Camberwell, London. Br J Psychiatry 126: 11–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Copeland JRM, Kelleher MJ, Kellett JM, Gourlay AJ, Gurland BJ, Fleiss JL, Sharpe L (1976) A semistructured clinical interview for the assessment of diagnosis and mental state in the elderly. The Geriatric Mental State Schedule 1. Development and reliability. Psychol Med 6: 439–449Google Scholar
  5. Copeland JRM, Dewey ME, Griffiths-Jones H (to be published) The development and preliminary assessment of a computerised psychiatric diagnostic system for elderly subjects: GMS and AGECATGoogle Scholar
  6. Gurland BJ, Fleiss JL, Goldberg K, Sharpe L, Copeland JRM, Kelleher MJ, Kellett JM (1976) A semistructured clinical interview for the assessment of diagnosis and mental state in the elderly. The Geriatric Mental State Schedule 2. A factor analysis. Psychol Med 6: 451–459Google Scholar
  7. Gurland BJ, Kuriansky JB, Sharpe L, Simon RJ, Stiller PR, Fleiss JL (US) with Copeland JRM, Kelleher MJ, Gourlay Ai, Cowan DW, Barron G (UK) (1976) A comparison of the outcome of hospitalisation of geriatric patients in public psychiatric words in New York and London. Can Psychiatr Assoc J 21: 421–431Google Scholar
  8. Gurland BJ, Cross P, Defiguerido J, Shannon M, Mann AM, Jenkin R, Bennett R, Wilder D, Wright H, Killeffer E, Godlove C (1979) A cross-national comparison of the institutionalized elderly in the cities of New York and London. Psychol Med 9: 781–788PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Gurland BJ, Copeland JRM, Kelleher MJ, Kuriansky J, Sharpe L, Dean L (1983) The mind and mood of ageing: the mental health problems of the community elderly in New York and London. Haworth, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  10. Kramer M (1961) Some problems for international research suggested by observations on differ-ence in first admission rates to the mental hospitals of England, Wales and the United States.In: Proceedings of the Third World Congress of Psychiatry, vol 3. Montreal, pp 153–160Google Scholar
  11. Post F (1951) The outcome of mental breakdown in old age. Br Med J 1: 436–448PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Roth M, Morrissey JD (1952) Problems in the diagnosis and classification of mental disorders in old age. J Ment Sci 98: 66–80PubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Spitzer RL, Endicott J, Fleiss JL, Cohen J (1970) Psychiatric status schedule: a technique for evaluating psychopathology and impairment in role functioning. Arch Gen Psychiatr 23: 4155Google Scholar
  14. Wing JK, Cooper JE, Sartorios N (1974) The description and classification of psychiatric symptoms: an instruction manual for the PSE and Catego System. Cambridge University Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  15. World Health Organization (1978) Mental disorders: glossary and guide to their classification in accordance with the Ninth Revision of the International Classification of Disorders. WHO, GenevaGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1985

Authors and Affiliations

  • J. R. M. Copeland
  • M. E. Dewey
    • 1
  1. 1.University Department of Psychiatry Royal Liverpool HospitalLiverpoolUK

Personalised recommendations