Deep-Sea Mining versus Land-Based Mining: A Cost Comparison

  • Rolf Dick

Abstract

During a Pacific voyage of the British Research Vessel “HMS Challenger” in 1876, nodular polymetallic structures containing large amounts of manganese were discovered on the ocean floor. One hundred years later, the planned mining of these manganese nodules became the central topic of debate at the Third UN Law of the Sea Conference. The main points at issue at this conference were the conditions under which deep-sea mining can be carried out1, the organization of the seabed supervisory authorities, the production quotas, the transfer of technology, and the taxation of deep-sea mining2.

Keywords

Cobalt Steam Transportation Diesel Sulfuric Acid 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. AMR (Association for the Extraction of Submarine Mineral Resources) Summary of Project Data for a 3 Mio DMT Nodule per Year Project, Four Metal Case, unpublished manuscript, Frankfurt, 1979.Google Scholar
  2. Andrew, Benjamin V., Relative Costs of U.S. and Foreign Nodule Transport Ships, 1978.Google Scholar
  3. Barons, “Mining the Deep”, Sept. 13, 1971.Google Scholar
  4. BGR, DIW (Bundesanstalt für Geowissenschaften und Rohstoffe, Hannover, und Deutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung, Berlin) Nickel — Analyses of the Supply and Demand of Mineral Raw Materials, Stuttgart 1978.Google Scholar
  5. Black, John Roland Howard, The Recovery of Metals from Deepsea Manganese Nodules and the Effects on the World Cobalt and Manganese Markets, Massachusetts 1980.Google Scholar
  6. Boin, Udo, The Limits and Possibilities of Ocean Mining as a Source of Mineral Raw Materials, Taking Manganese Nodules as the Example, in: Erzmetall Bd 32 (1979) H. 5, pp. 237 – 240.Google Scholar
  7. Boin, Law of the Sea Convention Hampers Free Competition in the Investment Sector, in: Handelsblatt 9.6.1980.Google Scholar
  8. Brooks, David B., “Deepsea Manganese Nodules: From Scientific Phenomenon to World Resources”, Natural Resources Journal, July 1968, pp. 401 – 423.Google Scholar
  9. Chaziteodorou, Georg, Fundamentals of Oceanic Mining — A Contribution to the Extraction and Handling of Solid Mineral Resources from the Sea, Stuttgart 1976/77.Google Scholar
  10. Clauss, G., Theoretical and Experimental Investigations of Deep Sea Ocean Mining Systems and Their Economic Evaluation, Paper presented at the Second International Ocean Development Conference, Tokyo, October 1972, pp. 1925 – 1955. As reported in United Nations “Economic Implications of Seabed Mineral Development in the International Area: Report of the Secretary General, A/Conf. 62/25 (22 May 1974) p. 67.Google Scholar
  11. Dasher, John, The Energy Picture in Nickel Production, in: Mining Magazine, May 1976, p. 389.Google Scholar
  12. Dasher, John, Deep Ocean and Offshore Mining, Mining Engineering, April 1975.Google Scholar
  13. Delach, M., B. Horn, and D. Horn, “Ocean Manganese Nodules: Metal Values and Mining Sites”, Technical Report No. 4, National Science Foundation, Washington D.C., 1973.Google Scholar
  14. Diederich, F., et al., Analysis of the MIT Study on Deep Ocean Mining — Critical Remarks on Technologies and Cost Estimates, Aachen/-Frankfurt 1979Google Scholar
  15. Dorstewitz, G., Ocean Mining of Cobalt, Copper, Manganese and Nickel, Essen 1971.Google Scholar
  16. Drechsler, Herbert David, A Study in Industrial Organization: The Potential Seabed Nodule Mining Industry, Columbia 1972.Google Scholar
  17. Dubs, M.A., J.E. Flipse and R.J. Greenwald, “Pre Production Manganese Nodule Mining Activities and Requirements”, in: U.S. Congress, Senate Subcommittee on Minerals, Materials and Fuels, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Mineral Resources of the Deep Seabed, 93 d. Cong. 1st. sess. May-June 1973, pp. 602 – 709.Google Scholar
  18. Ensign, C.O., “Economic Barriers Delay Underseas”, Mining Engineering 18 (1966) No. 9, pp. 59 – 62/73.Google Scholar
  19. Evans, D.J.I., R.S. Shoemaker, M. Veltman, (Editors) International Laterite Symposium, New York 1979.Google Scholar
  20. Gallagher, John T., Efficient Estimating of Worldwide Plant Costs, in: Chemical Engineering, June 2, 1969, pp. 196 – 202.Google Scholar
  21. Guthrie, K.M., Data and Techniques for Preliminary…: Capital Cost Estimating, in: Chemical Engineering, March 24, 1969, pp. 114 – 142.Google Scholar
  22. Hess, M.D., The Ocean: Mining’s Newest Frontier, Energy Mining Journal 166, 1965, No. 8, pp. 79 – 96.Google Scholar
  23. Hilmy, Joseph, “Old Nick”, An Anatomy of the Nickel Industry and its Future, Commodity Note No. 13, World Bank, Washington, September 1979.Google Scholar
  24. Jenisch, Uwe, Coming up to the 10th Session of the Law of the Sea Conference, in: Außenpolitik, Zeitschrift für internationale Fragen, 32. Jgg. H. 1/81, Hamburg 1982.Google Scholar
  25. Johnson, Robert J., Costs of Overseas Plants, in: Chemical Engineering, March 10, 1969, pp. 146 – 152.Google Scholar
  26. Kamphausen, Dieter, Deep-sea Mining of Mineral Raw Materials and Structural Changes in Land-based Mining Operations in Developing Countries, in: DIW, Vierteljahresheft 3, 1978.Google Scholar
  27. Kaufmann, Raymond, Arnold J.Rothstein, Deep-Sea Ventures Inc., “The Approaching Maturity of Deep Ocean Mining — The Pace Quickens”, in: U.S. Congress, Senate, Subcommittee on Minerals, Materials and Fuels; Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Mineral Resources of the Deep Seabed, 93. d.Cong. 1st sess. May — June 1973, pp. 201 – 222.Google Scholar
  28. Kaufmann, “Recent Developments in Deep Ocean Mining”, Marine Technol. (1970) pp. 935 – 962.Google Scholar
  29. Kaufmann, Alwin, “The Economics of Ocean Mining”, Marine Technological Society Journal, July — August 1970, pp. 58 – 65.Google Scholar
  30. Kennecott Copper Corporation, Comparative Economics of Recovery of Metals from Ocean Nodules, 1976.Google Scholar
  31. Kohn, Philip M.,CE Cost Indexes Maintain 13-Year Ascent. In: Chemical Engineering, May 8, 1978, pp. 189 – 190.Google Scholar
  32. Langer, Ernst, Ferronickel Production at Morro do Niquel, Minas Gerais, Brazil, in: Evans D.J.I., Shoemaker R.S., Veltman M. (ed.) International Laterite Symposium, pp. 397 – 411.Google Scholar
  33. Leipziger, Danny M., James L. Mudge, Seabed Mineral Resources and the Economic Interests of Developing Countries, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1976, Chapter 6.Google Scholar
  34. Little, Arthur D., Inc., Technological and Economic Assessment of Manganese Nodule Mining and Processing, Cambridge, Massachusetts, November 1977;Google Scholar
  35. Little, Arthur D., Inc., Technological and Economic Assessment of Manganese Nodule Mining and Processing, Cambridge, Massachusetts, revised version, November 1979.Google Scholar
  36. Masuda, Yoshio, The Continuous Line Bucket (CLB) System Used in Deep-sea Mining. A Comparison of this Recovery System with Other Extraction Methods. Heft 1/2, Jan./Febr. 1975.Google Scholar
  37. Mero, John L., The Mineral Resources of the Sea, New York 1965.Google Scholar
  38. Mero, John L., “Seafloor Minerals”, Chemical Engrs. 1968 Nr. 7, pp. 60–81.Google Scholar
  39. Mohide, T.P., J.D. Mason, C.L. Warden, Towards a Nickel Policy for the Province of Ontario, Mineral Policy Background Paper No. 4, Ontario 1977.Google Scholar
  40. Moncrieff, A., Smale-Adams, The Economies of First Generation Manganese Nodule Operations, Philadelphia: American Mining Congress, October 1974.Google Scholar
  41. Müller-Ohlsen, Lotte, Die Weltmetallwirtschaft im industriellen Ent-wicklungsprozeß. (Kieler Studie 165), Tübingen 1981.Google Scholar
  42. Norden, Robert B., CE Cost Indexes: A Sharp Rise Since 1965, In: Chemical Engineering May 5, 1969, pp. 134 – 138.Google Scholar
  43. Nyhart, J.D. u.a., A Cost Model of Deep Ocean Mining and Associated Regulatory Issues, Massachusetts 1978.Google Scholar
  44. Pasho, D.W., Ocean Mining Status of Technology, Ottawa 1979.Google Scholar
  45. Pearson, John S., Ocean Floor Mining, Park Ridge, New Jersey, London 1975.Google Scholar
  46. Prewo, Wilfried, Deep-sea Mining: Gold Mine, White Elephant or Trojan Horse? In: Die Weltwirtschaft, 1979, H. 1, Tübingen 1979, pp. 183 – 197.Google Scholar
  47. Sorenson, Philip E. and Walter J. Mead, A Cost — Benefit Analysis of Ocean Mineral Resource Development: The Case of Manganese Nodules In: American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Dec. 1968.Google Scholar
  48. Spangler, M.B., “The National Interest — A Care Study of Cupro-Nickel Nodules of the Deep Sea”, Marine Technol. 2 (1970) p. 341.Google Scholar
  49. Statham, Bo, Deep Seabed Mining, In: INCO Triangle, Toronto, Dec. 1980.Google Scholar
  50. Vitzthum, Wolfgang Graf, Die Bemühungen um ein Regime des Tiefseebodens. Das Schicksal einer Idee. In: Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht, Stuttgart, Bd. 38 (1978), Nr. 3–4, pp. 745–800.Google Scholar
  51. Wright, R.L., Ocean Mining: An Economic Evaluation, professional staff study, Ocean Min. Adm., Dept. Int. Mag. 1976, In: Deep Seabed Mining “Hearings” Sub-Comm. on Oceanography of the Comm. on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, House of Rep., 95th Cong., 1st sess. on H.R. 3350 and H.R. 4582, H.R. 4922, H.R. 5624, H.R. 6846 and H.R. 6784 (Wash. D.C. GPO, 1977).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1985

Authors and Affiliations

  • Rolf Dick

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations