Abstract
The present paper is concerned with Frank H. Knight (1885–1972) and his attitude towards the historical school of economics1. It is argued that Knight paid attention to the historical school during his whole life and struggled to develop his own historical framework. The paper falls into five sections. Following this overview the second section recalls the conventional view that there is no real relation between Knight and the historical school; Knight is introduced as a stranger to the historical school. In contrast to this textbook version the following passages analyze Knight’s way of thinking in three steps. His extensive commentaries on the historical school and their protagonists are discussed in the third section. Focusing on Knight as a promoter of Max Weber, the fourth section examines Knight’s role in the dissemination of German social thought into the Anglo-American context. Moreover, Weber is identified as a crucial influence on Knight. Comparing his notion of ideal competition with Weberian ideas it is shown how close his critical stand on the ethical consequences of ideal competition is to the dominant figure of the younger historical school. The fifth section aims at a reconstruction of a historical dimension in Knight’s economic methodology. The final conclusion reflects on the gap between Knight as a stranger to the historical school and his efforts to develop a historical framework of his own. It tries to understand the obvious tensions in Knight’s work from different angles and considers why Knight finally remained reluctant to convert to the historical school.
Special thanks to Ross B. Emmett and Stephen A. Marglin for extensive discussions of and comments on earlier drafts. Thanks also to Klaus Rathe, the participants at the Political Economy Seminar at Harvard University and the Kress Seminar on the History of Economic Thought. This article is based upon work supported by the Schweizerischer Nationalfonds.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Buchanan, J. M.: “Methods and Morals in Economics: The Ayres-Knight Discussion”, in: W. Breit, W. P. Culbertson (Eds.): Science and Ceremony: The Institutional Economics of C. E. Ayres, Austin (University of Texas Press) 1976, pp. 164–174.
Degregori, T. R.: “Ethics and Economic Inquiry: The Ayres-Knight Debate and the Problem of Economic Order”, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, (1977), pp. 41-50.
Eidenmüller, I.: “Discussion Summary”, in: P. Koslowski (Ed.): The Theory of Ethical Economy in the Historical School, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York (Springer) 1995, pp. 104–105.
Eisermann, G.: Max Weber und die Nationalökonomie, Marburg (Metropolis) 1993.
Emmett, R. B.: “Frank H. Knight”, in: J. Davis, W. Hands and U. Mäki: Handbook of Economic Methodology, Aldershot (E. Elgar) (forthcoming).
Erdelyi, A.: Max Weber in Amerika: Wirkungsgeschichte und Rezeptionsgeschichte Webers in der anglo-amerikanischen Philosophie und Sozialwissenschaft, Wien (Edition Passagen) 1992.
Knight, F. H.: Risk, Uncertainty and Profit, Reprints of Economic Classics, New York (A. M. Kelley) 1964. Original: Boston and New York (Houghton Mifflin) 1921. (Quoted as Knight [1921] and Knight [1933]).
Knight, F. H.: “Ethics and the Economic Interpretation”, in: F. H. Knight: The Ethics of Competition and Other Essays, Essays selected by Milton Friedman, Homer Jones, George Stigler, and Allen Wallis, New York, London (Harper & Brothers) 1935, pp. 19–40. Quoted as (Knight [1922]).
Knight, F. H.: “The Ethics of Competition”, in: F. H. Knight: The Ethics of Competition and Other Essays, Essays selected by Milton Friedman, Homer Jones, George Stigler, and Allen Wallis, New York, London (Harper & Brothers) 1935, pp. 41–75. Quoted as (Knight [1923]).
Knight, F. H., “Translator’s Preface”, in: M. Weber: General Economic History, translated by Frank H. Knight, London (George Allen & Unwin) 1927, pp. xvxvi.
Knight, F. H.: “Historical and Theoretical Issues in the Problem of Modern Capitalism”, in: F. H. Knight: On the History and Method of Economics: Selected Essays, Essays selected by William L. Letwin and Alexander J. Morin, Chicago (University of Chicago Press) 1956, pp. 89–103. Quoted as (Knight [1928]).
Knight, F. H.: “Das Wertproblem in der Wirtschaftstheorie”, in: H. Mayer (Ed.): Die Wirtschaftstheorie der Gegenwart, Zweiter Band: Wert, Preis, Produktion, Geld und Kredit, Wien (Julius Springer) 1932, pp. 52-72.
Knight, F. H.: “Economic Theory and Nationalism”, in: F. H. Knight: The Ethics of Competition and Other Essays, Essays selected by Milton Friedman, Homer Jones, George Stigler, and Allen Wallis, New York, London (Harper & Brothers) 1935, pp. 277–359.
Knight, F.H: “Anthropology and Economics”, Journal of Political Economy, 49 (1941), pp. 247–268.
Knight, F. H.: “Social Science”, Ethics 51 (1941), pp. 127–143. (Quoted as (Knight [1941a]).
Knight, F. H.: “Some Notes on the Economic Interpretation of History”, in: American Council of Learned Societies (Ed.): Studies in the History of Culture: The Disciplines of the Humanities, Menasha (Wisconsin) (George Banta Publishing) 1942, pp. 217–231.
Knight F. H.: “Introduction”, in: C. Menger: Principles of Economics: First General Part, translated and edited by James Dingwall and Bert F. Hoselitz, Glencoe (Illinois) (Free Press) 1950, pp. 9–35.
Knight, F. H.: “Economics”, in: W. Yust (Ed.): Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol. 7, Chicago, London, Toronto (University of Chicago Press) 1959, pp. 925–934. (Quoted as (Knight [1951a]).
Knight F. H.: “The Role of Principles in Economics and Politics”, in: F. H. Knight: On the History and Method of Economics: Selected Essays, Essays selected by William L. Letwin and Alexander J. Morin, Chicago (University of Chicago Press) 1956, pp. 251–281. (Quoted as (Knight [1951])
Knight, F. H.: “Economic Freedom and Social Responsibility: An Essay in Economics and Ethics”, Studies in Business and Economics, School of Business Administration, Emory University, No. 7, Atlanta (Georgia) 1952.
Knight, F. H.: “Theory of Economic Policy and the History of Doctrine”, Ethics, 63 (1953), pp. 276–292.
Knight, F. H.: “Structure and Operation of the Economic Order”, University of Arizona Bulletin, The Kennecott Lecture Series No. 27, April, Tuscon (University of Arizona Press) 1956, pp. 31–68.
Knight, F. H.: “Economic History”, in: P. P. Wiener (Ed.): Dictionary of the History of Ideas, Vol. II, New York (Scribner) 1973, pp. 44–61.
Raines, J. P., Jung, C. R.: “Schumpeter and Knight on Economic and Political Rationality: A Comparative Restatement”, Journal of Socio-Economics, 21 (1992), pp. 109–124.
Robbins, L. C: An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science, London (Macmillan) 1932.
Robbins, L. C: The Theory of Economic Policy in English Classical Political Economy, London (Macmillan) 1952.
Samuels, W. I: “The Knight-Ayres Correspondence: The Grounds of Knowledge and Social Action”, Journal of Economic Issues, 11 (1977), pp. 485–525.
Schweikhardt, D. B.: “The Role of Values in Economic Theory and Policy: A Comparison of Frank Knight and John R. Commons”, Journal of Economic Issues, 22 (1988), pp. 407–414.
Schweitzer, A.: “Frank Knight’s Social Economics”, History of Political Economy, 7 (1975), pp. 279–292.
Shils, E.: “Some Academics, Mainly in Chicago”, American Scholar, 50 (1981), pp. 179–196.
Stigler, G. J.: “Industrial Organization and Economic Progress”, in: L.D. White (Ed.): The State of the Social Science, Chicago (University of Chicago Press) 1956, pp. 269–282.
Tilman, R.: Thorstein Veblen and His Critics, Princeton (Princeton University Press) 1992.
Weber, M.: The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, translated by Talcott Parsons, New York (Scribner) 1930. Original: “Die Protestantische Ethik und der ‘Geist’ des Kapitalismus”, Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik, 20/21 (1904–1905), pp. 1-54 and 1-110. Quoted as (Weber [1904–1905]).
Weber, M.: Economy and Society, edited by Guenther Roth and Claus Wittich, New York (Bedminster) 1968. Original: Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft Tübingen (J.C.B. Mohr) 1922. Quoted as (Weber [1922]).
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1997 Springer-Verlag Berlin · Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Noppeney, C. (1997). Frank Knight and the Historical School. In: Koslowski, P. (eds) Methodology of the Social Sciences, Ethics, and Economics in the Newer Historical School. Studies in Economic Ethics and Philosophy. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-59095-5_13
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-59095-5_13
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-63849-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-59095-5
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive