Advertisement

The Analytic Hierarchy Process and Systems Thinking: A Response to Petkov & Mihova-Petkova

  • Denis Edgar-Nevill
  • Michael Jackson
Chapter
Part of the Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems book series (LNE, volume 465)

Abstract

Petkov and Mihova-petkova in their paper “The Analytic Hierarchy Process and Systems Thinking” make a well argued case for the addition of AHP to rthe methods and tools in Systems Thinking. The Claim is made that AHP is capable of dealing with Complexity and pluralism. In this paper the authors consider the argument put forward and raise concerns about the effectiveness of AHP in this regard. These centre around the particular Characteristics of complexity in social systems and the ability of AHP to allow each subjective viewpoint to be fully represented. It is argued that AHP can only reveal it’s full potential when used alongside other systems approaches which do pay more attention to these matters. On the basis of this argument the case for pluralism in Systems Thinking is made with AHP an important element in this Pluralism.

Keywords

AHP Systems Thinking Complexity Pluralism 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. G. Booch (1991): Object Oriented Design with Applications, The Benjamine/Cummings Publishing Company Inc.Google Scholar
  2. P. Checkland and J. Scholes (1991): Soft Systems Methodology in Action, WileyGoogle Scholar
  3. Edwards A (1957): Techniques of Attitude Scale Construction, Appleton- Century-Cofts Ine, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. M. Jackson (1991): Systems Methodologies for the Management Sciences, Plenum Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. M. Jackson (1994): Critical Systems thinking: Beyond the Fragments, Systems Dynamics review, 10, No 2–3, 213–229CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. B. Kosko (1994): Fuzzy Thinking – The New Science of Fuzzy Logic, Harper Collins PublishersGoogle Scholar
  7. D. Petkov and O. Mihova-Petkova (1996): The Analytic Hierarchy Process & Systems Thinking, 13th Conference on MCDM, Cape Town, South Africa, January 1997Google Scholar
  8. T. Saaty and J. Alexander (1989): Conflict Resolution: The Analytic Hierarchy Process, PraegerGoogle Scholar
  9. T. Saaty (1992): Multicriteria Decision Making – The Analytic Hierarchy Process, 2nd ed. RWS Publications, PittsburghGoogle Scholar
  10. T. Saaty (1994): How to Make a Decision: The Analytic Hierarchy Process, Interfaces, Vol 24, No 6, 19–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1998

Authors and Affiliations

  • Denis Edgar-Nevill
    • 1
  • Michael Jackson
    • 1
  1. 1.Lincoln School of ManagementLincoln University CampusLincolnUK

Personalised recommendations