The experiment of “one country, two systems” has been practiced in Hong Kong for almost 10 years. “One country, two systems” in Hong Kong can be considered a case study of autonomy in comparative constitutional law and politics. It is hoped that the study of Hong Kong's experience in this regard may contribute to general theories of autonomy as well as to other possible models of autonomy in China in future, particularly with regard to the issue of Taiwan. In this paper, we will (in part I) first review some general theoretical considerations relevant to the study of autonomy as a constitutional and political arrangement. We will then (in part II) consider the case of Hong Kong, including the historical origins of Hong Kong's autonomy under the conceptual framework of “one country, two systems”, the constitutional design of such autonomy, its general practice since 1997, and the possible strengths and weaknesses of this model of autonomy. We will then (in part III) explore the question of governance and democracy in Hong Kong as a possible test of Hong Kong's autonomy under Chinese rule. The article will (in part IV) conclude with some reflections regarding the “one country, two systems” model of autonomy as practiced in Hong Kong in the last 10 years.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allcock R (2000) Application of Article 158 of the Basic Law. Paper presented at Constitutional law conference on implementation of the Basic Law: a comparative perspective, Faculty of Law, University of Hong Kong and the Department of Justice, HKSAR. Hong Kong, 28–29 April 2000
Bonavia D (1983) Hong Kong 1999. South China Morning Post, Hong Kong
Chan MK (ed.) (1997) The challenge of Hong Kong's reintegration with China. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Chan MK, Clark DJ (eds.) (1991) The Hong Kong Basic Law: blueprint for “stability and prosperity” under Chinese sovereignty? Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Chan MK, Postiglione GA (eds.) (1996) The Hong Kong reader: passage to Chinese sovereignty. Armonk, New York
Chen AHY (1989) From colony to Special Administrative Region: Hong Kong's constitutional journey. In: Wacks R (ed.) The future of the law in Hong Kong. Oxford University Press, Hong Kong
Chen AHY (1994) Some reflections on Hong Kong's autonomy. Hong Kong Law J 24:173
Chen AHY (1997a) The provisional legislative council of the SAR. Hong Kong Law J 27(1):9–10
Chen AHY (1997b) Legal preparation for the establishment of the Hong Kong SAR: chronology and selected documents. Hong Kong Law J 27:405
Chen A (1999) Constitutional crisis in Hong Kong: congressional supremacy and judicial review. The International Lawyer 33:1025
Chen AHY (2008) A new era in Hong Kong's constitutional history. Hong Kong Law J 38:1
Chiu H et al (eds.) (1987) The future of Hong Kong: toward 1997 and beyond. Quorum Books, New York
Chow LCH, Fan YK (eds.) (1999) The other Hong Kong report 1998. Chinese University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong
Ghai Y (1995a) Hong Kong and Macau in transition (I): debating democracy. Democratization 2:270
Ghai Y (1995b) Hong Kong and Macau in transition (II): exploring the new political order. Democratization 2:291
Ghai Y (1999) Hong Kong's new constitutional order: the resumption of Chinese sovereignty and the Basic Law, 2nd edn. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Ghai Y (2000) The Basic Law of the Special Administrative Region of Macau: some reflections. Int Comp Law Q 49:183
Hannum H (1990) Autonomy, sovereignty and self-determination. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia
Huang Yi (1990) Xianggang Wenti He Yiguo Liangzhi (The question of Hong Kong and “one country, two systems”). Dadi Chubanshe, Beijing
Jao YC et al (eds.) (1985) Hong Kong and 1997: strategies for the future. Centre of Asian Studies, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
King AYC (1995) “One country, two systems”: an idea on trial. In: Gungwu W, Siu-lun W (eds.) Hong Kong's transition: a decade after the deal. Oxford University Press, Hong Kong
Kuan H-C et al. (1996) The 1995 legislative council elections in Hong Kong. The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Kuan H-C et al. (eds.) (1999) Power transfer and electoral politics: the first legislative election in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Leung B, Cheng J (eds.) (1997) Hong Kong SAR: in pursuit of domestic and international order. Chinese University Press, Hong Kong
Liaowang zhoukan haiwaiban bianjibu (eds.) (1988) “Yiguo Liangzhi” Yu Zuguo Tongyi (“One country, two systems” and China's reunification). Editorial department of the overseas edition of Liangwang weekly
Ling B (1999) Can Hong Kong courts review and nullify acts of the National People's Congress? Hong Kong Law J 29:8
Lo S-H (1995a) Comparative political systems: the cases of Hong Kong and Macau. J Contemp Asia 25:254
Lo S-H (1995b) Political development in Macau. Chinese University Press, Hong Kong
Lo S-H (1997) The politics of democratization in Hong Kong. Macmillan, London
Lynch K (1999) The temptation to intervene: problems created by government intervention in the Hong Kong stock market. Hong Kong Law J 29:123
Ma Y-J (1993) Policy towards the Chinese mainland: Taipei's view. In Tsang S (ed.) In the shadow of China: political developments in Taiwan since 1949. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Mushkat R (1997) One country, two international legal personalities: the case of Hong Kong. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Patrikeeff F (1989) Mouldering pearl: Hong Kong at the crossroads. George Philip, London
Postiglione GA, Tang JTH (eds.) (1997) Hong Kong's reunion with China: global dimensions. Armonk, New York
Tai BY (1999) The development of constitutionalism in Hong Kong. In: Wacks R (ed.) The new legal order in Hong Kong. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Wacks R (1993) One country, two Grundnormen? The Basic Law and the Basic Norm. In: Wacks R (ed.) Hong Kong, China and 1997: Essays in legal theory. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong
Wang S (ed.) (1997) Xianggang Tebiexingzhengqu Jibenfa Daolun (An introduction to the Basic Law of the HKSAR). Zhonggong Zhongyang Dangxiao Chubanshe, Beijing
Wang G, Wong J (eds.) (1999) Hong Kong in China: the challenges of transition. Times Academic, Singapore
Weng BSJ (1988) The Hong Kong model of “one country, two systems”: promises and problems. In: Wesley-Smith P, Chen A (eds.) The Basic Law and Hong Kong's future. Butterworth, London
Wesley-Smith P, Chen A (eds.) (1988) The Basic Law and Hong Kong's future. Butterworth, London
Wu H-H (1994), Bridging the strait: Taiwan, China, and the prospects for reunification. Oxford University Press, New York
Xiao W (ed.) (1990) Yiguo Liangzhi Yu Xianggang Tebiexingzhengqu Jibenfa (“One country, two systems” and the Basic Law of the HKSAR). Cultural and Educational Publications, Hong Kong
Xu Chongde (ed.) (1999) Xianfa (Constitutional law). Zhongguo zhengfa daxue chubanshe, Beijing
Yang J (1999) Aomen Jibenfa Shiyi (Commentary on the Basic Law of Macau). People's Press, Beijing
Yang J, Li X (1997) Gangao Jibenfa Bijiao Yanjiu (A comparative study of the Basic Laws of Hong Kong and Macau). Peking University Press, Beijing
Yee HS, Lo SH (1991) Macau in transition: politics of decolonisation. Asian Surv 31:905
Zhao C (ed.) (1988) Yiguo Liangzhi Gailun (General princiles of “one country, two systems”). Jilin Daxue Chubanshe, Jilin
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2009 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Chen, A.H.Y. (2009). The Theory, Constitution and Practice of Autonomy: The Case of Hong Kong. In: Oliveira, J.C., Cardinal, P. (eds) One Country, Two Systems, Three Legal Orders - Perspectives of Evolution. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-68572-2_47
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-68572-2_47
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-68571-5
Online ISBN: 978-3-540-68572-2
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawLaw and Criminology (R0)