Abstract
Frogs is a comedy which we can enjoy for its own sake, but it is also a document from which we can infer Athenian attitudes to tragedy. But when we speak of ‘Athenian’ attitudes, we are bringing together under a single rubric the ordinary member of the audience, the connoisseurs of poetry, the established conventional standpoint of comedy, the views of Aristophanes himself as an individual, and possibly also an intellectual treatment of tragedy which could reasonably be called ‘sophistic’. The general tendency in our own time has been to elevate the intellectual element. Pohlenz1 went so far as to suggest that a treatise by Gorgias, comparing Aeschylus and Euripides, was a source exploited by Aristophanes for the contest in Frogs. Radermacher, Denniston and Taillardat2, drawing attention to coincidences between terms used by Aristophanes in the criticism of poetry and those used by later literary critics, postulated a ‘technical’ language of criticism which took shape before the end of the fifth century B.C. and endured thereafter3. I would argue that the concept ‘technical’ has been used with insufficient rigour, and that the contribution of the sophists has been overrated. The sources of the terms in which Aristophanes presents the contest are much more varied than has commonly been allowed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Bibliography
Classen C. J. 1976. The Study of Language amongst Socrates’ Contemporaries. Wege der Forschung 187, 215–247. Darmstadt.
Clayman D. L. 1977. The Origin of Greek Literary Criticism and the Aitia Prologue. WSt. N.F. 11, 27–34.
Denniston J. D. 1927. Technical Terms in Aristophanes. CQ 21, 113–121.
Fehling D. 1965. Zwei Untersuchungen zur griechischen Sprachtheorie. RhM 108, 212–229.
Geizer T. 1971. Aristophanes der Komiker (= RE Supplement-Band 11, 1391–1570).
Harriott R. 1962. Aristophanes and the Plays of Euripides. BICS 9,1–8.
Harriott R. 1969. Poetry and Criticism before Plato. London.
Lanata G. 1963. Poetica Pre-Platonica. Firenze.
Lloyd-Jones H. 1990a. Greek Epic, Lyric and Tragedy. Oxford.
Lloyd-Jones H. 1990b. Greek Comedy, Hellenistic Literature, Greek Religion and Miscellanea. Oxford.
Meineke A. 1839. Historia Critica Comicorum Graecorum. Berlin.
Newiger H.-J. 1957. Metapher und Allegorie. Studien zu Aristophanes. München.
Pfeiffer R. 1968: History of Classical Scholarship from the Beginnings to the End of the Hellenistic Age. Oxford.
Pohlenz M. 1920. Die Anfänge der griechischen Poetik. NGG Phil.-hist. KL, 142–178.
Radermacher L. 1954. Aristophanes’ Frösche. Einleitung, Text und Kommentar, with revisions and an appendix by W. Kraus. SAWW 198 no. 4.
Römer A. 1905. Über den litterarischaesthetischen Bildungsstand des attischen Theaterpublikums. ABAW Phil.-hist. Kl. 22, 1–95.
Segal C. 1970. Protagoras’ Orthoepeia and Aristophanes’ Battle of the Prologues. RhM 103, 158–162.
Sicking C. J. 1962. Aristophanes’ Ranae. Een Hoofdstuk uit de Geschiedenis der Griekse Poetica. Assen.
Sommerstein A. H. 1986. The Decree of Syrakosios. CQ N.S. 36, 101–8.
Stevens P. T. 1956. Euripides and the Athenians. JHS 76, 87–94.
Stohn G. 1955. Spuren der voraristotelischen Poetik in der altattischen Komödie. Diss. Berlin.
Taillardat J. 1965. Les Images d’Aristophane. Etudes de langue et de style. 2nd ed. Paris.
Tsirimbas N. 1936. Die Stellung der Sophistik zur Poesie im fünften und vierten Jahrhundert bis zu Isokrates. München.
Walcot P. 1971. Aristophanic and Other Audiences. G&R 18, 35–50.
Wimmel W. 1960. Kallimachos in Rom (=Hermes Einzelschr. 16). Wiesbaden.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1992 Springer-Verlag GmbH Deutschland
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Dover, K.J. (1992). The Language of Criticism in Aristophanes’ Frogs. In: Zimmermann, B. (eds) Antike Dramentheorien und ihre Rezeption. J.B. Metzler, Stuttgart. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-476-04180-7_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-476-04180-7_1
Publisher Name: J.B. Metzler, Stuttgart
Print ISBN: 978-3-476-45022-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-476-04180-7
eBook Packages: J.B. Metzler Humanities (German Language)