Zusammenfassung
Nach der Diskussion der theoretisch-logischen Komponenten in Parsons’ Werk soll nun die empirisch-referentielle Ebene eingehender untersucht werden. Im Schema der Theoriestruktur handelt es sich um “Problemlösungen” und “Fakten”, denen in Stegmüllers Ansatz “paradigmatische Beispiele” und “intendierte Anwendungen” entsprechen.1 Im Zusammenhang mit der funktionalen und neo-evolutionären Analyse wurde bisher das Verhältnis von Theorie und Empirie primär unter dem Aspekt der Anbindung empirischer Konstrukte an die Theorie erörtert; nun soll die empirische Ebene selbst genauer untersucht werden.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Literatur
Die nachfolgende Kurzdarstellung meßtheoretischer Begriffe orientiert sich an: J. Bortz, Lehrbuch der Statistik. Für Sozialwissenschaftler, Berlin 1977, S. 24–32.
T. Parsons, “Some Comments on the State of the General Theory of Action”, ASR, 18, 1953, 618–631, S. 620.
T. Parsons, “A Revised Analytical Approach to the Theory of Social Stratification”, in: T. Parsons, Essays in Sociological Theory, New York 1964 (1953), 386–439.
T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, The American Academic Profession, A Pilot Study, Ms., Cambridge, Mass. 1968.
T. Parsons, “The American Family: Its Relations to Personality and to the Social Structure”, in: T. Parsons, R.F. Bales, Family, Socialization and Interaction Process, London 1968 (1955), 3–33.
T. Parsons, “’Voting’ and the Equilibrium of the American Political System”, in: T. Parsons, Politics and Social Structure, New York 1969 (1959), 204–240.
T. Parsons, “The School Class as a Social System: Some of its Functions in American Society”, in: T. Parsons, Social Structure and Personality, London 1970 (1959), 129–154.
R. Munch, Legitimität und politische Macht, Opladen 1976, S. 128–134
N. Luhmann, Legitimation durch Verfahren, Neuwied 1975 (1969), S. 155–173
B. Giesen, Makrosoziologie, Eine evolutionstheoretische Einführung, Hamburg 1980, S. 197.
M.J. Mulkey, Funktionalism, Exchange and Theoretical Strategy, London 1971, S. 72.
A. W. Gouldner, “Reciprocity and Autonomy in Functional Theory”, in: L. Gross (Hrsg.), Symposium on Sociological Theory, Evanston 1959, 241–270, S. 253
M.U. Martel, “Academentia Praecox: The Aims, Merits and Scope of Parsons’ Multisystemic Language Rebellion (1958–1968)”, in H. Turk, R.L. Simpson (Hrsg.), Institutions and Social Exchange, Indianapolis 1971, 175–211, S. 180.
B. Johnson, Functionalism in Modern Sociology: Understanding Talcott Parsons, Morristown, N.J. 1975, S. 8.
T. Parsons, “Comment on Burger’s Critique”, AJS, 83, 1978, 335–339, S. 336.
T. Parsons, “Comment on ‘Preface to a Metatheoretical Framework for Sociology’ by Llewellyn Gross”, AJS, 67, 1961, 136–140, S. 137.
T. Parsons, “General Theory in Sociology”, in: R. Merton et al. (Hrsg.), Sociology Today, Vol. I, New York 1959, 3–38, S. 22–29.
A.C. Hayes, “A Semi-formal Explication of Talcott Parsons’s Theory of Action”, Sociological Inquiry, 50, 1980, 39–56, S. 55
J.S. Coleman, “Comment on ‘On the Concept of Influence’”, The Public Opinion Quarterly, 27, 1963, 63–82, S. 65–67.
A.T. Turk, “On the Parsonian Approach to Theory Construction”, Sociological Quartery, 8, 1967, 37–50, S. 49
J.H. Turner, L. Beeghley, “Current Folklore in the Criticisms of Parsonian Action Theory”, Sociological Inquiry, 44, 1974, 47–55, S. 53
J.J. Loubser, “Handlung und Erlebnis”, in: J.J. Loubser et al. (Hrsg.), Allgemeine Handlungstheorie, Frankfurt a.M. 1981, 328–394, S. 385–386.
K. Menzies, Talcott Parsons and the Social Image of Man, London 1977, S. 158–159
T.B. Bottomore, “Out of this World: The Sociological Theory of Talcott Parsons”, in: T.B. Bottomore, Sociology as Social Criticism, New York 1975 (1969), 29–43, S. 39–40
G.C. Homans, “Zeitgenössische soziologische Theorie”, in: G.C. Homans, Grundfragen soziologischer Theorie, Opladen 1972 (1964), 9–43, S. 24–30.
T. Parsons, “On Building Social System Theory: A Personal History”, in: T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory, New York 1977 (1970), 22–76, S. 33–34, 63.
T. Parsons, “Graduate Training in Social Relations at Harvard”, Journal of General Education, 5, 1951, 149–157.
J.A. Kahl, The American Class Structure, New York 1967 (1957), S. 281–289
J.A. Kahl, “Educational and Occupational Aspirations of ‘Common Man’ Boys”, Harvard Educational Review, 23, 1953, 186–203.
T. Parsons et al., Working Papers in the Theory of Action, New York 1953, 163–269, S. 254–255
T. Parsons, “The Relation Between the Small Group and the Larger Social System”, in: G.R. Grinker (Hrsg.), Toward a Unified Theory of Human Behavior, 2nd ed., New York 1967 (1953–54), 190–200, S. 194–199
T. Parsons, “Psychology and Sociology”, in: J. Gillin (Hrsg.), For a Science of Social Man, New York 1954, 67–101, S. 78–80
J. Warner, D. Thissen, “Graphical Data Analysis”, Annual Review of Psychology, 32, 1981, 191–241
R. Gnanadesikan, Methods for Statistical Data Analysis of Multivariate Observations, New York 1977.
K.C. Land, “Identification, Parameter Estimation, and Hypothesis Testing in Recursive Sociological Models”, in: A.S. Goldberger, O.D. Duncan (Hrsg.), Structural Equation Models in the Social Sciences, New York 1973, 19–49.
O.D. Duncan, Introduction to Structural Equation Models, New York 1975.
H.M. Blalock, Jr., Causal Inferences in Nonexperimental Research, Chapel Hill, North Car. 1964.
P.M. Blau, O.D. Duncan, The American Occupational Structure, New York 1967, S. 170.
Vgl. Fig. 1 in: K.L. Alexander, B.K. Eckland, L.J.Griffin, “The Wisconsin Model of Socioeconomic Achievement: A Replication”, AJS, 81, 1975, 324–342.
O.D. Duncan, A.O. Haller, A. Portes, “Einflüsse der Peers auf das Anspruchsniveau: eine Neuinterpretation”, in: H.J. Hummell, R. Ziegler (Hrsg.), Korrelation und Kausalität, Bd. 3, Stuttgart 1976, 370–400.
K.L. Alexander, B.K. Eckland, “Basic Attainment Process: A Replication and Extension”, Sociology of Education, 48, 1975, 457–495, S. 457
K.L. Alexander, E.L. McDill, “Selection and Allocation within Schools: Some Causes and Consequences of Curriculum Placement”, ASR, 41, 1976, 963–980, S. 964–956.
J.S. Coleman, “The Mathematical Study of Change”, in: H.M. Blalock, Jr., A.B. Blalock (Hrsg.), Methodology in Social Research, New York 1968, 428–478.
A.B. Sorensen, “The Structure of Intragenerational Mobility”, ASR, 40, 1975, 456–471.
N.B. Tuma, M.T. Hannan, L.V. Groeneveld, “Dynamic Analysis of Event Histories”, AJS, 84, 1979, 820–854.
K.G. Jöreskog, D. Sörbom, LISREL VS Analysis of Linear Structural Relationships by Maximum Likelihood and Least Squares Models, Chicago 1981.
O.D. Duncan, D.L. Featherman, B. Duncan, Socioeconomic Background and Achievement, Chapt. 7, New York 1972
L.H. Boyd, Jr., G.R. Iversen, Contextual Analysis: Concepts and Statistical Techniques, Belmont, Cal. 1979.
T. Parsons, “Cause and Effect in Sociology”, in: D. Lerner (Hrsg.), Cause and Effect, New York 1965, 51–73, S. 63–64.
P.F. Lazarsfeld, “Concept Formation and Measurement”, in: G.J. Di Renzo, Concepts, Theory and Explanation in the Behavioral Sciences, New York 1966, 144–202.
Vgl. P. Suppes, “A Probabilistic Analysis of Causality”, in: H.M. Blalock et al. (Hrsg.), Quantitative Sociology, New York 1975, 49–77.
H.M. Blalock, “The Measurement Problem. A Gap between the Language of Theory and Research”, in: H.M. Blalock, Jr., A.B. Blalock (Hrsg.), Methodology in Social Research, New York 1968, 5–27
H.C. Costner, “Theory, Deduction, and Rules of Correspondence”, in: H.M. Blalock, Jr. (Hrsg.), Causal Models in the Social Sciences, Chicago 1971 (1969), 299–319.
Vgl. K.G. Jöreskog, “A General Method for Estimating a Linear Structural Equation System”, in: A.S. Goldberger, O.D. Duncan, Structural Equation Models in the Social Sciences, New York 1973, 85–112.
R.S. Burt, “Interpretational Confounding of Unobserved Variables in Structural Equation Models”, Sociological Methods and Research, 5, 1976, S. 3–52; Ubers. d. Verf.
T. Burger, “Talcott Parsons, The Problem of Order in Society, and the Program of an Analytical Sociology”, AJS, 83, 1977, 320–334, S. 329–330.
K.C. Land, “Formal Theory”, in: H.L. Costner (Hrsg.), Sociological Methodology 1971, San Francisco, Cal. 1971, 175–220.
N.J. Smelser, Comparative Methods in the Social Sciences, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1976, S. 164.
E.A. Tiryakian, “Typologies”, in: D.L. Sills (Hrsg.), IESS, Bd. 16, New York 1968, 177–186
J.C. McKinney, “Sociological Theory and the Process of Typification”, in: J.C. Mc Kinney, E.A. Tiryakian (Hrsg.), Sociological Theory, New York 1970, 235–269
J. Janoska-Bendl, Methodologische Aspekte des Idealtypus, Berlin 1965; D. Martindale, “Sociological Theory and the Ideal Type”, in: L. Gross (Hrsg.), Symposium on Sociological Theory, New York 1959, 57–91
A.D. Grimshaw, “Specification of Boundaries of Constructed Types through Use of Pattern Variable”, The Sociological Quarterly, 3, 1962, 179–194.
C.G. Hempel, “Typological Methods in the Social Sciences”, in: M.A. Natanson (Hrsg.), Philosophy in the Social Sciences, New York 1953 (1952), 210–230
P.F. Lazarsfeld, Sow me Remarks on the Typological Procedures in Social Research“, Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung, 6, 1937, 119–139
R. Ziegler, “Typologien und Klassifikationen”, in: G. Albrecht et al. (Hrsg.), Soziologie, Opladen 1973, 11–47
V. Capecchi, “On the Definition of Typology and Classification”, Quality and Quantity, 2, 1968, 9–30.
C.C. Clogg, “New Developments in Latent Structure Analysis”, in: D.J. Jackson, E.F. Borgatta (Hrsg.), Factor Analysis and Measurement in Sociological Research, Beverly Hills 1981, 215–246.
M. Küchler, Multivariate Analyseverfahren, Stuttgart 1979
G. Arminger, “Multivariate Analyse von qualitativen abhängigen Variablen mit verallgemeinerten linearen Modellen”, ZfS, 12, 1983, 49–64.
H.C. Selvin, “On Formalizing Theory”, in: L.A. Coser (Hrsg.), The Idea of Social Structure, New York 1975, 339–354.
T. Parsons, “The Prospects of Sociological Theory”, in: T. Parsons, Essays in Sociological Theory, New York 1964 (1950), 348–369, S. 352
T. Parsons, “An Outline of the Social System”, in: T. Parsons et al. (Hrsg.), Theories of Society, New York 1961, 30–79, S. 32; AU, S. 62.
T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, “Research Proposal Submitted to National Science Foundation”, Ms., Cambridge, Mass. 1968, S. III-19, III-20.
T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, “Considerations on the American Academic System”, Minerva, 6, 1968, 497–523
T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, “Decision-Making in the Academic System, Influence and Power Exchange”, in: C.D. Kruytbosch, S.L. Messinger (Hrsg.), The State of the University: Authority and Change, Beverly Hills 1970, 133–180.
G.M. Platt, T. Parsons, R. Kirshstein, “Faculty Teaching Goals, 1968–1973”, Social Problems, 24, 1976, 298–307.
Ebenda, S. 299. Vgl. auch Frage 8 des Fragebogens in: À.E. Bayer, Teaching Faculty in Academe: 1972–1973, Washington, D.C. 1973, Appendix C.
Parsons verwendet die Formulierung “trustee of the cultural tradition”, T. Parsons, “Remarks on Education and the Profession”, International Journal of Ethics, 47, 1937, 365–369, S. 366.
T. Parsons, “Propaganda and Social Control”, in: T. Parsons, Essays in Sociological Theory, New York 1964 (1942), 142–176, S. 165.
T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, “Higher Education and Changing Socialization”, in: M.W. Riley et al. (Hrsg.), Aging and Society, Vol. III, New York 1972, 236–291, S. 242.
R. Münch, Theorie des Handelns, Frankfurt a.M. 1982, S. 172–190.
T. Parsons, “The Academic System: A Sociologist’s View”, The Public Interest, 13, 1968, 173–197, S. 175–176.
T. Parsons, “Some Problems of General Theory in Sociology”, in: T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution Action Theory, New York 1977 (1970), 229–269, S. 252–253.
T. Parsons, “Social Structure and the Symbolic Media of Interchange”, in: T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory, New York 1977 (1975), 204–228, S. 217.
T. Parsons, “The Future of the University”, in: T. Parsons, Action Theory and the Human Condition, New York 1978 (1977), 96–114, S. 113
T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory, New York 1977 (1970), 321–380, S. 358; Übers. d. Verf.
T. Parsons, “The University ‘Bundle’: A Study of Balance between Differentiation and Integration”, in: N.J. Smelser, G. Almond (Hrsg.), Public Higher Education in California, Berkeley 1974, 275–299, S. 280–283.
J.C. Stanley, “Reliability”, in: R.L. Thorndike (Hrsg.), Educational Measurement, 2nd Ed., Washington, D.C. 1971, 356–442, S. 396–398.
A.W. Astin, “An Empirical Characterization of Higher Educational Institutions”, Journal of Educational Psychology, 53, 1962, 224–232, S. 229.
O. Fulton, M. Trow, “Research Activities in American Higher Education”, Sociology of Education, 47, 1974, 29–73, S. 35.
N.J. Smelser, “Epilogue: Social-Structural Dimensions of Higher Education”, in: T. Parsons, G.M. Platt, The American University, Cambridge 1974 (1973), 389–422.
G.M. Platt, T. Parsons, R. Kirshstein, “Undergraduate Teaching Environments: Normative Orientations to Teaching among Faculty in the Higher Educational System”, Sociological Inquiry, 48, 1978, 3–21, S. 13–20.
Vgl. P.F. Lazarsfeld, H. Menzel, “On the Relation Between Individual and Collective Properties”, in: P.F. Lazarsfeld et al. (Hrsg.), Continuities in the Language of Social Research, New York 1972 (1961), 225–237, S. 227–229.
R. Blank, “An Organizational Model of Higher Education Institutions and Faculty Teaching Goals”, Sociological Inquiry, 48, 1978, 23–35.
P.M. Blau, “Recruiting Faculty and Students”, Sociology of Education, 47, 1974, 93–113.
P.M. Blau, “Levels and Types of Structural Effects: The Impact of University and Professional Schools”, in: W.E. Snizek et al. (Hrsg.) Contemporary Issues in Theory and Research, A Metatheoretical Perspective, London 1979, 141–160.
R. Munch, Theorie des Handelns, Frankfurt a.M. 1982, S. 143–156.
T. Parsons, “Stability and Change in the American University”, Daedalus, Fall 1974, 269–277, 2. 276.
J.R. Gusfield, “Review of ‘The American University’ by Talcott Parsons and Gerald M. Platt”, Contemporary Sociology, 3, 1974, 291–295
P. Sexton, “Review of ‘The American University’ by Talcott Parsons and Gerald M. Platt”, Contemporary Sociology, 3, 1974, 296–300.
G. Grant, “Review of ‘The American University’ by Talcott Parsons and Gerald M. Platt”, Harvard Educational Review, 44, 1974, 314–318.
K. Menzies, Talcott Parsons and the Social Image of Man, London 1977, S. 158–159
J. Habermas, Theorie des kommunikativen Handelns, Bd. 2, Frankfurt a.M. 1981, S. 373–374
H. Joas, “Universität und Rationalität. über Talcott Parsons’ Beitrag zur Soziologie der Universität” in: G. Grohs, J. Schwerdtfeger, T. Strohm (Hrsg.), Kulturelle Identität im Wandel, Stuttgart 1980, 236–250;
G. Burkart, “Strukturtheoretische Vorüberlegungen zur Analyse universitärer Sozialisationsprozesse”, KZfSS, 34, 1982, 444–464.
G. Grant, D. Riesman, “An Ecology of Academic Reform”, Daedalus, Winter 1975, 166–191.
R. Bellah, “The World is the World through Its Theorists - In Memory of Talcott Parsons”, The American Sociologist, 15, 1980, 60–62, S. 61. Übers. und Einschub in Klammern d. Verf.
Vgl. R.K. Merton, “Discussion of ‘The Position of Sociological Theory’ by Talcott Parsons”, AJS, 13, 1948, 164–168, S. 166.
T. Parsons, “The Point of View of the Author”, in: M. Black (Hrsg.), The Social Theories of Talcott Parsons, London und Amsterdam 1976 (1961), 311–363, S. 322–323.
R.K. Merton, “Funktionale Analyse”, in: H. Hartmann (Hrsg.), Moderne amerikanische Soziologie, Stuttgart 1973 (1957), 171–214.
R. K. Merton, “Structural Analysis in Sociology”, in: R.K. Merton, Sociological Ambivalence and Other Essays, New York 1976, 109–144, S. 132.
R. Houdon, “Die Krise der Soziologie”, in: R. Boudon, Widersprüche sozialen Handelns, Darmstadt 1979 (1971), 13–47, S. 30.
J.J. Loubser, “Handlung und Erlebnis”, in: J.J. Loubser et al. (Hrsg.), Allgemeine Handlungstheorie, Frankfurt a.M. 1981 (1976), 328–394.
V. Lidz, “Introduction, Part II: General Action Analysis”, in: J.J. Loubser et al. (Hrsg.), Explorations in General Theory in Social Science, Vol. I, New York 1976, 124–150, S. 135.
W. Loh, Kombinatorische Systemtheorie: Evolution, Geschichte und logisch-mathematischer Grundlaqenstreit, Frankfurt 1980.
W. Loh, “AGIL-Dimensionen im Spätwerk von T. Parsons und Kombinatorik”, KZfSS, 32, 1980, 130–143.
T. Parsons, “Family Structure and the Socialization of the Child”, in: T. Parsons, R.F. Bales, Family, Socialization and Interaction Process, London 1968 (1955), 35–131, S. 47. Vgl. auch Kap. 2. 2. 2.
J. Laulicht, “Role Conflict, The Pattern Variable Theory and Scalogram Analysis”, Social Forces, 33, 1955, 250–254, S. 253
H.A. Scarr, “Measures of Particularism”, Sociometry, 27, 1964, 413–432, S. 432
J.A. Kahl, “Some Measurements of Achievement Orientation”, AJS, 70, 1965, 669–681, S. 671.
P.M. Blau, “Operationalizing a Conceptual Scheme: The Universalism-Particularism Pattern Variable”, ASR, 27, 1962, 159–169, S. 168–169.
G.L. Buck, A.L. Jacobson, “Social Evolution and Structural-Functional Analysis: An Empirical Test”, ASR, 33, 1968, 343–355
A.L. Jacobson, “A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Social Change and Conflict Based on Talcott Parsons’ Ideas”, in: H. Turk, R.L. Simpson (Hrsg.), Institutions and Social Exchange, Indianapolis 1971, 344–360.
T. Parsons, “Commentary”, in: H. Turk, R.L. Simpson (Hrsg.), Institutions and Social Exchange, Indianapolis 1971, 380–399, S. 396.
z.B. M.M. Tatsuoka, Multivariate Analysis: Techniques for Educational and Psychological Research, New York 1971
F.U. Pappi, E.O. Laumann, Gesellschaftliche Wertorientierungen und Politisches Verhalten, ZfS, 3, 1974, 157–188.
A.P.M. Coxon, C.L. Jones, “Multidimensional Scaling”, in: C.A. O’Muirchartaigh, C. Payne (Hrsg.), The Analysis of Survey Data, Vol. I, Exploring Data Structures, New York, 1977, 159–182.
A.P.M. Coxon, C.L. Jones, Multidimensional Scaling: Exploration to Confirmation, Quality and Quantity, 14, 1980, 31–73
J.C. Lingoes, E.E. Roskam, I. Borg (Hrsg.), Geometric Representations of Relational Data, Readings in Multidimensional Scaling, Ann Arbor 1979.
T. Parsons, “Review of Harold J. Bershady, ‘Ideology and Social Knowledge’” in: T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory, New York 1977 (1974), 122–134, S. 132.
T. Parsons, “The Present Status of ‘Structural-Functional’ Theory in Sociology”, in: T. Parsons, Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory, New York 1977 (1975), 100–117, S. 113.
U.Oevermann, T.Allert, E.Konau, J. Krambeck, “Die Methodologie einer ‘objektiven Hermeneutik’ und ihre allgemeine forschungslogische Bedeutung in den Sozialwissenschaften”, in: H.G. Soeffner (Hrsg.), Interpretative Verfahren in den Text-und Sozialwissenschaften, Stuttgart 1979, 352–434.
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1984 Westdeutscher Verlag GmbH, Opladen
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Miebach, B. (1984). Empirische Umsetzung theoretischer Modelle. In: Strukturalistische Handlungstheorie. Beiträge zur sozialwissenschaftlichen Forschung, vol 61. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-322-88677-4_5
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-322-88677-4_5
Publisher Name: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften
Print ISBN: 978-3-531-11696-9
Online ISBN: 978-3-322-88677-4
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive