Advertisement

Conclusion

  • Chris O’Riordan
  • Felicity Kelliher
  • Patrick C. Flood
  • Malcolm Higgs
Chapter

Abstract

This final chapter brings together a number of key themes that have been identified in the individual leader chapters, and examines these in the context of existing literature. Initially, the authors consider what an outsider leader is, before assessing what it is that outsider leaders bring to organisations by way of benefits. The arrival of the outsider leader is examined, looking at approaches that they can adopt on entry. Establishing relationships with insiders is identified as a critical early step for those outsiders who want to succeed, though this can present challenges. The hiring strategies of outsider leaders are contemplated in terms of the choices they make. Next, the insider/outsider perspective is considered and how this can be valuable to adopt in a hybrid sense at times. The challenges for and stemming from outsider leaders are then examined, at both a personal and organisational level. Closing the chapter is an examination of gender in the context of outsider leadership, before some concluding comments are presented.

References

  1. Adler, N.J. 1997. Global Leadership: Women Leaders. Management International Review 37 (1): 71–196.Google Scholar
  2. Ahn, M.J., L.W. Ettner, and A. Loupin. 2012. Values v. Traits-based Approaches to Leadership: Insights from an Analysis of the Aeneid. Leadership & Organization Development Journal 33 (2): 112–130.Google Scholar
  3. Becker, H.S. 2012. Outsiders: Studies in Sociology of Deviance. New York: NY Free Press.Google Scholar
  4. Bird, S.R. 2011. Unsettling Universities’ Incongruous, Gendered Bureaucratic Structures: A Case-study Approach. Gender, Work & Organization 18 (2): 202–230.Google Scholar
  5. Borokhovich, K.A., R. Parrino, and T. Trapani. 1996. Outside Directors and CEO Selection. Journal of Financial & Quantitative Analysis 31 (3): 337–355.Google Scholar
  6. Bower, J.L. 2007. Solve the Succession Crisis by Growing Inside-Outside Leaders. Harvard Business Review 85 (11): 90–96.Google Scholar
  7. Carlson, R.O. 1961. Succession and Performance Among School Superintendents. Administrative Science Quarterly 6 (2): 210–220.Google Scholar
  8. Chung, K.H., R.C. Rogers, M. Lubatkin, and J.E. Owers. 1987. Do Insiders Make Better CEOs than Outsiders? Academy of Management Executive (08963789) 1 (4): 325–331.Google Scholar
  9. Ciampa, D., and M. Watkins. 2005. Right from the Start: Taking Charge in a New Leadership Role. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.Google Scholar
  10. Clutterbuck, D. 1998. Handing Over the Reigns: Should the CEO’s Successor be an Insider or an Outsider. Corporate Governance: An International Review 6 (2): 78–85.Google Scholar
  11. Cormier, D. 2006. Why Top Professional Women Still Feel Like Outsiders. Employment Relations Today 33 (1): 27–32.Google Scholar
  12. Dalton, D.R., and I.F. Kesner. 1983. Inside/Outside Succession and Organizational Size: The Pragmatics of Executive Replacement. Academy of Management Journal 26 (4): 736–742.Google Scholar
  13. David, B., and J.C. Turner. 1996. Studies in Self-Categorization and Minority Conversion: Is Being a Member of the Out-Group an Advantage. British Journal of Social Psychology 35 (1): 179–199.Google Scholar
  14. Davidson, W., C. Nemec, D. Worrell, and J. Lin. 2002. Industrial Origin of CEOs in Outside Succession: Board Preference and Stockholder Reaction. Journal of Management & Governance 6 (4): 295–321.Google Scholar
  15. Davidson, W.N., S. Tong, D.L. Worrell, and W. Rowe. 2006. Ignoring Rules of Succession: How the Board Reacts to CEO Illness Announcements. Journal of Business Strategies 23 (2): 93–113.Google Scholar
  16. Dennehy, T., and N. Dasgupta. 2017. Female Peer Mentors Early in College Increase Women’s Positive Academic Experiences and Retention in Engineering. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 114 (23): 5964–5969.Google Scholar
  17. Diehl, A.B., and L.M. Dzubinski. 2016. Making the Invisible Visible: A Cross-Sector Analysis of Gender-Based Leadership Barriers. Human Resource Development Quarterly 27 (2): 181–206.Google Scholar
  18. European Commission. 2016. Gender Balance on Corporate Boards: Europe Is Cracking the Glass Ceiling, Fact Sheet, July 2016. https://ec.europa.eu/newsroom/document.cfm?doc_id=46280. Accessed Feb 2018.
  19. Finkelstein, S., and D.C. Hambrick. 1996. Strategic Leadership: Top Executives and Their Effects on Organizations. Minneapolis: West Publishing.Google Scholar
  20. Ford, E.W., K.B. Lowe, G.B. Silvera, D. Babik, and T.R. Huerta. 2016. Insider Versus Outsider Executive Succession: The Relationship to Hospital Efficiency. Health Care Management Review 43 (1): 61–68.Google Scholar
  21. Furnham, A. 2015. The Advantages of Being an Outsider: Does Coming from a Minority Group Offer Any Advantages? https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/sideways-view/201504/the-advantages-being-outsider. Accessed Sep 2017.
  22. Geiger, E. 2015. Five Ways Leaders Can Get “Fresh Eyes.” https://ericgeiger.com/2015/11/five-ways-leaders-can-get-fresh-eyes/. Accessed Nov 2017.
  23. Giambatista, R.C., W.G. Rowe, and S. Riaz. 2005. Nothing Succeeds Like Succession: A Critical Review of Leader Succession Literature Since 1994. The Leadership Quarterly 16 (6): 963–991.Google Scholar
  24. Gladwell, M. 2008. The Uses of Adversity. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2008/11/10/the-uses-of-adversity. Accessed Oct 2017.
  25. Haile, S., T. Emmanuel, and A. Dzathor. 2016. Barriers and Challenges Confronting Women for Leadership and Management Positions: Review and Analysis. International Journal of Business & Public Administration 13 (1): 36–51.Google Scholar
  26. Ibarra, H., S. Wittman, G. Petriglieri, and D.V. Day. 2014. Leadership and Identity: An Examination of Three Theories and New Research Directions. In The Oxford Handbook of Leadership and Organizations, ed. D.V. Day. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  27. Jiang, F., J. Huang, and K.A. Kim. 2013. Appointments of Outsiders as CEOs, State-owned Enterprises, and Firm Performance: Evidence from China. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 23: 49–64.Google Scholar
  28. Karaevli, A. 2007. Performance Consequences of New CEO “Outsiderness”: Moderating Effects of Pre- and Post-succession Contexts. Strategic Management Journal 28 (7): 681–706.Google Scholar
  29. ———. 2016. The “Turnaround Trap” of Outsider CEOs: Causes and Solutions for Succession Planning. Organizational Dynamics 45 (4): 278–282.Google Scholar
  30. Karaevli, A., and E.J. Zajac. 2012. When Is an Outsider CEO a Good Choice. MIT Sloan Management Review 53 (4): 15–17.Google Scholar
  31. Kelsey, R. 2015. The Outside Edge: How Outsiders Can Succeed in a World Made by Insiders. West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  32. Kesner, I.F., and D.R. Dalton. 1994. Top Management Turnover and CEO Succession: An Investigation of the Effects of Turnover on Performance. Journal of Management Studies 31 (5): 701–713.Google Scholar
  33. Kesner, I.F., and T.C. Sebora. 1994. Executive Succession: Past, Present & Future. Journal of Management 20 (2): 327–372.Google Scholar
  34. King, A. 2002. The Outsider as Political Leader: The Case of Margaret Thatcher. British Journal of Political Science 32 (3): 435–454.Google Scholar
  35. Koenig, A.M., A.H. Eagly, A.A. Mitchell, and T. Ristikari. 2011. Are Leader Stereotypes Masculine? A Meta-Analysis of Three Research Paradigms. Psychological Bulletin 137 (4): 616–642.Google Scholar
  36. Lauterbach, B., J. Vu, and J. Weisberg. 1999. Internal vs. External Successions and Their Effect on Firm Performance. Human Relations 52 (12): 1485–1504.Google Scholar
  37. Levett-Jones, T. and Bourgeois, S. 2015. The Clinical Placement: An Essential Guide for Nursing Students. Elsevier, New South Wales.Google Scholar
  38. Liang, F. 2016. Should Firms Look to an Insider or an Outsider When Hiring a New CEO? Evidence from China. Journal of Asia-Pacific Business 17 (2): 103–129.Google Scholar
  39. Louis, M.R. 1980. Surprise and Sense Making: What Newcomers Experience in Entering Unfamiliar Organizational Settings. Administrative Science Quarterly 25 (2): 226–251.Google Scholar
  40. Lublin, J. S. 2017. Can an Outside CEO Succeed? Look at the Board’s Diversity. https://theindustryspread.com/market-news/can-an-outside-ceo-succeed-look-at-the-boards-diversity/. Accessed Sep 2017.
  41. Manderscheid, S.V. 2008. New Leader Assimilation: An Intervention for Leaders in Transition. Advances in Developing Human Resources 10 (5): 686–702.Google Scholar
  42. Mayo, A.J., N. Nohria, and L.G. Singleton. 2006. Paths to Power: How Insiders and Outsiders Shaped American Business Leadership. Boston: Harvard Business School.Google Scholar
  43. McDonald, T., L. Toussaint, and J. Schweiger. 2004. The Influence of Social Status on Token Women Leaders, Expectations About Leading Male-Dominated Groups. Sex Roles 50 (5–6): 401–409.Google Scholar
  44. Miller, D. 1993. Some Organizational Consequences of CEO Succession. Academy of Management Journal 36 (3): 644–659.Google Scholar
  45. Moore, G. 1988. Women in Elite Positions: Insiders or Outsiders? Sociological Forum 3 (4): 566–585.Google Scholar
  46. Nickisch, C. 2016. Outsider CEOs Are on the Rise at the World’s Biggest Companies. https://hbr.org/2016/04/outsider-ceos-are-on-the-rise-at-the-worlds-biggest-companies. Accessed Dec 2017.
  47. Ocasio, W. 1994. Political Dynamics and the Circulation of Power: CEO Succession in U.S. Industrial Corporations, 1960–1990. Administrative Science Quarterly 39: 285–312.Google Scholar
  48. PricewaterhouseCoopers. 2016. Success Study & Outsider CEOs: Briefing Document. https://www.strategyand.pwc.com/media/file/2015-CEO-Success-Study-Outsider-CEOs.pdf. Accessed Aug 2017.
  49. Quinn, D.M., and V.A. Earnshaw. 2013. Concealable Stigmatized Identities and Psychological Well-Being. Social & Personality Psychology Compass 7 (1): 40–51.Google Scholar
  50. Rejchrt, P., and M. Higgs. 2014. Who Are Our Leaders? A Study of CEO Succession in the UK FTSE 350 Companies. Journal of General Management 39 (3): 3–16.Google Scholar
  51. Schneider, B. 1987. The People Make the Place. Personnel Psychology 40 (3): 437–453.Google Scholar
  52. Shapira, R. 1995. “Fresh Blood” Innovation and the Dilemma of Personal Involvement. Creativity and Innovation Management 4 (2): 86–99.Google Scholar
  53. Shen, W., and A.A. Cannella Jr. 2002. Revisiting the Performance Consequences of CEO Succession: The Impacts of Successor Type, Postsuccession Senior Executive Turnover, and Departing CEO Tenure. Academy of Management Journal 45 (4): 717–733.Google Scholar
  54. Thomas, H., and N. Anderson. 1998. Changes in Newcomers’ Psychological Contracts During Organizational Socialization: A Study of Recruits Entering the British Army. Journal of Organizational Behavior 19: 745–767.Google Scholar
  55. Thorndike, W. 2012. The Outsiders: Eight Unconventional CEOs and Their Radically Rational Blueprint for Success. Boston: Harvard Business Review Press.Google Scholar
  56. Uhl-Bien, M. 2006. Relational Leadership Theory: Exploring the Social Processes of Leadership and Organizing. The Leadership Quarterly 17 (6): 654–676.Google Scholar
  57. Unger, R.K. 2000. Outsiders Inside: Positive Marginality and Social Change. Journal of Social Issues 56 (1): 163–179.Google Scholar
  58. Vaid, J. 2015. Successful Leadership: Traits Revisited. Global Journal of Enterprise Information System 7 (2): 117–118.Google Scholar
  59. Villadsen, A.R. 2012. New Executives from Inside or Outside? The Effect of Executive Replacement on Organizational Change. Public Administration Review 72 (5): 731–740.Google Scholar
  60. Williams, C.L. 1992. The Glass Escalator: Hidden Advantages for Men in the “Female” Professions. Social Problems 39 (3): 253–267.Google Scholar
  61. Williams, K.D., J.P. Forgas, and W. v Hippel. 2014. The Social Outcast: Ostracism, Social Exclusion, Rejection, and Bullying. New York: Psychology Press.Google Scholar
  62. Women in STEM. 2017. WISE Campaign. https://www.wisecampaign.org.uk/resources/2017/10/women-in-stem-workforce-2017. Accessed Jan 2018.
  63. Zajac, E.J. 1990. CEO Selection, Succession, Compensation and Firm Performance: A Theoretical Intergration and Empirical Analysis. Strategic Management Journal (1986–1998) 11 (3): 217–230.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Chris O’Riordan
    • 1
  • Felicity Kelliher
    • 1
  • Patrick C. Flood
    • 2
  • Malcolm Higgs
    • 3
  1. 1.School of BusinessWaterford Institute of TechnologyWaterfordIreland
  2. 2.DCU Business SchoolDublin City UniversityDublinIreland
  3. 3.Hull University Business SchoolUniversity of HullHullUK

Personalised recommendations