Advertisement

Unamendability in Israel: A Critical Perspective

  • Mazen MasriEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Ius Gentium: Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice book series (IUSGENT, volume 68)

Abstract

This chapter explores unamendability in Israel. Even though Israel has no full or formal constitution, and no specific amendment rules, two forms of unamdenability could be identified. The first form is concealed unamendability, which prevents certain kinds of amendments through controlling the composition of the Knesset (the legislature which also has the power to enact and amend constitutional Basic Laws). The second is judicially-introduced unwritten unamendability. Unamendability in both cases aims to protect Israel’s definition as a Jewish and democratic state. The chapter will examine both forms of unamendability and the functions they serve, highlighting the expressive and the preservative functions. It will also examine the implications of unamendability for constitutionalism in Israel emphasizing the impact of entrenching particular values such as the Jewish definition and its contribution to creating a hierarchy among the citizenry and the entrenchment of favourable status for certain groups.

Notes

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank the participants of the ‘Workshop on Unamendable Constitutional Provisions’ for their comments and feedback. Special thanks to Richard Albert and Bertil Emrah Oder for organizing the workshop, to Esra Ozcan and Zeynep Kocer for helping host the workshop, and to Yaniv Roznai for thorough and very helpful comments.

References

  1. Aaronsohn R (1996) Settlement in Eretz Israel: a colonial enterprise? “Critical” scholarship and historical geography. Israel Stud 1(2):214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Albert R (2009) Nonconstitutional amendments. Can J Law Jurisprud 22:5, 32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Albert R (2010) Constitutional handcuffs. Arizona State Law J 42:663Google Scholar
  4. Albert R (2013) The expressive function of constitutional amendment rules. McGill Law J 59(2):225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Albert R (2014) Constructive unamendability in Canada and the United States. Supreme Court Law Rev 67:181, 189Google Scholar
  6. Albert R (2015) Amending constitutional amendment rules. Int J Const Law 13(3):655Google Scholar
  7. Barak A (1994) Interpretation in law. Nevo Publishing, New York (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  8. Barak A (2004) A Judge in a democratic society. Nevo Publishing, New York (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  9. Barak A (2011) Unconstitutional constitutional amendments. Israel Law Rev 44:321Google Scholar
  10. Bendor A (2000) The legal status of the basic laws. In: Barak A, Berenson C (eds) Berenson book, vol 2. Nevo Publishing, New York (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  11. Choudhry S (2005) Old imperial dilemmas and the new nation-building: constitutive constitutional politics in multinational polities. Connecticut Law Rev 37:933, 939Google Scholar
  12. Colón-Ríos J (2010) The legitimacy of the juridical: constituent power, democracy and the limits of constitutional reform. Osgoode Hall Law J 48:199Google Scholar
  13. Colón-Ríos J (2014) Five conceptions of constituent power. Law Q Rev 130:306Google Scholar
  14. Dershowitz A (2003) The case for Israel. Wiley, HobokenGoogle Scholar
  15. Dicey AV (1895) Constitutional revision. Law Q Rev 11:387, 388Google Scholar
  16. Dixon R (2011) Constitutional amendment rules: a comparative perspective. In: Ginsburg T, Dixon R (eds) Comparative constitutional law. Edward Elgar, CheltenhamGoogle Scholar
  17. Gavison R (2003) The Jews’ Right to statehood: a defense. Azure 15:70Google Scholar
  18. Guberman S (1967) Israel’s supra-constitution. Israel Law Rev 2:445, 460Google Scholar
  19. Harris R (2001) Jewish democracy and Arab politics: Al-Ard movement at the Supreme Court. Plileem 10:107Google Scholar
  20. Hesketh K (2011) The inequality report: the Palestinian Arab minority in Israel. Adalah, Israel. http://adalah.org/upfiles/2011/Adalah_The_Inequality_Report_March_2011.pdf
  21. Holmes S, Sunstein C (1995) The politics of constitutional revision in Eastern Europe. In: Levinson S (ed) Responding to imperfection: the theory and practice of constitutional amendment. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  22. Jabareen H (2002) The future of Arab citizenship in Israel: Jewish-Zionist time in a place with No Palestinian memory. In: Levy D, Weiss Y (eds) Challenging ethnic citizenship. Berghahen Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  23. Jiryis S (1976) The Arabs in Israel. Monthly Review Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  24. Klein C (1978) Is there a need for an amending power theory? Israel Law Rev 12:303Google Scholar
  25. Klein C (1993) Basic law: human dignity and freedom: an initial normative assessment. HaMishpat 1:123 (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  26. Klein C (1997) After the Bank Mizrahi decision: constituent power through the mirror of the Supreme Court. Mishpatim 28:341 (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  27. Klein C, Sajo A (2012) Constitution-making: process and substance. In: Rosenfeld M, Sajo A (eds) The Oxford handbook of comparative constitutional law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  28. Masri M (2013) Love suspended: demography, comparative law, and Palestinian couples in the Israeli Supreme Court. Soc Legal Stud 22(3):309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Masri M (2017) The dynamics of exclusionary constitutionalism: Israel as a Jewish and democratic State. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  30. Minister of Finance (2012) The Alumni of the Arab Orthodox High School in Haifa (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  31. Morris B (2004) The birth of the Palestinian refugee problem revisited, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  32. Neiman (1985) Chairman of the central elections committee for the Eleventh Knesset. IsrSC 39(2):225 (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  33. Neiman (1988) Chairman of the central elections committee for the Twelfth Knesset. IsrSC 42(4):177, 187 (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  34. Pappe I (2006) The ethnic cleansing of Palestine. One World, LondonGoogle Scholar
  35. Piterberg G (2008) The returns of Zionism: myths, politics and scholarship in Israel. Verso, MemphisGoogle Scholar
  36. Preuss U (2011) The implications of “eternity clauses”: The German experience. Israel law Rev 44:429, 445Google Scholar
  37. Rodinson M (1973) Israel: a Colonial Settler state?. Pathfinder, New DelhiGoogle Scholar
  38. Roznai Y (2016) Unamendability and the genetic code of the constitution. Eur Rev Public Law 27(2):775Google Scholar
  39. Rubenstein A, Yakobson A (2009) Israel and family of nations. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  40. Said E (1979) The question of Palestine. Times Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Sayeg F (1965) Zionist colonialism in Palestine. Research Center—Palestine Liberation Organization, BeirutGoogle Scholar
  42. Schwartzberg M (2007) Democracy and legal change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Shafir S (1996) Land labour and the origins of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, 1882–1914, updated edn. California University Press, CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
  44. Shalhoub-Kevorkian N (2015) Security theology, surveillance and the politics of fear. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Sultany N (2012) The state of progressive constitutional theory: the paradox of constitutional democracy and the project of political justification. Harvard Civ Rights-Civ Liberties Law Rev 47(2):371Google Scholar
  46. Sultany N (2017) The legal structure of subordination: The Palestinian minority and Israeli law. In: Rouhana N (ed) Israel and its Palestinian citizens: ethnic privileges in the Jewish state. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  47. Sunstein C (1996) On the expressive function of law. Univ Pennsylvania Law Rev 144(5):2021CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Troper M (2012) Sovereignty. In: Rosenfeld M, Sajo A (eds) The Oxford handbook of comparative constitutional law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  49. Tushnet M (1999) The possibilities of comparative constitutional law. Yale Law J 108(6):1225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Veracini L (2006) Israel and Settler society. Pluto Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  51. Weintal S (2011) The challenge of reconciling constitutional eternity clauses with popular sovereignty: toward three-track democracy in Israel as a Universal Holistic Constitutional System and Theory. Israel Law Rev 44:449, 494Google Scholar
  52. Weintal S (2013) The inherent authority of judges in a three-track democracy to recognise unenumerated constitutional rights: the Israeli story of a Judicial Mission with no ammunition. In: Sapir G, Barak-Erez D, Barak A (eds) Israeli constitutional law in the making. Hart Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  53. Weintal S (2014) Judicial limitation clause: on the appropriate scope of protection for abstract constitutional principles. Moznei Mishpat 9:177 (Hebrew)Google Scholar
  54. Zureik E (1979) The Palestinians in Israel: a study in internal colonialism. Routldge & Kegan Paul, AbingdonGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.The City Law SchoolCity, University of LondonLondonUK

Personalised recommendations