Advertisement

Amending the Unamendable: The Case of Article 20 of the German Basic Law

  • Serkan KöybaşıEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Ius Gentium: Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice book series (IUSGENT, volume 68)

Abstract

The power which has the right to approve a constitutional norm is called pouvoir constituant. The original pouvoir constituant which drafts a new constitution is hierarchically higher than the derived one which has only the right to amend an existing constitution in the framework allowed by the original one. In other words, parliaments who want to amend the constitutions are limited by the unamendable provisions. In 1968, Parliament of Germany added the 4th paragraph (which provides German citizens the right to resist any person seeking to abolish the constitutional order) to Article 20 which had been rendered unamendable by the Article 79 of the Basic Law of Germany during the drafting process in 1949. Consequently, although this newly added paragraph is present in an unamendable article, any derived pouvoir constituant can amend, change or annul it because it is not approved by an original pouvoir constituant.

References

  1. Barthelemy J, Duez P (1993) Traité de Droit Constitutionnel. Dalloz, Paris, p 231Google Scholar
  2. Beaud O (1994) La Puissance de l’Etat. PUF, ParisCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Beaud O (1993) Maastricht et la Théorie Constitutionnelle (1ere partie)—La Nécessaire et Inévitable Distinction entre le Pouvoir Constituant et le Pouvoir de Révision Constitutionnelle, no 39. Les Petites Affiches, 31 Mar 1993Google Scholar
  4. Beaud O (1993) Le Souverain. Pouvoirs 67:37Google Scholar
  5. Burdeau G (1950) Traité de Science Politique, vol III. LGDJ, Paris, p 209Google Scholar
  6. Duguit L (1994) Traité de Droit Constitutionnel. In: Beaud O (ed) La Puissance De l’Etat, vol IV, 3rd edn. PUF, Paris, pp 370–371Google Scholar
  7. Duguit L (2005) Egemenlik ve Özgürlük. In: Akal CB (ed) Devlet Kuramı. Dost, Ankara, pp 383–385Google Scholar
  8. Duverger M (1948) Manuel de Droit Constitutionnel et de Science Politique, 5th edn. PUF, Paris, p195Google Scholar
  9. Dérosier J-P (2008) Enquête sur la Limite Constitutionnelle: du Concept à la Notion. In: Revue Française de Droit Constitutionnel, no 76, pp. 785–795Google Scholar
  10. Esmein A (1909) Elements de Droit Constitutionnel Français et Comparé, 5th edn. Sirey, Paris, pp 980–981Google Scholar
  11. Gallagher SCP (2012) Euro Crisis: Challenges to the ESM Treaty and the Fiscal Compact Treaty before the German constitutional court. Working paper, p 2, 30 Aug 2012. http://www.iiea.com/publications/challenges-to-the-esm-treaty-and-the-fiscal-compact-treaty-before-the-german-constitutional-court
  12. Grimm D (2010) The basic law at 60—identity and change. Ger Law J 11(1):34Google Scholar
  13. Gárdos-Orosz F (2015) Unamendable Constitutional Provisions and Judicial Review. Paper presented in Koç University in workshop on unamendable constitutional provisions, p 1, 9 June 2015Google Scholar
  14. Gözler K (1997) Le Pouvoir de Révision Constitutionnelle, vol I. Presses Universitaires de Septentrion, Villeneuve d’AscqGoogle Scholar
  15. Hailbronner M (2014) Rethinking the rise of the German constitutional court: from Anti-Nazism to value formalism. Int J Const Law 12(3):628–634Google Scholar
  16. Khan DE, Zöckler M (1992) Germans to the front? or le Malade Imaginaire. Eur J Int Law 3:168. http://www.ejil.org/pdfs/3/1/1174.pdf
  17. Klein C (1996) Théorie et Pratique du Pouvoir Constituant. PUF, ParisGoogle Scholar
  18. Kubalı HN (1971) Anayasa Hukuku Dersleri: Genel Esaslar ve Siyasî Rejimler. İstanbul Üniversitesi Yayınları, İstanbulGoogle Scholar
  19. Lavroff DG (1995) Le Droit Constitutionnel de la Ve République. Dalloz, Paris, pp 99–100Google Scholar
  20. Michel S, Cofone IN (2015) Credible Commitment or Paternalism? The Case of Unamendability. Paper presented in Koç University in workshop on unamendable constitutional provisions, p 6, 9 June 2015Google Scholar
  21. Murswiek D (2008) Ungeschriebene Ewigkeitsgarantien in Verfassungen. Unpublished paper presented in Bilkent University, Ankara, p 3, 10 Nov 2008. http://www.jura.uni-freiburg.de/institute/ioeffr3/forschung/papers/murswiek/ewigkeitsgarantie
  22. Onar E (1993) 1982 Anayasası’nda Anayasayı Değiştirme Sorunu. Ankara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayınları, Ankara, p 18Google Scholar
  23. Paine T (1984) Rights of Man. Viking Penguin, New Jersey, p 41Google Scholar
  24. Renoux TS, de Villiers M (1994) Code Constitutionnel. Litec, Paris, p 624Google Scholar
  25. Robert J (2003) La Forme Républicaine du Gouvernement. Revue du Droit Public 2:362Google Scholar
  26. Roznai Y (2015) Necrocracy or democracy. Paper presented in Koç University in workshop on unamendable constitutional provisions, 9 June 2015Google Scholar
  27. Sağlam F (2010) Anayasa ve Değişmez Kurallar. In: Prof. Dr Tunçer Karamustafaoğlu’na Armağan. Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, p 575Google Scholar
  28. Schmitt C (2008) Théorie de la Constitution, 1st edn. PUF, ParisGoogle Scholar
  29. Sieyes E (1999) Des Manuscrits de Sieyes, 1773–1799. Honoré Champion, Paris, pp 492–493Google Scholar
  30. Sieyes E (1989) Motion sur la Vérification des Pouvoirs. In: Furet F, Halevi R (eds) Orateurs de la Révolution Française I—Les Constituants. Gallimard, Bruges, pp 1004–1018Google Scholar
  31. Teziç E (2012) Anayasa Hukuku (Genel Esaslar), 15th edn. Beta, IstanbulGoogle Scholar
  32. Teziç E (2012) Anayasa Hukuku (Genel Esaslar), 15th edn. Beta, Istanbul, p 158Google Scholar
  33. Turpin D (1992) Droit Constitutionnel. PUF, Paris, p 81Google Scholar
  34. de Malberg RC (1920) Contribution à la Théorie Générale de l’Etat Spécialement d’après les Données Fournies par le Droit Constitutionnel Français, vol II. Librairie du Receuil Sirey, Paris, pp 509–510Google Scholar
  35. de Malberg RC (1922) Contribution à la Théorie Générale de l’Etat Spécialement d’après les Données Fournies par le Droit Constitutionnel Français, vol II. Librairie du Receuil Sirey, Paris, pp 496–497Google Scholar
  36. de Malberg RC (1931) La Loi Expression de la Volonté Générale—Etude sur le Concept de la Loi dans la Constitution de 1875, Librairie du Receuil Sirey, ParisGoogle Scholar
  37. du Loû DMD (2003) Le Pouvoir Constituant Dérivé Reste Souverain. Revue du Droit Public 3:731Google Scholar
  38. Özbudun E (2013) Türk Anayasa Hukuku, 14th edn. Ankara, Yetkin Yayınları, pp 180–181Google Scholar
  39. Özbudun E (2013) Türk Anayasa Hukuku, 14th edn. Yetkin, Ankara, p 175Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Law FacultyBahçeşehir UniversityIstanbulTurkey

Personalised recommendations