Advertisement

Criminalising Neonaticide: Reflections on Law and Practice in England and Wales

  • Karen BrennanEmail author
  • Emma MilneEmail author
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter considers the unusual case where a woman is suspected of killing her newborn baby following a secret pregnancy and birth. The research on what we know about the circumstances and incidence of what has been termed ‘neonaticide’ is explored. The complexities of these cases in terms of their circumstances and the vulnerability of women who conceal their pregnancies are highlighted. Following this, the difficulties, from a legal perspective, that arise when seeking to prosecute women for homicide when their babies die following an unassisted concealed birth are considered. What we know about current criminal justice practice in these cases is also explored. Unfortunately, there is limited research on current criminal justice practice in these cases, and little is therefore known about the approach taken by the police, prosecutors and the courts in cases involving suspected homicides of newborns. The need for further research on the criminal justice response is highlighted, and the appropriateness of criminalising women and girls in these cases, particularly given their unique circumstances of vulnerability, is questioned.

References

Case Law

  1. Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171.Google Scholar
  2. Attorney General’s Reference (No. 3 of 1994) [1997] 3 All ER 936.Google Scholar
  3. Brain (1834) 6 C. and P. 349.Google Scholar
  4. Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority v. First-tier Tribunal (Social Entitlement Chamber) (British Pregnancy Advisory Service and others intervening) [2014] EWCA Civ 1554.Google Scholar
  5. Crutchley (1839) 7 C. and P. 814.Google Scholar
  6. Enoch and Pulley (1833) 5 C. and P. 539.Google Scholar
  7. Izod (1904) 20 Cox 690.Google Scholar
  8. Knights (1860) 2 F and F 46.Google Scholar
  9. M’Naghten’s Case (1843) 10 C and F 200; 8 ER 718.Google Scholar
  10. Moloney [1985] AC 905.Google Scholar
  11. Poulton (1832) 5 C. and P. 329.Google Scholar
  12. Reeves (1839) 9 C. and P. 25.Google Scholar
  13. Sellis (1837) 7 C. and P. 850.Google Scholar
  14. St George’s Healthcare NHS Trust v. S [1998] 3 All ER 673.Google Scholar
  15. Trilloe (1842) C. and M. 650; 2 Mood. 260.Google Scholar
  16. Alder, C. M., & Baker, J. (1997). Maternal filicide: More than one story to be told. Women and Criminal Justice, 9(2), 15–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Allen, H. (1987). Justice unbalanced: Gender, psychiatry, and judicial decisions. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.Google Scholar
  18. Amon, S., Putkonen, H., Weizmann-Henelius, G., Almiron, M., Formann, A., Voracek, M., et al. (2012). Potential predictors in neonaticide: The impact of the circumstances of pregnancy. Archives of Women’s Mental Health, 15(3), 167–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Atkinson, S. B. (1904). Life, birth and live-birth. Law Quarterly Review, 20(2), 134–159.Google Scholar
  20. Beier, K. M., Wille, R., & Wessel, J. (2006). Denial of pregnancy as a reproductive dysfunction: A proposal for international classification systems. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 61(5), 723–730.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Beyer, K., McAuliffe Mack, S., & Shelton, J. L. (2008). Investigative analysis of neonaticide: An exploratory study. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 35(4), 522–535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Brazier, M. (1999). Liberty, responsibility, maternity. Current Legal Problems, 52(1), 359–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Brennan, K. (2013a). “A fine mixture of pity and justice:” The criminal justice response to infanticide in Ireland 1922–1949. Law and History Review, 31(4), 793–841.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Brennan, K. (2013b). “Traditions of English liberal thought”: A history of the enactment of an infanticide law in Ireland. Irish Jurist, 50, 100–137.Google Scholar
  25. Brennan, K. (forthcoming-a). Murdering mothers and gentle judges: paternalism, patriarchy and infanticide. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism.Google Scholar
  26. Brennan, K. (forthcoming-b). Social norms and the law in responding to infanticide. Legal Studies.Google Scholar
  27. Brezinka, C., Brezinka, C., Biebl, W., & Kinzl, J. (1994). Denial of pregnancy: Obstetrical aspects. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics & Gynecology, 15(1), 1–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Cave, E. (2004). The mother of all crimes: Human rights, criminalization and the child born alive. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  29. Coke, E. (1681). The fourth part of the institutes of the laws of England: Concerning the jurisdiction of courts (6th ed.). London: Printed by W. Rawlins, for Thomas Basset at the George near St. Dunstans Church in Fleet-street.Google Scholar
  30. Craig, M. (2004). Perinatal risk factors for neonaticide and infant homicide: Can we identify those at risk? Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 97(2), 57–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Crown Prosecution Service. (2013). The code for crown prosecutors. Available at: https://www.cps.gov.uk/publications/docs/code_2013_accessible_english.pdf.
  32. Davies, D. S. (1937). Child killing in English law, Part I. The Modern Law Review, 1(3), 202–223.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Davies, D. S. (1938). Child killing in English law, Part II. The Modern Law Review, 1(4), 269–287.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. d’Orbán, P. T. (1979). Women who kill their children. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 134(6), 560–571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Friedman, S. H., & Friedman, J. B. (2010). Parents who kill their children. Pediatrics in Review, 31(2), 10–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Gonçalves, T., Macedo, M., & Conz, J. (2014). Non-psychotic denial of pregnancy: A psychoanalytical comprehension. Interamerican Journal of Psychology, 48(1), 23–29.Google Scholar
  37. Jenkins, A., Millar, S., & Robins, J. (2011). Denial of pregnancy: A literature review and discussion of ethical and legal issues. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 104(7), 286–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kaplan, R., & Grotowski, T. (1996). Denied pregnancy. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 30(6), 861–863.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Kramar, K. J. (2005). Unwilling mothers, unwanted babies: Infanticide in Canada. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
  40. Kramar, K. J., & Watson, W. D. (2006). The insanities of reproduction: Medico-legal knowledge and the development of infanticide law. Social & Legal Studies, 15(2), 237–255.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Mackay, R. D. (1993). The consequences of killing very young children. Criminal Law Review, (January), 21–30.Google Scholar
  42. Mackay, R. D. (2006). Appendix D: Infanticide and related diminished responsibility manslaughters: An empirical study. Murder, Manslaughter and Infanticide: Project 6 of the Ninth Programme of Law Reform: Homicide. Available at: http://lawcommission.justice.gov.uk/docs/lc304_Murder_Manslaughter_and_Infanticide_Report.pdf.
  43. Maier-Katkin, D., & Ogle, R. S. (1997). Policy and disparity: The punishment of infanticide in Britain and America. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 21(2), 305–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Meyer, C. L., & Oberman, M. (2001). Mothers who kill their children: Understanding the acts of moms from Susan Smith to the “Prom Mom”. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  45. Miller, L. J. (2003). Denial of pregnancy. In M. G. Spinelli (Ed.), Infanticide: Psychosocial and legal perspectives on mothers who kill (pp. 81–104). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric.Google Scholar
  46. Milne, E. (2017a). Murder or infanticide? Understanding the causes behind the most shocking of crimes. The Conversation (30 June). Available at: https://theconversation.com/murder-or-infanticide-understanding-the-causes-behind-the-most-shocking-of-crimes-79808 (Accessed 17 July 2017).
  47. Milne, E. (2017b). Suspicious perinatal death and the law: Criminalising mothers who do not conform. (PhD, University of Essex, UK). Available at: http://repository.essex.ac.uk/20474/.
  48. Milne, E. (forthcoming). Concealment of birth: Time to repeal a 200-year-old convenient stop-gap?.Google Scholar
  49. Morris, A., & Wilczynski, A. (1993). Rocking the cradle: Mothers who kill their children. In H. Birch (Ed.), Moving targets: Women, murder, and representation (pp. 198–217). London: Virago.Google Scholar
  50. Nirmal, D., Thijs, I., Bethel, J., & Bhal, P. S. (2006). The incidence and outcome of concealed pregnancies among hospital deliveries: An 11-year population-based study in South Glamorgan. Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 26(2), 118–121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Oberman, M. (1996). Mothers who kill: Coming to terms with modern American infanticide. American Criminal Law Review, 34(1), 1–110.Google Scholar
  52. Oberman, M. (2003). Mothers who kill: Cross-cultural patterns in and perspectives on contemporary maternal filicide. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 26(5), 493–514.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Office for National Statistics. (2016). Births in England and Wales: 2015 (13 July). Available at: http://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/livebirths/bulletins/birthsummarytablesenglandandwales/2015-the-number-of-stillbirths-decreased-in-2015 (Accessed 30 August 2016).
  54. Ormerod, D., & Laird, K. (2015). Smith and Hogan’s Criminal Law (14th ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Parveen, N. (2016). Prosecutors to re-examine vicarage death of newborn baby. The Guardian (5 October edn). Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/oct/05/prosecutors-to-re-examine-vicarage-death-of-newborn-baby (Accessed 15 May 2017).
  56. Porter, T., & Gavin, H. (2010). Infanticide and neonaticide: A review of 40 years of research literature on incidence and causes. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 11(3), 99–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Resnick, P. J. (1969). Child murder by parents: A psychiatric review of filicide. American Journal of Psychiatry, 126(3), 325–334.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Resnick, P. J. (1970). Murder of the newborn: A psychiatric review of neonaticide. American journal of psychiatry, 126(10), 1414–1420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Simester, A. P., Spencer, J. R., Stark, F., Sullivan, G. R., & Virgo, G. J. (2016). Simester and Sullivan’s criminal law: Theory and doctrine (6th ed.). Oxford and London: Hart.Google Scholar
  60. Spinelli, M. G. (2003). Neonaticide: A systematic investigation of 17 cases. In M. G. Spinelli (Ed.), Infanticide: Psychosocial and legal perspectives on mothers who kill (pp. 105–118). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric.Google Scholar
  61. Spinelli, M. G. (2010). Denial of pregnancy: A psychodynamic paradigm. Journal of American Academy of Psychoanalysis, 38(1), 117–131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Temkin, J. (1986). Pre-natal injury, homicide and the draft criminal code. Cambridge Law Review, 45(3), 414–429.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. The Telegraph. (2017). ‘“Insufficient evidence” to charge anyone over baby’s death at vicarage’. The Telegraph (20 March edn). Available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/03/20/insufficient-evidence-charge-anyone-babys-death-vicarage/ (Accessed 15 May 2017).
  64. Vellut, N., Cook, J. M., & Tursz, A. (2012). Analysis of the relationship between neonaticide and denial of pregnancy using data from judicial files. Child Abuse & Neglect, 36(7–8), 553–563.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Walker, N. (1968). Crime and insanity in England: Volume 1, The Historical Perspective. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
  66. Ward, T. (1999). The sad subject of infanticide: Law, medicine and child murder 1860–1938. Social & Legal Studies, 8(2), 163–180.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Wessel, J., Endrikat, J., & Buscher, U. (2002). Frequency of denial of pregnancy: Results and epidemiological significance of a 1-year prospective study in Berlin. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica, 81(11), 1021–1027.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Wilczynski, A. (1997). Child homicide. London: Greenwich Medical Media Ltd.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of LawUniversity of EssexColchesterUK
  2. 2.Department of Criminology and SociologyMiddlesex UniversityLondonUK

Personalised recommendations