Is a Space Interval a Set of Infinite Points? A Very Old Question
In this paper we will address the question whether a space interval is a set of infinite points . It is a very old problem, but despite its age it is still a live issue, and one we have to confront. We will analyze some topics regarding this question using the most influential objections against it, i.e. The Large and the Small paradox (in particular its Small Horn). We will consider classical contemporary reformulations of the argument (Grünbaum in Philosophy of Science 19:280–306, 1952; Grünbaum in Modern science and Zeno’s paradoxes. Allen and Unwin, London, 1968) and the possible ‘solutions’ to it. Finally, we will propose a new formulation of the paradox and analyze its consequences. In particular, we will bring further arguments supporting the standard thesis that it is possible that a segment of space is composed of a non-denumerable set of indivisible 0-length points.
KeywordsZeno’s paradoxes Argument from complete divisibility Large and small paradox Paradox of measure Metrical paradox
We would like to thanks our colleagues from the Department of Mathematics at the Polytechnic University of Milan, from the Department of Philosophy at the University of Bologna, from the Department of Philosophy at the University of Cagliari, and from the Department in Pure and Applied Sciences at the University of Urbino for their helpful comments during the presentations of earlier versions of this paper. In particular we would like to thank Claudio Calosi for his helpful suggestions.
- Aristotle. (1984). On generation and corruption. In A. A. Joachim (Trans.), J. Barnes (Ed.), The complete works of Aristotle. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Arntzenius, F. (2003). Is quantum mechanics pointless? Philosophy of Science, 70(5), 1447–1458.Google Scholar
- Arntzenius, F. (2008). Gunk, topology and measure. In D. Zimmerman (Ed.), Oxford studies in metaphysics (Vol. 4, pp. 225–247).Google Scholar
- Barnes, J. (1982). The presocratic philosophers. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Cantor, G. (1879–1884). Über unendliche lineare Punktmannigfaltigkeiten. In Cantor (1962), Gesammelte Abhandlungen, hrsg. v. E. Zermelo (pp. 139–246). Hildesheim: Olms.Google Scholar
- Fano, V. (2012). I paradossi di Zenone. Roma: Carocci.Google Scholar
- Grünbaum, A. (1968). Modern science and Zeno’s paradoxes. London: Allen and Unwin.Google Scholar
- Huggett, N. (2010). Zeno’s paradoxes. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Summer 2009. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/paradox-zeno/.
- Hurewicz, W., & Wallman, H. (1941). Dimension theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Le, D. (2010). Lebesgue measure. http://zeta.math.utsa.edu/~mqr328/class/real2/L-measure.pdf.
- Makin, S. (1998). Zeno of Elea. In E. Craig (Ed.), Routledge encyclopedia of philosophy (Vol. 10, pp. 843–853). London.Google Scholar
- Russell, J. (2008). The structure of Gunk: Adventures in the ontology of space. In D. Zimmerman (Ed.), Oxford studies in metaphysics (Vol. 4, pp. 248–278). Oxford: University Press.Google Scholar
- Salmon, W. (1975). Space, time and motion. A philosophical introduction. Dickenson, Encino.Google Scholar
- Salzmann, H., Grundhöfer, T., Hähl, H., & Löwen, R. (2007). The classical fields. Structural features of the real and rational numbers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Simplicius. (1989). On Aristotle’s Physics 6, D. Konstan (Trans.), London: Gerald Duckworth & Co. Ltd.Google Scholar
- Simplicius. (1995). On Aristotle’s physics. In S. M. Cohen, P. Curd & C. D. C. Reeve (Eds.), Readings in Ancient Greek Philosophy from Thales to Aristotle (pp. 58–59). Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Co. Inc.Google Scholar
- Skyrms, B. (1983). Zeno’s paradox of measure. In R. S. Cohen & L. Laudan (Eds.), Physics, philosophy and psychoanalysis. Essays in honour of Adolf Grünbaum (pp. 223–254). Reidel, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
- Sorabji, R. (1983). Time, creation and the continuum. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar