Abstract
This chapter analyses the lessons learned from Scottish independence referendum as a model for future referendums held by sub-state national units to decide on their constitutional future, either for Scotland and further afield. It begins by highlighting the main positive aspects of the process. It argues that the Scottish independence referendum was an example of political negotiation and agreement between the Scottish and UK governments that provided a solid legal framework for the referendum, including the setting of a clear, neutral and independently tested question. This enabled an extensive informed and deliberative process focused on the central issue to be decided: independence for Scotland. The chapter then considers two factors that added unnecessary uncertainty to the referendum debate and had an impact on the decisiveness of the outcome. The first was the importance of continuing EU membership for Scotland and the lack of a clear position in EU law on what would happen in the case of a ‘Yes’ vote. The second was the removal of the intermediate option between ‘independence’ and the ‘status quo’ from the ballot paper, despite it being the preferred option of a significant majority of Scottish citizens. The chapter concludes that a clear and effectively neutral position from the EU would be required to avoid this issue affecting the debate and decision on an internal constitutional issue, and that more generally a multi-option referendum may be more suited to providing an encompassing debate on the sub-state national unit’s constitutional future and a more decisive outcome.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
References
Anderson G, Bell C, Craig S, MacHarg A, Mullen T, Tierney S, Walker N (2012) The independence referendum, legality and the contested constitution: widening the debate. UK Constitutional Law Blog. Available at: https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2012/01/31/gavin-anderson-et-al-the-independence-referendum-legality-and-the-contested-constitution-widening-the-debate/
Aroney N (2014) Reserved matters, legislative purpose and the referendum on Scottish independence. Public Law:422–445
BBC (2014) Scottish independence: Barroso says joining EU would be ‘difficult’. BBC News. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-26215963
Boyle A, Crawford J (2013) Opinion: referendum on the independence of Scotland – international law aspects. Annex A. In: UK Government (ed) Scotland analysis: devolution and the implications of Scottish independence. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/scotland-analysis-devolution-and-the-implications-of-scottish-independence
Boyle K, Tierney S (2014) The vow delivered? Experts respond to the recommendations of the Smith Commission. Democratic Audit UK. Available at: http://www.democraticaudit.com/?p=9578
Burgess M, Tarr GA (eds) (2012) Constitutional dynamics in federal systems. Sub-national perspectives. Forum of federations. McGill-Queen’s University Press, Ontario, 352 pp
Carrel S (2016) Second Scottish independence vote not yet on table, says Nicola Sturgeon. The Guardian. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/01/scottish-independence-vote-referendum-off-table-nicola-sturgeon
Carrell S (2012) Barroso casts doubt on independent Scotland’s EU membership rights. The Guardian. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2012/sep/12/barroso-doubt-scotland-eu-membership
Carrell S (2014) Alex Salmond accepts defeat and presses for new Holyrood powers. The Guardian. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/sep/19/alex-salmond-accepts-scotland-independence-defeat-holyrood-powers
Casanas Adam E (2014) Self-determination and the use of referendums: the case of Scotland. Int J Polit Cult Soc 27(1):47–66
Casanas Adam E (2017) The constitutional court of Spain: from system-balancer to centralizing polarist, and now the central state’s enforcer? In: Aroney N, Kinkaid J (eds) Courts in federal countries: federalists or unitarists? University of Toronto Press, Toronto, ON, pp 367–403
Curtice J (2015) Scotland ‘One year On’: the legacy of the independence referendum. Discussion Paper, International Public Policy Institute, University of Strathclyde. Available at: https://pure.strath.ac.uk/portal/files/44366982/Curtice_IPPI2015_scotland_one_year_on_the_legacy_of_the_independence_referendum.pdf
Douglas-Scott S (2014a) How easily could an independent Scotland join the EU? University of Oxford Legal Research Paper Series. Paper No XXX/2014
Douglas-Scott S (2014b) Why the EU should welcome and independent Scotland. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/4041/Sionaidh-Douglas-Scott-Why-the-EU-Should-Welcome-an-Independent-Scotland.aspx
Green H (2014) The Supreme Court upholds referendum ban on prisoner voting. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/3978/Heather-Green-The-Supreme-Court-Upholds-Referendum-Ban-on-Prisoner-Voting.aspx
Hopkins S (2016) Nicola Sturgeon confirms intention to relaunch SNP’s independence campaign. The Huffington Post. Available at: http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/nicola-sturgeon-confirms-intention-to-relaunch-snps-independence-campaign_uk_572f557ae4b0ade291a2027e
Johnson S (2014) Nicola Sturgeon urged to stop referendum ‘betrayal bandwagon’. The Telegraph. Available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/scotland/11170398/Nicola-Sturgeon-urged-to-stop-referendum-betrayal-bandwagon.html
Jovanovik MA (2009) Can constitutions be of use in the resolution of secessionist conflicts. J Int Law Int Rel 5(2):59–87
Keating M (2012) Rethinking sovereignty. Independence-lite, devolution-max and national accommodation. Revista d’Estudis Federals i Autonomics 16:9–29
Keating M (2015) The Scottish independence referendum and after. Revista d’Estudis Federals i Autonomics 21:73–98
Kellner P (2013) EU referendum: provincial England versus London and the Celts. YouGov. Available at: https://yougov.co.uk/news/2016/03/24/eu-referendum-provincial-england-versus-london-and/
McHarg A (2014a) Further devolution and the unionists’ credibility gap. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/3261/Aileen-McHarg-Further-Devolution-and-the-Unionists-Credibility-Gap.aspx
McHarg A (2014b) The vow: vote no for more devo. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/4270/Aileen-McHarg-The-Vow-Vote-No-for-More-Devo.aspx
McHarg A (2014c) The referendum: memorandum agreement and draft section 30 order. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/340/Aileen-McHarg-The-Referendum-Memorandum-of-Agreement-and-Draft-Section-30-Order.aspx
Macnab S (2016a) Nicola Sturgeon: ‘I will win case for independence’. The Scotsman. Available at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/nicola-sturgeon-i-will-win-case-for-independence-1-4105616
Macnab S (2016b) Nicola Sturgeon: Brexit will make Indyref2 ‘highliy likely’. The Scotsman. Available at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/nicola-sturgeon-brexit-will-make-indyref-2-highly-likely-1-4109114
Merrilees I (2014) Excluding Scotland from the EU: definitely difficult; probably impossible. Scottish Constitutional Futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/4234/Ian-Merrilees-Excluding-Scotland-from-the-EU-Definitely-Difficult-Probably-Impossible.aspx
Ormston R, Curtice J (2013) The option not on the table. Attitudes to more devolution. Scotcen Social Research. Available at: http://www.scotcen.org.uk/media/205479/the-option-not-on-the-table-final.pdf
Parliament of Catalonia (2013) Resolution 5/X of the Parliament of Catalonia, adopting the Declaration of sovereignty and of the right to decide of the people of Catalonia. Available at: http://www.parlament.cat/document/intrade/7176
Remirez C (2014) Rajoy: ‘Mientras yo sea presidente del Gobierno, ni se celebrará ese referéndum ilegal ni se fragmentará España. Que quede claro’. El Mundo. Available at: http://www.elmundo.es/espana/2014/01/25/52e3a247e2704e964f8b4570.html
Ridoch L (2013) Uncertainty is a starting point too. The Scotsman. Available at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/lesley-riddoch-uncertainty-is-a-starting-point-too-1-2968882
Scottish Conservatives (2014) Commission on the Future Goverment of Scotland. Available at: http://www.scottishconservatives.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Strathclyde_Commission_14.pdf
Scottish Executive (2007) Choosing Scotland’s future – a national conversation. Available at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2007/08/13103747/0
Scottish Government (2009) Your Scotland your voice. Available at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2009/11/26155932/0
Scottish Government (2010) Scotland’s future: draft referendum (Scotland) Bill Consultation Paper. Available at: http://www.gov.scot/resource/doc/303348/0095138.pdf
Scottish Government (2012) Your Scotland, your referendum. Available at: http://www.gov.scot/Resource/0038/00386122.pdf
Scottish Government (2013a) Scotland’s future: from the referendum to independence and a written constitution. Available at: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/0041/00413757.pdf
Scottish Government (2013b) Scotland’s future. Your guide to an independent Scotland. Available at: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2013/11/9348
Scottish Labour (2014) Powers for a purpose. Strengthening accountability and empowering people. Available at: https://b.3cdn.net/scotlab/c07a7cdb97a522f4c5_h1m6vwh8l.pdf
Scottish Liberal Democrats (2014) Campbell II. The second report of the home and community rule commission. Available at: http://worldofstuart.excellentcontent.com/repository/CampbellIIreport.pdf
Swanson I (2013) Is Salmond only offering us independence-lite? The Scotsman. Available at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/ian-swanson-is-salmond-only-offering-us-independence-lite-1-2948858
The Electoral Commission (2013) Referendum on independence for Scotland: advice of the Electoral Commission on the Proposed Referendum Question. Available at: https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/153691/Referendum-on-independence-for-Scotland-our-advice-on-referendum-question.pdf
Tierney S (2004) Constitutional law and national pluralism. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 392 pp
Tierney S (2007) ‘We the Peoples’: constituent power and constitutionalism in plurinational states. In: Loughlin M, Walker N (eds) The paradox of constitutionalism: constituent power and constitutional form. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 229–246
Tierney S (2012) Constitutional referendums. The theory and practice of republican deliberation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 352 pp
Tierney S (2013a) Legal issues surrounding the referendum on independence for Scotland. Eur Constit Law Rev 3:359–390
Tierney S (2013b) The multi-option referendum: international guidelines, international practice and practical issues. Edinburgh Law School Research Paper Series. No 2013/33. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2328076
Tierney S (2014) ‘And the winner is… .the Referendum’: Scottish Independence and he Deliberative Participation of Citizens. Int’l J Const L Blog. Available at: http://www.iconnectblog.com/2014/09/and-the-winner-is-the-referendum-scottish-independence-and-the-deliberative-participation-of-citizens/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+I-CONnect+%28I-CONnect+Blog%29
Tierney S (2015a) Direct democracy in the United Kingdom: reflections from the Scottish independence referendum. Public Law (4):633–651
Tierney S (2015b) Sovereignty and crimea: how referendum democracy complicates constituent power in multinational societies. Ger Law J 16(3):523–541
Tomkins A (2012) The Scottish parliament and the independence referendum. UK Constitutional Law Blog. Available at: https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2012/01/12/adam-tomkins-the-scottish-parliament-and-the-independence-referendum/
Trench A (2013) Scottish independence: does taking a sterling currency union off the table change the game? UK Constitutional Law Association Blog. Available at: https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2014/02/13/scottish-independence-does-taking-a-sterling-currency-union-off-the-table-change-the-game/
UK Government (2012) Scotland’s constitutional future. Available at: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/39249/Responses_to_Scotlands_Constitutional_Future.pdf
UK Government (2013) Scotland analysis: devolution and the implications of Scottish independence. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/scotland-analysis-devolution-and-the-implications-of-scottish-independence
UK Government (2014) Scottish independence referendum: statement by the Prime Minister. Prime Minister’s Office. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/scottish-independence-referendum-statement-by-the-prime-minister
UK Government and Scottish Government (2012) Agreement between the United Kingdom Government and the Scottish Government on a referendum on independence for Scotland. Available at: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/About/Government/concordats/Referendum-on-independence
Vintro J (2012) Legality and the referendum on independence in Catalonia. Blog del IDP. Available at: http://idpbarcelona.net/docs/blog/legality_referendum.pdf
Walker N (2013) Scotland’s constitutional future: interdependent independence or independent interdependence. Edinburgh Law School Research Paper Series. No 2013/05. Available at: http://www.research.ed.ac.uk/portal/files/14644690/Walker_N_Scotland_s_Constitutional_Future.pdf
Walker N (2014) Hijacking the debate. Scottish constitutional futures Forum Blog. Available at: http://www.scottishconstitutionalfutures.org/OpinionandAnalysis/ViewBlogPost/tabid/1767/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/3068/Neil-Walker-Hijacking-the-Debate.aspx
Walker N (2015) Beyond secession? Law in the framing of the national polity. In: Tierney S (ed) Nationalism and globalisation. Hart, Oxford, pp 155–185
Whitaker A (2014) Independence: Juncker ‘sympathetic’to Scots EU bid. The Scotsman. Available at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/independence-juncker-sympathetic-to-scots-eu-bid-1-3482266
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2019 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Casanas-Adam, E. (2019). The Scottish Independence Referendum: Lessons Learned for the Future. In: López-Basaguren, A., Escajedo San-Epifanio, L. (eds) Claims for Secession and Federalism. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-59707-2_10
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-59707-2_10
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-59706-5
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-59707-2
eBook Packages: Law and CriminologyLaw and Criminology (R0)