Moving Beyond “Illiberal Democracy” in Sub-Saharan Africa: Recalling the Significance of Local Governance

Abstract

The developmental history of today’s liberal-democratic states demonstrates a clear parallel between liberal state practice and functioning local government institutions. This simple fact has implications for today’s policymakers interested in the political liberalization of Sub-Saharan Africa’s newly declared “democracies.” Among the many debates taking place in developmental politics, local governance remains—at best—a niche area that is usually brought up within the context of decentralization policy. Largely due to the recent history of Cold War patronage that focused on central over local government relations, the newly declared democracies of Sub-Saharan Africa consistently rank among the lowest in the world in the yearly indexes on freedom compiled by Freedom House. This chapter argues that if political liberalism is to be realized within these democracies, a renewed emphasis on the role of local government institutions must take place. It emphasizes the recent experience of Zambia, which demonstrates the kinds of internal and external policy challenges that proponents of local governance have faced.

Christopher LaMonica’s major research interests are comparative politics, African politics, and international relations. In this chapter he argues that a renewed emphasis on the role of local government institutions must take place in the newly declared democracies of Sub-Saharan Africa. He uses the recent experience of Zambia to illustrate and support his position.

This article was first published in the African Journal of Political Science and International Relations in July 2015, Vol.9, 7. It has been modified for this book.