Advertisement

Not Quite Wild, But Not Domesticated Either: Contradicting Management Decisions on Free-Ranging Sika Deer (Cervus nippon) at Two Tourism Sites in Japan

  • Rie UsuiEmail author
  • Carolin Funck
Chapter
Part of the Geoheritage, Geoparks and Geotourism book series (GGAG)

Abstract

Previous studies on the conventional form of wildlife tourism have limited the discussion on wildlife management to the context in which wild animals are regarded exclusively as ecologically significant beings. With ever-increasing tourism development around the world, wildlife tourism takes place in a wide range of forms and settings beyond their natural environment. In many Asian countries, where certain species of animals have a long history of close associations with humans, the animals are often found in human modified environments. Thus, their cultural significance is expected to play an important role in management decision-making process. In this chapter, we shift our attention to wild animals whose habitats extensively overlap with human modified space using two case studies from Nara Park and Miyajima Island in Japan. Wild sika deer (Cervus nippon) found in these sites are well-adapted to the human modified environment and have close interactions with humans. A rapid growth in tourism at these locations in modernity created the challenge of managing the deer that hold ecological and cultural values simultaneously. We review the history of deer at each site, their management practices, and challenges that they face. While both Nara and Miyajima deer are considered wild, they are managed in dissimilar manner. We argue that understanding the context of wildlife tourism and the history of the human and animal relationship is a necessary component of more sustainable wildlife management for tourism.

Keywords

Cultural and ecological significance Human environment Habituated deer Wildlife management Wildlife tourism Nara park Miyajima Island Japan 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We sincerely thank all individuals who made our work possible. Special acknowledgement is made to Taoyaka Program Scholarship at Hiroshima University for the financial support throughout my academic career. We would also like to extend our acknowledgement to Dr. Ismar Borges de Lima and Dr. Ronda J. Green for giving us the opportunity to contribute to this book.

References

  1. Apps K, Dimmock K, Lloyd D, Huveneers C (2016) In the water with white sharks (Carcharodon carcharias): participants’ beliefs toward cage-diving in Australia. Anthrozoös 29(2):231–245CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Argüelles MB, Coscarella M, Fazio A, Bertellotti M (2016) Impact of whale-watching on the short-term behavior of southern right whales (Eubalaena australis) in Patagonia, Argentina. Tour Manag Perspect 18:118–124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Asano T (2002) Potential for ecotourism development at Miyajima Island (Miyajima ni okeru ecotourism no kokoromi). Geogr Sci (Chiri-Kagaku) 57(3):194–207 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  4. Asano T, Funck C (2001) Development and alteration of Setouchi tourism region: case studies of Miyajia Island and Shimanami Kaidō (Setouchi kankō chiiki no keisei to henyō: Miyajima to Shimanami Kaidō o jirei toshite). Research enter for Regional geography special publication no. 36 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  5. Bach L, Burton M (2016) Proximity and animal welfare in the context of tourist interactions with habituated dolphins. J Sustain Tour, pp 1–17Google Scholar
  6. Burgin S, Hardiman N (2016) Crocodiles and grey nomads: a deadly combination? Curr Iss Tour 19(1):60–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. City of Nara (2014) Report of incoming tourists of Nara City (Nara-shi kankō irikomikyakusū chōsa hōkoku). http://www.city.nara.lg.jp/www/contents/1347582712483/files/H26.pdf. Accessed 23 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  8. Cong L, Newsome D, Wu B, Morrison AM (2014a) Wildlife tourism in China: a review of the Chinese research literature. Curr Iss Tour, pp 1–24. doi: 10.1080/13683500.2014.948811
  9. Cong L, Wu B, Morrison AM, Shu H, Wang M (2014b) Analysis of wildlife tourism experiences with endangered species: an exploratory study of encounters with giant pandas in Chengdu, China. Tour Manag 40:300–310Google Scholar
  10. Foundation for the Protection of Deer in Nara (2010) Nara no shika: “shika no kuni” no hajimete no hon. Keihanna Jōhō Kyōiku Shuppan, JapanGoogle Scholar
  11. Foundation for the Protection of Deer in Nara (2015) Nara deer population census of 2015 fiscal year. (Heisē 27 nendo “Nara no sika” seisoku tōsū chōsa). http://naradeer.com/common/img/aboutnaradeer/naratousu.pdf. Accessed 23 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  12. Foundation for the Protection of Deer in Nara (2016) Problems. http://naradeer.com/problems/index.html. Accessed 23 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  13. Fuentes A, Shaw E, Cortes J (2007) Qualitative assessment of macaque tourist sites in Padangtegal, Bali, Indonesia, and the Upper Rock Nature Reserve, Gibraltar. Int J Primatol 28:1143–1158Google Scholar
  14. Fukuda N (1973) Itsukushima Zue. Miyajima Town, Japan (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  15. Funck C (2013) International and Japanese tourists’ behaviors at Miyajima Island. (Miyajima ni okeru gaikokujin to nihonjin kankōkyaku no kōdō). Studies of the Itsukushima Island (World Heritage Itsukushima, History and Culture of the Inland Sea Projects Research Center) 9:(1)–(12) (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  16. Funck C, Maruyama N (2011) Nature-based tourism at Miyajima Island and Mt. Misen (Miyajima to Misen ni okeru shizen kankō). Studies of the Itsukushima Island (World heritage Itsukushima, history and culture of the inland sea projects research center) 7:(1)–(12) (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  17. Granquist SM, Nilsson PÅ (2016) Who’s watching whom?—An interdisciplinary approach to the study of seal-watching tourism in Iceland. J Clean Prod 111:471–478CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Hatakama K (2010) From emergence of Nara deer to antler cutting. (Shinroku no tanjō kara tsunokiri e). In: Nagano H (ed) Nara deer: the first book of the deer kingdom (Nara no sika: “sika no kuni” hajimete no hon). Keihan Nara Jōhō Kyōiku Shuppan, Japan, pp 103–170 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  19. Hatsukaichi City (2008) Miyajima region deer protection management planning. https://www.city.hatsukaichi.hiroshima.jp/uploaded/attachment/8228.pdf. Accessed 31 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  20. Hatsukaichi City (2014) Miyajima region deer protection management planning (second term). https://www.city.hatsukaichi.hiroshima.jp/uploaded/attachment/8229.pdf. Accessed 31 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  21. Hatsukaichi City (2016a) National census (Kokuzei chōsa). https://www.city.hatsukaichi.hiroshima.jp/soshiki/10/10962.html. Accessed June 4 2016 (in Japanese)
  22. Hatsukaichi City (2016b) Miyajima incoming tourists chart (Miyajima raitōshasū ichiranhyō). https://www.city.hatsukaichi.hiroshima.jp/uploaded/attachment/12566.pdf. Accessed June 4 2016 (in Japanese)
  23. Hill M (1997) The policy process in the modern state. Prentice-Hall, LondonGoogle Scholar
  24. Hiroshima Prefectural Art Museum (2012) Interesting details of Itsukushima Zubyōbu (4) and (5). http://www.hpam.jp/blog/?p=3885. Accessed June 23 2016
  25. Hiroshima Prefecture (2011) Hunting license. https://www.pref.hiroshima.lg.jp/site/huntinglicense/hunter-map.html. Accessed 5 June 2016 (in Japanese)
  26. Ikeda S (2010) Visiting Foundation For Protection of the Deer in Nara (“Nara no sika aigokai” o tazunete). In: Nagano H (ed) Nara deer: the first book of the deer kingdom (Nara no sika: “sika no kuni” hajimete no hon). Keihan Nara Jōhō Kyōiku Shuppan, Japan, pp 13–58 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  27. Ikeya K (2009) From the principle of exclusion to the principle of coexistence: a new relationship concerning wildlife protection area (Haijo no ronri kara kyōzon no ronri e—doubutsu hogoku o meguru aratana kankei). In: Ikeya K, Hayashi Y (eds) Human-animal relationship studies the fourth edition: wild and environment (Hito to doubutsu no kankeigaku dai 4 kan: yasei to kankyō). Iwanami Shoten, Tokyo, pp 296–319 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  28. Knight J (2011) Herding monkeys to paradise: how macaque troops are managed for tourism in Japan. Brill, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Kurita H (2012) Provisioning and tourism in free-ranging Japanese macaques. In: Russon AE, Wallis J (eds) Primate tourism: a tool for conservation?. Cambridge University Press, UK, pp 44–55Google Scholar
  30. Lemelin RH (2015) From the recreational fringe to mainstream leisure: the evolution and diversification of entomotourism. In: Markwell K (ed) Animals and tourism: understanding diverse relationships. Channel View Publications, Bristol, pp 229–239Google Scholar
  31. Maesako Y (2002) Ecological issues relating to the conservation of Sika deer (Cervus nippon TEMMINCK) and the warm-temperature evergreen forest on Mt. Kasugayama, Nara, Japan. Vegetation Sci 19:61–67 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  32. Miyajima Tourism Association (2009) Home. http://www.miyajima.or.jp/english/index.html. Accesed 4 June 2016
  33. Nara Deer Supporters Club (2016) Q&A. http://www.shikasapo.jp/qa.html. Accessed 4 June 2016 (in Japanese)
  34. Nara Prefecture (2016a) About deer. http://www.pref.nara.jp/5819.htm. Accessed 23 May 2016 (in Japanese)
  35. Nara Prefecture (2016b) Nara deer conservation management plan discussion committee. http://www.pref.nara.jp/33948.htm. Accessed 2 June 2016 (in Japanese)
  36. Newsome D, Dowling RK, Moore SA (2005) Wildlife tourism. Channel View Publications, ClevedonGoogle Scholar
  37. Official Website of Miyajima Tourism (2016) Summary of Miyajima history (Miyajima rekishi gaiyō). Accessed 12 June 2016. http://www.miyajima-wch.jp/index.html
  38. Okuda T (1984) Food habits of sika deer (Cervus nippon) and their ecological influence on the vegetation of Miyajima Island. Hikobia Suppl 9:93–102Google Scholar
  39. Orams MB (1996) A conceptual model of tourist-wildlife interaction: the case for education as a management strategy. Aust Geogr 27:39–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Orams MB (2002) Feeding wildlife as a tourism attraction: a review of issues and impacts. Tour Manag 23(3):281–293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Paksuz S, Özkan B (2012) The protection of the bat community in the Dupnisa Cave System, Turkey, following opening for tourism. Oryx 46:130–136Google Scholar
  42. Ponting HG (2005) Enoura bay and Miyajima Island (Enourawan to Miyajima). In: In Lotus-land Japan (Translated by Nagaoka S. Kodansha Academic Library, Tokyo), pp 302–323Google Scholar
  43. Qingming C, Gonggang X, Wall G (2012) A cultural perspective on wildlife tourism in China. Tour Recreat Res 37(1):27–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. ‘Revival of Miyajima’ (1966) Chūgoku Shinbun, 18 Sept, p 14 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  45. Ruesto LA, Sheeran LK, Matheson MD, Li JH, Wagner RS (2010) Tourist behavior and decibel levels correlate with threat frequency in Tibetan macaques (Macaca thibetana) at Mt. Huangshan, China. Primate Conserv 25:99–104CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Saarinen J (2016) Wilderness use, conservation and tourism: what do we protect and for and from whom? Tour Geogr 18(1):1–8. doi: 10.1080/14616688.2015.1116599
  47. Sinha BC, Sinha SP (2008) Impact of religious tourism on Gir National Park, Gujarat, India. Indian Forester 134(5–8):667–673Google Scholar
  48. Smith H, Samuels A, Bradley S (2008) Reducing risky interactions between tourists and free-ranging dolphins (Tursiops sp.) in an artificial feeding program at Monkey Mia, Western Australia. Tour Manag 29(5):994–1001. doi: 10.1016/j.tourman.2008.01.001
  49. Takahashi S (1999) People’s attitudes and feelings towards deer in Nara Park. Sōgō Kenkyūsho Shohō, pp 91–100 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  50. Takeda Y (2010) The deer crackers that deer beg to get are additives-free and high quality (Shika mo atama o sagete hoshigaru shikasenbei wa mutenka yūryōhin nanoda). In: Nagano H (ed) Nara deer: the first book of the deer kingdom (Nara no sika: “sika no kuni” hajimete no hon). Keihan Nara Jōhō Kyōiku Shuppan, Japan, pp 59–68 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  51. Torii H, Tatsuzawa S (2009) Sika deer in Nara Park: unique human-wildlife relations. In: McCullough DR, Takatsuki S, Kaji K (eds) Sika deer: biology and management of native and introduced populations. Springer, Tokyo, pp p347–p363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. UNESCO (2016) Historic monuments of ancient Nara. http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/870/. Accessed 23 May 2016
  53. Usui R, Sheeran LK, Li JH, Sun L, Wang X, Pritchard AJ, DuVall-Lash AS, Wagner RS (2014) Park rangers’ behaviors and their effects on tourists and Tibetan macaques (Macaca thibetana) at Mt. Huangshan, China. Animals 4(3):546–561. doi: 10.3390/ani4030546
  54. Watanabe S (2001) Dealing with the damage to the crops cause by a protected animal: a case with “Nara-no-shika” authorized as a national monument. Jpn Assoc Environ Sociol, pp 129–144 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  55. Watanabe S (2007) Idea and reality in measures of agricultural damage by NARA-NO-SHIKA -based on the questionnaire survey to the farmer around Nara Park- Bullten of Center for Natural Environment Education. Nara University of Education (Nara Kyōiku Daigaku Fuzoku Shizen Kankyō Kyōiku Sentā Kiyō) 8:23–41 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  56. Watanabe S (2010) Nara deer in modern days: seeking for “coexistence” and challenges (Kindai ni okeru Nara no sika: “kyōzon” e no mosaku to kon’nan). In: Nagano H (ed) Nara deer: the first book of the deer kingdom (Nara no sika: “sika no kuni” hajimete no hon). Keihan Nara Jōhō Kyōiku Shuppan, Japan, pp 171–214 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  57. Watanabe S (2012) The problems about provisions and capture in “free-randing” animals—why are there two provisions concerning the “Deer of Nara”? Bull Nara Univ Educ 61(1):109–119 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  58. ‘We often hear’ (2010) Asahi Shinbun digital. http://www.asahi.com/kansai/travel/news/OSK201002190061.html. Accessed 21 June 2016 (in Japanese)
  59. Wheatly BP (1999) The sacred monkeys of Bali. Waveland Press, IllinoisGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Graduate School of Integrated Arts and SciencesHiroshima UniversityHigashihiroshimaJapan

Personalised recommendations