Advertisement

Ethics and Responsibility in Wildlife Tourism: Lessons from Compassionate Conservation in the Anthropocene

  • Georgette Leah BurnsEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Geoheritage, Geoparks and Geotourism book series (GGAG)

Abstract

Whether captive or non-captive, consumptive or non-consumptive, targeted or non-targeted, guided or non-guided, wildlife tourism activities have traditionally been dominated by an anthropocentric worldview that recognizes wildlife only for its extrinsic value. This chapter argues that the advent of the Anthropocene provides an opportunity for humans to accept responsibility for how they engage with animals in tourism settings and ethically reassess this engagement. Reviewing theories of ethics dealing with animals, tourism, the environment and conservation, the conclusion is drawn that in order to effectively manage wildlife tourism for the equitable benefit of both humans and wildlife, and thus create a viable wildlife tourism ethic, valuable lessons can be extracted from an approach that embodies compassionate conservation.

Keywords

Ethics Responsibility Wildlife tourism Management Compassionate Conservation Anthropocene 

References

  1. ABC (Australian Broadcasting Commission) (2016) Hunter who killed black bear with spear and left it to die overnight could face charges, 17 August 2016. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-17/outcry-over-spear-hunted-bear/7750326
  2. Ballantyne R, Packer J, Falk J (2011) Visitors’ learning for environmental sustainability: testing short-and long-term impacts of wildlife tourism experiences using structural equation modeling. Tour Manage 32(6):1243–1252Google Scholar
  3. Ballantyne R, Packer J, Hughes K (2009) Tourists’ support for conservation message and sustainable management practices in wildlife tourism experiences. Tour Manage 30(5):658–664CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Ballantyne R, Packer J, Hughes K, Dierking L (2007) Conservation learning in wildlife tourism settings: lessons from research in zoos and aquariums. Environ Educ Res 13(3):367–383CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bekoff M (2010) First do no harm. New Scientist, August 24–25Google Scholar
  6. Bekoff M, Jamieson D (1996) Ethics and the study of carnivores: doing science while respecting animals. In: Gittleman JL (ed) Carnivore behavior, ecology, and evolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 15–45Google Scholar
  7. Bekoff M, Nystrom J (2004) The other side of silence: Rachel Carson’s views of animals. Zygon 39(4):861–883CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bekoff M, Ramp D (2014) Cruel to be kind. New Scientist, June 26–27Google Scholar
  9. Bock B, Buller H (2013) Healthy, happy and humane: evidence in farm animal welfare policy. Sociologia Ruralis 53(3):390–411CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bruni CM, Fraser J, Schultz PW (2008) The value of zoo experience for connecting people with nature. Visitor Stud 11(2):139–150CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Burns GL (2004) The host community and wildlife tourism. In: Higginbottom K (ed) Wildlife tourism: impacts, management and Planning. Common Ground Publishing, Altona, pp 125–144Google Scholar
  12. Burns GL (2014) Animals and anthropomorphism in the Anthropocene. In: Burns GL, Paterson M (eds) Engaging with animals: interpretations of a shared existence. Sydney University Press, Sydney, pp 3–20Google Scholar
  13. Burns GL (2015a) Ethics in tourism. In: Hall CM, Gössling S, Scott D (eds) The Routledge handbook of tourism and sustainability. Routledge, London, pp 117–126Google Scholar
  14. Burns GL (2015b) Animals as tourism objects: Ethically refocusing relationships between tourists and wildlife. In: Markwell K (ed) Animals and tourism: understanding diverse relationships. Channel View Publications, Bristol, pp 44–59Google Scholar
  15. Burns GL, Howard P (2003) When wildlife tourism goes wrong: a case study of stakeholder and management issues regarding Dingoes on Fraser Island. Aust Tourism Manage 24(6):699–712CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Burns GL, Macbeth J, Moore S (2011) Should dingoes die? Principles for engaging ecocentric ethics in wildlife tourism management. J Ecotourism 10(3):179–196CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Burns GL, Paterson M (2014) Introduction. In: Burns GL, Paterson M (eds) Engaging with animals: Interpretations of a shared existence. Sydney University Press, Sydney, pp ix–xivGoogle Scholar
  18. Carr N, Cohen S (2011) The public face of zoos: images of entertainment, education, and conservation. Anthrozoos 24(2):175–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Carrington D (2014) Earth has lost half of its wildlife in the last 40 years, says WWF. Guardian. 30 Sept 2014. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/sep/29/earth-lost-50-wildlife-in-40-years-wwf
  20. Ceballos G, Garcia A, Ehrlich P (2010) The sixth extinction crisis: loss of animal populations and species. J Cosmol 8:1821–1831Google Scholar
  21. Ceballos G, Ehrlich PR, Barnosky AD, Garcia A, Pringle RM, Palmer TM (2015) Accelerated modern human-induced species losses: Entering the sixth mass extinction. Sci Adv 1(5):1–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Dawson J, Johnston MJ, Stewart EJ, Lemieux CJ, Lemelin RH, Maher PT, Grimwood BSR (2011) Ethical considerations of last chance tourism. J Ecotourism 10(3):250–265CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dobson J (2011) Towards a utilitarian ethic for marine wildlife tourism. Tourism Mar Environ 7(3–4):213–222CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Dorresteijn I, Schultner J, Nimmo DG, Fischer J, Hanspach J, Kuemmerle T, Kehoe L, Ritchie EG (2015) Incorporating anthropogenic effects into trophic ecology: predator-prey interactions in a human-dominated landscape. Proc Bio Sci 282(1814):301–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Draper C, Bekoff (2013) Animal welfare and the importance of compassionate conservation—a comment on McMahon et al. 2012. Biol Conserv 158: 422–423Google Scholar
  26. Fennell DA (2006) Tourism ethics. Channel View Publications, ClevedonGoogle Scholar
  27. Fennell DA (2012) Tourism and animal ethics. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  28. Fennell DA (2015a) The status of animal ethics research in tourism. In: Markwell K (ed) Animals and tourism: understanding diverse relationships. Channel View Publications, Bristol, pp 27–43Google Scholar
  29. Fennell DA (2015b) Tourism and the precautionary principle in theory and practice. In: Hall CM, Gössling S, Scott D (eds) The Routledge handbook of tourism and sustainability. Routledge, London, pp 67–77Google Scholar
  30. Fox CH, Bekoff M (2011) Integrating values and ethics into wildlife policy and management—Lessons from North America. Animals 1(4):126–143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Frost W (2011) Zoos and tourism: conservation, education, entertainment? Channel View Publications, BristolGoogle Scholar
  32. Fulton D, Manfredo M, Lipscomb J (1996) Wildlife value orientations: a conceptual and measurement framework. Human Dimensions Wildlife 1(2):24–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Gamborg C, Palmer C, Sandoe P (2012) Ethics of wildlife management and conservation: what should we try to protect? Nature Edu Know 3(10):8Google Scholar
  34. Garner R (1993) Political animals: a survey of the animal protection movement in Britain. Parliamentary Affairs 46(3):333–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Gascon C, Brooks TM, Contreras-MacBeath T, Heard N, Konstant W, Lamoreux J, Vié JC (2015) The importance and benefits of species. Curr Biol 25(10):431–438CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Gore ML, Nelson MP, Vucetich JA, Smith A, Clark M (2011) Exploring the ethical basis for conservation policy: the case of inbred wolves on Isle Royale, USA. Conserv Lett 4:394–401CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Gössling S, Hall CM (eds) (2006) Tourism and global environmental change: ecological, social, economic and political interrelationships. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  38. Granquist SM, Sigurjonsdottir H (2014) The effect of land based seal watching tourism on the haul-out behaviour of harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) in Iceland. Appl Animal Behav Sci 156:85–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Green R, Giese M (2004) Negative effects of wildlife tourism on wildlife. In: Higginbottom K (ed) Wildlife tourism: impacts, management and planning. Common Ground Publishing, Altona, pp 81–98Google Scholar
  40. Gusset M, Dick G (2010) ‘Building a Future for Wildlife’? Evaluating the contribution of the world zoo and aquarium community to in situ conservation. Int Zoo Year Book 44:183–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hadidian J, Fox CH, Lynn WS (2006) The ethics of wildlife control in humanized landscapes. In: Timm RM, O’Brien JM (eds) Proceedings of the 22nd Vertebrate Pest Conference. University of California, Davis, pp 500–504Google Scholar
  42. Hardin G (1968) Tragedy of the commons. Science 162(3859):1243–1248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Higginbottom K (ed) (2004a) Wildlife tourism: Impacts, management and planning. Common Ground Publishing, AltonaGoogle Scholar
  44. Higginbottom K (2004b) Managing impacts of wildlife tourism on wildlife. In: Higginbottom K (ed) Wildlife tourism: impacts, management and planning. Common Ground Publishing, Altona, pp 211–230Google Scholar
  45. Higginbottom K, Tribe A (2004) Contributions of wildlife tourism to conservation. In: Higginbottom K (ed) Wildlife tourism: impacts, management and Planning. Common Ground Publishing, Altona, pp 99–124Google Scholar
  46. Higham J, Hopkins D (2015) Wildlife tourism: “call it consumption”. In: Hall CM, Gössling S, Scott D (eds) The Routledge handbook of tourism and sustainability. Routledge, London, pp 280–293Google Scholar
  47. Higham J, Shelton EJ (2011) Tourism and wildlife habituation: reduced population fitness or cessation of impact? Tour Manag 32(6):1290–1298CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Holden A (2005) Achieving a sustainable relationship between common pool resources and tourism: the role of environmental ethics. J Sustain Tourism 13(4):339–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Jafari J (1990) The Basis of tourism education. J Tourism Stud 1:33–41Google Scholar
  50. Jafari J (2001) The Scientification of tourism. In: Smith V, Brent M (eds) Hosts and guests revisited: Tourism issues of the 21st Century. Cognizant Communications, Elmsford, pp 28–41Google Scholar
  51. Jóhannesson GT, Huijbens EH (2010) Tourism in times of crisis: exploring the discourse of tourism development in Iceland. Curr Issues Tourism 13:419–434CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Kellert SR (1985) Public perceptions of predators, particularly the Wolf and Coyote. Biol Conserv 31:167–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Kellert SR (2003) Kinship to mastery: Biophilia in human evolution and development. Island Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  54. Lewis P-M, Burns GL, Jones D (2016) Response and responsibility: Humans as apex predators and ethical actors in a changing societal environment. Food WebsGoogle Scholar
  55. Littin KE, Mellor DJ, Warburton B, Eason CT (2004) Animal welfare and ethical issues relevant to the humane control of vertebrate pests. New Zealand Vet J 52(1):1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Littin KE, Mellor DJ (2005) Strategic animal welfare issues: Ethical and animal welfare issues arising from the killing of wildlife for disease control and environmental reasons. Rev Sci Tech (Int Off Epizootics) 24(2):767–782CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Lovelock B, Lovelock KM (2013) The Ethics of tourism: critical and applied perspectives. Routledge, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  58. Manfredo MJ (1989) Human dimensions of wildlife. Wildl Soc Bull 17(4):447–449Google Scholar
  59. Manfredo MJ (2008) Who cares about wildlife? Social science concepts for exploring human-wildlife relationships and conservation issues. Springer, Fort CollinsGoogle Scholar
  60. Manfredo MJ, Teel TL, Bright AD (2003) Why are public values toward wildlife changing? Human Dimensions Wildlife 8:287–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Manfredo MJ, Teel TL, Bright AD (2004) Application of the concepts of values and attitudes in human dimensions of natural resources research. In: Manfredo MJ, Vaske JJ, Field D, Brown PJ (eds) Society and Natural Resources: a summary of knowledge prepared for the 10th International Symposium on Society and Natural Resources. Jefferson, MO, Modern Litho, pp 271–282Google Scholar
  62. Manfredo MJ, Teel TL, Zinn HC (2009) Understanding global values toward wildlife. In: Manfredo MJ, Vaske JJ, Brown PJ, Decker DJ, Duke EA (eds) Wildlife and society: The Science of human dimensions. Island Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  63. Marschall S, Granquist S, Burns GL (2017) Interpretation in wildlife tourism: Assessing the effectiveness of signage to modify visitor behaviour at a seal watching site in Iceland. J Outdoor Recreation Tourism 17:11–19Google Scholar
  64. Mason P (2000) Zoo tourism: the need for more research. J Sust Tourism 8:333–339CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Macbeth J (2006) Towards an ethics platform for tourism. Annals Tourism Res 32(4):962–984CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. MacClellan J (2013) How (not) to defend a Rawlsian approach to intergenerational ethics. Ethics Environ 18(1):67–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Minteer B (2011) Refounding environmental ethics: Pragmatism, principle, and practice. Temple University Press, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  68. Moore S, Rodger K (2010) Wildlife as a common pool resource issue: enabling conditions for sustainability governance. J Sustain Tourism 18(7):831–844CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Moore, RS, Wihermanto, Nekaris, KAI (2014) Compassionate conservation, rehabilitation and translocation of Indonesian slow lorises. Endangered Species Res 26:93–102Google Scholar
  70. Moscardo G, Woods B, Saltzer R (2004) The Role of interpretation in wildlife tourism. In: Higginbottom K (ed) Wildlife tourism: Impacts, management and planning. Common Ground Publishing, Altona, pp 231–251Google Scholar
  71. Nelson MP, Bruskotter JT, Vucetich JA, Chapron G (2016) Emotions and the ethics of consequence in conservation decisions: Lessons from Cecil the Lion. Conserv Lett 9(4):302–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Newsome D, Dowling R, Moore S (2005) Wildlife tourism. Channel View Publications, ClevedonGoogle Scholar
  73. Newsome D, Rodger K (2007) Impacts of tourism on pinnipeds and implications for tourism management. In: Higham J, Lück M (eds) Marine wildlife and tourism management: insights from the natural and social sciences. CABI, Oxfordshire, pp 182–205CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Óladóttir O (2016) Tourism in Iceland in figures—May 2016. Icelandic Tourist Board, ReykjavikGoogle Scholar
  75. Ostrom E, Burger J, Field CB, Norgaard RB, Policansky D (1999) Revisiting the commons: local lessons, global challenges. Science 284:278–282CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Ragnarsson A (2015) Norðurland Vestra, Stöðugreining 2014 [Northwest Status Analysis 2014]. Byggðastofnun, IcelandGoogle Scholar
  77. Ramp D (2013) Bringing compassion to the ethical dilemma in killing kangaroos for conservation: comment on “Conservation through sustainable use” by Rob Irvine. J Bioethical Inquiry 10(2):267–272CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Ramp D, Bekoff M (2015) Compassion as a practical and evolved ethic for conservation. Bioscience 65:323–327CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Regan T (2001) Defending animal rights. University of Illinois Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  80. Regan T (2004) The Case for animal rights: Updated with a new preface. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  81. Shackley M (1996) Wildlife tourism. International Thomson Business Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  82. Singer P (1975) Animal liberation: a new ethics for our treatment of animals. Harper Collins, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  83. Singer P (ed) (2005) In defense of animals: the second wave. Blackwell, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  84. Skibins JC, Powell RB (2013) Conservation caring: measuring the influence of zoo visitors` connection to wildlife on pro-conservation behaviors. Zoo Biology 32:528–540CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Soulé M (1985) What is conservation biology? Bioscience 35(11):727–734CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Teel TL, Manfredo M (2009) Linking society and environment: a multi-level model of shifting wildlife value orientations in the western U.S. Soc Sci Q 90(2):407–427CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Tribe A, Booth R (2003) Assessing the role of zoos in wildlife conservation. Human Dimensions Wildlife 8(1):65–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Vaske JJ, Shelby LB, Manfredo MJ (2006) Bibliometric reflections on the first decade of human dimensions of wildlife. Human Dimensions Wildlife 11(2):79–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Wallach AD, Bekoff M, Nelson PM, Ramp D (2015) Promoting predators and compassionate conservation. Conserv Biol 29(5):1481–1484CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. White L (1967) The Historical roots of our ecological crisis. Science 155(3767):1203–1207CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Þórisson SL (2017) Selasetur Íslands Annual Report 2016. Icelandic Seal Center, HvammstangiGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Environmental Futures Research Institute and Faculty of Environmental ScienceGriffith UniversityNathanAustralia

Personalised recommendations