A Simple Metaheuristic for the FleetSize and Mix Problem with TimeWindows

Bräysy, Olli; Dullaert, Wout; Porkka, Pasi P.

doi:10.1007/978-3-319-54490-8_4

Olli Bräysy⁷,
Wout Dullaert⁸ &
Pasi P. Porkka⁹

Part of the book series: Computational Methods in Applied Sciences ((COMPUTMETHODS,volume 45))

Included in the following conference series:

European Congress on Computational Methods in Applied Sciences and Engineering

770 Accesses

Abstract

This paper presents a powerful new single-parameter metaheuristic to solve the Fleet Size and Mix Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows. The key idea of the new metaheuristic is to perform a random number of random-sized jumps in random order through four well-known local search operators. Computational testing on the 600 large-scale benchmarks of Bräysy et al. (Expert Syst Appl 36(4):8460–8475, 2009) show that the new metaheuristic outperforms previous best approaches, finding 533 new best-known solutions. Despite the significant number of random components, it is demonstrated that the variance of the results is rather low. Moreover, the suggested metaheuristic is shown to scale almost linearly up to 1000 customers.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this chapter

Log in via an institution

Chapter: USD 29.95; Price excludes VAT (USA)

eBook: USD 109.00; Price excludes VAT (USA)

Softcover Book: USD 139.99; Price excludes VAT (USA)

Hardcover Book: USD 139.99; Price excludes VAT (USA)

Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout

Purchases are for personal use only

Institutional subscriptions

References

Baldacci R, Battarra M, Vigo D (2008) Routing a heterogeneous fleet of vehicles. In: The vehicle routing problem: latest advances and new challenges. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 3–27
Google Scholar
Bräysy O (2003) A reactive variable neighborhood search for the vehicle-routing problem with time windows. INFORMS J Comput 15(4):347–368
Article MathSciNet MATH Google Scholar
Bräysy O, Dullaert W, Hasle G, Mester D, Gendreau M (2008) An effective multirestart deterministic annealing metaheuristic for the fleet size and mix vehicle-routing problem with time windows. Transp Sci 42(3):371–386
Article Google Scholar
Bräysy O, Porkka PP, Dullaert W, Repoussis PP, Tarantilis CD (2009) A well-scalable metaheuristic for the fleet size and mix vehicle routing problem with time windows. Expert Syst Appl 36(4):8460–8475
Article Google Scholar
Campbell AM, Savelsbergh M (2004) Efficient insertion heuristics for vehicle routing and scheduling problems. Transp sci 38(3):369–378
Article Google Scholar
Clarke GU, Wright JW (1964) Scheduling of vehicles from a central depot to a number of delivery points. Oper Res 12(4):568–581
Article Google Scholar
Gehring H, Homberger J (1999) A parallel hybrid evolutionary metaheuristic for the vehicle routing problem with time windows. In: Proceedings of EUROGEN99, vol. 2. Citeseer
Google Scholar
Gendreau M, Potvin J-Y, Bräumlaysy O, Hasle G, Løkketangen A (2008) Metaheuristics for the vehicle routing problem and its extensions: a categorized bibliography. In: The vehicle routing problem: latest advances and new challenges. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 143–169
Google Scholar
Kirkpatrick S, Gelatt CD, Vecchi MP et al (1983) Optimization by simmulated annealing. Science 220(4598):671–680
Article MathSciNet MATH Google Scholar
Kytöjoki J, Nuortio T, Bräysy O, Gendreau M (2007) An efficient variable neighborhood search heuristic for very large scale vehicle routing problems. Comput Oper Res 34(9):2743–2757
Article MATH Google Scholar
Liu F-H, Shen S-Y (1999) The fleet size and mix vehicle routing problem with time windows. J Oper Res Soc 50(7):721–732
Article MATH Google Scholar
Or I (1976) Traveling salesman-type combinatorial problems and their relation to the logistics of regional blood banking. Xerox University Microfilms
Google Scholar
Solomon MM (1987) Algorithms for the vehicle routing and scheduling problems with time window constraints. Oper Res 35(2):254–265
Article MathSciNet MATH Google Scholar

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, P.O. Box 35, FI-40014, Jyväskylä, Finland
Olli Bräysy
Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, VU University Amsterdam, De Boelelaan 1105, 1081 HV, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Wout Dullaert
Justecon Oy, Fredrikinkatu 64 b 22, 00100, Helsinki, Finland
Pasi P. Porkka

Authors

Olli Bräysy
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Wout Dullaert
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Pasi P. Porkka
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Olli Bräysy .

Editor information

Editors and Affiliations

CIMNE, International Center for Numerical Methods in Engineering, Barcelona, Spain
Pedro Diez
Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland
Pekka Neittaanmäki
Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland
Jacques Periaux
Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland
Tero Tuovinen
Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland
Olli Bräysy

Appendix

Data set	MSDAL		Normal		New		Data set	MSDAL		Normal		New
Data set	Best	CPU	Best	CPU	Best	CPU	Data set	Best	CPU	Best	CPU	Best	CPU
C121A	17478.35	95.30	17456.15	7.55	16146.77	14.32	C121C	4216.08	106.09	4216.08	8.34	3801.05	19.15
C122A	17056.41	96.25	17095.62	7.58	16929.05	10.69	C122C	4165.48	119.16	4164.70	7.58	4162.99	13.53
C123A	16897.70	92.95	16820.15	7.86	16629.48	14.45	C123C	4104.72	114.55	4093.93	8.72	4068.95	14.80
C124A	16563.86	95.13	16529.97	6.58	16364.38	16.10	C124C	4009.70	108.95	3988.11	7.89	3966.33	15.27
C125A	17452.85	108.22	17450.12	6.91	17311.40	8.07	C125C	4210.44	114.11	4210.35	7.58	4210.35	8.85
C126A	17528.25	114.49	17466.85	8.09	17407.42	10.83	C126C	4210.35	108.91	4210.35	8.47	4210.35	10.17
C127A	17539.70	106.81	17427.81	7.80	17280.28	10.31	C127C	4196.00	125.78	4191.71	7.84	4191.71	9.69
C128A	17366.06	107.13	17284.68	9.03	17118.19	11.56	C128C	4165.85	121.14	4169.79	7.84	4165.50	12.64
C129A	16963.26	85.86	17018.38	7.64	16810.15	12.17	C129C	4106.18	131.17	4086.01	7.31	4069.22	10.39
C1210A	16884.73	102.50	16749.52	7.41	16618.35	12.90	C1210C	4051.22	102.95	4038.56	8.11	4001.34	13.67
C221A	17787.35	69.27	17901.59	6.53	17281.46	8.10	C221C	3530.70	82.17	3547.22	7.75	3533.53	9.31
C222A	17591.14	54.52	17649.04	6.09	16955.05	9.81	C222C	3465.22	70.08	3462.97	7.39	3420.01	8.30
C223A	17139.14	62.72	16984.26	6.28	16946.04	12.50	C223C	3397.72	75.94	3396.56	7.05	3356.29	11.69
C224A	17048.28	86.38	17177.17	5.83	16823.39	9.21	C224C	3381.71	89.45	3333.64	6.83	3294.95	10.81
C225A	17627.05	58.06	17567.03	6.14	17175.93	9.34	C225C	3483.03	67.34	3496.70	7.14	3462.77	7.74
C226A	17321.54	65.31	17415.59	6.25	16999.21	6.19	C226C	3447.47	74.23	3439.13	7.39	3415.59	7.30
C227A	17496.18	66.75	17477.99	6.38	17015.52	8.08	C227C	3507.58	67.89	3491.72	7.11	3419.37	10.05
C228A	17399.34	60.69	17177.48	7.31	16890.76	8.96	C228C	3451.61	69.92	3425.01	7.58	3372.27	7.27
C229A	17600.02	62.81	17478.95	5.98	16991.30	9.88	C229C	3481.13	78.67	3439.75	7.06	3415.39	9.39
C2210A	17324.16	63.83	17024.78	6.19	16805.04	10.28	C2210C	3363.75	68.09	3408.34	6.92	3334.50	6.49
R121A	13904.64	90.36	13897.19	5.78	13790.32	9.19	R121C	5713.38	100.48	5700.76	6.03	5669.65	9.67
R122A	12467.81	84.94	12367.64	7.36	12234.33	11.59	R122C	4931.09	85.88	4889.25	7.59	4833.51	14.40
R123A	11207.92	80.00	11122.32	6.80	11026.50	12.98	R123C	4211.11	85.06	4125.01	7.48	4092.97	13.26
R124A	10466.36	74.38	10388.10	6.28	10267.04	13.00	R124C	3576.54	93.22	3517.42	7.41	3497.69	12.92
R125A	12336.34	81.27	12294.94	7.33	12110.40	7.60	R125C	4974.72	89.55	4941.12	7.69	4857.98	10.50
R126A	11620.63	79.56	11332.67	6.74	11269.22	10.67	R126C	4331.41	80.02	4340.97	6.94	4283.74	10.92
R127A	10868.82	76.19	10669.74	7.23	10569.21	9.89	R127C	3823.36	80.72	3759.99	8.06	3719.42	12.09
R128A	10361.97	72.53	10216.89	6.22	10167.08	12.18	R128C	3445.34	81.13	3421.79	7.70	3362.84	14.88
R129A	11812.63	73.99	11639.96	7.53	11443.92	8.96	R129C	4567.00	77.06	4553.55	7.69	4471.58	8.96
R1210A	10890.60	71.27	10780.94	7.39	10641.88	10.20	R1210C	3922.18	75.00	3867.58	7.25	3817.39	11.61
R221A	14355.06	71.61	14840.05	6.30	14874.75	6.01	R221C	4972.08	52.34	4805.18	6.98	4758.35	12.62
R222A	13543.70	52.16	14209.18	6.19	13799.69	12.36	R222C	4526.72	63.00	4344.74	6.64	4258.26	13.06
R223A	12103.17	57.30	12706.39	6.28	12008.67	10.52	R223C	3984.50	61.58	3795.58	6.97	3767.15	13.45
R224A	10520.72	57.80	11122.21	6.11	10514.71	11.39	R224C	3143.03	72.02	3097.62	6.98	2887.55	10.37
R225A	13081.80	38.53	13444.59	6.48	13383.36	10.97	R225C	4369.26	54.05	4375.84	6.77	4278.22	7.49
R226A	12543.67	48.02	12599.55	6.20	12098.39	10.97	R226C	4046.82	49.58	3947.06	7.05	3873.87	11.86
R227A	11137.18	52.20	11657.07	6.33	11325.15	11.65	R227C	3648.21	58.73	3477.60	6.69	3409.74	11.67
R228A	10274.93	65.78	10717.99	6.59	10004.11	11.59	R228C	2935.01	73.13	2896.26	7.23	2792.17	9.83
R229A	12586.96	34.84	12636.17	6.24	12183.42	9.39	R229C	4173.26	44.49	4138.39	7.36	4026.33	11.54
R2210A	11347.19	41.95	12182.76	6.08	11263.86	10.25	R2210C	3843.46	36.20	3817.64	6.42	3672.94	10.34
RC121A	10995.16	94.88	10885.35	6.52	10814.30	7.15	RC121C	4239.52	95.44	4239.69	7.24	4181.93	10.20
RC122A	10413.91	83.36	10214.64	6.94	10103.06	8.75	RC122C	3919.43	91.63	3882.92	7.33	3828.64	9.55
RC123A	9909.46	77.89	9644.62	6.97	9590.68	12.43	RC123C	3587.59	81.97	3498.29	7.53	3431.44	11.09
RC124A	9494.38	74.58	9378.79	6.28	9260.15	13.96	RC124C	3289.12	93.98	3197.80	7.81	3167.56	13.42
RC125A	10603.03	93.73	10509.68	7.41	10299.01	10.33	RC125C	4021.30	89.45	3984.16	7.70	3932.96	9.75
RC126A	10526.77	86.44	10368.06	7.47	10145.36	8.42	RC126C	3945.98	96.44	3926.56	8.06	3839.79	11.51
RC127A	10179.64	83.75	10030.10	7.83	9941.54	10.17	RC127C	3799.75	88.03	3728.42	7.25	3676.90	9.52
RC128A	9856.77	77.39	9714.63	7.42	9655.27	10.19	RC128C	3552.67	85.84	3564.54	7.78	3472.88	12.73
RC129A	9813.89	80.84	9737.70	7.56	9609.07	10.28	RC129C	3532.69	85.20	3541.33	7.47	3452.41	12.01
RC1210A	9645.79	74.55	9558.28	7.49	9425.92	9.77	RC1210C	3358.61	76.81	3361.24	7.61	3306.65	11.64
RC221A	14529.34	61.31	14520.71	6.09	14427.00	4.74	RC221C	4149.91	62.95	4114.66	7.09	4047.60	6.05
RC222A	13425.73	64.33	13705.36	5.89	13105.64	14.07	RC222C	3807.73	67.23	3784.42	7.49	3687.16	9.74
RC223A	11976.30	64.14	12827.49	5.53	11738.56	7.15	RC223C	3701.30	78.53	3498.41	7.03	3386.92	8.14
RC224A	10811.14	91.09	11279.77	6.16	10850.91	12.59	RC224C	3219.43	101.28	2980.75	6.66	2968.82	13.02
RC225A	13392.72	51.97	14359.90	5.52	13170.90	11.47	RC225C	3887.52	51.31	3769.78	6.91	3684.16	13.00
RC226A	13295.09	45.20	13565.32	5.63	12916.40	13.31	RC226C	3820.37	52.39	3761.27	7.31	3663.62	13.35
RC227A	12345.43	52.80	12879.30	6.33	12363.69	11.36	RC227C	3545.04	57.17	3572.29	7.41	3463.24	12.07
RC228A	11989.91	55.75	12449.37	5.33	11600.87	12.25	RC228C	3440.13	54.98	3351.74	7.31	3244.29	12.22
RC229A	11640.05	41.98	12109.84	8.09	11136.85	14.42	RC229C	3326.45	63.41	3257.88	6.84	3165.38	11.03
RC2210A	11345.16	51.19	11603.96	5.30	10339.85	9.25	RC2210C	3005.69	48.02	3142.97	6.97	2984.82	9.02
C141A	37156.67	368.98	37097.84	13.89	37004.00	10.30	C141C	10186.68	366.30	10185.25	14.16	10183.32	12.71
C142A	36287.65	375.16	36456.97	15.70	36095.64	18.77	C142C	10084.39	382.86	10130.08	14.64	10067.15	22.07
C143A	35443.86	366.56	35281.26	14.61	34936.70	23.37	C143C	9703.27	370.94	9848.58	15.34	9683.62	29.11
C144A	34483.09	353.73	33896.21	15.25	33646.05	28.74	C144C	9149.61	366.09	9134.87	15.75	8999.95	29.38
C145A	37423.25	375.06	37323.54	14.47	36985.55	17.05	C145C	10179.76	392.80	10178.79	13.89	10178.79	17.92
C146A	37640.19	389.23	37632.95	16.36	37006.93	17.80	C146C	10177.34	384.77	10181.25	14.78	10177.34	20.90
C147A	37628.29	368.61	37656.93	16.64	37157.52	18.86	C147C	10162.34	432.42	10260.60	16.11	10162.03	19.63
C148A	37268.20	356.30	37174.88	18.25	36643.17	20.09	C148C	10121.30	407.55	10150.06	17.09	10078.15	23.57
C149A	36408.62	371.00	36532.43	16.80	35952.34	25.65	C149C	9949.86	405.22	9968.79	16.86	9832.26	26.16
C1410A	35691.67	354.22	35847.06	17.11	35442.90	27.16	C1410C	9660.06	381.63	9763.37	17.48	9580.12	27.00
C241A	37214.21	305.72	37088.94	9.75	35018.11	16.01	C241C	7574.53	339.64	7511.11	12.08	7265.86	16.86
C242A	35332.57	296.28	34896.10	11.27	34394.99	18.63	C242C	7507.78	324.50	7289.22	13.11	7087.05	18.41
C243A	35391.65	296.09	35503.71	10.48	34322.87	20.97	C243C	7460.24	337.22	7092.95	12.33	7020.11	19.86
C244A	34815.47	358.92	34546.07	10.81	33721.40	20.08	C244C	7172.85	387.73	6943.14	12.81	6816.11	24.32
C245A	37085.14	297.52	36290.36	10.78	34785.97	17.38	C245C	7493.45	317.08	7367.54	12.70	7152.30	16.68
C246A	36175.26	291.80	35696.75	11.72	34489.11	19.05	C246C	7331.15	324.31	7182.54	13.78	7036.19	18.49
C247A	36025.56	304.25	36003.90	11.55	34384.41	19.00	C247C	7407.89	316.39	7387.50	12.80	7140.91	17.33
C248A	35900.06	307.61	35860.75	10.55	34167.01	17.89	C248C	7317.89	306.81	7243.95	12.75	6922.05	16.83
C249A	36117.04	320.34	36265.80	10.64	34482.65	20.52	C249C	7395.61	325.31	7192.29	13.11	7072.88	21.11
C2410A	35373.19	321.88	35217.67	10.52	33999.22	16.99	C2410C	7076.80	327.58	7156.69	12.47	6826.55	18.24
R141A	28667.92	329.58	28416.94	10.45	28106.24	17.72	R141C	12254.98	370.05	12212.22	11.89	12152.43	19.69
R142A	25397.84	318.11	25291.12	13.14	24902.38	21.37	R142C	10502.18	349.16	10560.12	14.31	10332.34	25.94
R143A	23134.81	297.03	22818.20	12.55	22602.52	26.43	R143C	8956.00	318.00	8795.12	14.61	8672.50	28.85
R144A	21970.88	303.78	21715.80	12.41	21503.57	26.97	R144C	8043.02	343.14	7870.61	14.59	7747.60	30.97
R145A	25347.71	317.28	25250.04	13.11	24774.88	16.47	R145C	10608.92	334.73	10656.56	14.33	10487.93	18.85
R146A	23905.30	301.91	23641.90	15.19	23373.36	19.55	R146C	9713.02	327.27	9633.82	15.55	9475.35	23.32
R147A	22687.50	301.45	22352.49	13.59	22121.96	25.02	R147C	8555.58	323.72	8417.54	13.22	8236.43	25.43
R148A	21909.69	298.95	21606.92	13.14	21444.98	29.13	R148C	7905.12	335.55	7772.45	14.66	7630.77	25.96
R149A	24180.08	297.16	24065.69	13.56	23661.41	17.94	R149C	9921.21	318.06	9832.68	14.64	9670.65	20.75
R1410A	23130.23	285.44	22884.25	13.03	22603.72	21.92	R1410C	9078.38	308.25	8944.72	12.83	8793.32	23.20
R241A	30752.74	321.22	31463.53	13.16	31502.10	22.75	R241C	10799.49	185.02	10370.89	13.03	10066.55	19.47
R242A	27372.86	220.03	30025.97	12.03	28893.61	28.46	R242C	9635.11	267.55	9171.98	12.80	9010.48	21.33
R243A	24922.94	264.44	27621.15	11.81	25112.82	15.38	R243C	8338.94	330.72	8089.29	11.75	7779.07	14.93
R244A	21552.34	331.88	21894.05	10.66	21645.36	19.66	R244C	6809.50	306.08	6493.74	13.39	6283.62	23.13
R245A	27302.03	179.00	30007.57	11.42	28472.48	18.74	R245C	9644.09	204.39	9447.63	12.55	9028.41	17.61
R246A	24400.15	183.64	26785.61	11.17	25635.31	21.90	R246C	9092.40	240.33	8528.13	12.92	8189.75	17.41
R247A	22749.95	248.61	24206.06	10.49	22908.83	22.82	R247C	8004.41	269.05	7449.61	12.17	7137.50	17.55
R248A	21298.98	362.19	20392.97	10.58	20334.21	16.19	R248C	6552.64	313.17	6176.44	14.64	5950.25	15.49
R249A	25891.73	155.73	27132.32	11.38	26350.33	23.49	R249C	8991.19	196.50	8864.43	12.95	8435.10	24.06
R2410A	23894.38	184.95	25154.26	12.39	24447.99	26.19	R2410C	8567.66	200.52	8386.89	13.20	7923.03	19.13
RC141A	23667.18	348.45	23429.93	12.98	23161.68	12.79	RC141C	9839.00	360.55	9812.02	14.42	9708.76	17.25
RC142A	22066.80	327.91	21860.59	13.50	21533.88	18.77	RC142C	8970.15	349.41	8859.79	15.70	8699.61	21.87
RC143A	20597.40	316.80	20446.10	12.78	20142.14	24.04	RC143C	8140.88	337.50	8089.51	15.17	7924.20	25.69
RC144A	20080.59	331.70	19809.80	13.38	19672.56	26.75	RC144C	7723.72	361.88	7558.39	14.28	7470.42	28.39
RC145A	22271.61	341.41	22197.31	14.45	21979.77	17.38	RC145C	9306.67	341.63	9147.86	15.50	8985.27	19.38
RC146A	22257.21	338.55	21760.79	14.47	21678.32	19.77	RC146C	9150.17	338.03	9127.43	15.36	8904.58	16.77
RC147A	21663.84	327.77	21460.28	15.36	21218.09	20.44	RC147C	8844.62	328.13	8754.82	13.91	8557.48	20.70
RC148A	21004.48	313.55	20879.27	14.20	20577.53	21.26	RC148C	8391.29	323.69	8427.69	14.56	8197.76	22.64
RC149A	20841.74	311.05	20742.67	15.06	20401.44	21.61	RC149C	8297.20	309.86	8318.95	13.50	8099.14	23.76
RC1410A	20439.53	306.94	20197.91	12.97	20101.92	23.35	RC1410C	8085.39	320.97	8025.24	13.89	7838.42	23.60
RC241A	30354.46	348.42	29970.85	12.50	29280.00	23.96	RC241C	9035.96	267.58	8849.39	11.27	8558.49	22.83
RC242A	26847.73	341.09	28733.62	11.44	26869.42	20.62	RC242C	8567.81	356.14	7984.16	11.16	7856.42	22.51
RC243A	24497.60	345.91	26844.11	10.47	23597.58	22.67	RC243C	7763.58	361.31	7137.48	12.00	6910.54	23.10
RC244A	21047.48	359.88	20679.44	14.63	20859.13	19.13	RC244C	6609.23	375.17	5769.86	13.31	5621.26	21.03
RC245A	28217.45	264.09	28456.96	11.42	27225.33	22.84	RC245C	8289.54	272.08	8142.32	12.47	7793.09	21.26
RC246A	27157.56	292.84	28627.03	11.56	26486.60	21.81	RC246C	8063.89	302.53	8022.63	11.59	7695.75	20.76
RC247A	26655.32	247.58	27342.13	11.20	25504.91	23.28	RC247C	7724.78	259.39	7589.56	12.14	7306.26	21.14
RC248A	25030.18	250.05	25521.11	12.03	23869.02	22.81	RC248C	7338.61	257.86	7197.08	13.39	6922.08	21.70
RC249A	23893.36	255.91	23348.97	13.08	22760.50	21.68	RC249C	7235.74	287.03	7003.77	13.14	6664.64	19.20
RC2410A	23346.33	231.13	22963.14	16.47	21397.63	20.86	RC2410C	6931.63	258.11	6567.66	13.45	6377.35	14.01
C161A	59689.55	760.17	59586.47	21.09	59481.40	18.72	C161C	18707.09	793.52	18716.49	19.03	18699.39	21.22
C162A	58755.09	785.00	58571.76	24.34	58079.81	35.99	C162C	18526.04	793.52	18502.45	22.34	18454.09	37.94
C163A	57563.30	771.61	56829.20	24.06	56346.77	43.54	C163C	17911.72	799.81	17970.54	22.67	17700.27	48.14
C164A	56426.93	783.73	55567.63	22.53	55186.06	48.70	C164C	17264.42	779.80	17123.40	22.58	16981.84	48.02
C165A	59855.49	757.41	59943.50	21.64	59422.74	23.34	C165C	18706.06	822.45	18693.84	17.95	18686.38	26.47
C166A	60653.99	801.13	60318.27	23.66	59381.65	30.25	C166C	18717.27	813.41	18707.56	21.69	18686.50	31.57
C167A	60286.25	776.58	60294.54	24.36	59443.34	29.58	C167C	18704.18	863.47	18701.59	21.66	18683.86	32.06
C168A	59920.91	776.97	59595.55	25.70	58996.74	36.13	C168C	18571.11	801.09	18682.18	23.31	18510.70	36.61
C169A	58156.55	786.81	58567.22	27.03	57804.33	38.11	C169C	17887.99	815.83	18242.30	23.27	17763.93	41.73
C1610A	57870.92	754.78	57896.52	27.27	57194.78	43.93	C1610C	17639.89	815.38	17887.74	24.09	17646.48	45.05
C261A	58825.82	714.53	58082.40	17.44	55132.04	26.85	C261C	13015.11	716.86	13332.62	15.05	12604.76	23.92
C262A	58081.86	741.48	57698.77	19.27	54475.36	26.47	C262C	13020.56	742.78	12918.37	18.03	12457.44	28.70
C263A	55943.84	775.75	55292.05	16.86	53935.22	29.47	C263C	12849.37	779.22	12715.31	16.64	12328.78	31.97
C264A	55141.06	863.83	54421.80	16.83	52625.95	33.85	C264C	12532.26	830.28	12377.14	16.34	11918.71	35.80
C265A	58023.94	714.28	57227.76	19.17	54984.43	24.76	C265C	13424.80	703.59	13080.26	17.11	12461.79	24.76
C266A	57196.13	738.19	56603.26	17.83	54784.32	26.93	C266C	13769.02	745.63	13050.43	17.91	12337.14	22.76
C267A	57811.18	739.98	56829.07	19.36	54898.39	29.03	C267C	13399.36	711.77	13223.82	17.24	12577.49	24.41
C268A	56595.38	776.39	56119.74	18.13	54172.38	27.21	C268C	13038.78	764.05	12680.30	17.27	12237.35	26.69
C269A	56210.82	761.52	56183.81	19.19	54197.74	27.92	C269C	13054.19	754.39	12995.09	17.88	12148.71	26.55
C2610A	55862.66	735.16	55607.16	18.30	53561.63	26.63	C2610C	13189.45	753.11	12730.64	16.95	12113.26	30.75
R161A	48768.16	724.11	48035.25	16.31	47810.70	28.94	R161C	24292.87	751.25	24277.93	15.97	23991.86	35.52
R162A	43036.65	683.81	42172.33	21.94	42115.37	36.02	R162C	20600.75	697.09	20575.01	20.86	20243.80	38.00
R163A	39796.18	668.28	39089.63	21.48	38733.18	40.65	R163C	18382.28	691.66	17908.61	20.52	17597.84	43.62
R164A	37493.03	683.09	36769.21	20.94	36402.21	49.48	R164C	16321.85	718.95	15765.01	19.45	15657.10	45.60
R165A	43303.32	671.16	42517.05	23.97	41881.58	27.78	R165C	21421.98	674.55	21118.63	18.58	20607.54	26.61
R166A	41316.95	658.94	40314.96	21.25	39953.39	37.32	R166C	19323.65	672.50	19015.45	20.27	18759.35	33.51
R167A	38989.63	672.41	38234.20	20.67	37851.14	41.22	R167C	17921.75	681.05	17025.78	20.81	17023.24	40.89
R168A	36982.48	694.75	36390.44	21.97	36175.07	45.49	R168C	16051.66	722.38	15616.18	21.83	15418.46	41.71
R169A	41915.91	654.11	40960.30	23.81	40522.86	29.89	R169C	20085.27	656.09	19767.32	20.03	19380.68	30.42
R1610A	40068.23	637.75	39521.70	23.38	39093.56	30.67	R1610C	18891.04	652.08	18449.85	19.89	18111.24	36.10
R261A	55926.79	826.92	53192.13	20.61	51291.20	28.98	R261C	20981.80	470.61	19697.79	17.81	19035.79	29.30
R262A	48401.15	473.86	49406.02	18.70	46659.77	36.07	R262C	18525.78	562.38	17182.59	17.03	16909.31	32.01
R263A	40919.19	586.42	44327.34	17.02	40101.74	31.67	R263C	16550.00	616.45	14510.42	17.45	14184.89	33.37
R264A	35706.92	678.59	35083.09	17.39	33980.67	26.96	R264C	13157.25	707.73	11449.41	17.55	11008.94	27.53
R265A	49199.77	372.17	50693.53	20.89	49223.50	31.12	R265C	19533.05	447.58	18294.03	17.56	17771.90	33.01
R266A	42134.19	405.91	46572.58	17.70	43295.07	31.87	R266C	18749.86	404.58	16356.36	17.83	15661.50	30.06
R267A	39024.05	526.75	42750.32	16.58	38492.23	23.85	R267C	14898.00	544.27	13805.47	15.74	13255.61	31.87
R268A	35947.38	688.89	34233.23	17.80	32580.85	32.46	R268C	13082.88	702.95	10865.64	19.80	10454.96	28.00
R269A	45496.03	447.63	49347.98	19.33	45496.03	29.91	R269C	18567.27	469.55	17034.98	17.20	16551.68	29.67
R2610A	42371.50	437.70	42719.16	19.41	42085.73	32.28	R2610C	17087.31	521.34	16213.20	18.38	15482.84	27.36
RC161A	38981.34	723.89	38568.22	21.20	37966.63	20.78	RC161C	18691.07	742.28	18469.16	19.52	17829.78	24.06
RC162A	36931.09	701.08	36115.10	22.45	35558.83	27.46	RC162C	17192.16	703.69	16864.48	20.17	16400.23	30.90
RC163A	35118.63	694.70	34183.42	22.06	33888.57	36.54	RC163C	15987.36	703.31	15442.62	19.81	15227.84	43.97
RC164A	34036.86	714.39	33177.38	22.61	33100.75	42.06	RC164C	15029.87	729.91	14541.66	20.72	14395.73	44.37
RC165A	37890.20	698.89	37031.67	21.27	36368.56	26.66	RC165C	18122.45	700.42	17505.80	20.86	17015.78	27.02
RC166A	36917.19	688.64	36479.06	24.06	36087.67	24.17	RC166C	17417.86	692.80	17359.22	18.42	16924.63	25.93
RC167A	36045.20	673.61	35613.49	23.75	35130.32	27.58	RC167C	16906.27	687.48	16801.52	20.08	16317.85	29.50
RC168A	35731.11	658.69	34989.07	21.52	34769.63	32.99	RC168C	16665.67	667.88	16303.91	20.06	15989.32	35.12
RC169A	35355.26	661.61	34969.48	24.63	34614.31	32.03	RC169C	16387.88	667.16	16224.11	19.67	15867.19	33.63
RC1610A	35048.50	647.77	34707.66	22.63	34405.79	34.49	RC1610C	16380.54	666.22	15828.02	21.30	15625.16	37.94
RC261A	50965.70	728.20	49713.11	20.45	48026.06	35.41	RC261C	16887.29	517.75	16473.45	16.48	15836.79	27.77
RC262A	45977.09	669.75	46584.05	18.78	43708.88	26.18	RC262C	15607.40	611.44	14470.66	15.52	14027.61	28.72
RC263A	40652.52	675.24	40861.20	15.86	38816.75	30.87	RC263C	14175.00	716.31	12795.89	17.36	12445.42	25.99
RC264A	34595.77	711.36	34942.97	18.14	33183.89	27.61	RC264C	11806.37	749.49	10402.35	18.97	10039.03	24.60
RC265A	46462.01	552.95	47600.73	18.58	46462.01	31.39	RC265C	16152.60	525.72	15449.32	16.30	14886.59	30.69
RC266A	47640.27	589.58	47295.00	18.53	45939.67	27.96	RC266C	15578.28	581.92	15413.57	17.66	14649.05	25.77
RC267A	44631.66	655.25	44216.27	18.97	44922.08	28.47	RC267C	15535.85	542.03	14576.06	17.66	13939.88	26.18
RC268A	41694.33	487.59	42675.06	17.70	41694.33	31.84	RC268C	14289.59	536.38	14095.21	18.23	13314.74	26.62
RC269A	40365.67	514.88	39103.91	17.44	39103.91	25.82	RC269C	14628.42	614.84	13627.13	16.22	12864.97	30.58
RC2610A	38217.84	485.91	37492.89	18.00	40310.55	24.01	RC2610C	13745.89	578.67	13019.75	17.02	12191.27	22.83
C181A	85904.80	1331.39	85377.70	24.34	85118.97	27.71	C181C	31846.67	1306.95	31306.21	26.94	31287.09	27.80
C182A	84580.95	1330.84	83500.72	30.70	82931.70	41.08	C182C	31581.31	1348.14	30995.73	32.52	30758.37	42.99
C183A	80617.52	1296.75	80226.37	29.25	79244.66	54.23	C183C	29319.89	1433.02	29599.34	33.39	28994.36	60.33
C184A	77870.83	1309.70	77236.34	31.89	76324.25	55.79	C184C	27860.33	1410.50	27715.07	33.94	27226.22	64.46
C185A	86500.22	1329.36	85756.73	33.09	85178.09	28.85	C185C	31521.56	1433.78	31268.45	31.39	31255.85	34.35
C186A	86386.20	1319.61	86476.10	32.55	85170.68	37.39	C186C	31456.02	1448.78	31312.16	31.77	31258.70	40.11
C187A	86215.78	1350.13	86513.45	33.97	85384.66	41.17	C187C	31456.56	1478.83	31284.95	30.66	31239.50	41.04
C188A	86156.11	1319.23	85234.16	35.94	84384.02	46.14	C188C	31424.64	1447.25	31179.57	34.95	30981.25	48.24
C189A	84033.43	1313.17	83810.09	36.45	82275.05	49.51	C189C	30327.43	1438.94	30582.53	35.94	29660.17	52.90
C1810A	82053.96	1331.73	82036.56	37.22	81018.18	59.02	C1810C	29490.43	1418.89	29925.15	34.31	29143.52	59.14
C281A	81655.68	1297.78	78151.77	24.05	76114.02	30.62	C281C	18867.04	1433.24	19104.26	25.02	18067.45	30.89
C282A	79202.33	1341.41	76323.83	24.59	75577.78	35.96	C282C	19618.88	1445.19	19022.27	25.55	18033.72	38.50
C283A	78244.81	1319.11	76453.56	24.36	75004.70	38.39	C283C	19866.43	1533.70	18778.22	24.98	18271.39	44.69
C284A	74952.77	1458.69	73761.73	23.89	73570.12	44.88	C284C	19095.48	1621.47	18312.74	24.53	17753.38	44.15
C285A	80079.09	1291.39	77151.81	25.80	75848.80	31.31	C285C	18951.86	1323.30	19142.23	23.69	18236.47	30.31
C286A	78828.71	1308.94	77715.28	25.59	75134.46	33.04	C286C	18824.79	1250.08	18883.89	26.00	18202.91	33.96
C287A	80072.08	1317.11	77071.63	25.75	75469.62	30.23	C287C	19959.09	1278.97	19662.82	26.00	18082.19	36.64
C288A	78157.06	1336.98	76148.19	23.06	75053.58	34.74	C288C	19567.56	1278.56	18870.43	26.09	17982.05	31.87
C289A	78640.20	1339.33	76617.84	24.99	75194.23	36.74	C289C	19663.36	1302.88	19153.84	25.03	18247.55	34.02
C2810A	76765.70	1325.14	75010.33	25.22	74068.15	35.91	C2810C	19182.40	1297.06	18528.86	24.08	17875.26	37.60
R181A	73423.38	1262.56	72590.84	21.42	71956.95	38.11	R181C	40738.97	1405.81	40722.32	24.86	39903.48	49.58
R182A	65257.05	1202.75	64562.15	28.84	63415.68	48.31	R182C	35459.84	1326.39	35039.90	28.08	34134.84	54.85
R183A	59820.10	1182.33	57934.34	28.78	57328.28	54.48	R183C	30784.69	1323.24	29859.11	28.67	29384.40	59.03
R184A	55631.60	1226.55	54311.52	31.05	54020.09	65.43	R184C	27472.15	1375.56	26571.09	33.17	26391.02	71.90
R185A	65112.59	1170.44	64073.48	28.22	63164.19	36.65	R185C	36029.45	1318.28	35683.17	29.23	34750.04	44.60
R186A	61688.93	1162.14	59854.79	29.19	59218.27	49.13	R186C	32471.26	1309.08	31401.22	33.06	31239.21	56.55
R187A	57701.16	1170.03	56186.56	33.22	55876.16	54.66	R187C	29303.08	1351.52	28486.17	31.64	28248.58	61.46
R188A	55067.66	1240.86	54076.86	29.63	53756.47	70.31	R188C	27181.22	1423.31	26306.48	31.56	26130.05	65.15
R189A	63014.13	1158.69	61284.97	29.66	60379.76	39.84	R189C	33991.16	1292.28	33099.81	28.00	32487.48	47.46
R1810A	61051.45	1143.00	59296.93	33.11	58539.97	44.10	R1810C	31979.75	1272.61	31285.10	31.86	30639.84	49.64
R281A	76129.39	1142.08	76800.86	29.66	76015.08	48.08	R281C	33865.73	925.58	31588.51	26.33	30305.13	42.73
R282A	68541.41	872.50	69237.10	27.05	68541.41	50.33	R282C	29710.76	1113.41	27601.50	25.88	26647.88	42.20
R283A	60673.82	1112.23	60335.26	23.97	60335.26	51.30	R283C	25814.85	1246.00	23026.31	25.31	22132.13	40.90
R284A	52897.81	1199.94	52007.50	22.39	52007.50	39.33	R284C	19584.68	1263.48	18353.81	25.31	17249.25	39.42
R285A	70570.70	1043.31	73100.38	31.02	70570.70	44.84	R285C	31565.70	830.22	29379.08	25.31	28067.24	40.05
R286A	63607.13	844.80	66345.27	24.20	63607.13	50.94	R286C	28039.16	1109.69	25993.16	25.08	24831.53	45.52
R287A	59941.44	1180.83	59135.41	25.00	59135.41	45.30	R287C	25839.81	1042.83	22317.59	24.44	21110.35	41.98
R288A	50457.42	1234.20	49862.94	25.02	49862.94	42.53	R288C	19474.12	1223.72	17544.24	23.49	16677.97	35.86
R289A	67169.72	783.03	70365.53	27.66	67169.72	46.77	R289C	30039.87	763.03	27794.89	23.05	26471.23	43.24
R2810A	64422.00	634.05	65480.44	26.00	64422.00	42.81	R2810C	28481.98	883.42	26502.74	24.23	25153.17	37.70
RC181A	59150.52	1237.28	58036.37	28.78	56448.46	34.45	RC181C	32201.65	1253.56	31311.17	32.22	30538.56	36.15
RC182A	55364.17	1204.48	53906.74	31.30	53097.49	43.53	RC182C	29402.58	1234.13	28263.09	30.61	27689.98	47.92
RC183A	52680.52	1231.88	51423.03	31.91	51310.77	55.88	RC183C	27766.02	1252.24	26776.21	32.92	26179.77	63.58
RC184A	50474.12	1265.33	49389.16	30.49	49314.78	61.03	RC184C	25379.72	1285.17	24802.80	30.33	24662.89	55.69
RC185A	57066.52	1202.56	55811.28	29.91	54591.68	38.49	RC185C	30521.64	1225.08	30023.54	32.64	29334.44	44.85
RC186A	55904.77	1207.13	55368.05	31.22	54173.58	39.02	RC186C	29693.74	1213.64	29376.62	33.39	28916.35	44.67
RC187A	54825.86	1186.95	53951.41	31.86	53099.90	46.74	RC187C	29040.12	1201.38	28469.93	30.66	27862.34	47.72
RC188A	54077.31	1172.06	52573.27	29.80	52058.95	44.05	RC188C	28744.38	1194.99	27713.70	34.05	27190.09	53.29
RC189A	54060.53	1164.98	52536.89	31.53	51820.68	52.42	RC189C	28365.75	1190.58	27503.60	30.81	27073.12	59.78
RC1810A	52977.40	1158.20	52055.42	30.16	51203.98	55.18	RC1810C	27446.71	1191.06	26982.44	31.91	26730.07	56.44
RC281A	72564.38	1180.42	68932.23	29.66	68932.23	46.29	RC281C	26967.79	1094.53	25510.42	25.92	24403.06	39.81
RC282A	65076.57	1235.95	63429.73	23.53	63429.73	52.39	RC282C	24967.48	1241.05	22564.77	23.78	21796.86	41.23
RC283A	57898.17	1325.23	56750.79	23.84	56750.79	46.47	RC283C	21165.76	1392.27	19486.10	24.56	18750.79	46.96
RC284A	51738.96	1349.83	49084.96	22.77	48176.69	40.01	RC284C	17256.03	1489.83	15650.35	24.39	16048.69	35.16
RC285A	65302.06	1051.83	65449.16	25.58	65302.06	57.86	RC285C	24480.05	1150.34	23440.24	24.03	23403.65	43.96
RC286A	65842.89	1086.66	62731.40	23.25	62731.40	54.91	RC286C	24864.24	1038.98	23389.50	24.44	22937.89	40.26
RC287A	63694.95	1030.31	61200.18	25.38	61200.18	51.48	RC287C	23640.37	1088.58	22536.80	27.53	22031.78	44.43
RC288A	59340.22	977.31	57763.84	22.97	57763.84	52.43	RC288C	22731.98	1052.16	21481.50	24.59	20758.74	36.79
RC289A	57960.22	995.58	56770.02	23.45	56770.02	49.76	RC289C	22423.33	1115.30	20964.52	23.45	20641.88	37.77
RC2810A	54409.41	998.69	54190.70	22.80	54190.70	42.84	RC2810C	21656.00	1091.56	20208.70	25.58	19503.18	35.71
C1101A	118787.14	1983.70	117485.38	35.27	117207.95	35.07	C1101C	50787.86	2021.80	50065.08	36.55	50057.53	36.38
C1102A	116725.88	1987.66	115410.43	46.91	114115.83	58.16	C1102C	49784.06	2048.88	49606.12	45.03	49365.50	64.76
C1103A	112483.80	1981.67	111346.16	47.77	109840.98	65.74	C1103C	47210.25	2058.17	47948.33	49.47	47078.95	73.02
C1104A	106391.73	2042.83	104794.52	44.94	104186.72	83.97	C1104C	43981.17	2177.30	43895.81	48.11	42999.37	83.60
C1105A	118762.64	2028.78	117881.98	42.61	117198.64	43.28	C1105C	50310.32	2201.94	50075.16	45.20	50032.87	45.99
C1106A	120062.98	2027.02	118269.16	46.00	117143.79	51.76	C1106C	50139.08	2208.06	50131.77	42.36	50033.15	48.81
C1107A	118882.44	2044.41	119287.70	43.56	117212.94	47.02	C1107C	50344.85	2201.61	50179.69	43.84	50023.45	51.35
C1108A	118720.60	2010.92	117465.45	47.41	116276.77	57.52	C1108C	50059.20	2206.91	50078.75	44.41	49692.13	65.60
C1109A	115666.78	2043.36	114729.25	49.77	114032.42	70.51	C1109C	48281.63	2239.78	49033.63	45.05	47616.00	69.56
C11010A	113723.05	2018.86	113565.70	48.25	111928.58	70.01	C11010C	47767.31	2189.56	48006.15	48.13	46606.41	82.70
C2101A	104405.41	1895.28	101055.51	33.80	99171.59	41.22	C2101C	27565.94	2273.83	26914.42	33.97	25081.81	38.61
C2102A	104122.18	1910.50	99865.72	35.19	99865.72	45.19	C2102C	27451.23	2237.17	26360.07	34.03	24946.05	52.63
C2103A	100344.77	1969.92	97243.95	32.99	97243.95	52.12	C2103C	27775.83	2340.63	26335.14	33.88	25294.95	51.11
C2104A	99061.77	2187.19	95365.89	32.52	95303.05	60.72	C2104C	26171.65	2457.75	25404.70	35.55	24720.91	64.02
C2105A	102803.17	1850.39	99935.95	34.17	99935.95	42.62	C2105C	27069.58	2163.28	26709.19	35.14	25164.18	44.40
C2106A	102681.81	1896.06	99364.25	32.88	97425.92	43.43	C2106C	27874.57	2252.98	26926.17	31.20	24826.73	47.72
C2107A	103154.60	1881.92	99228.42	33.66	98391.09	47.24	C2107C	27906.83	2217.74	26664.01	32.72	26200.46	51.23
C2108A	101995.64	1915.75	97999.53	34.11	96851.00	42.84	C2108C	27492.01	2220.94	26398.24	34.13	25584.10	47.13
C2109A	101620.37	1898.66	98829.27	33.20	97843.37	46.50	C2109C	27589.01	2241.56	26563.02	33.48	25962.44	51.42
C21010A	101197.13	1938.42	96876.09	32.73	96513.50	46.11	C21010C	26891.55	2240.75	26151.47	32.24	24881.47	50.65
R1101A	100212.48	2040.98	98182.30	30.14	97552.74	49.45	R1101C	58943.11	2178.30	58614.10	28.39	57340.91	72.46
R1102A	89838.07	1853.09	87719.66	39.27	86698.79	66.94	R1102C	51655.98	2084.27	50395.03	42.08	49488.02	75.13
R1103A	81944.28	1725.16	79314.20	40.33	78694.48	76.91	R1103C	45856.57	2062.03	43793.72	40.02	43168.66	90.37
R1104A	76926.73	1806.22	74883.88	40.28	74448.69	92.68	R1104C	41019.65	2139.47	39729.29	41.39	39336.09	95.64
R1105A	90778.97	1703.67	87170.08	36.02	86018.13	55.86	R1105C	53446.32	2078.80	51998.27	40.47	50455.79	65.24
R1106A	85998.64	1694.72	82132.25	39.27	81654.91	67.05	R1106C	48283.29	2045.13	46956.65	42.64	45874.48	81.85
R1107A	80195.64	1733.50	77698.93	40.56	77295.04	86.99	R1107C	44417.54	2087.34	42431.94	40.38	41982.23	91.40
R1108A	76503.94	1761.13	74621.00	43.72	74191.95	90.26	R1108C	40368.48	2159.92	39378.73	44.86	39012.00	95.35
R1109A	88163.81	1688.74	85080.58	37.31	83994.10	59.11	R1109C	50974.68	2044.73	49370.69	41.14	48257.65	69.27
R11010A	85534.08	1671.95	82393.37	39.45	81317.50	64.04	R11010C	48615.96	2017.91	46699.48	42.25	45601.70	72.32
R2101A	110184.33	1313.19	104301.16	42.06	101743.42	61.65	R2101C	49601.56	1829.30	45786.67	35.08	43912.34	58.24
R2102A	97442.41	1501.20	94750.47	38.34	91999.25	68.70	R2102C	45550.71	1918.45	39158.92	33.06	38138.85	65.75
R2103A	83346.44	1714.33	80347.20	38.19	79405.92	67.33	R2103C	37908.70	2233.11	31949.84	30.06	30898.94	55.55
R2104A	70656.05	1757.58	65589.11	28.13	65616.95	58.11	R2104C	28511.63	2028.28	24545.11	33.19	23218.64	58.45
R2105A	104693.34	1206.02	100037.95	42.27	100037.95	63.35	R2105C	46757.77	1514.56	43108.04	34.14	40929.15	57.30
R2106A	90800.22	1400.36	87520.57	35.44	87520.57	53.21	R2106C	42134.09	1608.91	37719.80	30.58	35894.18	57.13
R2107A	76471.25	1706.22	75569.19	34.63	75569.19	63.94	R2107C	35172.42	1887.48	30835.81	33.17	29276.42	62.03
R2108A	69906.48	1778.36	63537.16	31.73	63537.16	55.55	R2108C	27657.81	2122.02	23537.39	32.70	22319.10	50.09
R2109A	96569.63	1050.55	97251.31	40.09	96569.63	61.37	R2109C	44953.75	1488.67	40990.00	34.45	38742.40	56.63
R21010A	90303.81	1071.19	93063.65	37.48	90303.81	60.25	R21010C	43142.36	1199.31	39200.86	35.94	38064.95	48.47
RC1101A	82815.73	1876.09	79959.62	39.94	78031.41	48.69	RC1101C	48849.41	2037.16	47049.28	39.42	45756.90	49.30
RC1102A	77839.84	1885.22	73959.01	42.27	72774.02	53.13	RC1102C	44660.72	2122.11	42589.15	42.98	41655.57	65.68
RC1103A	72778.05	1865.02	70309.67	44.02	69879.53	78.53	RC1103C	41370.69	2157.48	39278.03	41.47	38931.45	82.88
RC1104A	69462.56	1937.08	68081.25	41.99	67776.59	92.87	RC1104C	38606.30	2212.52	37534.31	43.00	37178.45	100.22
RC1105A	79230.56	1877.63	76776.20	40.53	75250.41	54.88	RC1105C	46503.62	2113.03	44786.32	40.30	43533.30	57.16
RC1106A	77781.09	1877.72	75310.20	42.14	73961.84	51.04	RC1106C	46316.18	2081.97	44116.07	40.05	42585.26	44.74
RC1107A	75976.66	1845.33	73748.70	44.55	72905.91	58.67	RC1107C	45117.43	2072.89	43211.56	43.08	42054.25	55.51
RC1108A	75322.36	1837.09	72488.42	40.33	71715.46	60.39	RC1108C	44002.29	2058.11	41422.41	40.25	40985.61	59.87
RC1109A	74556.65	1833.77	72499.64	40.98	71628.86	54.88	RC1109C	43665.91	2002.34	41758.04	40.00	40977.04	57.14
RC11010A	74562.46	1826.00	71752.19	41.52	70987.31	50.56	RC11010C	42647.78	1875.02	40857.08	39.42	40109.00	61.37
RC2101A	96431.08	1718.86	92100.95	36.59	92100.95	53.59	RC2101C	39684.66	1405.31	36591.16	36.44	34879.15	47.97
RC2102A	87586.31	1651.05	82790.18	33.86	82790.18	44.52	RC2102C	36250.77	1799.69	32209.94	31.31	30925.31	58.36
RC2103A	74445.37	1918.56	69548.62	25.39	69548.62	48.25	RC2103C	30443.51	2185.44	26761.99	32.25	25570.40	56.79
RC2104A	64687.95	2113.05	61890.14	33.45	61890.14	49.84	RC2104C	25704.52	2427.97	21596.82	36.56	20690.84	49.12
RC2105A	88789.04	1470.70	87244.16	36.31	87244.16	49.94	RC2105C	36891.79	1587.11	34349.43	36.20	32316.64	48.74
RC2106A	90015.29	1518.77	85087.14	35.89	85087.14	44.62	RC2106C	37837.96	1567.25	34312.05	32.77	32194.44	45.96
RC2107A	86259.89	1397.72	83513.57	34.17	83513.57	47.02	RC2107C	36658.46	1595.92	33036.03	33.45	30571.31	51.40
RC2108A	80197.05	1495.63	80933.86	31.77	80197.05	57.44	RC2108C	33952.09	1539.23	31815.12	33.99	29466.26	42.56
RC2109A	79337.48	1414.70	73604.45	33.33	73604.45	44.85	RC2109C	33757.40	1591.59	30717.02	31.81	28540.66	49.22
RC21010A	75617.04	1443.11	71194.46	33.72	71194.46	45.83	RC21010C	33072.73	1567.84	29522.06	34.28	27463.52	49.70

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

Copyright information

About this paper

Cite this paper

Bräysy, O., Dullaert, W., Porkka, P.P. (2018). A Simple Metaheuristic for the FleetSize and Mix Problem with TimeWindows. In: Diez, P., Neittaanmäki, P., Periaux, J., Tuovinen, T., Bräysy, O. (eds) Computational Methods and Models for Transport. ECCOMAS 2015. Computational Methods in Applied Sciences, vol 45. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-54490-8_4

Download citation

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-54490-8_4
Published: 30 June 2017
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-54489-2
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-54490-8
eBook Packages: EngineeringEngineering (R0)

Publish with us

Policies and ethics

A Simple Metaheuristic for the FleetSize and Mix Problem with TimeWindows

Abstract

Access this chapter

References

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Corresponding author

Editor information

Editors and Affiliations

Appendix

Appendix

Rights and permissions

Copyright information

About this paper

Cite this paper

Download citation

Share this paper

Publish with us

Search

Navigation