Advertisement

Overcoming the Gender Pay Gap: Equal Pay Policies Implementation in France and the United Kingdom

  • Cécile Guillaume
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter looks into the two legal routes France and the UK have chosen to enforce equal pay legislation, and more specifically the complicated relationship between litigation and bargaining strategies to advance equality. Whereas France has relied on state intervention and, more recently, on collective bargaining to implement equal pay policies, we argue that lessons could be drawn from the British case where trade unions’ mass litigation strategies have resulted in an unequalled understanding of the concepts of equal value and indirect discrimination, and the development of comprehensive methods of job evaluation. While being very controversial, this litigious approach has demonstrated an emerging relationship between the system of collective bargaining and the litigation process depicted as complements, allowing to address implicit representations of the value of women’s work and to challenge traditional unions’ views on collective bargaining.

References

  1. Acker, Joan. 1989. Doing Comparable Worth. Gender, Class and Pay Equity. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  2. Alter, Karen, and Jeanette Vargas. 2000. Explaining Variation in the Use of European Litigation Strategies: European Community Law and British Gender Equality Policy. Comparative Political Studies 4(33): 452–482.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Arthurs, Alan. 1992. Equal Value in British Banking: The Midland Bank Case. In Equal Value/Comparable Worth in the UK and the USA, ed. Peggy Kahn, and Elizabeth Meehan, 119–136. Basingstoke: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Barnes, Jeb, and Thomas Burke. 2012. Making Way: Legal Mobilization, Organizational Response, and Wheelchair Access. Law & Society Review 46(1): 167–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Beirne, Martin, and Fiona Wilson. 2016. Running with “Wolves” or Waiting for a Happy Release? Evaluating Routes to Gender Equality. Work, Employment and Society 30(2): 220–236.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Cockburn, Cynthia. 1995. Strategies for Gender Democracy: Women and the European Social Dialogue. Social Europe, Supplement 4 (95).Google Scholar
  7. Colling, Trevor. 2006. What Space for Unions on the Floor of Rights? Trade Unions and the Enforcement of Statutory Individual Employment Rights. Industrial Law Journal 35(2): 140–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. ———. 2012. Trade Union Roles in Making Employment Rights Effective. In Making Employment Rights Effective. Issues of Enforcement and Compliance, ed. Linda Dickens, 183–204. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
  9. Conley, Hazel. 2014. Trade Unions, Equal Pay and the Law in the UK. Economic and Industrial Democracy 35(2): 309–323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Conley, Hazel, and Margaret Page. 2015. Gender Equality in Public Services Chasing the dream. London/New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  11. Cousin, Olivier. 2007. La construction des inégalités hommes–femmes dans l’entreprise. Une analyse de cas dans la métallurgie. Sociologie du Travail 49(2): 195–219.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cristofalo, Paula. 2014. Négocier l’égalité professionnelle: de quelques obstacles à la prise en charge syndicale de la thématique. Nouvelle revue de psychosociologie 18(2): 133–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Deakin, Simon, Sarah Fraser Butlin, Colm McLaughlin, and Aleksandra Polanska. 2015. Are Litigation and Collective Bargaining Complements or Substitutes for Achieving Gender Equality? A Study of the British Equal Pay Act. Cambridge Journal of Economics 39(2): 381–404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Dickens, Linda. 2000. Collective Bargaining and the Promotion of Gender Equality at Work: Opportunities and Challenges for Trade Unions. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 6(2): 193–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. ———. 2007. The Road Is Long: Thirty Years of Equality Legislation in Britain. British Journal of Industrial Relations 45(3): 463–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. ———. 2012. Introduction—Making Employment Rights Effective: Issues of Enforcement and Compliance. In Making Employment Rights Effective. Issues of Enforcement and Compliance, ed. Linda Dickens, 1–6. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
  17. Dickens, Linda, and Mark Hall. 2006. Fairness—Up to a Point: Assessing the Impact of New Labour’s Employment Legislation. Human Resource Management Journal 16(4): 338–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dickens, Linda, Barbara Townley, and David Winchester. 1988. Tackling Sex Discrimination Through Collective Bargaining—The Impact of Section 6 of the Sex Discrimination Act 1986. London: Her Majesty’s Stationary Office.Google Scholar
  19. Fredman, Sandra. 2008. Reforming Equal Pay Laws. Industrial Law Journal 37(3): 193–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Fuchs, Gesine. 2013. Strategic Litigation for Gender Equality in the Workplace and Legal Opportunity Structures in Four European Countries. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 28(2): 189–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gilbert, Kay. 2012. Promises and Practices: Job Evaluation and Equal Pay Forty Years On! Industrial Relations Journal 43(2): 137–151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Gregory, Jeanne. 1982. Equal Pay and Sex Discrimination: Why Women Are Giving Up the Fight. Feminist Review 10(1): 75–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. ———. 1987. Sex, Race and the Law. Legislating for Equality. London: Sage.Google Scholar
  24. ———. 1996. Dynamite or Damp Squib? An Assessment of Equal Value Law. International Journal of Discrimination and the Law 1(4): 313–333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Grimshaw, Damian, and Jill Rubery. 2007. Undervaluing Women’s Work. EOC Working Paper Series No. 53.Google Scholar
  26. Guillaume, Cécile. 2013. La mobilisation des syndicats anglais en faveur de l’égalité salariale (1968–2012). ‘Women at the table, Women on the table’? Travail, genre et société 30(2): 93–110.Google Scholar
  27. ———. 2015a. Les syndicats britanniques et le recours au contentieux juridique. Accessed 27 April 2016. http://nrt.revues.org/2354
  28. ———. 2015b. Understanding the Variations of Union’s Litigation Strategies to Promote Equal Pay. Reflection on the British Case (1970–2000). Cambridge Journal of Economics 39(2): 363–379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Guillaume, Cécile, and Sophie Pochic. 2012. Breaking Through the Union Glass Ceiling in France: Between Organisational Opportunities and Individual Resources. In Gendering and Diversifying Trade Union Leadership, ed. Sue Ledwith, and Lise Lotte Hansen, 385–414. London/New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  30. Guillaume, Cécile, Sophie Pochic, and Vincent-Arnaud Chappe. 2016. The Promises and Pitfalls of Collective Bargaining for Ending Union Victimization. Lessons from France. Economic and Industrial Democracy 37(3). doi: 10.1177/0143831X16639657.
  31. Hart, Susan M. 2002. The Pay Equity Bargaining Process in Newfoundland: Understanding Cooperation and Conflict by Incorporating Gender and Class. Gender, Work and Organizations 9(4): 355–371.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Jacquot, Sophie. 2014. L’égalité au nom du marché: Émergence et démantèlement de la politique européenne d’égalité entre les hommes et les femmes. Brussels: Peter Lang.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jobert, Annette. 1993. L’égalité professionnelle dans la négociation collective en France. Travail et Emploi 63: 77–87.Google Scholar
  34. Kilpatrick, Claire. 1997. Effective Utilisation of Equality Rights: Equal Pay for Work of Equal Value in France and the UK. In Sex Equality Policy in Western Europe, ed. Frances Gardiner, 25–45. London/New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  35. Lanquetin, Marie-Thérèse. 2004. Une loi inappliquée? Travail, genre et societés 12(2): 182–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Laufer, Jacqueline. 2003. Equal Employment Policy in France: Symbolic Support and a Mixed Record. The Review of Policy Research 20(3): 423–444.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Laufer, Jacqueline, and Rachel Silvera. 2006. L’égalité des femmes et des hommes en entreprise. De nouvelles avancées dans la négociation ? Revue de l’OFCE 97: 245–271.Google Scholar
  38. Leonard, Alice. 1987. Judging Inequality: The Effectiveness of the Industrial Tribunal System in Sex Discrimination and Equal Pay Case. London: The Cobden Trust.Google Scholar
  39. Mazur, Amy. 2003. Drawing Comparative Lessons from France and Germany. The Review of Policy Research 20(3): 493–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. ———. 2004. La France est-elle toujours le pays des réformes symboliques? Travail, Genre et Sociétés 12: 173–181.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Mercat, Marie. 2010. Egalité salariale, discriminations individuelles et systémiques: un éclairage de la jurisprudence américaine. Revue de l’OFCE 3(114): 95–112.Google Scholar
  42. Milner, Susan, and Abigail Gregory. 2014. Gender Equality Bargaining in France and the UK: An Uphill Struggle? Journal of Industrial Relations 56(2): 246–263.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Oliver, Liz, Mark Stuart, and Jennifer Tomlinson. 2014. Equal Pay Bargaining in the UK Local Government. Journal of Industrial Relations 56(2): 228–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. O’Reilly, Jacqueline, Mark Smith, Simon Deakin, and Brendan Burchell. 2015. Equal Pay as a Moving Target: International Perspectives on Forty-Years of Addressing the Gender Pay Gap. Cambridge Journal of Economics 39(2): 299–318.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2012. Employment Outlook 2012. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.Google Scholar
  46. Peruzzi, Marco. 2015. Contradictions and Misalignments in the EU Approach Towards the Gender Pay Gap. Cambridge Journal of Economics 39(2): 441–466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Pochic, Sophie. 2014. Femmes responsables syndicales en Angleterre et identification féministe: neutraliser leur genre pour mieux représenter leur classe? Sociologie 5(4): 369–386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Pollert, Anna. 2007. Britain and Individual Employment Rights: ‘Paper Tigers’, Fierce in Appearance but Missing in Tooth and Claw. Economic and Industrial Democracy 28(1): 110–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Rabier, Marion. 2008. Analyse du contenu des accords d’entreprise portant sur l’égalité professionnelle entre les femmes et les hommes signés depuis la loi du 23 mars 2006. In La négociation collective en 2008, edited by DARES. Accessed 24 April 2016. http://www.ladocumentationfrancaise.fr/rapports-publics/094000282/
  50. Renton, David. 2012. Struck Out. Why Employment Tribunals Fail Workers and What Can Be Done. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
  51. Rubery, Jill, and Damian Grimshaw. 2015. The 40-Years Pursuit of Equal Pay: A Case of Constantly Moving Goalposts. Cambridge Journal of Economics 39(2): 319–344.Google Scholar
  52. Silvera, Rachel. 2014. Un quart en moins. Des femmes se battent pour en finir avec les inégalités de salaires. Paris: La Découverte.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2017

Open Access This chapter is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License, which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Business SchoolUniversity of RoehamptonLondonUK

Personalised recommendations