Test of the FCC’s Virtuous Circle: Preliminary Results for Edge Provider Innovation and BIAS Provider Investment by Country with Hard Versus Soft Rules

  • Roslyn Layton


The net neutrality movement, its leaders and acolytes, should take stock of their success. Barely a decade ago “network neutrality” was an academic concept, but no longer. A recent blog from Access Now shows a world map with some two dozen nations with net neutrality rules of some kind, 28 EU member nations on track with rules, and India, Pakistan and South Africa considering rules.


Mobile Application Initial Public Offering Content Delivery Network Virtuous Circle Initial Public Offering 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


  1. A View of Traffic Management and Other Practices Resulting in Restrictions to the Open Internet in Europe BEREC Findings on Traffic Management Practices in Europe – Traffic Management Investigation. (2012, May 29).
  2. Antitrust: Commission Closes Investigation into Internet Connectivity Services but Will Continue to Monitor the Sector. (2014, October 3).,
  3. Bergström, O. Director at Swedish Post and Telecom Authority - PTS, Gives an Interview at ETNO-MLex Summit 2014. viEUws (ETNO, 2014, July 7).
  4. Besluit van de Minister van Economische Zaken van 11 mei 2015, nr. WJZ/15062267, houdende beleidsregel inzake de toepassing door de Autoriteit Consument en Markt van artikel 7.4a van de Telecommunicatiewet (Beleidsregel netneutraliteit). (2015, May 15). officiële publicatie, officielebekendmakingen,
  5. Brake, D. (2015, August 14). Legal arguments take shape against title II. The Innovation Files,
  6. Case Search – Competition – European Commission – Google. (2015, August 31).,
  7. Christiansen, C. (1997). The innovator’s dilemma: When new technologies cause great firms to fail. Harvard Business Review.Google Scholar
  8. Commission Welcomes Agreement to End Roaming Charges and to Guarantee an Open Internet. (2015, June 30).,
  9. Consagra El Principio de Neutralidad En La Red Para Los Consumidores Y Usuarios de Internet. (Ley 20.45, 2010, August 26).
  10. Crawford, S. (2013, December 17). Stockholm and Leverett: Case studies in fiber deployment.,
  11. Crawford, S., & Scott, B. (2015, June). Be careful what you wish for: Why Europe should avoid the mistakes of US internet access policy. Stiftung-Nv,
  12. Estabelece Princípios, Garantias, Direitos E Deveres Para O Uso Da Internet No Brasil. (Lei 12965, 2014, April 23).
  13. European Commission. (2015, June 10). Net neutrality challenges. Digital Agenda for Europe, http://digital-agenda/en/net-neutrality-challengesGoogle Scholar
  14. European Innovation Scoreboards. (2015, July 8). European Commission,
  15. European Single Market for Electronic Communications. (2014, April 3).,
  16. Facts on Android. (2015, August 31).,
  17. Falch, M., & Henten, A. (2015). European Broadband Policy – Regulation vs. Facilitation, Aalborg University, Denmark. doi: 10.13140/RG.2.1.4728.0484.
  18. Faris, R. (2015, February 10). Score another one for the Internet? The role of the networked public sphere in the U.S. net neutrality policy debate|Berkman Center. Harvard University, Berkman Center for Internet and Society.
  19. Farivar, C. (2012, May 30). Silicon valley donations to Obama reach record levels. Ars Technica,
  20. FCC. (2015, March 12). Net neutrality ruling by FCC.
  21. FCC Open Internet Report & Order 10-201, Paragraph 14 (FCC, 2010, December 21),
  22. FCC Open Internet Rules Paragraph 372 (p. 171). Retrieved August 20, 2015.
  23. FCC Press Release. (2015, July 2). Public notice: Open internet advisory opinion procedures.
  24. FCC Releases Open Internet Order. (2015, March 12). FCC,
  25. Federal Communications Commission. (2015, March 12). Report and order on remand, declaratory ruling, and order. Washington DC: FCC.
  26. Freeman, C. (1995). The national system of innovation in historical perspective. Cambridge Journal of Economics (19), 5–24.
  27. Geoghegan, T. (2013, October 28). Why is broadband more expensive in the US? BBC News. Washington.
  28. Grant, E., & Khosla, S. (2015, April 8). Here’s everywhere Uber is banned around the world. Business Insider,
  29. Hattem, J. (2014, October 10). New net neutrality coalition gets first lobbyists. The Hill,
  30. Henten, A., & Falch, M. (2014, June). The future of telecom regulation: The case of Denmark.
  31. Hestres, L. E. (June 30, 2013). App neutrality: Apple’s app store and freedom of expression online. International Journal of Communication, 7(0), 15.Google Scholar
  32. How Do Consumers Value Net Neutrality in an Evolving Internet Marketplace? A Report into Ecosystem Dynamics and Demand-Side Forces. (2015, June). BEREC,
  33. Innovation Indicators. (2015, August 31).,
  34. Karr, R. (2011, June 28). Why is European broadband faster and cheaper? Blame the government. Engadget,
  35. Kehl, D., Morgus, R., & Morris, S. (2014, October 30). The cost of connectivity 2014 – data and analysis on broadband offerings in 24 cities across the world. New America,
  36. Kelly, W. (2014, August 25). How Rahm Emanuel profits from brother Ari’s Uber Payday. Communities Digital News,
  37. Kende, M., & Rose, K. (2015, January 12). The content side of the access equation. Internet Society,
  38. Layton, R. (2014, September). Net neutrality regulation and broadband infrastructure investment: How to make an empirical assessment. Network Neutrality: An Ongoing Regulatory Debate, Second Report of the Dynamic Coalition on Network Neutrality.
  39. Layton, R., & Elaluf-Calderwood, S. M. (2015, August 15). Zero rating: Do hard rules protect or harm consumers and competition? Evidence from Chile, Netherlands and Slovenia. SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
  40. Lemley, M. A., & Lessig, L. (2000, October 1). The end of end-to-end: Preserving the architecture of the internet in the broadband era. SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
  41. Lemley, M. A., & Lessig, L. (2003, June 5). The end of end-to-end: Preserving the architecture of the internet in the broadband era. SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
  42. Ley de Promocion de La Banda Ancha Y Construccion de La Red Dorsal Nacional de Fibra Optica. (Ley 29904, 2012, July 20).
  43. Liebenau, J. (2012). Strategic challenges for the European telecom sector: The consequences of imbalances in internet traffic. Journal of Information Policy, 2, 248–272.Google Scholar
  44. Liebenau, J., Elaluf-Calderwood, S., & Kärrberg, P. (2013, June). European internet traffic: Problems and prospects of growth and competition. Monograph,
  45. Luca, M., Wu, T., & Yelp Data Science Team. (2015, June 28). Is Google degrading search? Consumer harm from universal search.
  46. Marcus, J. S. (2014, December). Network neutrality revisited: Challenges and responses in the EU and in the USA. European Parliament, IMCO Committee.
  47. Marsden, C. (2015, March 31). Comparative case studies in implementing net neutrality: A critical analysis. SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
  48. Nagesh, G. (2014, November 10). Obama calls on FCC to issue rules protecting ‘Net Neutrality. Wall Street Journal, sec. Tech.
  49. Nätneutralitet. (2011). Post-och Telestyrelsen (PTS),
  50. Negro, G. (2015, June 11). Opinion: U.S. follows China’s example on internet regulation. InsideSources,
  51. When It Comes to Net Neutrality, Why Don’t People Talk about Operating Systems? (2013, June). Strand Consult,
  52. Netflix Has Replaced Google as the Face of Net Neutrality Netflix Has Replaced Google as the Face of Net Neutrality. (2014, September 14). National Journal,
  53. Nettnøytralitet: Retningslinjer for Nøytralitet På Internett. Oslo, NO: Post-og Teletilsynet (PT), February 24, 2009.øytralitet/nettnøytralitet/attachment/972?_ts=13837548973
  54. Netzneutralität: Bericht Zur Arbeitsgruppe. Bern, SUI: Bundesamt für Kommunikation (BAKOM), October 23, 2014.
  55. Neutralité de l’Internet et Des Réseaux. Paris, FR: Autorité de Régulation des Communications électroniques et des Postes (ARCEP), September 2010.
  56. New Competition Promotion Program 2010. (2007, October 23). Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC) Japan, Soumu,
  57. Nye Jr., J. S. (2005). Soft power: The means to success in world politics (New Ed). New York: PublicAffairs.Google Scholar
  58. O Razglasitvi Zakona O Elektronskih Komunikacijah (ZEKom-1). (2012, December 21). Uradni,
  59. O’Brien, C. (2014, November 12). What France has taught me: Americans are suckers who have themselves to blame for Crappy broadband. VentureBeat,
  60. O’connell, R. (2013, May 8). 10 app stores in China you really ought to be on, Appflood,
  61. Ofcom’s approach to net neutrality. London, UK: Ofcom, November 24, 2011.
  62. Olukotun, D. (2015, August 11). Status of net neutrality around the world. Blog|Access,
  63. Open Internet Advisory Committee. (November 4, 2014). FCC,
  64. Petitioners’ Join Proposed Briefing Format and Schedule. (2015). United States Telecom Association, et al., v Federal Communications Commission, and United States of America.
  65. Por La Cual Se Expide El Plan Nacional de Desarrollo. (Ley 1450, 2011, June 16).
  66. Public Knowledge. (2015, May 15). Amicus Brief on behalf of FCC in US Telecom et al v. FCC.
  67. R: R Foundation Members & Supporters. (2015, September 7).
  68. Expiden La Ley Federal de Telecomunicaciones Y Radiodifusion, Y La Ley Del Sistema Publico de Radiodifusion Del Mixcano; Y Se Reforman, Adicionan Y Derogan, Diversas Disposiciones En Materia de Telecomunicaciones Y Radiodifusion. (2014, July 14).
  69. Ramos, A. (2014, October). The ASO book: App store optimization by Andreas Ramos.,
  70. Ramos, A., & Cota, S. (2009). Search engine marketing. McGraw-Hill.
  71. Report: China Surpasses United States by iOS Downloads. (2015, April 28). App Annie Blog,
  72. Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). New York: Free PressGoogle Scholar
  73. Rogers, K. (2015, April 16). Meet six-figure entrepreneurs behind the Etsy IPO. CNBC,
  74. Samarbejde Om – Og Retningslinjer fornetneutralitet”. Copenhagen, DK: Tele Industrien (TI), September 20, 2011.
  75. Schumpeter, J. A. (1942) Capitalism, socialism, and democracy. New York: Harper.Google Scholar
  76. Scott, B., Heumann, S., & Kleinhans, J-P. (2015, July 30). Landmark EU and US net neutrality decisions: How might pending decisions impact internet fragmentation? Cigionline,
  77. Sebastien Soriano: Speech ETNO-MLEX 2015. (2015). European Telecommunications Network Operators’ Association,
  78. Silvius, S. (2011). Internet exchange points: A closer look at the differences between Continental Europe and the rest of the world. Amsterdam: EURO-IX.
  79. Singer, H. (2015, August 26). Does the tumble in broadband investment spell doom for the FCC’s open internet order? Forbes,
  80. Smith, J. (2015, August 25). The net neutrality report: Where we are now, what happens next, and why mobile is central to the debate. Business Insider,
  81. Sørensen, F. (2013). The Norwegian model for net neutrality. Norwegian Post and Telecommunications Authority.
  82. Teece, D. (1986, June). Profiting from technological innovation: Implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy. School of Business Administration, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, U.S.A. Google Scholar
  83. Broadcasting and Telecom Decision CRTC 2015-26. Ottawa, CA: Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, January 29, 2015.
  84. Telecom Regulatory Policy CRTC 2009-657. Ottawa, CA: Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, October 21, 2009.
  85. The Bloomberg Innovation Index. (2015).,
  86. The Global Innovation Index. (2015, September 17). Global Innovation Index,
  87. Traffic Management Detection Methods & Tools. (2015).,
  88. Van Eijk, N. (2014, August 2). The proof of the pudding is in the eating: Net neutrality in practice, the Dutch example. SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
  89. Vargas-Leon, P. (2014, September). Network neutrality: An ongoing regulatory debate, Chapter 2. 2nd Report for Dynamic Coalition of Net Neutrality.
  90. Veigle, A. (2015, July 8). Amicus briefs show open internet order illegalities. USTelecom,
  91. Weller, D., & Woodcock, B. (2013, January 29). Internet Traffic Exchange. OECD Digital Economy Papers. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
  92. Why Can’t We Be Like South Korea? When Internet Access Is Slow or Just Nonexistent in the US, We Shrug Our Shoulders. But in That Small Asian Nation, Lousy Connections Are Not Tolerated. (2015, July 23). Medium,
  93. WIPO Intellectual Property Statistics Data Center. (2015, July 24).,
  94. World Telecommunication/ICT Indicators Database. (2015, June). ITU,
  95. Wu, T. (2003). Network neutrality, broadband discrimination. Journal of Telecommunications and High Technology Law, 2(1), 141–176.
  96. Yoo, C. (2009, September). Free speech and the myth of the internet as an unintermediated experience. George Washington Law Review, Vol. 78, Pg. 697, 2010 University of Pennsylvania, Inst for Law & Econ Research Paper No. 09-33 University of Pennsylvania Law School, Public Law Research Paper No. 09-26 TPRC 2009, 77.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  • Roslyn Layton
    • 1
  1. 1.Center for Communication, Media and Information Technologies,Aalborg UniversityCopenhagenDenmark

Personalised recommendations