Abstract
The Swiss political system is decentralized, and this includes voting operations. Several cantons have implemented Internet-based e-voting systems. The system used until recently in Geneva was a simple Internet voting system which assumed that the voter’s personal computer had not been compromised. This was considered risky already at the time and various counter-measures were considered. The one that was implemented in practice was to limit the proportion of voters that could vote via Internet. At present, there is consensus amongst experts that such systems are unsafe and should be improved, in particular by implementing verification. In order to stimulate improvements in the system, the author challenged the use of the Geneva system in court, arguing that it was not compliant with constitutional principles and cantonal law on voting rights. At the end of a long and complex legal process, the Swiss Federal Tribunal (supreme court) ruled that the complaints could not be heard on their merits, because they did not allege that weaknesses had actually been exploited in a specific vote. This decision differs from those taken in other jurisdictions and highlights the difficulties of bringing scientific arguments into the court system.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
References
Maurer, A.D.: Internet Voting and Federalism: The Swiss Case. Revista General de Derecho Público Comparado, No. 13, 2013. In: Barrat, J. (ed.) El voto electronico y sus dimensiones juridicas: entre la ingenua complacencia y el rechazo precipitado, Iustel, Madrid, Spain (2015)
Swiss Federal Chancellery: Vote électronique. http://www.bk.admin.ch/themen/pore/evoting/index.html?lang=fr
Commission externe d’évaluation des politiques publiques: Voter par Internet: évaluation des effets du vote électronique à Genève, Geneva, Switzerland (2013). http://goo.gl/BZpFn4
Chevalier, M.: Internet Voting: Status, Perspectives, and Issues, Chancellery of the canton of Geneva, ITU-T Workshop on e-Government (2003). http://www.itu.int/itudoc/itu-t/workshop/e-gov/e-gov010.html
Oppliger, R.: Traitement du problème de la sécurité des plate-formes pour le vote par Internet à Genève, Chancellerie du canton de Genève, Geneva, Switzerland (2002). http://goo.gl/t8o9gG
Chevalier, M.: La solution genevoise de vote électronique à cœur ouvert, Direcktdemokratie, Flash Informatique No. 6 (2011). http://goo.gl/9HUZXx
Dubuis, E., Haenni, R., Koenig, R.: Konzept und implicationen eines verifizierbaren Vote Eletronique Systems. Berner Fachhochschule, Bern, Switzerland (2012). http://goo.gl/pj7Gyl
Dubuis, E., Fischli, S., Haenni, R., Serdült, U., Spycher, O.: A verifiable internet voting system. In: CeDEM 2011, Conference for E-Democracy and Open Government, Krems, Austria, pp. 301–312 (2011)
Barrat, J., Chevallier, M., Goldsmith, B., Jandura, D., Turner, J., Sharma, R.: Internet voting and individual verifiability: the Norwegian return codes. In: EVOTE2012, Bregenz, Austria, pp. 35–45 (2012)
Swiss Federal Council: Rapport sur le vote électronique (2013). http://www.admin.ch/opc/fr/federal-gazette/2013/4519.pdf
Andrivet, S.: Attacking E-Voting: A Concrete Case, in Nuit du Hack 2013, Advtools (2013). http://goo.gl/1FamYU
Jones, Douglas W., Simons, Barbara: Broken Ballots: Will Your Vote Count?. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (2012)
Maurer, A.D., Barrat, J. (eds.): E-Voting Case Law: A Comparative Analysis. Ashgate, Farnham (2015)
Auer, A., Malinverni, G., Hottelier, M.: Droit constitutionnel suisse. Staempfli, Bern (2006)
Christin, T., Trechsel, A.S.: Analyse du scrutin du 26 septembre 2004 dans quatre communes genevoises. E-Democracy Center, University of Geneva, Geneva, Swittzerland (2005). http://goo.gl/4YqhFz
Chambre administrative, Cour de Justice de Genève: ATA/533/2012, 21 August 2012. http://justice.geneve.ch/tdb/Decis/TA/ata.tdb?F=ATA/533/2012
Chambre administrative, Cour de Justice de Genève, ATA/414/2011, 28 June 2011. http://justice.geneve.ch/tdb/Decis/TA/ata.tdb?F=ATA/414/2011
Federal Tribunal: 1C_329/2014, 22 July 2014. http://relevancy.bger.ch/php/aza/http/index.php?type=highlight_simple_query&highlight_docid=aza%3A%2F%2F22-12-2011-1C_329-2011
Federal Tribunal: 1F_5/2012, 19 March 2012. http://relevancy.bger.ch/php/aza/http/index.php?type=highlight_simple_query&highlight_docid=aza%3A%2F%2F19-04-2012-1F_5-2012
Federal Tribunal: 1C_477/2012, 27 March 2013. http://relevancy.bger.ch/php/aza/http/index.php?type=highlight_simple_query&highlight_docid=aza%3A%2F%2F27-03-2013-1C_477-2012
Federal Tribunal: ATF 1C_563, 29 August 2013. http://relevancy.bger.ch/php/aza/http/index.php?type=highlight_simple_query&highlight_docid=aza%3A%2F%2F29-08-2013-1C_563-2013
Chambre administrative, Cour de Justice de Genève, ATA 118/2014, 25 February 2014. http://justice.geneve.ch/tdb/Decis/TA/FichierWord/2014/0001/ATA_000118_2014_A_3506_2011.pdf
Federal Tribunal: 1C_136, 22 July 2014. http://relevancy.bger.ch/php/aza/http/index.php?type=highlight_simple_query&highlight_docid=aza%3A%2F%2F22-07-2014-1C_136-2014
Wikipedia: Catch-22 (logic). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catch-22_(logic)
Swiss Federal Chancellery: Des nouvelles dispositions régissent le vote électronique. http://www.bk.admin.ch/themen/pore/evoting/index.html?lang=fr
Seedorf, S.: Germany: the public nature of elections and its consequences on e-voting. In: [13]
Madise, U., Vinkel, P.: A judicial approach to internet voting in Estonia. In: [13]
Driza Mauer, A., Barrat, J.: Conclusions. In: [13]
Kuoni, B.: Case Law on e-voting – a swiss perspective. In: [13]
Swiss Parliament: Zulassung einer rechtlichen Prüfung der Modalitäten der elektronischen Stimmabgabe, Curia Vista 15.412. http://www.parlament.ch/d/suche/Seiten/geschaefte.aspx?gesch_id=20150412
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2015 Springer International Publishing Switzerland
About this paper
Cite this paper
Hill, R. (2015). Challenging an E-voting System in Court. In: Haenni, R., Koenig, R., Wikström, D. (eds) E-Voting and Identity. Vote-ID 2015. Lecture Notes in Computer Science(), vol 9269. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-22270-7_10
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-22270-7_10
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-22269-1
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-22270-7
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)