Abstract
Over the last years new incentives for professors were introduced into the German university system in order to strengthen the external motivation and the productivity of professors. At the same time a critical reflection has begun, in which the effects on internal motivation and deficiencies concerning the measurement and the overall effects on the science and higher education system were discussed. In addition to these criticisms, we will argue from an organizational perspective. From that perspective, incentives are a central aspect of power in organizations. This allows us to put incentives in a broader perspective, in which also other forms of power in higher education organizations come into light. Such forms are the power over resources, careers, and, ultimately, membership. The article argues that due to the specificities of the German university system and its organizations, the nexus between power and incentives is rather weak as compared to other systems. However, such a structure is not per se problematic. It generates a specific set of advantages and disadvantages with regard to the missions of universities in a knowledge society and some critical side-effects of a strong nexus between power and incentives can thus be avoided.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
The discussion shares many parallels with that currently underway in regard to the public sector as a whole (Frey et al. 2013).
- 2.
- 3.
For reasons of simplicity we will not consider the Junior Professors because they hardly figure in the German system. Only 4 % of professors are Junior Professors (Statistisches Bundesamt 2013).
- 4.
In contrast to other systems, this distinction is usually not directly visible to outsiders. Normally one can not find this information on the professors’ websites or their business cards.
- 5.
- 6.
The number of tenured academics in the USA declined from 65 % in 1980/1981 to 49 % in 2007/2008 [cf. National Center for Education Statistics (NCES)]. According to Chait (2002, p. 19) the number of part-time professorships nearly doubled from 22 % in 1970 to 41 % in 1995. According to Donoghue (2008) this trend is particularly dramatic in subjects like humanities from which no immediate economic utility can be expected, or at higher education institutions that are orientated toward profit and/or training.
References
Askling B (2001) Higher education and academic staff in a period of policy and system change. High Educ 41(1–2):157–181
Baker DP, Lenhardt G (2008) The institutional crisis of the German research university. High Educ Pol 21(1):49–64
Ben-David J (1971) The scientist’s role in society. A comparative study. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Blau PM, Scott RW (1969) Formal organizations. A comparative approach. Routledge; Kegan Paul, London
BMBF (2014) Datenportal. Studienanfänger/-innen im 1. Hochschulsemester und Studienanfängerquoten nach Geschlecht und Land des Erwerbs der Hochschulzugangsberechtigung. http://www.datenportal.bmbf.de/portal/Tabelle-2.5.73.xls. Accessed 18 May 2014
Bode I (2010) Der Zweck heil(ig)t die Mittel? Ökonomisierung und Organisationsdynamik im Krankenhaussektor. In: Endreß M, Matys T (eds) Die Ökonomie der Organisation - die Organisation der Ökonomie. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden, pp 63–92
Bosbach E (2009) Von Bologna nach Boston? Perspektiven und Reformansätze in der Doktorandenausbildung anhand eines Vergleichs zwischen Deutschland und den USA. Akademische Verlags-Anstalt, Leipzig
Brown AD, Lewis MA (2011) Identities, discipline and routines. Organ Stud 32(7):871–895
Bruneau W, Savage DC (2002) Counting out the scholars: the case against performance indicators in higher education. James Lorimer & Company, Toronto
Brunsson N, Sahlin-Andersson K (2000) Constructing organizations: the example of public sector reform. Organ Stud 21(4):721–746
Bundesamt S (2013) Bildung und Kultur: Personal an Hochschulen 2012. Statistisches Bundesamt, Wiesbaden
Butler L (2003) Explaining Australia’s increased share of ISI publications—the effects of a funding formula based on publication counts. Res Policy 32(1):143–155
BVerfG (2010) 1 BvR 748/06 vom 20.7.2010
BVerfG (2012) 2 BvL 4/10 vom 14.02.2012
Capano G (2008) Looking for serendipity: the problematical reform of government within Italy’s universities. High Educ 55(4):481–504
Chait R (2002) The questions of tenure. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Clegg SR, Courpasson D, Phillips N (2006) Power and organizations. SAGE Publications, Los Angeles, CA
Cyert RM, March JG (1963) A behavioral theory of the firm. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
de Boer H, Enders J, Leisyte L (2007a) Public sector reform in Dutch higher education: the organizational transformation of the university. Public Adm 85(1):27–46
de Boer H, Enders J, Schimank U (2007b) On the way towards new public management? The governance of university systems in England, the Netherlands, Austria, and Germany. In: Jansen D (ed) New forms of governance in research organizations, Disciplinary approaches, interfaces and integration. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 137–152
de Weert E (2000) Academic staff in the Netherlands. In: Enders J (ed) Employment and working conditions of academic staff in Europe. German Trade Union for Education & Science, Frankfurt/Main, pp 168–180
Diefenbach T, Sillince JAA (2011) Formal and informal hierarchy in different types of organization. Organ Stud 32(11):1515–1537
Diefenbach T, By RT, Klarner P (2009) A multi-dimensional analysis of managers’ power. Functional, socio-political, interpretive-discursive, and socio-cultural approaches. Manag Rev 20(4):413–431
Dilger A (2007) German universities as state-sponsored co-operatives. Manag Rev 18(2):102–116
Donoghue F (2008) The last professors: the corporate university and the fate of the humanities. Fordham University Press, New York
Emerson RM (1962) Power-dependence relations. Am Sociol Rev 27(1):31–41
Enders J (2000a) Academic staff in the European Union. In: Enders J (ed) Employment and working conditions of academic staff in Europe. German Trade Union for Education & Science, Frankfurt/Main, pp 29–53
Enders J (ed) (2000b) Employment and working conditions of academic staff in Europe. GEW, Frankfurt/Main
Enders J (2008) Professor werden ist sehr schwer, professor sein dann gar nicht mehr? Ein Betrag zur Personalstrukturreform an den Hochschulen. In: Matthies H, Simon D (eds) Wissenschaft unter Beobachtung. Effekte und Defekte von Evaluationen. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden, pp 83–99
Enders J, Bornmann L (2001) Karriere mit Doktortitel? Ausbildung, Berufsverlauf und Berufserfolg von Promovierten. Campus-Verlag, Frankfurt/Main u.a
Enders J, Boer H, Weyer E (2013) Regulatory autonomy and performance: the reform of higher education re-visited. High Educ 65(1):5–23
Espeland WN, Sauder M (2007) Rankings and reactivity: how public measures recreate social worlds. Am J Sociol 113(1):1–40
Etzioni A (1964) Modern organizations. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Flexner A (1930) Universities - American, English, German. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Frey BS, Oberholzer-Gee F (1997) The cost of price incentives: an empirical analysis of motivation crowding-out. Am Econ Rev 87:746–755
Frey BS, Homberg F, Osterloh M (2013) Organizational control systems and pay-for-performance in the public service. Organ Stud 34(7):949–972
Fulton O (2000) Academic staff in the United Kingdom. In: Enders J (ed) Employment and working conditions of academic staff in Europe. German Trade Union for Education & Science, Frankfurt/Main, pp 224–234
Hagstrom WO (1965) The scientific community. Basic Books, New York
Hannan MT, Freeman J (1984) Structural inertia and organizational change. Am Sociol Rev 49(2):149–164
Heinz JP, Nelsen RL, Sandefur RL, Laumann EO (2005) Urban lawyers: the new social structure of the bar. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Heinze T, Shapira PRJ, Senker J (2009) Organizational and institutional influences on creativity in scientific research. Res Policy 38:610–623
HRK (2012) HRK Senate criticises the draft amendments to the “W” professorial salary scale. http://www.hrk.de/press/press-releases/press-release/meldung/hrk-senate-criticises-the-draft-amendments-to-the-w-professorial-salary-scale-2340/
Hüther O (2008) Starke Dekane - Schwache Professoren? Vergleich und Analyse der deutschen Landeshochschulgesetze. Hochschulmanagement 3(1):23–27
Hüther O (2010) Von der Kollegialität zur Hierarchie? Eine Analyse des New Managerialism in den Landeshochschulgesetzen. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden
Hüther O, Krücken G (2011) Wissenschaftliche Karriere und Beschäftigungsbedingungen – organisationssoziologische Überlegungen zu den Grenzen neuer Steuerungsmodelle an deutschen Hochschulen. Soziale Welt 62(3):305–325
Hüther O, Krücken G (2013) Hierarchy and power: a conceptual analysis with particular reference to new public management reforms in German universities. Eur J High Educ 3(4):307–323
Jacob AK, Teichler U (2011) Der Wandel des Hochschullehrerberufs im internationalen Vergleich. Ergebnisse einer Befragung in den Jahren 2007/08. BMBF, Bonn
Jansen D, Wald A, Franke K, Schmoch U, Schubert T (2007) Drittmittel als Performanzindikator der wissenschaftlichen Forschung. Zum Einfluss von Rahmenbedingungen auf Forschungsleistungen. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 59(1):125–149
Kärreman D, Alvesson M (2004) Cages in tandem: management control, social identity, and identification in a knowledge-intensive firm. Organization 11(1):149–175
Kreckel R (2008) Großbritannien. In: Kreckel R (ed) Zwischen promotion und professur. Akademische Verlags-Anstalt, Leipzig, pp 124–165
Krücken G (2003) Learning the ‘new, new thing’: on the role of path dependency in university structures. High Educ 46(3):315–339
Krücken G (2008) Lässt sich Wissenschaft managen? Wissenschaftsrecht 41(4):345–358
Krücken G (2014) Higher education reforms and unintended consequences: a research agenda. Studies of Higher Education.
Krücken G, Meier F (2006) Turning the university into an organizational actor. In: Drori GS, Meyer JW, Hwang H (eds) Globalization and organization. World society and organizational change. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 241–257
Krücken G, Blümel A, Kloke K (2013) The managerial turn in higher education? On the interplay of organizational and occupational change in German academica. Minerva 51(5):417–442
Lee FS (2007) The research assessment exercise, the state and the dominance of mainstream economics in British universities. Camb J Econ 31(2):309–325
Luhmann N (1964) Funktionen und Folgen formaler Organisation. Duncker & Humblot, Berlin
Luhmann N (1980) Trust and power. Two works by Niklas Luhmann. Wiley, Chichester
Luhmann N (1992) Die Wissenschaft der Gesellschaft. Frankfurt/M, Suhrkamp
Maasen S, Weingart P (2006) Unternehmerische Universität und neue Wissenskultur. die hochschule 15(1):19–45
MacRoberts MH, MacRoberts BR (1996) Problems of citation analysis. Scientometrics 36(3):435–444
Martin B, Whitley R (2010) The UK research exercise: a case of regulatory capture? In: Whitley R, Gläser J, Engwall L (eds) Reconfiguring knowledge production. Changing authority relationships in the sciences and their consequences for intellectual innovation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 51–80
Mayntz R (ed) (1968) Bürokratische organisation. Kiepenheuer & Witsch, Köln
Merton RK (1973) The sociology of science. Theoretical and empirical investigations. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL
Mignot G (2003) Who are the actors in the government of French universities? The paradoxal victory of deliberative leadership. High Educ 45(1):71–89
Minssen H, Wilkesmann U (2003) Lassen Hochschulen sich steuern? Soziale Welt 54(2):123–141
Münch R (2006) Die Entsorgung wissenschaftlicher Kreativität Latente Effekte der kennzifferngesteuerten Mittelverteilung im akademischen Feld. die hochschule 15(2):98–122
Musselin C (2005) European academic labor markets in transition. High Educ 49(1):135–154
Musselin C (2010) The market for academics. Routledge, New York
Musselin C (2013) Redefinition of the relationships between academics and their university. High Educ 65(1):25–37
Neave G, Rhoades G (1987) The academic estate in western Europe. In: Clark B (ed) The academic profession. National, disciplinary and institutional settings. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, pp 211–270
OECD (2012) Education at a glance 2012. OECD Publishing, Paris
Osterloh M (2012) New public management‘versus ‚Gelehrtenrepublik’- rankings als instrument der qualitätsbeurteilung in der wissenschaft? In: Wilkesmann U, Schmid C (eds) Hochschule als organisation. Organisationssoziologie. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden, pp 209–221
Osterloh M, Frey BS (2000) Motivation, knowledge transfer, and organizational forms. Organ Sci 11(5):538–550
Osterloh M, Frey BS (2009) Research governance in academia: are there alternatives to academic rankings? CESifo working paper. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID1460691_code968850.pdf?abstractid=1460691&mirid=1. Accessed 15 Apr 2014
Paradeise C, Bleiklie I, Ferlie E, Reale E (eds) (2009) University governance: western European comparative perspectives. Springer, Dordrecht
Partha D, David PA (1994) Toward a new economics of science. Res Policy 23(5):487–521
Pollitt C, Bouckaert G (2004) Public management reform: a comparative analysis. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Preston AM (1992) The birth of clinical accounting: a study of the emergence and transformations of discourses on costs and practices of accounting in U.S. hospitals. Acc Organ Soc 17(1):63–100
Reay T, Hinings CR (2005) The recomposition of an organizational field: health care in Alberta. Organ Stud 26(3):351–384
Röbken H (2007) Postgraduate studies in Germany - how much structure is not enough? South Afr J High Educ 21(8):1054–1066
Royston G, Hinings CR (1996) Understanding radical organizational change: bringing together the old and the new institutionalism. Acad Manag Rev 21(4):1022–1054
Schimank U (2001) Festgefahrene Gemischtwarenläden - Die deutschen Hochschulen als erfolgreich scheiternde Organisationen. In: Stölting E, Schimank U (eds) Die Krise der Universitäten. Westdeutscher Verlag, Wiesbaden, pp 223–242
Schofer E, Meyer JW (2005) The worldwide expansion of higher education in the twentieth century. Am Sociol Rev 70(6):898–920
Scholkmann A (2011) Deans in German universities: goal acceptance and task characteristics. Tert Educ Manag 17(4):337–353
Schubert T, Schmoch U (2010) Finanzierung der Hochschulforschung. In: Simon D, Knie A, Hornbostel S (eds) Handbuch Wissenschaftspolitik. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden, pp 244–261
Scott RW (1966) Professionals in bureaucracies - areas of conflict. In: Vollmer HM, Mills DL (eds) Professionalization. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp 265–275
Scott RW (1981) Organizations: rational, natural, and open systems. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Seidler HH (2004) Hochschulfinanzierung, evaluation und mittelvergabe. In: Hartmer M, Detmer H (eds) Hochschulrecht. Ein Handbuch für die Praxis. Verlagsgruppe Hüthig-Jehle-Rehm, Heidelberg, pp 478–510
Shils E (1991) The idea of a university and the right to academic freedom. In: Altbach PG (ed) International higher education. An encyclopedia, vol 1. New York; London, pp. 1–22
Stern S (2004) Do scientists pay to be scientists? Manag Sci 50(6):835–853
Sutton JR (1984) Organizational autonomy and professional norms in science: a case study of the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory. Soc Stud Sci 14(2):197–224
Trow M (2010) Twentieth-century higher education: elite to mass to universal. JHU, Baltimore, MD
Wilkesmann U (2010) Die vier Dilemmata der wissenschaftlichen Weiterbildung. Zeitschrift für Soziologie der Erziehung und Sozialisation 30(1):28–42
Wilkesmann U, Schmid CJ (2012) The impacts of new governance on teaching at german universities. Findings from a national survey. High Educ 63(1):33–52
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2015 Springer International Publishing Switzerland
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Hüther, O., Krücken, G. (2015). Incentives and Power: An Organizational Perspective. In: Welpe, I., Wollersheim, J., Ringelhan, S., Osterloh, M. (eds) Incentives and Performance. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-09785-5_5
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-09785-5_5
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-09784-8
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-09785-5
eBook Packages: Business and EconomicsBusiness and Management (R0)