Analogical Proportions and Square of Oppositions
The paper discusses analogical proportions in relation with the square of oppositions, a classical structure in Ancient logic which is related to the different forms of statements that may be involved in deductive syllogisms. The paper starts with a short reminder on the logical modeling of analogical proportions, viewed here as Boolean expressions expressing similarities and possibly differences between four items, as in the statement “a is to b as c is to d”. The square of oppositions and its hexagon-based extension is then restated in a knowledge representation perspective. It is observed that the four vertices of a square of oppositions form a constrained type of analogical proportion that emphasizes differences. In fact, the different patterns making an analogical proportion true can be covered by a square of oppositions or by a “square of agreement”, leading to disjunctive expressions of the analogical proportion. Besides, an “analogical octagon” is shown to capture the general construction of an analogical proportion from two sets of properties. Since the square of oppositions offers a common setting relevant for syllogisms and analogical proportions, it also provides a basis for the discussion of the possible interplay between deductive arguments and analogical arguments.
KeywordsTruth Table Boolean Variable Analogical Reasoning Formal Concept Analysis Syllogistic Reasoning
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.Béziau, J.-Y.: New light on the square of oppositions and its nameless corner. Logical Investigations 10, 218–233 (2003)Google Scholar
- 2.Blanché, R.: Structures Intellectuelles. Essai sur l’Organisation Systématique des Concepts. Vrin, Paris (1966)Google Scholar
- 4.Lepage, Y.: De l’analogie rendant compte de la commutation en linguistique. Habilit. à Diriger des Recher. Univ. J. Fourier, Grenoble (2003)Google Scholar
- 7.Parsons, T.: The traditional square of opposition. In: Zalta, E.N. (ed.) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2008 Edition) (2008)Google Scholar
- 10.Prade, H., Richard, G.: Homogeneous logical proportions: Their uniqueness and their role in similarity-based prediction. In: Brewka, G., Eiter, T., McIlraith, S.A. (eds.) Proc. 13th Int. Conf. on Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning (KR 2012), Roma, June 10-14, pp. 402–412. AAAI Press (2012)Google Scholar
- 13.Stroppa, N., Yvon, F.: Analogical learning and formal proportions: Definitions and methodological issues. Technical report (June 2005)Google Scholar